Oppenheimer Review: 8 Ups & 2 Downs

Is Oppenheimer a big bang or a big bomb?

Oppenheimer Cillian Murphy
Universal Pictures

Christopher Nolan's early films, like Insomnia and Memento proved the British filmmaker was one to look out for. But with his work on The Dark Knight, The Prestige, Inception, and Interstellar, Nolan didn't just showcase his talents, but helped mould the modern age of cinema.

As such, the esteemed director's latest outing, Oppenheimer, isn't perceived as a movie, but a global event. (And not just because of the Barbenheimer phenomenon). Detailing the life of theoretical physicist, J. Robert Oppenheimer, (Cillian Murphy) as he oversees the creation of the first atomic bomb, Nolan promised this historic thriller was his most important feature yet.

With a tour-de-force cast, Nolan regular, Hoyte van Hoytema on cinematography, and Oscar-winning composer, Ludwig Goransson in charge of the score, it seemed like Nolan had collected all the brightest talent in Hollywood to ensure this unbelievable story was done justice.

Though Nolan's previous feature, Tenet, didn't set the world on fire, early buzz for Oppenheimer proved the film auteur is back in his element.

Before gushing over this biographical drama, let's look at a few things in the movie that didn't work.

10. DOWNS - It's Very Dialogue-Heavy

Oppenheimer Film
Universal Films

Nolan has proven time and time to have a gift for action. And because Oppenheimer centres around World War II and the creation of the world's most powerful weapon at the time, many fans expected the film to contain elements of a blockbuster.

Though Nolan himself described his latest feature as a "horror movie," Oppenheimer is better described as a historic thriller and a court-case drama. Most of the story doesn't centre around the crafting of he bomb, but explaining how it works and why it needs to be used. These sequences are often intercut with scenes of a court hearing and the titular scientist being interrogated by a special counsel.

Because of this, Oppenheimer mainly consists of talking. LOTS of talking.

To be fair, these discussing are deeply fascinating and boundlessly compelling. In the words of Matt Damon's character, they're speaking about "the most important thing to happen in the history of the world".

These scenes may be fast-paced and riveting, but there's simply too much to digest. As a result, there are times where viewers will just tune out.


9. The Sound Mixing Drowns Out Some Of The Dialogue

Oppenheimer Film
Universal Pictures

Ever since The Dark Knight Rises, Nolan has garnered a reputation for mishandling sound mixing in his work. Because of this, there are times during his films where it's impossible to hear what the characters are saying. Since this was a sticking point with Tenet, fans hoped Nolan had learned the error of his ways.

Sadly, this issue is apparent throughout Oppenheimer. The sound mixing is nowhere near as bad, but there are times where the dialogue can't be heard, since Nolan can't help inserting rumbling sounds and deafening blasts in the background.

Although these noises are intended to heighten the drama, they impair it, since they drown out everything else. Since the characters are often talking about intricate legalities and quantum mechanics, listeners need to hear every word to comprehend what they're saying. But no matter how attuned your ears are, at least 15% of the dialogue is too muffled to be understood.

Even though it's clear what this sound mixing is trying to accomplish, it feels like Noland should retire this counterproductive technique, or at the very least, rein it in.


8. UPS - Cillian Murphy Delivers An Unforgettable Performance

Oppenheimer Cillian Murphy
Universal

Since Cillian Murphy has worked with Christopher Nolan six times, it's clear the director has a soft spot for him. (Nolan also strongly considered having the Irish actor portray the lead role in Batman Begins.)

Despite working together for nearly 20 years, this is the first time Murphy has taken the helm in a Nolan property. Although everyone in Oppenheimer gives a great performance, Murphy towers over his co-stars. Even though it's challenging to play an inverted character, Murphy has no trouble conveying the weight that constantly lingers on Oppenheimer's shoulders.

To emphasise the power behind physicist's words, his speeches are sometimes accompanied by explosive shaking or a symbolic atomic light. However, these accompaniments are unneeded, since Murphy is able to convey the gravitas of the situation and the conviction of his character through his acting alone. (It's pretty impressive when there's a nuclear blast going off, and viewers are compelled to look at Murphy instead.)

If Murphy isn't nominated for an Academy Award for his performance, it would be a ghastly oversight.


7. It Has One Of The Best Casts Ever

Oppenheimer Film
Universal

Although Nolan's work often contains an impressive cast, nothing can compare to Oppenheimer's ensemble. Once the credits roll, viewers will struggle to think of a single movie with a more diverse array of A-listers.

The main players are Cillian Murphy, Emily Blunt, Matt Damon, and Robert Downey Jr. Because that's already a pretty impressive troupe, it's easy to forget Oppenheimer also includes Florence Pugh, Casey Affleck, Kenneth Branagh, Josh Hartnett, and over a dozen more big names.

Surprisingly, the decorated cast is never distracting. Because there are a lot of players in this complex narrative, it could've been difficult to keep track of everyone if the characters were portrayed by unknowns. But because viewers should recognise the faces of the story's heavy-hitters, it's much easier to follow the plot.

Some roles are cameos, but that doesn't mean they're wasted. In Rami Malek's singular speech, he reminds everyone why he's an Academy Award winner. Gary Oldman's Harry S. Truman only appears for two minutes, but delivers one of the most powerful performances in the whole movie.

Even though an all-star ensemble can be gimmicky, it's reassuring to see Nolan utilise his performers so efficiently.


6. Surprisingly, It Doesn't Feel Overly Long

Oppenheimer Cillian Murphy
Universal

Oppenheimer could be a hard-sell for some, due to its staggering run-time. Watching a 180-minute movie is no easy task, especially when it's a complex historic drama with black-and-white scenes, that regularly discusses quantum mechanics. (Also, viewers will have no better understanding of quantum physics when the movie ends.)

Against the odds, Oppenheimer never fails to be enrapturing. The film details the visionary scientist's college years, his time as a teacher, his rise to stardom in the physics world, his failed relationships, his ties to Communism, the trials, his life after World War II, his relationship with Albert Einstein, and his fall from grace.

While all these subplots are playing out, Nolan also has to find time to cover the period where the prized physicist built the world's first nuclear weapon.

Since there's so much content to get through, most scenes have rapid-fire dialogue and cut to the chase immediately. Not only does the expeditious line-delivery stop the movie from becoming boring, the injected dynamism intensifies every actor's performance.


5. The Lack Of CGI Is Heavily Appreciated

Oppenheimer Bomb
Universal Pictures

Christopher Nolan is responsible for creating some of the most magnificent action sequences in cinema. What's more impressive is how many of these scenes were achieved through practical methods. Although Nolan has no aversion to computer generated effects, he only utilises them as a last resort.

But since Oppenheimer taps into the unseen world of quantum mechanics, it seemed CGI was fully warranted.

But according to Nolan, Oppenheimer contains no CGI whatsoever. Even though viewers catch glimpses of sub-atomic particles like quarks, electrons, and superstrings, these visuals were brought to life through practical and optical effects. These magnificent images can be attributed to visual effects supervisor, Andrew Jackson, who also created the stunning SFX on Mad Max: Fury Road, without relying on computers.

This decision is deeply appreciated since badly rendered effects can take viewers out of the story, ruining the cinematic experience. Since this isn't a concern here, Oppenheimer keeps viewers enchanted from beginning to end.


4. Ludwig Göransson's Score Is Suitably Terrifying

Oppenheimer Cillian Murphy
Universal

It's ironic how Oppenheimer's greatest weakness is also one of its greatest strengths - sound. Even though the score can be overwhelming at times, there's no question Ludwig's Göransson's audio skills enhance this story.

As our titular character is overburdened with responsibility, the crackling of radiation is mixed in with the music, to emphasise the turbulence within Oppenheimer's mind and life. The sound effects are so deeply entrenched in each frame, Göransson's music feels more like a character than a tool.

As has been mentioned, the sound can be pointlessly loud occasionally, rendering it impossible to hear the dialogue. Despite the fact this can be frustrating, there are plenty of moments where this decision pays off.

While the titular physicist speaks to a crowd about the success of the Japanese bombing, their questions are nullified by the sound of an explosive blast which is only audible to Oppenheimer's ears. We can't hear what the audience is saying, but it doesn't matter, since the scene is about Oppenheimer's internal struggle, which is perfectly accentuated by the overbearing score.


3. Matt Damon's Comedy Is Welcome

Oppenheimer Matt Damon
Universal Pictures

Based on the premise alone, it's obvious Oppenheimer is a dead-serious drama. But if the tone remained sombre throughout the three-hour runtime, it would be pretty draining for viewers. As a result, Nolan wisely chose to inject a bit of humour, in the form of Matt Damon's character, Leslie Groves.

Being an army general, Groves is a stickler for the rules, causing him to butts heads with Oppenheimer when he doesn't do things by the book. As Groves starts to comprehend the significance of The Manhattan Project, he starts respecting Oppenheimer, even defending him when government officials aren't on his side.

Groves may not sound like a comedic character on paper... and he's not. But Damon's comic timing is so impeccable, he's responsible for the movie's funniest moments.

Even though a joke can deflate a serious scene, this never happens with Damon, since his delivery is always sincere and understated. The fact Damon can make viewers laugh during a scene where Oppenheimer talks about the world ending is a perfect example of the actor's comedic talents.


2. The Blast Sequence

Oppenheimer Bomb
Universal Pictures

Because Oppenheimer is centred around the atomic bomb's creation, it goes without saying the film's action centrepiece is the weapon's detonation. Although moviegoers have seen explosions a million times, nobody has seen a blast like this.

The scene opens, not just with a great sense of fear, but confusion. Since this sort of explosion is uncharted waters, Oppenheimer's team have no idea what they will witness. As a result, each of them take precautions in their own way, either by hiding in cars, wearing goggles, or smearing themselves in radiation-protective lotion.

Although listeners are expecting a deafening noise, the blast is silent, since it takes a moment for the sound waves to reach Oppenheimer's station. Even though viewers know the din is coming, no one is ready for it. When the sound is finally unleashed upon moviegoers' poor eardrums, they'll receive the biggest jump-scare of the year.

Because the detonation is built up throughout the entire movie, some viewers may worry it won't live up to expectations. Luckily, skeptics have nothing to worry about, since the detonation sequence is one of the most memorable sequences of Christopher Nolan's career.


1. The Einstein Interactions Tie Everything Together

Albert Einstein
Universal Pictures

It's common knowledge that Albert Einstein's equations helped the atomic bomb come to be. Since he and J. Robert Oppenheimer consulted each other during the weapon's construction, it made sense for the German physicist to show up in Oppenheimer.

But since Einstein is a towering figure in history, it would be extremely difficult to incorporate him in the story without feeling forced.

But not only does Einstein's interactions with Oppenheimer work well, they're vital for the plot Their opening conversation triggers Lewis Strauss' (Robert Downey Jr.) grudge against Oppenheimer. Because the details of this discussion are undisclosed until the end, it kicks off a mini-mystery that lingers in every scene, which keeps viewers permanently on edge.

Though Einstein could've appeared as a quick cameo, Oppenheimer has multiple interactions with his esteemed colleague. However, each meeting feels natural, and give viewers great insight into the way the world sees this pair and more importantly, how they see themselves.

It's also fascinating to look at Einstein, not as an icon or a scientist, but as a human being, fully aware his life's work came at a terrifying cost. Because Oppenheimer shares the same sentiment, it feels like the movie wouldn't have worked without him.


Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows