Oscars 2015: Best Actress Predictions

The 5 leading ladies who will be competing for this year's top individual award.

The most coveted of all awards for female thespians, the list of actresses who have won the Oscar for Best Actress reads like a hall of fame of actresses. Katherine Hepburn, Bette Davis, Vivien Leigh, Audrey Hepburn, Elizabeth Taylor, Sophia Loren, Meryl Streep, Jodie Foster, Julia Roberts, Nicole Kidman, Kate Winslett, Jennifer Lawrence and Cate Blanchett are just some of the illustrious actresses who have been crowned the year's best female performance by the Academy in past years. It's quite an impressive list that any ingénue with Hollywood stardom on the mind would love to join, but only one actress each year may be added to the list. Which new actress will join the prestigious list this year? Or may a previous winner add on to their Oscar tally? As has become the trend in recent years, the list of actresses with a legitimate shot at contending for the award isn't exactly overflowing. With precursor awards' nomination lists from groups such as the Golden Globes, Screen Actors Guild, and the Broadcast Film Critics Association having an almost identical lineup, it appears this year's Best Actress nominees may already be set in stone. However, the slightly askew nature of this year's Oscar race, with many of the studios "heavy hitters" playing second fiddle to indie films such as Boyhood, may prove the 2015 Oscar nominations to be more prone to surprise candidates than usual. For now though, the following five leading ladies, listed from least likely to be nominated to most likely to be nominated, will probably end up being this year's roster of Best Actress nominees. Although here's to hoping for a surprise or two come January 15.


5. Jennifer Aniston - Cake

That's right, Rachel from Friends may soon be an Oscar nominee. There are a couple of fringe candidates that could spoil Aniston's chances of becoming the first (and surely only) member of the Friends cast to receive an Oscar nomination, but their chances grow slimmer and slimmer by the day and the only potential spoiler to Aniston's Oscar hopes that has a legitimate shot at pulling off the surprise nomination is former Oscar winner Marion Cotillard. The Parisian-born actress actually appeared in two movies this year, The Immigrant and Two Days, One Night, that could see Cotillard receive her second Oscar nomination. However, both films are likely to be too under the radar to build up enough traction for a nomination, which brings us back to Aniston. In Cake, Aniston plays a mentally unstable women who strikes up a relationship with a recent widower only to be confronted with hallucinations of the man's dead wife. The film, which debuted at this year's Toronto Film Festival to a lukewarm reception, is said to be a self-consciously serious drama about mental illness. Even those who are less than enthusiastic about the film itself though have had good things to say about Aniston's performance, which is why she is likely to find herself with her first ever Oscar nomination. Aniston may not be exactly the most chic pick for an Oscar nomination amongst high-brow critics organizations, but the Academy has never been on their wave length anyway. Unless a large majority of Academy members get to their screeners of either Two Days, One Night or The Immigrant and love Cotillard's performance in one of the films, Aniston will have finally graduated from Emmy nominee to Oscar nominee.

4. Reese Witherspoon - Wild

The following four actresses on this list are guaranteed to be nominated in this year's Best Actress race. In fact, their nominations are so predictable that its sureness puts Old Faithful to shame. However, theoretically speaking, if you had to say which of the actresses could possibly, in some bizarre-o parallel universe, miss out on the nomination, it would probably be Reese Witherspoon. This isn't meant as a commit on Ms. Witherspoon's acting abilities or her performance in Wild, which is actually quite impressive, but rather an observation on the Academy's reception of the film. Last year, Jean-Marc Vallee's Dallas Buyers Club proved to be extremely popular among Academy members, earning the film's stars Matthew McConaughey and Jared Leto their first Oscars, but Wild, Vallee's newest film, has not caught on fire the way Dallas Buyers Club. Particularly troubling for the film is the way Laura Dern's Best Supporting Actress campaign has almost totally dissipated in a relatively weak year for the category. However, Reese Witherspoon is her own woman, and even those who have been critical of Wild itself have cited Witherspoon's performance as the highlight of the film. Witherspoon portrays Cheryl Strayed, a woman who had hit rock bottom, using hard drugs and having sex with random strangers after the passing of her mother. In order to gain some semblance of who she use to be, Strayed decided to hike the Pacific Crest Trail, an arduous 1,100 mile trek through the deserts and mountains of the varied Pacific Cost terrain. Witherspoon's performance is a powerful and emotional one. Much like McConaughey's performance in Dallas Buyer's Club, it is a relatively low-key performance that is most effective in the film's quieter moments. Witherspoon's Cheryl is a woman left totally devastated by the loss of the warmest influence in her life, her mother, but this devastation is never overwrought in Witherspoon's hands, but rather appropriately melancholy. It is the type of performance that is both good and within the somewhat limited taste of Academy members. This means, barring some undercurrent of apathy or hate towards the film, expect Witherspoon to receive her second Oscar nomination.

3. Rosamund Pike - Gone Girl

Fincher's Gone Girl proved to be one of the more successful films of the fall movie season, grossing over $165 million in the United States, which has many an Oscar pundit began predicting that Gone Girl could be a major Oscar player, believing the film could ride its popularity into a Best Picture nomination despite its grim subject matter and sardonic tone. Thus far the film's Best Picture prospects are still up in the air, with a few key victories from certain critics groups here and there, but not enough to assure it of a forthcoming Best Picture nomination. However, even if the film shoots blanks in every other category, one nomination that Gone Girl will most certainly obtain is a Best Actress nomination for Rosamund Pike's lead performance. Starring as the eponymous Gone Girl, Rosamund Pike is the crown of Fincher's unrelentingly cynical take on both relationships and the media's obsession with forming narratives in missing persons cases. It's hard to discuss Pike's performance as Amy Dunne without getting into major spoiler territory for those that have not seen the film, but needless to say, Pike's Amy is one of the more memorable female performances of the year. It's the type of performance that demands your attention and does not let go. The dark nature of Gone Girl leaves open the slightest chance that Pike could miss a nomination if Academy members are feeling especially stuffy, but chances of that happening are virtually zero. Pike has been cited by a number of regional critics groups as the Best Actress of the year so don't be surprised if Pike pulls off the upset when the Oscars are actually handed out.

2. Felicity Jones - The Theory Of Everything

If there were a book entitled, "How To Be Nominated For An Academy Award When You're An Actor", the first chapter would be called "Play A Famous Person (Or Someone Related To Them)". The history of the Academy Awards is filled with both acting nominees and winners who either played a character based on a famous real life figure or a character who was important in the life of a famous real life figure. The Academy eats up performances in biopics like a fat man consumes pies in a state fair eating competition, except the Academy never seems to get full. Which brings us to Felicity Jones' performance in The Theory of Everything, one of the choice du jour biopics of this year's awards season. Jones plays Jane Hawking, the wife of famous theoretical physicist Stephen Hawking, the man who helped expand humanity's understanding of black holes. Stephen Hawking was tragically struck by ALS (more commonly referred to as Lou Gehrig's Disease) while he was attending Cambridge, and the onset of the disease and the couple's courageous attempts to deal with its consequences is the central focus of The Theory of Everything. Jones gets to play the part of the burdened loving wife, but while it may be easy to pigeonhole the role in the "cliché" corner, Jones actually does a rather good job of fleshing out Jane Hawking as a full character. Jane's hardships go beyond those of the obvious physical inconveniences of Stephen's disease, as the man's extreme intelligence also makes him sarcastic and unpleasant at times. Their relationship is a complicated one and all the different emotions between husband and wife are brought to life by the subtle gestures and expressions in Jones' face. The Theory of Everything appears destined to be one of those films that receives a multitude of nominations from Academy in January, but goes home empty-handed come February. In fact, in terms of their chances at actually winning the Oscar, Rosamund Pike is probably more likely to win than Felicity Jones, but while some members of the Academy may be turned off from nominating Pike due to the film's harsh tone, almost all of the Academy will eat up Jones' turn in The Theory of Everything.

1. Julianne Moore - Still Alice

Still Alice seemingly came out of nowhere. Premiering at this year's Toronto International Film Festival, the film received minimal buzz beforehand, but upon its debut, Moore's performance became one of the biggest headlines coming out of Canada with Moore an instant Best Actress contender. Fast forward five months later and not only is Moore's performance in the film still around in the Best Actress conversation, but she remains the presumed frontrunner to win the Oscar itself. In Still Alice, Moore plays Dr. Alice Howland, a linguistics professor who is diagnosed with Alzheimer's disease at a relatively young age. The film which also features the likes of Alec Baldwin and Kristin Stewart, is said to deal with the family's coping of Alice's deteriorating mental health. While Moore's performance has received universal praise from the critics community, the film itself has received mixed-to-positive notices, but then for a role like this, the Academy's reception of the film is actually pretty irrelevant. As crude as it may sound, playing someone who is diseased or disabled is a big plus in the eyes of the Academy. Even films that have been maligned by critics and audiences alike have managed to secure their actors Oscar nominations when they play characters with either physical or mental disadvantages. The Academy's Acting Branch seems to give high marks for degree of difficulty when their fellow thespians take on these types of roles. There is also the fact that Moore herself is a four-time Oscar nominee who has yet to win the Academy Award. Moore is highly regarded among critics and her fellow actors, so even if some Academy members aren't totally enthralled with her performance in Still Alice, they may still vote for her in order to see her win her first Oscar. Narratives can be key in any Oscar race and a narrative for Moore's Oscar victory is one any publicist would die for. However, unlike some of this year's other acting races, Best Actress might not be as predictable as some pundits would have you believe. Julianne Moore in undoubtedly the favorite at the moment, but watch the race closely through January and February as it may evolve into a much tighter affair than anyone is expecting. How would you rank this year's Best Actress race? Share your thoughts in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

A film fanatic at a very young age, starting with the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle movies and gradually moving up to more sophisticated fare, at around the age of ten he became inexplicably obsessed with all things Oscar. With the incredibly trivial power of being able to chronologically name every Best Picture winner from memory, his lifelong goal is to see every Oscar nominated film, in every major category, in the history of the Academy Awards.