Oscars 2021: Ranking The Nominated Performances From Worst To Best

Who gave the best performances of the year? Promising Young Woman, Nomadland, Minari and more!

Trial of the Chicago 7 Sacha Baron Cohen
Netflix

The Oscars are fast approaching and it is that time of year to not only guess who might take home the trophies but to judge who should take home the trophies or if they should even be nominated at all!

All 20 of the nominated individuals on this list gave worthy and credible performances, despite a hectic COVID year, the Oscars managed to find some decent work amongst all the delayed releases. Of those 20, 12 have never been nominated before. And of the eight who have, only five have won in the past. From a deaf heavy metal drummer to a Blues singer to a Hollywood screenwriter to a dementia sufferer to Borat's own daughter! There are several varied and unique performances to choose from this year.

With a record number of non-white performances recognised from a whole crop of films covering differing social issues such as racism, sexism and immigration, the nominees represent a great shift in Hollywood's focus and make for an exciting collection of nominations.

Not everyone that will win should win when compared to their fellow nominees but each one of these performances are worthy of praise none the less.

20. Gary Oldman - Mank

Mank Gary Oldman
Netflix

Gary Oldman is a legend and a well respected actor for good reason, he already has one Oscar to his name for his leading performance in Darkest Hour which he won in 2018. That being said, Mank is hardly his best work.

Starring as the titular screenwriter as he struggles with alcoholism and morals as he writes a first draft of Citizen Kane, Oldman is not bad at all here and an actor of his calibre can always make whatever he's doing seem interesting. What that amounts to however, is Oldman stumbling around being drunk and disagreeable for two hours in a performance that isn't exactly revolutionary.

One of the primary reasons for Oldman to rank last here is the fact there was clearly a better alternative the Academy ignored. Delroy Lindo's unhinged performance in Da 5 Bloods was snubbed here (and practically everywhere else) and is a far superior performance to Oldman's. Tahar Rahim in The Mauratanian would have been a worthy replacement also.

It's not a wholly unworthy nomination, but it is the worst of the bunch.


19. Paul Raci - Sound Of Metal

Sound of Metal Paul Raci
Amazon Studios

After years of small bit parts in film and television, Paul Raci finally got his big break in Sound of Metal, the story of a heavy metal drummer who suddenly loses his hearing. Raci plays Joe, the deaf leader of a rehab facility who helps deaf addicts and other members of the community.

Raci is fantastic here and feels like a strong emotional core for the film as he tries to calmly help the chaotic and angry Ruben get to grips with his new predicament. One scene in particular is especially heart-breaking when Joe is faced with a betrayal and it is clear how deeply he cares about those in the community.

To a degree, Raci can feel like he is playing himself. He isn't deaf in real life but he is a child of deaf parents and does a lot of work within the community and strives to raise awareness and widen inclusion. What this means is that despite Raci's touching performance, it doesn't feel particularly out of his comfort zone.


18. Amanda Seyfried - Mank

Mank Amanda Seyfried
Netflix

As faded movie star Marion Davies, Amanda Seyfried manages to give one of the best performances of her career so far as easily the most likable thing in the David Fincher directed biopic Mank. Still most known for her roles in Mean Girls and Mama Mia, Seyfried hasn't had many opportunities to show off her dramatic potential in the past.

In an incredibly chaotic Supporting Actress category which easily could have snubbed any of the nominated performers in the race, Seyfried is still the least likely to win out of the five other nominations. It isn't so much that she's the worst, it's the combination of the fact she isn't in a particularly stellar film and has a weak awards season narrative.

The category is rather weak compared to the other acting races and Seyfried does little to standout in the mind after the credits have rolled. That doesn't change the fact she is the most relatable character in Mank and will hopefully lead to more dramatic opportunities for Seyfried.


17. Maria Bakalova - Borat Subsequent Moviefilm

Borat Subsequent Moviefilm Tutar Maria Bakalova
Amazon Studios

It is very hard to judge Maria Bakalova's work against the rest of the nominations as she is the only purely comedic performance on the list. The Academy has a strong aversion to nominating comedic performances, especially ones from outrageous comedies such as Borat, so Bakalova being here is an achievement in itself. A unique performance such as Bakalova's going all the way wouldn't be the most shocking thing in the world.

Bakalova is the breath of fresh air that managed to keep Borat both interesting and unpredictable in its sequel. She has great chemistry with Sacha Baron Cohen and her ability to stay in character like him in the face of anything is worthy of praise.

Regardless, Bakalova was likely given the boost to a nomination for being part of one of the most remarkable and memorable scenes of the last year featuring Rudy Giuliani. That scene alone is what scored her a nomination here.


16. Glenn Close - Hillbilly Elegy

Hillbilly Elegy Glenn Close
Netflix

The legendary Glenn Close is looking to score her first win after eight nominations with the critically savaged Hillbilly Elegy. The film did not have a favourable response at all but in actuality it is a serviceable and cliché drama with above average performances from Amy Adams and Glenn Close who manage to make the film more than watchable.

Close is always great, she's incapable of being bad, but this is still far removed from her recent nominated performances in The Wife and Albert Nobbs which proved to be some of her career best work. If her status as an icon and the fact that she's never won an Oscar allows her to capitalise on a weak Supporting Actress category (not impossible but unlikely) then her win will be bittersweet.

Like Al Pacino for Scent of a Woman, everyone will know that they are awarding the individual rather than the performance. She is capable of better but she still manages to hold the divisive film together. Perhaps it is time to award Close for her phenomenal contributions throughout the years.


15. Steven Yeun - Minari

Minari Steven Yeun
A24

The Walking Dead alum made history as the first man of East-Asian descent to be nominated for Best Actor and it is deserved for his leading turn in Minari. Steven Yeun plays the patriarch of the Yi family, who uproot their life and move to Arkansas to pursue their American dream.

Yeun's work here is very reserved, his character has to balance appeasing his family and making sure his Korean vegetable farm will be viable for harvest practically on his own. The performance is strong in its subtlety as Yeun bares the stress and anguish of his predicament all on his facial expressions.

Understated work such as this is rarely awarded a win but it is appreciated for the lack of over the top monologues or showy displays that make other performers seem more desirable. It is far harder to convey emotion through the exhaustion of the character you're playing, but that is exactly why Yeun does and he does it well.


14. Olivia Colman - The Father

The Father Olivia Colman
Sony Pictures Classics

In a film dominated by Anthony Hopkins, it is to Oliva Colman's credit that she managed to stand out enough for a nomination here. Colman plays Anne, the daughter of her mentally deteriorating aging father. The Father is an incredibly hard watch and the strained relationship that dementia facilitates can be heart-breaking to see unfold.

Colman portrays the quiet sadness of watching her father slip away before her eyes with a great sense of pain and anger. She is a necessary part of a film that grounds you in the real life consequences of those left behind after a loss. It's strong work from start to finish.

She doesn't manage to come close to touching Hopkins, understandably as he is doing all the heavy lifting here but she is still worthy of praise. What is likely an afterglow nomination in the wake of Colman's Oscar win a few years ago for The Favourite, it would be highly surprising to see Colman best four other actresses looking for their first Oscar in the supporting actress category.


13. Sacha Baron Cohen - The Trial Of The Chicago 7

Trial of the Chicago 7 Sacha Baron Cohen
Netflix

Sacha Baron Cohen finally makes it onto the acting ballot at the Oscars for the role of Abbie Hoffman, one of the Chicago 7 on trial for inciting a riot. Cohen actually has a previous nomination for writing the first Borat film and is a dual nominee this year for Trial of the Chicago 7 and for writing Borat's sequel.

Cohen is the heart of Trial, bringing an immature yet passionate energy to the film who is given some of the best lines that are often hilarious. He also manages to delve into some deep and emotional beats that audiences and voters alike aren't necessarily used to seeing from the comedic actor.

The ensemble for Trial is large and so many of the performers could have, and perhaps should have been recognised from Mark Rylance to Yahya Abdul-Mateen II. It's a shame because Cohen isn't obviously better than anyone else in the film, he is just as good as his peers. Yet it is just him that is recognised in the nominations.


12. Andra Day - The United States Vs. Billie Holiday

The United States vs. Billie Holiday Andra Day
Hulu

Andra Day felt like she's been acting for years in her debut role as the troubled singer and icon. The R&B singer/songwriter became Billie Holiday seamlessly with an open and brave performance.

The Oscars tend to love it when professional singers turn to Hollywood and quite often their nominations can feel undeserving resulting from a form of special treatment (Lady Gaga comes to mind). That is not the case here, Day is exceptional and fully commands the screen with a presence of an actor with decades more experience.

Although the film itself is a conventional biopic with few instances of greatness, Day raises the film up to a new level of praise with a gutsy and brutal portrayal of the troubled singer's life.

With a shocking upset victory at the Golden Globes, The Best Actress category has refused to settle on a frontrunner over the course of the season making it incredibly hard to predict who could win. The smart money is likely on Viola Davis or Carey Mulligan but Day is not to be counted out. This is a remarkable performance worthy of recognition and she is more than deserving of her nomination.


11. Frances McDormand - Nomadland

Nomadland Frances McDormand
Searchlight Pictures

Starring in the likely Best Picture winner, Frances McDormand is in almost every frame of Nomadland as Fern, a woman who loses everything and decides to live on the road in her van. In a film that features very few professional actors and a screenplay that doesn't have too much dialogue scripted and instead relies of free flowing improvised conversation, there are several layers to McDormand's performance here.

McDormand is one of the best actors working today and she already has two Oscar statuettes to her name, if she were to collect her third here I don't think anyone would say it was undeserved. A great deal of dramatic weight is placed on McDormand's shoulders as she spends time on her own doing mundane tasks or sleeping in her van. When she is improvising with the non-professional actors, it is on McDormand to keep the conversation flowing in an interesting way not them (some of them didn't even realise she was an actress).

Although it seems unlikely she will go all the way this year, McDormand's talents are still a large reason that Nomadland will do as well as it will elsewhere and that cannot be understated.


10. Viola Davis - Ma Rainey's Black Bottom

Ma Rainey's Black Bottom Viola Davis
Netflix

A fantastic Viola Davis gives one of her most transformative turns as the Mother of the Blues Ma Rainey. Unfortunately, Davis should have campaigned in supporting rather than lead because despite her name being in the title of the film, Ma Rainey plays second fiddle to Chadwick Boseman's Levee.

Davis could have run away with the best Supporting Actress category and scored her second win without having to worry about the overly competitive field in Best Actress. Although, with an upset victory at the SAG awards, Davis may actually manage to beat her co-nominees that have twice her screen time in their respective films. Either way, Davis has still made history as the most nominated black actress at the Oscars.

Davis is still outstanding here, the makeup department help her to embody Ma Rainey and she does so fearlessly. The film lacks much of an arc for her character, sometimes relegating Davis to just sparring with Boseman and those playing her white management but, she still manages to be captivating and enthralling with every moment she's gracing the screen.


9. Yuh-jung Youn - Minari

Minari Yuh-Jung Youn
A24

A renowned Korean actress with many credits to her name makes a definitive splash in Hollywood as the scene stealing grandmother in Lee Isaac Chung's Minari. Yuh-Jung Youn is a whacky and fierce addition to the film who, along with Alan Kim, provides some of film's sweetest and most hilarious moments.

The critical favourite amongst the supporting actress nominees, Youn is the likeliest to win now that nominees such as Maria Bakalova and Glenn Close have failed to solidify their momentum. Youn is fantastic as the grandmother who is anything like what the Yi children were expecting from a grandmother. Foul mouthed and a player of cards, Youn's building bond with Alan Kim's David is one of the most enduring relationships of the whole film.

Originally seeming like the most unpredictable category of the year, the conversation has appeared to converge on Youn and she would be a deserving winner as the veteran actress pushes the emotional limits of the wholesome drama in all the best ways.


8. LaKeith Stanfield - Judas And The Black Messiah

Judas and the Black Messiah LaKeith Stanfield
Warner Bros. Pictures

Regardless of the admittedly bewildering category fraud accusations (which have nothing to do with Stanfield or his performance), LaKeith Stanfield is absolutely phenomenal as Bill O'Neal, the FBI informant that infiltrated Fred Hampton's chapter of the Black Panther party.

The film splits equal time between O'Neal and Hampton and when we're with O'Neal, it is a fascinating experience. To get a chance to look inside the mind of a man so corrupted and warped yet so painfully human is portrayed incredibly well and Stanfield does an amazing job.

O'Neal has several layers to unravel and Stanfield has a hold on each and every one. It is impressive to play someone so dislikeable as this and still find them compelling. Stanfield failed to pick up nominations at any other major awards show and that is likely due to the fact he was campaigned in lead which was already oversaturated. Despite that, he deserves to be here and provides one of the best performances of the year.


7. Leslie Odom Jr. - One Night In Miami

One Night in Miami... Leslie Odom Jr.
Amazon Studios

Leslie Odom Jr. quickly became the frontrunner for a nomination amongst the four One Night in Miami standouts and his turn as singer Sam Cooke is a refined and deeply powerful performance that stands as a highlight of both the film and the year.

Of all the characters in One Night in Miami, Sam Cooke is the one that goes through the clearest arc as the character is challenged on his approach to the movements concerning racial equality and injustice. Odom Jr. fills his performance with resentment and rage and a burning frustration as Cooke holds a different worldview to that of Malcolm X.

This all culminates in the final song of the film, sung by Odom Jr., which manages to be both powerful and emotionally arresting. It is the best moment in the film and Odom Jr. nails it.

Odom Jr. is primarily known for his work on Hamilton, but this powerful performance and subsequent nomination should easily propel him into a mainstay of cinema to come.


6. Daniel Kaluuya - Judas And The Black Messiah

Judas And The Black Messiah Daniel Kaluuya
Warner Bros. Pictures

Daniel Kaluuya received his second Oscar nomination for playing Black Panther party leader Fred Hampton and he feels like the safest lock for a win out of all the categories for his supporting performance in Judas and the Black Messiah.

It can be hard to choose between the two nominated Judas co-stars as to who is better but Kaluuya's work is some of the most raw and powerful of the whole year. When the film gets dark and difficult, it is Kaluuya that keeps those beats as impactful as they can be. The emotion felt from the performance will resonate with many and Kaluuya embodies the civil rights icon.

He has great chemistry with co-stars LaKeith Stanfield and Dominique Fishback and can carry the film on his electrifying chemistry alone. With an ending that kicks you in the teeth, the film works only as well as it does thanks to Kaluuya who will soon be an Academy Award winning actor thanks to his work here.


5. Carey Mulligan - Promising Young Woman

Promising Young Woman
Searchlight Pictures

Her second career nomination at the Oscars more than 10 years after her first is a monumental leap in quality from everything Carey Mulligan has done previously. Not to say her previous work was poor, but Promising Young Woman is a cut above for the actor and she is simply extraordinary.

After a terrible event that happened in her past, Cassie becomes a vengeful figure looking to terrorise predatory men on a weekly basis. To say much more would over-spoil but Mulligan shows Cassie's struggle between her own human desires and her determined goals with great believability.

Mulligan keeps you guessing as to just how unhinged her character is and how far she is willing to go throughout the film and it is thoroughly enjoyable to watch. It is unclear with such a chaotic Best Actress race, if a performance as dark and different as this will manage to take her to the win. She is probably still the odds on favourite (with Viola Davis and Andra Day biting at her heels) and if she does succeed in winning, she would be more than a justified victor.


4. Riz Ahmed - Sound Of Metal

Sound of Metal Riz Ahmed
Amazon Studios

In what is easily his career best performance to date, Riz Ahmed is sensational as Ruben, a heavy metal drummer who has to come to terms with the sudden loss of his hearing. The film is a great tool to raise awareness for an issue that is hard to understand for those that don't suffer from it and Ahmed approaches the material with maturity and sensitivity.

Ruben goes through several emotions as he comes to terms with his new impairment and the whole ordeal and reaction feels natural and realistic thanks to Ahmed. Commanding empathy with great skill, Ahmed manages to give a heart-breaking performance as Ruben loses everything around him.

Ultimately feeling like a necessary and important film, Sound of Metal shows that living without hearing is not something to be ashamed of and Ahmed walks the fine line of accepting that fact and struggling with it. It results in what feels like an incredibly real performance and one of the very best of the year.


3. Vanessa Kirby - Pieces Of A Woman

Pieces of a Woman Vanessa Kirby
Netflix

The former Crown star gives a career making performance as a grieving mother who has a catastrophic home birth. Pieces of a Woman is one of the two most difficult films of the year and there is little to no enjoyment to be had in this painful cinematic experience. None of that is a criticism as Pieces of a Woman forces you to look at all the misery and digest it fully through Vanessa Kirby's brave and relentless performance.

Kirby's range here is ever reaching, with a first half that features an unbroken extended take of the home birth that throws you into the exhaustion and anguish of Kirby's character. The devastation she feels for the rest of the film can be harrowing and Kirby rarely gets a moment when she is not asked to fully commit emotionally.

She will rip your heart out in this film but she also has no chance of winning which is a real shame. A film as difficult and challenging as this won't be everyone's cup of tea, especially those that are voting in the Academy. That doesn't change the fact that Vanessa Kirby gives the best female performance of the year.


2. Chadwick Boseman - Ma Rainey's Black Bottom

Ma Rainey's Black Bottom Chadwick Boseman
Netflix

The late actor will almost definitely be winning the award for Best Actor for his leading performance in Ma Rainey's Black Bottom. Overshadowing the title character and performance from co-star Viola Davis, Chadwick Boseman plays the ambitious horn player Levee who is given numerous monologues for the actor to sink his teeth into.

Loud and in your face, Boseman dominates the screen and gives a reverent and powerful performance that will captivate and enthral all that watch. His range is on full display as the film will often feel like a showcase for the star to exhibit his incredible abilities.

The role is complex and Boseman shines in what will be remembered as the best performance of his career. He is far better than the film he is a part of and raises it up to a new level of appreciation. His coming win will be most deserved and it is a fitting show of respect and support from the industry.


1. Anthony Hopkins - The Father

The Father Anthony Hopkins
Sony Pictures Classics

One of the greatest actors of all time, Sir Anthony Hopkins bares all in The Father, a drama about a man struggling with dementia told through his eyes. Along with Pieces of a Woman, this is the hardest film of the year to watch, with a leading performance straight out of Shakespearean tragedy that shall be burned into your mind and never leave.

The one thing holding Boseman back from this top spot is the stagey nature of Ma Rainey's performance and script. Boseman doesn't speak like a normal human being would and the refined dialogue can take you out of the film at times. Hopkins feels honest and naturalistic as he struggles to cope with his increasingly unexplainable reality.

The legend has no shortage of iconic roles but he has never been better here. The titanic performance covers several emotional beats and stages and Hopkins nails every single one. It is a brutally sincere performance that will leave you broken and hollow and in any other year, Hopkins would run away with the Best Actor Oscar.

At 83, Hopkins shows that he can still give a perfect performance, and his work in The Father is unquestionably the best performance of the year.


Contributor

Opinionated pop-culture commentator who aspires to be a writer so people can opinionatedly comment on the pop-culture I put out.