Oscars 2014: Who Is Winning The Best Director Race?

122

As an auteurist, Best Director, maybe even more than Best Picture, is the Oscar category that most fascinates me. The interesting thing about the category is that it tends to simultaneously be both a point of pride and shame for the Academy Awards. On the one hand, the Directors branch has done a decent job of nominating directors who push and expand the boundaries of cinema, regardless of the genre they work in and from whichever country they hail from. Directors such as Alfred Hitchcock, Federico Fellini, Stanley Kubrick, Ingmar Bergman, John Cassavetes, Francois Truffaut, David Lynch, Akira Kurosawa, and Spike Jonze have all seen recognition in this category (some multiple times) for films that received very little attention from any other branches of the Academy. On the other hand, when it comes to actually crowning a Best Director (which is a job given to the Academy as a whole, not just the Director's branch), the Academy's record isn't so sterling. All of the aforementioned directors have never won the Best Director Oscar, while directors such as Tony Richardson, Barry Levinson, Kevin Costner, and Tom Hooper all have. Clearly, something's not right. However, when long over-due directors have finally received their golden statuettes, it has made for some of the best moments of Oscar history. In recent memory, perhaps my favorite moments in Oscar history came in the back-to-back years of 2007 and 2008 when the Best Director award was handed out to Martin Scorsese and the Coen Brothers, respectively. In all honesty though, more than even joy for these masterful directors, the main emotion I felt was relief, relief for the Academy that they wouldn't have to live with yet another embarrassing factoid that neither Martin Scorsese or the Coen Bros. had never won a Best Director Oscar. This is why every year I anticipate this category, hoping that the Academy will be able to mark off another preeminent director off their checklist before it becomes too late to recognize some of the numerously talented auteurs who have yet to win the Oscar. Fortunately though, with the abundance of riches of talented directors doing top tier work this year, the Academy is going to have to work overtime in order to screw this up (as long as John Lee Hancock doesn't win... just kidding... maybe). The two leading candidates for the award, Steve McQueen and Alfonso Cuaron, are both would-be first-time nominees, but beyond this, the field is chock-full of respected names, many of which have previously been nominated in this category. Between the likes of Martin Scorsese, Woody Allen, Joel and Ethan Coen, David O. Russell, Paul Greengrass, Alexander Payne, Spike Jonze, Lee Daniels, and Jason Reitman, there have been a lot of cumulative Oscar nominations in the group of potential nominees. As we saw last year with the somewhat surprising inclusions of Michael Haneke and Benh Zeitlin over the surprising omissions of Ben Affleck and Kathryn Bigelow, the Directors branch holds its own court, which can make it difficult (and exciting) to predict if you're an Oscar prognosticator such as myself. Inevitably then, my predictions for this category are likely to change occasionally (maybe even daily, or hourly) all the way up until the announcement of the nominees. As of this time though, right here right now, in our current coordinates of Space-Time, these are my predictions for the 2014 Best Director lineup.

1. Alfonso Cuaron - Gravity

Gravity Gravity In the Best Picture race, I currently have 12 Years a Slave slightly ahead of Gravity, but in the Best Director race, I have Alfonso Cuaron slightly ahead of Steve McQueen. Why the swap you ask? While in reality both films and directors are pretty much in a dead heat, I'm giving Cuaron the microscopic edge over McQueen for two reasons. The first reason is because Gravity is such as visual film, and as such, will likely be thought of in the minds of your average Academy voter as having a, "director's stamp," so to speak. Not to say that McQueen's 12 Years a Slave doesn't have a prominent and distinct visual aesthetic, because it most certainly does and its aesthetic qualities play a significant role in shaping the overall tone of the film, but the aesthetically 12 Years a Slave is much more subtle than Gravity and subtlety is almost never a bonus in the eyes of the Academy. The second reason I decided to place Cauron ahead of McQueen is because of the much publicized struggle Cauron had to even get Gravity onto the silver screen. Cuaron spent over four years of his life making Gravity. Some of this lengthy development process was due to technological limitations and the learning curve associated with expanding such limitations, but other times it was simply because of the typical hesitance the Hollywood system has with funding expensive non-derivative projects. Gravity was originally set up at Universal Studios (with Robert Downey Jr. and Angelina Jolie attached), but when this fell through, Cuaron was forced to set up shop at Warner Bros. Luckily for Cuaron (and the movie-going public), Warner Bros. took a role of the dice and green lit a $100 million+ budget for a film about astronauts floating adrift in space. Given the current state of production at the major movie studios, many a director may vote for Cauron out of principle, in order to support the minor miracle that this film got made at all. Nomination Chances: 97%

2. Steve McQueen - 12 Years A Slave

Steve Mcqueen Steve McQueen, not to be confused with the legendary actor of films like The Great Escape, has been an up-and-coming director since his debut film, Hunger, back in 2008. That film won him numerous awards, including the Camera d'Or at the Cannes film festival, but it wasn't until his next film, Shame, that his work got any serious Oscar buzz. While his frequent thespian collaborator, Michael Fassbender, received a Golden Globe nomination for his work in the NC-17 rated film, when the final Best Actor nominations were announced, Fassbender's name was nowhere to be seen (which may very well likely have been due to the film's touchy subject matter of sex addiction). It is with his third feature film, 12 Years a Slave, that Steve McQueen has officially made it into the mainstream. Based on the autobiography of a 19th Century free African-American man who was tricked and kidnapped into slavery in the South, while the film tackles the difficult subject of slavery in America (an issue that has seldom been explored in a serious manner up until this point), it is still accessible enough to let the Academy recognize the talent behind the work. While some feared the film could prove too brutal for Academy members to stomach, and there have been articles written on what a "tough sit" the film is, the truth of the matter is that the film is done in such an elegant and dispassionate manner, without lessening the cruelty of the institution of slavery, that only the most squeamish will be unable to see the film for the achievement it is. We also have some empirical evidence, such as the film's Audience Award at the Toronto Film Festival, that not only can audiences stomach the film's stark presentation, but they are actually appreciating the frank depiction. The real question now then is not if McQueen will be nominated, but can he win Best Director? The answer to that question remains to be seen. Nomination Chances: 96%

3. Paul Greengrass - Captain Phillips

Paul Greengrass Captain Phillips Unlike the first two entrees in this article, Paul Greengrass has been here before. Back in 2006, Greengrass received a Best Director nomination from his fellow directors for his film recreating another "taken from the headlines" story, United 93, dealing with the plane crash of the titular flight that was hijacked by Islamic terrorists on 9/11. This time, yet again dealing with another hijacking, Greengrass has brought to cinematic life the true story of a U.S. cargo ship that was taken hostage by Somali pirates, led by the eponymous Captain Phillips (Tom Hanks). Given the fact that the Academy has already shown their love for Greengrass' style in the past, and that if the Best Picture "race" were truly a race, Captain Phillips would surely be in third place at the moment, I feel pretty confident that Greengrass will be among the five nominees for Best Director. If he were to miss to the cut though, here are some possible reasons why. The first primary reason why the Directors branch might consider passing Greengrass over is the "been-there-done-that" effect. As I eluded to above, there really are a lot of similarities between Captain Phillips and the previous film Greengrass was nominated for, United 93, so given what a competitive field Best Director is this year, some in the branch may look elsewhere to reward something that hasn't already been awarded before. Greengrass' now patented cinematographic style, with shaky camera, uncomfortable close-ups, and lightning fast editing (which I thought frankly detracted from an otherwise well made film), a style which seemed new and edgy back in 2006 but feels a bit played out now, could also count against Greengrass. Finally, and unfortunately, some rumblings of inaccuracies in the film could conceivably prevent Greengrass from a nomination as well. Personally, I think we can count Greengrass as a fairly certain nominee, but I also thought that about Kathryn Bigelow last year for Zero Dark Thirty, and given how competitive of a year this is shaping up to be, we can't be too certain about anything. Nomination Chances: 80%

4. David O. Russell - American Hustle

David O Russell American Hustle This is where it gets really hard. In fact, it's a god damned nightmare to try to make choices between the likes of David O. Russell, Martin Scorsese, Joel and Ethan Coen, Woody Allen, Spike Jonze, and Alexander Payne. All of these directors are highly esteemed auteurs among cinephiles (of which there are surely many in the Directors branch) and most them have been fairly successful in their past with the Academy. For my choice among these greats though, I decided to double down on my bet that American Hustle is going to be a major Academy Awards player, thus placing David O. Russell ahead of the competitive field. Russell has the feel of a director working in his prime. After his career seemed on the verge of collapse after the flop of I Heart Huckabees and his reputation of being a director who couldn't keep his cool (he has had infamously angry dustups with the likes of George Clooney and Lily Tomlin), Russell managed a remarkable comeback with the comeback-boxer story of The Fighter that earned him his first ever Best Director nomination. He followed that success last year with the enormously popular Silver Linings Playbook, which earned him his second Best Director nomination. It would seem then that Russell is on a role with the Academy, and even though American Hustle has yet to be seen, this is why I'm betting hard on the film to be a major awards season player. Russell has assembled an incredibly impressive cast for the film, and even more than his own Oscar successes, Russell has proven to have the Midas touch with getting his actors Oscar nominations (8 total in his last two movies). Whether it's the actors who have made Russell look good, or whether it really is Russell's brilliant direction doesn't matter, because either way, it's got to help Russell's odds. Nomination Chances: 40%

5. Martin Scorsese - The Wolf Of Wall Street

The Wolf Of Wall Street For the last, and very difficult, choice of likely Best Director nominees, I decided to pick Martin Scorsese for The Wolf of Wall Street. Now the fact that out of all the very plausible nominees for Best Director, I picked the two directors of films which have yet to be seen by anybody may illustrate that I'm stupidly optimistic, but I do think there is a solid basis for both of these choices. While the legendary director got off to somewhat of a rocky start with the Academy early in his career (the lack of a nomination for Taxi Driver is still unfathomable to me), since 2002, he has been one of the Academy's favorite sons. In fact, every single feature film of Scorsese's with the exception of Shutter Island has been nominated for Best Picture (Gangs of New York, The Aviator, The Departed, and Hugo), so the man is definitely on a roll. Now many pundits are concerned that the tone of The Wolf of Wall Street is simply too darkly comedic to receive any major Oscar play. The excellent trailers for the film released thus far certainly seem to confirm the edgy-comedic tone of Scorsese's latest, and while this may be a concern for its chances at landing a Best Picture nomination, I really don't see it as being an issue with the Directors branch. After all, this is the branch that has nominated directors for films like 8 & 1/2, Dr. Stangelove, and Being John Malkovich. The biggest obstacle I see in Mr. Scorsese landing yet another nomination is simply the competition. As I already mentioned a couple of times, this is a highly competitive Best Director field, and I could see a number of different names taking this slot. In particular, I was extremely close to including the Coen Brothers in this spot instead of Scorsese, but the supposed low key nature of Inside Llewyn Davis, as opposed to the apparent gonzo-stylings of The Wolf of Wall Street, made me decide in favor of Scorsese, as the Coen's more subtle work is not as commonly recognized. Even with their recent success with the Academy, the Coen's couldn't manage a Best Director nomination for A Serious Man, and I can see that path materializing again. Whoever does or doesn't end up making it though, it is going to be one hell of a race this year, and there are going to be a lot of disappointed people when the nominees are finally unveiled. Nomination Chances: 35%

Dark Horse Contenders

1. Joel and Ethan Coen for Inside Llweyn Davis2. Spike Jonze for Her3. Woody Allen for Blue Jasmine4. Alexander Payne for Nebraska5. John Lee Hancock for Saving Mr. Banks

Long Shot Contenders

Richard Linklater1. J.C. Chandor for All Is Lost2. Lee Daniels for Lee Daniels' The Butler3. Richard Linklater for Before Midnight4. Stephen Frears for Philomena5. Jean-Marc Vallee for Dallas Buyers Club

Contributor
Contributor

A film fanatic at a very young age, starting with the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle movies and gradually moving up to more sophisticated fare, at around the age of ten he became inexplicably obsessed with all things Oscar. With the incredibly trivial power of being able to chronologically name every Best Picture winner from memory, his lifelong goal is to see every Oscar nominated film, in every major category, in the history of the Academy Awards.