Onward Review: 6 Ups & 4 Downs

A middling effort from Pixar.

Onward Pixar
Pixar

Though Pixar's reputation for consistently delivering brilliantly creative and affecting animated films has taken a bit of a hit in recent years, they're still one of the most reliable Hollywood studios working today.

And so any year where Pixar releases two movies is a welcome one, even if the first one out of the gate is a bit of a disappointment.

While on paper Onward had the potential to be another radically inventive and emotionally devastating Pixar joint, it settles for being an acceptably middle-of-the-road outing that's fine while you're watching it, yet ultimately doesn't boast much staying power.

As an animation that'll keep adults and kids alike occupied, it's servicably entertaining, and most other animation studios would kill to release a movie this solid, but coming from the studio that practically reinvented the art form, it can't help but feel a little by-the-numbers.

Hopefully Pixar's Soul coming later this year, written and directed by Pixar's brilliant Pete Docter, will serve up a more thought-provoking and memorable offering.

Even so, Onward largely does what it needs to: it gently amuses, it dazzles with its visuals, and it tugs at the heartstrings just enough...


Downs...

4. The Formulaic Road Movie Plot

Onward Pixar
Pixar

Onward quickly establishes that brothers Ian and Barley Lightfoot (Tom Holland and Chris Pratt) need to find a magical gem which will complete the ritual to resurrect their father for 24 hours - who is currently just a pair of legs.

Though Pixar has cleverly reinvented well-trod genres in the past, Onward plays it pretty safe in this regard, serving up a mostly standard fare animated road trip movie with little in the way of smart subversion.

As a result, the narrative largely sees Ian and Barley travelling from one zany scenario to the next in shamelessly formulaic fashion, with several of these detours feeling less like comedically or dramatically inspired sojourns and more like contrived padding.


3. A Lot Of The Humour Falls Flat

Onward Pixar
Pixar

As reliably as Pixar has mastered the art of spoken witticisms and charmingly creative sight gags, humour is a major area where Onward just doesn't feel up to the studio's usual standard.

The banter between Ian and Barley, though jovial enough, is disappointingly broad, smacking of first draft material that needed a few more passes before being passed off to Holland and Pratt.

There's nothing offensive or cringe-worthy about the jokes, but they just come across as oddly low-effort, while the physical gags similarly lack the uproarious punchiness or ingenuity you'd expect.

Onward didn't need to be a laugh-a-minute romp to succeed, but there are often long stretches between truly funny moments, which is a real shame.


2. The Central Gimmick Feels Like A Missed Opportunity

Onward Pixar
Pixar

The idea of a Weekend at Bernie's-inspired Pixar movie sounds absolutely hilarious on paper, but as much as Onward's marketing has focused on the gimmick of the brothers bringing the disembodied legs of their father on their journey, it's ultimately a fairly tepid element of the story.

The legs are almost always there, yes, but given the obvious potential to shape the film's humour and set-pieces around them, playing-up the physically expressive potential of a pair of legs for big laughs, they're often just...there.

Bringing character to a pair of legs is obviously a massive creative challenge, but not one Pixar's previous work would suggest they were beyond.

And yet, we don't really get much sense of who Ian and Barley's dad was, and the limbs mostly end up feeling like a marketing ploy rather than a genuine entity in their own right.


1. It's One Of Pixar's Worst Films

Onward Pixar
Pixar

Onward isn't a bad movie by any means, but given the esteem of even most of Pixar's "lesser" output, it does decisively end up on the weaker end of their releases to date.

It's certainly sturdier and more entertaining than Cars 2, but of the studio's 22 movies to date, it's tough to place many others behind Onward - Cars 3 for sure, and perhaps The Last Dinosaur and Brave at a stretch, but nothing else.

Pixar has certainly spoiled audiences over the decades, and again, Onward would be undeniably viewed under a different lens if it came from, say, DreamWorks, but for the most consistently acclaimed animation studio on the planet, this can't help but feel like a rather underwhelming work.

Yet while not a great film, there is enough that nevertheless makes Onward a spry and entertaining romp for all the family. Here's what it gets right...


Ups...

6. Tom Holland & Chris Pratt's Brotherly Chemistry

Onward Pixar
Pixar

Pixar sure knew what they were doing when they cast Tom Holland and Chris Pratt as the leads in this movie.

Holland and Pratt rather unsurprisingly play hilariously unsubtle variations on their Marvel Cinematic Universe superheroes, with Holland the anxious nerd and Pratt the more aloof klutz character.

Put them together and you've got effortlessly entertaining banter, because no matter that the script is fairly middling at the best of times, their energetic and enthusiastic performances significantly elevate the material.

They both obviously deserve better, but even at its weakest, the film is focused on animated elf versions of Spider-Man and Star-Lord riffing off one another. There are far worse things to sit through.


5. It's Beautifully Animated

Onward Pixar
Pixar

As will surprise absolutely nobody who has ever seen a Pixar film before, Onward is a gorgeously animated movie, as is surely its strongest suit.

Even when the story is at its least interesting, director Dan Scanlon demonstrates his sure knack for eye-catching imagery, cleverly combining a heightened, fantastical aesthetic with the jaw-droppingly photorealistic humanoid world the elves reside in.

The best is also surely saved for last, with the film's brief but electric final showdown unleashing a barrage of kinetic and colourful action.

Few are going to rank it among Pixar's most technically astonishing releases, but Onward is served well by Scanlon's penchant for picturesque and dynamic visuals.


4. Octavia Spencer (Almost) Steals The Show

Onward Octavia Spencer Pixar
Pixar

By far the meatiest supporting role in the movie goes to Octavia Spencer, who provides the voice for Corey, a domesticated manticore who runs her own restaurant and, unsurprisingly, ends up roped into Ian and Barley's adventure.

Corey spends most of the movie teaming up with the brothers' mother Laurel (Julia Louis-Dreyfus) as she heads out in pursuit of her sons, and thanks largely to Spencer's excellent vocal performance, this subplot provide a welcome periodic diversion to the film's main plot.

Spencer ends up with many of the funniest one-liners, and though few will be surprised by the arc of her character, the ludicrously entertaining payoff makes it hard to much care.


3. It's Got A Great Message For Kids & Adults

Onward Pixar
Pixar

Like the majority of Pixar's movies, Onward isn't just made for kids: it also operates on a level that adults will surely relate to.

The movie is of course thoroughly concerned with themes of family and parenthood in particular, and the prevailing message is one that just about anyone can identify with.

Without going into too many plot details, there's a real appreciation here for cherishing what you have and not losing sight of what's in front of you, with the film serving as a tribute to brotherhood above all else.

It's hardly a groundbreaking or particularly left-field message compared to say, Inside Out telling children to embrace their "negative" feelings, but in a society currently obsessed with nostalgia and looking over one's shoulder, there's something refreshing about a movie that champions the joy of the present.


2. The Excellent World-Building

Onward Pixar
Pixar

Easily the most interesting thing about Onward is the world that Dan Scanlon has created - a peculiar yet compelling combination of fantasy tropes and real-life drudgery.

The movie kicks off by hastily explaining that magic has largely taken a backseat to the technological conveniences of the modern day, such that even those capable of grand supernatural feats tend to rely on the machinery you'd expect humans to use (namely cars).

But of course, Onward is concerned with its brother protagonists rediscovering magic, and so the fantastical and the mundane are amusingly intermingled.

Far more could certainly have been done to flesh this world out, but there's a sure charm to how cleverly two disparate aesthetics and civilisations are melded together.


1. The Emotionally Satisfying Ending

Onward Pixar
Pixar

No spoilers here, but as is characteristic of Pixar, Onward certainly ends with an emotional banger of a climax.

Even if it surely won't leave you a sobbing mess on the level of Toy Story 3, it arrives at a meaningful and poignant crescendo that helps smooth over the somewhat generic route the film took getting there.

Writer-director Scanlon has made it clear that Onward was a deeply personal project for him, having lost his own father at a young age, and there's no doubt that the filmmaker's own connection to this story helps imbue it with such a potent visceral impact in its final moments.

That it doesn't assault the viewer with a contrived attempt to wring tears from their eyes is admirable, opting instead for a modestly earnest finale that's all the more gratifying as a result.


In this post: 
Pixar Onward
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.