Oscars 2016 Nominations: 15 Insane Shocks & Snubs

What a day! What a lovely day!

The nominations have been unveiled for the 88th Academy Awards, and as ever, it's a mixture of jubilation and disappointment, as blockbusters and indies alike fared unexpectedly well in the field, while a number of obvious picks were inexplicably snubbed. No film fan is ever going to come away from the nominations announcement 100% satisfied, and so it's time to look at the big shocks and depressing snubs which characterised this year's set of nods. Though the Best Picture winner feels pretty sewn up at this point, a number of categories (namely Best Director) have been crowbarred wide open by some of the unexpected contenders to enter the fray, so hopefully this year's ceremony won't be another boring and predictable one. We'll have to wait until February 28th to know for sure, but until then, here are 15 shocks and snubs from this year's Oscar nominations...

15. Snub: Carol Misses Out On Best Picture

The exclusion of Todd Haynes' highly acclaimed, Oscar-buzzed period drama was all the more shocking because there were only eight Best Picture nominees announced this year, yet it seems that Carol didn't meet the minimum threshold in the controversial preferential ballot system, and so shocked everyone by missing out. This one pretty much seemed like a lock, and so it's a huge surprise that the film has gone from being a front-runner for winning the big one outright to getting shut out in just a few short months. Such is the fickle nature of Oscar.

14. Shock: Ex Machina & Straight Outta Compton Beat Quentin Tarantino For Best Original Screenplay

One of the most unpredictable categories this year was the Best Original Screenplay field, which saw Ex Machina and Straight Outta Compton getting nominated, while Quentin Tarantino's The Hateful Eight missed out. Though it's just expected that a QT film will get a screenplay nod these days, it's likely that Oscar voters were turned off by his film's excessive run-time, which has been deemed self-indulgent in some quarters. It seems that the Academy's patience with Tarantino's refusal to self-edit has finally come back to bite him. On the other hand, it was fantastic to see two movies that weren't really in the Oscar conversation much at all get recognised, especially Compton, which very few surely saw coming.

13. Shock: The Good Dinosaur & Peanuts Miss Out On Best Animated Feature

Pixar's The Good Dinosaur and The Peanuts Movie both missed out on Best Animated Feature nods, their places instead being taken by the $500,000 Brazilian film Boy and the World, and Studio Ghibli's When Marnie Was There. Though neither The Good Dinosaur nor Peanuts were particularly great films, their ridiculously high profile and campaigning budgets compared to the latter two made most assume that they would sneak into the five. In fairness, Pixar was already competing against itself (a vastly superior film in Inside Out, no less, which got nominated), so it's hard to be disappointed, just hugely surprised. Even though Inside Out and Anomalisa are the only serious contenders in the group, it's always fun to have an underdog or two in the fight.


12. Snub: Steve Jobs For Best Adapted Screenplay

The Best Adapted Screenplay category was a fairly solid selection of nominees, including The Big Short, Brooklyn, Carol, The Martian and Room, but where the hell was Aaron Sorkin for his fantastic work on Steve Jobs? The likely answer is that the movie's poor box office performance caused it to divebomb with voters, but even so, given Sorkin's legendary status in the industry and the endless praise that has been heaped on his work here, it's pretty shocking that he didn't get the rub. Or perhaps the contentious nature of Jobs' character was enough for voters to be turned off by Sorkin's beautiful work, though that wouldn't explain why Fassbender still scored a Best Actor nomination.

11. Shock: Spectre Beats Furious 7 For Best Original Song

After winning the Golden Globe for Best Original Song, Sam Smith's "Writing on the Wall" for Spectre has also picked up a Best Original Song Oscar nod, despite being the most maligned Bond song in years and being generally accepted to be a fairly lazy, effortless Bond theme. More frustratingly, it beat out the widely acclaimed Wiz Khalifa song from Furious 7, "See You Again", which was widely expected to make the five nominees for its moving tribute to the late Paul Walker. If Smith wins the Oscar, we riot.

10. Shock: Sicario Gets Three Nominations

Though Denis Villeneuve's riveting thriller scored high acclaim upon release, it's flown incredibly low as far as awards prospects go, so it was a surprise to see the film end up with three nominations, even if many believe it also deserved recognition for Best Picture, Director and Supporting Actor. Sicario scored massively unexpected nods for Best Original Score and Sound Editing, while Roger Deakins nailed his 13th nomination (without a single win, no less) for Best Cinematography, though sadly he's dead-set to lose out yet again to Emmanuel Lubezki (The Revenant). It deserves more, but hey, it still did much better than expected.

9. Snub: Going Clear For Best Documentary

The Best Documentary Feature field is notorious for its ridiculous snubs of highly-praised films, and the casualty this year was that Alex Gibney's Scientology doc Going Clear: Scientology and the Prison of Belief, which was widely touted to be a front-runner in the category. Naturally many are going to speculate that Scientology may have compromised voters in the category somehow, and given the movie's important message about a horrifying organisation, its snub is a damn shame.

8. Shock: Star Wars Beats The Martian For Best Film Editing

With Spotlight getting a rather undeserved Best Film Editing nomination, this meant that one film that actually did deserve it was going to get shut out, and that unfortunately was The Martian. Given the high complexity of the production and lengthy but superbly-paced run-time, it was more deserving of the nod than almost every other film in the category (except perhaps for Mad Max: Fury Road). Extra surprising was the fact that Star Wars: The Force Awakens scored a nomination here also, considering that its other four nods were in fairly "soft" technical categories such as Visual Effects, Sound Mixing & Editing, and Original Score.

7. Snub: No Best Makeup For Black Mass

The Makeup & Hairstyling category frequently only selects three nominees, but how on Earth was the sublimely creepy work on Johnny Depp in Black Mass not nominated? The spoiler came in the form of little-seen indie film The 100-year-old Man Who Climbed Out a Window and Disappeared, which features a plethora of excellent old-man make-up, but still... This seemed like Black Mass' guaranteed sole nomination, but nope, not even that.

6. Shock: Charlotte Rampling For Best Actress

Though 45 Years has quietly been one of the best-reviewed films of the year, there wasn't much hope for the slight drama picking up any Oscar nods given its low-flying nature. Still, the actors' branch decided to nominate Charlotte Rampling for her superbly subtle work in the film as an aging woman who finds out a dark secret about her husband from decades prior. It's terrific work and, considering that it's the best performance of Rampling's career, a very well-deserved if surprising nod all the same.

5. Snub: Carol For Best Production Design

Even though it was snubbed for Best Picture, Best Production Design seemed like a category where Carol would shine massively, given how intricately-curated every aspect of its style was. Instead, Bridge of Spies, The Danish Girl, Mad Max: Fury Road, The Martian and The Revenant snuck in there, with The Revenant being the most surprising considering how much of the production was shot out in the natural wilderness, not requiring all that much design as it were. Given the regal look and feel of the film, it's pretty shocking it didn't make the cute.

4. Shock: Ex Machina For Best Visual Effects

Many believed that the fifth spot in the Best Visual Effects category would go to Avengers: Age of Ultron, but in a surprise turn it in fact went to $15 million sci-fi thriller Ex Machina. Though Age of Ultron featured a crapton of CGI in almost every frame, Ex Machina utilised it with more subtlety and grace, which explains how it ended up in the five: surely the branch gets fed up of nominating movies soaked in just-decent CGI simply because this category rarely has more than one or two standouts.

3. Snub: No Sound Mixing For Straight Outta Compton

The five Best Sound Mixing nods went to Bridge of Spies, Mad Max: Fury Road, The Martian, The Revenant and Star Wars: The Force Awakens, but what about Straight Outta Compton? As a musical biopic, the film had to naturally integrate music, score and dialogue into a seamless mix, and certainly did a more interesting and dynamic job than Bridge of Spies. But maybe this is just greedy: after all, Compton did get that screenplay nod nobody expected.

2. Shock: Mad Max: Fury Road Gets 10 Nominations

There's been a back-and-forth narrative ever since Mad Max: Fury Road hit cinemas about whether or not it would end up making an impact on the Oscar nominees list or not. Though its success on the awards circuit so far pointed to yes, nothing was ever certain, and so it's a pleasant surprise to report that the blockbuster scored a total of 10 nominations, for Best Picture, Director, Film Editing, Production Design, Visual Effects, Cinematography, Costume Design, Sound Editing, Sound Mixing and Makeup & Hairstyling. Though Max won't win many of these awards, it still takes its rightful place in history as being one of only a small handful of movies (also including The Revenant) to be nominated for every single technical award at the Oscars. And now fanboys quietly hope that George Miller can win Best Director, but alas, it probably won't happen.

1. Snub: Ridley Scott For Best Director

After being nominated for a Director's Guild of America award, it was a huge shock that Ridley Scott didn't get a Best Director nod for his superb work on The Martian, his spot instead being taken up by the unexpected nomination for Lenny Abrahamson (Room). It's all the more sad when you consider that Scott, at the age of 78, will struggle to get another chance at a Best Director Oscar, and though he probably wouldn't have won anyway, for him the nomination would have essentially been the win. Plus, the fact that the Academy nominated Thomas McCarthy for his rather TV-esque direction of Spotlight over Scott's sublime work is just jaw-dropping. And though it's well-deserved, consider that the director of Anchorman and Step Brothers, Adam McKay, is now a Best Director nominee for The Big Short. What do you make of the 2016 Oscar nominations? Shout them out in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.