Oscars 2021: Final Predictions In All 23 Categories
11. Best Costume Design
Another category where the transformation of Viola Davis will help to win an Oscar. A notably weaker category than usual, Pinocchio's appeal is in its prosthetics not its costumes and Mulan has done nothing new or original with its armours and robes.
Emma does have something to offer here with bright and gorgeous dresses and suits that jump off the screen thanks to their varied colours. Mank is likely here solely for the third act costume party scene which admittedly had a number of standout costumes (Amanda Seyfried's Ringmaster being the best).
It will be Ma Rainey's Black Bottom that will emerge the victor however, almost singlehandedly down to the costumes of the eponymous character. The suits of the bandmembers are good too and all the costumes are period appropriate but it is Ma Rainey who is fully embodied here, from the combined work of Viola Davis, the makeup department and the illustrious costumes.
What Should Win: Ma Rainey's Black Bottom
What Will Win: Ma Rainey's Black Bottom
10. Best Cinematography
A relatively close race between Nomadland and Mank, two films where the cinematography is a huge selling point of the whole film. Judas and the Black Messiah and Trial of the Chicago 7 both managed to score nominations here but neither have particularly memorable shots or camerawork to be considered legitimate contenders.
News of the World takes advantage of its wide open spaces to capture the landscape of the Wild West to good effect but the film under performed elsewhere so it is unlikely to gain much traction.
Nomadland's visuals are one of the universally praised aspects of the film with gorgeous shots that show off the beautiful American wilderness. Mank on the other hand, is less about showing off the natural world and more about exhibiting the impeccable production design wherever it can.
Both are strong contenders but Nomadland took a hit after Mank beat it at the American Society of Cinematographers awards closing the gap between the two nominees. Nomadland will still take this one, the film falls apart without its cinematography and the Academy will want to reward that, but it will be a close race.
What Should Win: Nomadland
What Will Win: Nomadland
9. Best Editing
The all important Editing category that is likely to contain the Best Picture winner even if that film doesn't end up winning this award. Nomadland is the Best Picture frontrunner and Chloé Zhao did her own editing which both helped to land it a nomination. It won't win here though.
The Father's subtle editing to make the narrative like a puzzle is appreciated and a welcome nomination but this is the category where that film is weakest. Promising Young Woman's nomination here over something like Minari should speak to the support of the picture but nobody is talking about this film for its editing.
This is a race between Trial of the Chicago 7 and Sound of Metal. Both are really strong in their editing and have each picked up precursor victories (Sound of Metal at BAFTA, Trial of the Chicago 7 at the ACE Eddie Awards).
Sound of Metal is unquestionably picking up Best Sound whereas Trial is flagging in all other categories. If the Academy wants to spread the wealth, it will award Trial of the Chicago 7 for its editing.
What Should Win: Trial of the Chicago 7
What Will Win: Trial of the Chicago 7
8. Best Adapted Screenplay
This is one of those cases where there is a 'right' winner and a 'wrong' winner. Some unexpected nominees in this category to be sure, The White Tiger was a welcome surprise with a script that feels like The Favourite set in India. Borat Subsequent Moviefilm made the cut which is curious considering how much of that film relies on the unscripted interactions with the public.
One Night in the Miami which underperformed considerably is here as well which is rightfully deserved, the film managed to take the stage play and successfully make it especially cinematic which is worthy of recognition.
The nominees this comes down to are the current frontrunner Nomadland and The Father. The Father most recently won this category at the BAFTAs which has sparked genuine conversation about its chances. Neither script was eligible at the WGA which means the only time the two have faced off with any voting overlap with the Oscars was with the British Academy.
The Father is coming on strong and if Nomadland is weak anywhere it'll be here. With a script that is focused on unscripted interactions with non-professional actors, it makes sense to give the nod to The Father for its tight focus and crisp dialogue. Hopefully the Nomadland hype train will stop to recognise the best script of the category. It's entirely possible.
What Should Win: The Father
What Will Win: The Father
7. Best Original Screenplay
At one point, this was Trial of the Chicago 7's to lose. It started off the season with a strong Globe win but has fallen one too many times to Promising Young Woman since. All five nominees are strong, Judas and the Black Messiah is the weakest with an unfocused second act but it still deserves its placement here.
Sound of Metal feels like the most lucky to be here (most likely taking a spot that would have gone to a more traditional Oscar bait film such as Mank) and that isn't a slight against the film at all.
Minari should be a stronger contender here than it ultimately will be which is a shame because the screenplay for the wholesome drama is one of its high points.
Trial of the Chicago 7 and Promising Young Woman both deserve to win this award and are the two best screenplays of the year which is unfortunate as they fall in the same category. Both are ambitious which means neither is perfect.
Promising Young Woman has some minor plot holes and Trial feels like it's trying too hard at times. Those are nit-picks because they are both exceptional scripts. Aaron Sorkin already has an Oscar and Trial is very on brand for him, Promising Young Woman has the potential to be talked about for years to come on its concept alone.
What Should Win: Promising Young Woman
What Will Win: Promising Young Woman
6. Best Supporting Actress
Without being too critical, this is a rather weak category and earlier in the season it seemed like it could be anyone's to win. The nominated supporting actresses aren't bad they just don't compare to their companion categories.
Amanda Seyfried makes the cut for being the most enjoyable character in the dour drama Mank and Maria Bakalova breaks the comedy curse by breaking into the Oscars on her very first performance.
Olivia Colman is always excellent but this is an after glow nomination from her win a few years ago. Her work is strong but she lacks a standout scene that will stick in the minds of voters.
Glenn Close has the strongest narrative of the five as this is her eighth career nomination without a win. Unfortunately, Hillbilly Elegy has been critically massacred and it just doesn't feel like it is her time this year.
That leaves the perfectly charming Yuh-Jung Youn who steals as many scenes as she can in the tender drama Minari. Youn has solidified herself as the frontrunner after a rocky start to the season that saw (an Oscar snubbed) Jodie Foster take the Golden Globe. Youn is the best of the bunch and seems unlikely to face an upset at this stage.
Who Should Win: Yuh-Jung Youn
Who Will Win: Yuh-Jung Youn
5. Best Supporting Actor
The easiest of the acting categories to call, Daniel Kaluuya has swept the season being the only actor this year to win every major precursor. The nomination of his co-star LaKeith Stanfield in this same category caused some discussions of category fraud but that doesn't mean he doesn't deserve recognition. Every year Supporting Actor is bloated with more lead stars that it isn't that surprising to see Stanfield nominated.
Paul Raci is the only unquestionably supporting actor here with a role that is both authentic and close to Raci's heart. Sacha Baron Cohen has been singled out from Trial of the Chicago 7's excellent ensemble and there's a chance that some voters will look at him as a 'vote for one is a vote for all' kind of nominee but it won't be enough.
Leslie Odom Jr. is excellent in One Night in Miami but he may vote split with himself as he is also nominated in Best Song. Stanfield goes to some great lengths to portray the many layers of Bill O'Neil but this is too late in the game to consider him a threat to Kaluuya's momentum.
This will be the only place where Judas and the Black Messiah will realistically be awarded and the Academy will not want to miss that chance.
What Should Win: Daniel Kaluuya
What Will Win: Daniel Kaluuya
4. Best Actress
By far, the most difficult category to call of the night, there is a scenario where anyone of these actresses could walk away the winner. Four out of the five nominees have won a significant precursor from: Andra Day (Golden Globe), Carey Mulligan (Critics' Choice), Viola Davis (SAG) and Frances McDormand (BAFTA). There's even precedent for the fifth nominee Vanessa Kirby to win without any precursor victories (looking at you Marcia Gay Harden).
Kirby gives the best performance of the five, with a towering turn in Pieces of a Woman that will leave you breathless. Unfortunately, the film may be too intense for some voters so she remains the least likely to prevail.
The remaining four are hard to discuss in terms of who is better as they are all excellent. McDormand is an Academy favourite but are they likely to award her a third Best Actress trophy so soon after her second? Davis is picking up steam and Day is a slight wildcard but both are playing relatively similar roles that may split the vote. They also both share the narrative of being the second black woman to win Best Actress which means that neither can claim that boost.
Carey Mulligan gives the buzziest performance in the most discussed film of the nominees which may give her the edge she needs. All five are deserving and it will be an incredibly close race regardless of who wins.
What Should Win: Vanessa Kirby
What Will Win: Carey Mulligan
3. Best Actor
What would have been the most competitive Best Actor race in years has narrowed since the tragic passing of Chadwick Boseman.
There are three men here who could easily win in any other year but they sadly have to go against each other. Riz Ahmed gives an exceptional performance in Sound of Metal and makes it very clear that he'll be back and will no doubt win an Oscar in the future.
The other two are slightly more difficult to navigate. Again, both men deserve to win, but by rights Anthony Hopkins should have swept the season as the best performance of the year. Hopkins portrayal of a man suffering from dementia in The Father is a once-in-a-lifetime performance and is faultless in its execution.
Chadwick Boseman also gives the best work of his career and there is no doubt that a win for him here is a celebration of his life and career as well as the performance he gives in Ma Rainey's Black Bottom.
Perhaps with Hopkins' surprise BAFTA win this race is closer than people are giving it credit for and it is starting to mirror upset wins of the past (Olivia Colman over Glenn Close and Alan Arkin over Eddie Murphy come to mind) but for every one voter that recognises the superior performance of Hopkins, two more want to honour the life of the Chadwick Boseman.
What Should Win: Anthony Hopkins
What Will Win: Chadwick Boseman
2. Best Director
Perhaps the most straightforward category of the lot, Chloé Zhao is running away with this award and rightfully so. Thomas Vinterburg slipped in here for Another Round, perhaps taking the slot of Aaron Sorkin or Regina King, his placement is deserved but he has no chance of pulling off an upset.
Lee Isaac Chung and Emerald Fennel have both done an amazing job on Minari and Promising Young Woman but their strengths reside more within their writing than their skill behind the camera.
David Fincher wouldn't actually be an undeserving winner in this category, Mank is a technical masterpiece albeit a boring one. If the film were stronger this would perhaps be a tighter race.
Instead, Zhao exquisitely captures the wide open spaces of America which merges beautifully with the stories of the real life nomads. Zhao will make history as the second woman to win Best Director and the first woman of Asian descent to do so. It is thoroughly deserved and will likely provide Zhao with the opportunity to do whatever she wants going forward.
What Should Win: Chloé Zhao
What Will Win: Chloé Zhao