Oscars 1967: If We Picked The Winners (Best Picture)
You may have heard how a week or two ago, while speaking at the opening of a new media center at the University of Southern California, the titans of blockbuster filmmaking, Steven Spielberg and George Lucas, ominously predicted a forthcoming "implosion" of the movie industry and its current business model. This controversial prophecy, which has drawn a slew of interesting responses throughout the cyber-cinephile community, is based on the fact that, as far as Spielberg and Lucas see it, the studios' current reliance on prefabricated, ready-made, focus-group-tested movies, with a connection to some preexisting, market-proven intellectual property, can not go on indefinitely. The auteurs posit that at some point audiences will tire of these glorified 2-hour tests in simple pattern recognition (my words, not theirs) and that when the movie-going public reaches this saturation point, a sudden and financially disastrous summer blockbuster backlash will forever change the production and distribution landscape of the film industry. Now, putting aside whatever snide remark you want to make about the irony of Lucas and Spielberg bemoaning the pervasive commercialization of cinema (although I would state that I don't think Spielberg ever maliciously contributed to the commoditization of film except maybe in his acquiescence to the pressures of making a fourth Indiana Jones movie), it is an interesting theory, and one that I pray is true. While some have called the grim prediction preposterous, it actually isn't without precedence. In fact, if Spielberg and Lucas prove to be accurate augurs, it wouldn't be the first time the film industry was reborn again due to a lack of fresh ideas. The 1950's was, in terms of mainstream American cinema, an abysmal decade for the advancement of film as an art. While, as always, there are exceptions, in general, the American films of 1950's gave in to every negative impulse of drama. Maybe in a vain attempt to differentiate itself from the oncoming threat of television, the studios' answer to everything in the 1950's was apparently, "Let's make it bigger". The "issues" were bigger, the "emotions" were bigger, the "realism" was bigger, and sometimes the screen was just literally larger, but whatever the case, like a man with a bruised ego, it was all hot air. The only cinematic neophytes of the era who were able to cut through the hyperbole and find something meaningful were actors such as James Dean and Marlon Brando, the former who would not survive the excesses of the era, and the latter who would only be able to cover up serious emotional problems (including a massive eating disorder) for about the span of the decade. By the early to mid-1960's, the industry was in dire straits. People had tired of the tricks and gimmicks of the 1950's that had manage to slow the bleeding of the end of the studio era and after big-budget flops such as Tora, Tora, Tora, and Hello, Dolly!, the studios were at their wits end. Then the late 1960's came around (and more specifically, 1967) and the anointed "New Hollywood" and its forthcoming renaissance began. This new generation would go on to create the greatest decade in cinema history, 1970's, but it was in its roots, 1967, that you find the most exciting examples of cinema. The new auteurs were still honing their craft, but what they lacked in polish they made up for with an abundance of passion. This emotional devotion to creation is palpable, which is why 1967 is the brilliant year that it is. For the most part, though probably filled with old-timers of the Hollywood of yesteryear, the Academy did a decent job recognizing the films of the new generation. The largest glaring omission, and the film that is actually my favorite of the year, is Cool Hand Luke. The film and the character "Cool Hand Luke" is one of the coolest creations in film history, the ultimate rebel (a much less self-aware version of A Rebel Without a Cause), a true existential warrior. How the Academy passed over the film, especially in favor of one particularly miserable film I will be discussing briefly, is a mystery that I frankly don't want to uncover. Another great American film that should have received consideration for the top prize is The Dirty Dozen, a fun "group of men on a mission" movie that would later influence such great work as Quentin Tarantino's Inglourious Basterds. Finally, there are two films from around the era that certainly were deserving of Best Picture nominations but whose eligibility for the year 1967 is questionable. The first is Sergio Leone's The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly. The film was first released in 1966, but did not receive an American release until 1967, so I don't know what year the Academy would have considered it eligible. Whichever year it fell under the proper eligibility though, it definitely should have been nominated, although considering its undeniably genre-esque flourishes (some of which the movie helped establish), it was never going to be seriously considered by the Academy anyway. The last case is that of The Battle of Algiers, which is a strange case indeed. First released internationally in 1966, and receiving an Oscar nomination for Best Foreign Film that year, the film would not receive an American release until 1967. However, somehow the film managed to receive Oscar nominations for Best Director and Screenplay in 1968, hopping over 1967. Had it been eligible though, it too should have absolutely been included into the list of the year's five best films. Now though, it's on to the actual nominees.
5. Doctor Dolittle
In a year with such an abundance of great films, there is no excuse for why something as dreadful as Doctor Dolittle managed to receive an Oscar nomination for Best Picture, and this just isn't hindsight talking either. When the nominees were announced at the time, there was a huge outcry over Doctor Dolittle receiving a Best Picture nomination. The film was an absolute critical and commercial flop, pretty much ending the career of leading man Rex Harrison, and the casual observer was befuddled as to how such a universally derided film could receive praise from one of the most prestigious film bodies in the world. Insiders, while maybe dismayed, were not so flummoxed as to how the film managed to steal the nomination from a number of more worthy nominees. All they had to do, as is almost always the case, is follow the money.The studio behind the film, 20th Century Fox, held elaborate promotional parties for members of the Academy in hopes that their efforts would be reciprocated with Oscar nominations. Their efforts proved not to be in vain (dispelling the notion that only the Hollywood Foreign Press is open for bribes). In fairness towards the film in my own analysis, I should point out that it has been many years since I have seen the film, but my response was strong enough that I know it is not an experience that I wish to repeat. Doctor Dolittle, loosely based on novels by Hugh Lofting about a veterinarian who talks with animals, was an attempt by the studio to cash in on the recent musical successes of My Fair Lady and The Sound of Music, but while those films were adaptations of musicals that had already successfully debuted on stage, Doctor Dolittle was a haphazard attempt to duplicate those films and their monetary success. The result of this executive/committee made film is a paint-by-numbers affair that is exactly how it appears, a poor attempt to recreate something without any original voice or author. In other words, a complete and utter mess. The film has a score of 6.0 on IMDb, which is the lowest score I can recall seeing for a film nominated for Best Picture. The only thing from the film that has managed to partially stand the test of time, is the incredibly schmaltzy song "Talk with the Animals". When that's all you have to show for yourself, you don't have much to be proud of.
4. Guess Who's Coming To Dinner
Being the late 1960's, any Oscar lineup for Best Picture would be incomplete without some "issue" film that liberals could pat themselves on the back for nominating, proving once again how Hollywood is always "a step ahead" of most of the nation in terms of moral superiority (which George Clooney, I'm sure very reluctantly, had to point out during his Oscar acceptance speech in 2006). In this case, the crusade that Hollywood threw it's support behind was the Civil Rights Movement, and specifically in this film, taking up the flag for interracial marriage. As much as I usually dislike "soapbox" films (another frequent problem of films in the 1950's), 1967 was such a groovy year (to get into the parlance of the times) that even something as purely issue driven and reliant on a concept as Guess Who's Coming to Dinner is much better than it has any right being. I guess that's 1967 for you, just too damn cool to settle for the stereo-typical. Somewhat miraculously, Guess Who's Coming to Dinner manages to transcend it's contrived concept, on-the-nose dialogue, character manipulation, and it's all-around pompous, patronizing attitude. It manages do to this solely based on the film's primary strength: an amazing display of acting prowess by a brilliant, experienced cast (with the exception Katherine Houghton, who got the job simply by being Katherine Hepburn's niece). Katherine Hepburn, Sidney Poitier, and especially Spencer Tracy in his last role (he died just days after the completion of filming), all knock their roles out of the ballpark, somehow managing to create something real and compelling out of a concept that reeks of the inauthentic and convoluted. As I've said to others before, and will continual to say until I find a better example, no film owes more to it's actors than Guess Who's Coming to Dinner (Stanley Kramer should have denoted his earnings from the film to the actor's charity of choice), because thanks to its thespians, a film built purely on good intentions actually turned out to be a piece of compelling cinema in its own right.
3. Bonnie And Clyde
Originally viewed as a "B" movie by the studio (and as such, was initially only shown in small theaters and drive-ins), Bonnie and Clyde soon received raved reviews from critics as well as a quickly growing fanbase among the youth of America. Before the studio knew it, Bonnie and Clyde was the surprise hit of the year. Frankly though, I can't blame the studio for looking at the movie as a "B" movie, because in a lot of ways, that's exactly what it is. Based loosely on the string of Depression-era bank robberies committed by Clyde Barrow (Warren Beatty), Bonnie Parker (Faye Dunaway) and their gang, the film is not really concerned with getting all the small details of Bonnie and Clyde's life correct and instead opts for a more romanticized tale of misfits against the world. The film moves pretty quickly from one scene to the next, giving you the jest of what they're going for, and then without much nuance, jumps into to the next broad-stroked tableau. The film's use of violence, which was extremely controversial at the time, also feels a bit exploitative, which is yet another element the film has in common with its less widely acclaimed "B" movie brethren. Finally, the film has a real sense of fun, which is usually the only saving grace of the better "B" movies. Of course, the film is quite a few steps ahead of the average "B" movie in many departments. For one, the acting in Bonnie and Clyde, headlined by great performances from the two leads, is much better than your typical performances in the average cheap films of the day. The direction from Arthur Penn and the film's script (written by David Newman and Robert Benton, along with some uncredited contributions from Robert Towne) is also a notch or two above what you would expect from a "drive-in" film. Finally, probably my favorite part of the film, and the thing that really gives it some tonal cohesion, is its excellent use of Bluegrass music, with a soundtrack almost exclusively made up of Flatt & Scruggs & the Foggy Mountain Boys. While I don't quite see it as the classic that some do, Bonnie and Clyde was certainly befitting of the times, and another reason why 1967 was such a great year for the movies.
2. In The Heat Of The Night
The eventual winner of the award, In the Heat of Night is a prime example of how to make a great movie that tackles an "issue" (in this case, racism). Unlike Guess Who's Coming to Dinner, In the Heat of the Night doesn't rely on its actors to bail it out (although it too has great performances). Based on a novel by John Ball, the film tells the story of an African-American detective from Philadelphia, Virgil Tibbs (played with great poise by Sidney Poitier), who gets coerced into solving a murder mystery in the heart of the racist South. Along with the already existing tensions among the people of the town, each with their own dark secrets, the good ol' boys of the South don't none too appreciate a black man from the north poking the beehive, heightening the suspense even further than normal for noire-esque mysteries. And that's what so great about the movie, everything serves the purpose of the story. While it does tangentially (and effectively) touch on the issues of racism in the South at that period and time in America's history, it never does so at the expense of the film's tone. In the Heat of the Night is first and foremost a murder mystery, and it executes all the tropes of the genre with impeccable style and flawless confidence. Another strong point of the film is the authenticity of the characters. Not everyone in the small Mississippi town is racist to the same degree (like Rod Steiger's character for instance), and even Tibbs himself must overcome his (justified) prejudice to see the real truth of what's going on. When murder mysteries are done right, it is a hard genre to beat, and with a good story, excellent writing, assured direction, and career best performances from two very talented actors, In the Heat of the Night is one of the best in the genre.
1. The Graduate
The Graduate ranks among my all-time favorite films (probably in the top ten), and the film is one of the most unique movies in cinema history. I have yet to see any film, from any era, match the genius style and pacing of The Graduate. Simultaneously funny, insightful, sad, and romantic, this incredible combination is masterfully mixed by Mr. Mike Nichols into some coherent tale of existential angst. If you think The Graduate is just about some kid sleeping with some old lady (like I did going in), you're in for a big surprise. Based on a book by Charles Webb and adapted for the screen by Calder Willingham and Buck Henry, The Graduate tells the story of one Benjamin Braddock (in a superb performance by the great Dustin Hoffman), a recent college graduate who has now come home and is looking to embark on the journey called life. The only problem is Benjamin has absolutely zero clue what he wants to do with his life. He gets a lot of advice from his elders ("Plastics!"), but none of these ideas seem satisfactory to Benjamin. He is a soul adrift at sea, a man without purpose. Benjamin eventually finds some meaning to his life when he, somewhat reluctantly at first, strikes up an affair with a much older woman, Mrs. Robinson (Anne Bancroft), who happens to be the wife of his father's business associate. The tryst gives Benjamin something to hold onto, finally feeling not like a boy, but in his eyes, a real man. This false bravado evaporates though when, much to the dismay of Mrs. Robinson, he is forced by his parents to take the Robinson's daughter Elaine (Katherine Ross) out on a date. After an initial horrible start, the young couple soon fall in love, but Benjamin's affair with Mrs. Robinson soon threatens to end the relationship. Much more than this simple story though, it's how it's told, with humor, philosophy, and poetry, that makes The Graduate such a breathlessly impactful film. The film is an insane mix of emotions and styles that unintentionally illustrates what the medium of film can accomplish that no other art form can. The film famously also has a beautiful score composed by Simon and Garfunkel, in what has to be one of the most perfect image/music synching in the history of cinema. If you can't tell yet, I really love The Graduate, and as great as In the Heat of the Night is, The Graduate, without a doubt, would be my choice to win Best Picture of 1967. That concludes this article, but for the film historians among you, let me know in the comments section which films from this cinematically groundbreaking year you would have crowned champion had you been in the Academy in 1967.