Oscars 2014: 5 Things We Learned From Cannes

By appearances, the Cannes Film Festival and the Academy Awards may look like horses of two completely different colors. Cannes favors "high-art" films that push the boundaries of cinema; the Academy favors middle-brow films focusing on some "real-life" event. Cannes rewards groundbreaking auteurs with singular artistic visions; the Academy rewards actors who try their hand at directing. The Cannes awards are decided by a selective jury of esteemed figures in world cinema, the Academy's awards are decided by a large body of voters made up of predominantly older Hollywood insiders. Despite these cosmetic (and ideological) differences, the paths of the Cannes Film Festival and the Academy Awards cross more often than you might think. Particularly in recent years, with films like No Country for Old Men, The Tree of Life, The Artist, and Amour, we have seen that films receiving critical approval from the Croisette can often turn that goodwill into a sustained, successful campaign that eventuates into Oscar glory come February. This is why Cannes now marks the unofficial start of the Oscar season. Sure, the season doesn't really heat up until the trifecta of Venice, Telluride, and Toronto around late August and early September, but only the laziest and most pig-headed of Oscar prognosticators would ignore the potential of films coming out of Cannes. So why we may have a full summer left to go of mostly vapid popcorn-munching blockbusters before the prestige season really kicks in, here is five crucial lessons Cannes taught us about 2014's upcoming Oscar season, as well as a few other bonus notes and musings on potential awards players emerging out of Southern France.

5. The Palme d'Or Best Picture Streak Is Done

Blue is the Warmest Color Over the past two years, rather improbably, the winner of Cannes' most prestigious award, the Palme d'Or, has managed to garner enough support within the artistic-leaning sect of the Academy to achieve a surprise Best Picture nomination. First in 2011 was Terrence Malick and his ethereal, experimental meditation on God, the Cosmos, and the relationship between child and parents, The Tree of Life. Given that film's free-flowing, non-narrative style, it was surprising to see The Tree of Life make it into the Best Picture lineup (even with an expanded field), but Malick had been previously successful with the Academy. German auteur Michael Haneke on the other hand has never been simpatico with the Academy, so despite his good reputation among cinephiles, it was quite the achievement last year for Haneke's Amour to receive both the Palme d'Or and a Best Picture nomination, the first completely foreign-produced, foreign-language film to do so since Ang Lee's Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon. The third time will most likely not be the charm though with this year's Palme d'Or winner, Blue is the Warmest Color. While Abdellatif Kechiche's film may be a perfectly wonderful movie, the chances of a 3-hour, French coming-of-age lesbian film, with purported graphic and gratuitous sex scenes, being successful at the Academy Awards is slim to none. Given the amount of universal praise the film is receiving from critics, Blue is the Warmest Color might have a shot in the Foreign Film category, but it's not even certain yet whether the French will choose it as their representative. In fact, another well-received premiere on the Croisette, Asghar Farhadi's follow up to A Seperation, The Past, may well end up being France's choice du jour for the Academy this year (although whether the claim on the film's Oscar chances belongs to France or Iran is unclear at this point). While its chances at the Oscars are probably better than 2010's Palme d'Or winner, Uncle Boonmme Who Can Recall His Past Lives, anyone involved with Blue is the Warmest Color shouldn't get their hopes up.

4. 2013 Won't Be As Vintage As 2012 For The Weinstein Company

It has become an annual tradition at Cannes for Harvey Weinstein to preview his slate of upcoming prestige films in an E3-esque style presentation. Last year, he really stoked the fires and got the salivary glands of cineastes working overtime with his preview of such highly anticipated films as The Master, Silver Linings Playbook, and Django Unchained. This year, his preview mainly focused on the unveiling of clips and trailers for the Nicole Kidman-starring Grace Kelly biopic, Grace of Monaco, and the Idris Elba and Naomi Harris two-hander, Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom, as well as previews of two films that later premiered at Cannes, Only God Forgives and The Immigrant. While it is obviously somewhat perilous to put too much stock in analysis of a film's awards chances based on clips or trailers, from the sound of it (and this correlates with my gut instinct anyway), Grace of Monaco will most likely end up being nothing more than a play for a Best Actress nomination for Nicole Kidman. Ditto goes for Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom, which, with a trailer some said was akin to an action flick in tone, will probably have its best shot at an Oscar nod with Naomi Harris' performance, and maybe Idris Elba too if his category isn't overly competitive. Biopics, such as these two films, often end up being nothing more than vehicles for actors to show off their imitative abilities (i.e. My Week with Marilyn and Hitchcock for two recent examples), and without any big name directors behind the cameras, that is most likely what we will get with these two flicks. Weinstein also showed a few trailers for films that have already been previewed or seen by some, such as The Butler, Grandmasters, Ain't Them Bodies Saints, and Fruitvale Station, but none ignited the anticipatory fever of too many pundits. Now it is true that Weinstein's heaviest awards hitter, August: Osage County, was MIA at the presentation, but even if August ends up sweeping every award in sight, I think it is safe to say that when considered in totality, the lineup of films at the Weinstein Company this year won't be as well remembered as their platter of classic cinematic offerings they brought forth onto cinema-goers last year.

3. Only God Forgives Indeed

Only-God-Forgives Maybe the single most anticipated film of Cannes this year, especially among the uber-chic hipster crowd, was Nicolas Winding Refn's Only God Forgives. Refn's last film, Drive, as with his newest feature, teamed him up with the ever-growing-in-popularity Ryan Gosling. The film was the hit film among the "in-crowd" in 2011, and if you were anybody who was somebody, you made sure to be vocal about how much you liked the film. (I enjoyed Drive myself, but not at the same level that its passionate and vociferous fanbase did). You can imagine then the hype surrounding the second Refn-Ryan collaboration. With a sleek sexy trailer, bathed in the neon-sepia color palette of underground Bangkok, and an intriguing premise about a boxer ordered by his gangster queen mother to seek revenge for his brother's murder, Only God Forgives promised to offer up more of the detached, Euro-posh, super violence that made Drive so in vogue just two short years ago. So what could possibly go wrong, right? Right?! The film has been savaged by many a critic (including WhatCulture's own Simon Gallagher, who was compelled enough by his dislike for the film to write a separate article detailing 5 reasons why you will hate the film).

2. It's More Of The Same With Alexander Payne

Nebraska 2 One of the biggest potential Oscar contenders to premiere at Cannes was Alexander Payne's film, Nebraska. In a script not written by Payne (a rarity for him) but by relative newcomer Bob Nelson, the film stars veteran character actor Bruce Dern as an elderly man who believes he is the winner of some sweep stakes prize with a pile of cash just waiting to be picked up in Nebraska. His son (Will Forte) decides to humor his father and takes him on a road trip from Billings, Montana to Nebraska in order to point out his father's increasing senility. Along the way of course, they meet a colorful cast of characters and come to a better understanding of one another. Made to aesthetically evoke classic 1970's black-and-white pictures such as Peter Bogdanovich's The Last Picture Show and Paper Moon, the film promised to be a classic comedy/drama mix that should hit the sweet spot for your typical Academy voter, but how was it received at Cannes you ask? Well... lukewarmly would probably be the most apt description, but frankly, that's good enough. Since the film's premiere and subsequent apathetic reaction among critics, I've heard a few Oscar prognosticators dismiss the film's chances at a Best Picture nomination, but they do so at their own risk. Nebraska is a film that was never meant to please the type of international critics that attend the Cannes film festival, in fact, it needn't even please that many film critics in general. If you will remember back to 2011, The Descendants was a film that was hardly beloved by all. In fact, the film's critics were quite vocal about its flaws, but it had just enough of a support base among the critics community, and more importantly, among the Academy's voters themselves, to gin up multiple Oscar nominations. This is why I think it is so incredibly short sighted of those who proclaim the film too "slight" to receive serious Oscar attention. Too slight to according to who, you? A film critic whose taste align with that of Oscars only occasionally. While it's true the film lacks the star power of a George Clooney like The Descendants, and the earlier bow will allow the more negative opinions on the film enough time to gestate and possibly shape the perception of Nebraska, I would not write off this film yet, or prepare for some egg on your face come year's end.

1. CBS Films Or Not, Inside Lewyn Davis is a Genuine, Bona Fide Awards Player

inside Llewyn Davis 2 On my initial list of possible 2014 Best Picture nominees, I had Inside Llewyn Davis ranked at the sixteenth spot. This was not due to any dislike of the Coens or disinterest in Lweyn Davis (in fact it's quite the opposite, as the Coens are some of my favorite filmmakers and Inside Llewyn Davis is one of my most hotly anticipated films of the year), but merely because the film struck me as to small to garner enough buzz for a Best Picture nomination. The film, which centers on the folk music scene during the early 1960's, seemed like a smaller-scale film in the vein of A Serious Man, but without the serious subject matter or semi-autobiographical nature of that film, it seemed unlikely that Inside Llewyn Davis could sneak into the expanded Best Picture lineup, as A Serious Man managed to do back in 2009. It strikes me now at this time just how established the Coens are in being monumental figures on the landscape of cinema. While their films may have started out with humble independent beginnings, since their debut film Blood Simple,they have managed to win awards multiple times at the Cannes Film Festival, and if Inside Lewyn Davis does manage a Best Picture nomination, it will be the Coens' fourth film out of their last five to do so. They are unarguably among the cinematic giants of their generation. Beyond Best Picture, the film is assuredly in line for a Best Original Screenplay nomination, as well as a possible Best Director nomination for the brothers. There was much praise for the lead turn from the up-and-coming Oscar Issac, but if his performance is relatively subdued compared to the competition, it might not strike the Actors branch as flashy enough to deserve nomination.

In this post: 
Cannes 2013
 
Posted On: 
Editor-in-chief
Editor-in-chief

Matt Holmes is the co-founder of What Culture, formerly known as Obsessed With Film. He has been blogging about pop culture and entertainment since 2006 and has written over 10,000 articles.