Oscars 2022 Review: 7 Ups & 8 Downs

The slap heard around the world derails a messy, bloated Oscars.

Oscars 2022 Will Smith
ABC

This year's Academy Awards was primed to be a return to glitzy best for a show that, due to pandemic-related restrictions, took place in scaled-back form in a train station last year.

Aside from a few potentially chaotic spoilers in the Best Actress and Best Picture fields, it was set to be a safely predictable Oscars that spread the wealth around many worthy films, and on paper that's largely what happened.

But this year's show will ultimately be defined by one thing and one thing only: Will Smith slapping Chris Rock in the face for making an insensitive joke about his wife, Jada Pinkett Smith.

It's a moment that stopped the 2022 Oscars dead in their tracks and has dominated social media and the news ever since.

It isn't without irony that the Academy desperately attempted to re-engineer this year's show to recover its declining ratings, and such a moment of genuinely unscripted drama ultimately got more people talking about the Oscars than in many years.

But it also cast a dark pall over the rest of the ceremony and distracted massively from the many great films and artists picking up awards. It certainly wasn't the worst Oscars ever in terms of awards doled out, but it sure was the messiest.

And so first, here's what this year's Academy Awards got wrong...


Downs...

8. Cutting Eight Awards From The Main Show

Oscars 2022 Joe Walker
ABC

The show's producers made the extremely controversial decision this year to pre-record eight of the awards, with categories such as Best Film Editing, Best Original Score, Best Sound, and all three short film fields being doled out before the main show.

Despite considerable protest from many high-profile figures in the Academy, this went ahead as planned in an apparent attempt to shorten the ceremony's length and allow more time for skits and segments that might bring audiences back to the Oscars.

Beyond the fact that the show ended up clocking in at a weighty 3 hours and 42 minutes, it was embarrassing to see extremely crucial categories like Best Film Editing get revealed on Twitter and then be given a piecemeal chopped-down treatment in the show itself.

Dune, the big winner of the night with six awards, won five of its awards off-screen, which seems even sillier when you consider that it was by far the highest-grossing of the ten Best Picture nominees and therefore the most popular.

Ultimately it's tough to accept that saving a minute or two for each of these awards was really worth the feathers it ruffled in the Academy. Above all else, it seems flagrantly disrespectful to the artists whose work is effectively implied to be "less important."


7. The Painfully Unfunny "Comedy" Segments

Oscars 2022 Wanda Sykes
ABC

The Oscars' comedy skits have always been a hugely mixed bag, and this year's show was no exception, though left an especially sour taste given that they stole precious time that could've - and should've - been allotted to the eight cast-off categories.

A lousy opening segment from the three hosts, Amy Schumer, Wanda Sykes, and Regina Hall, was mostly a bust, unaided by the inexplicable presence of DJ Khaled on the stage.

So much of the on-stage humour felt low-effort and perfunctory: gags about snubbed potential nominees, how hot Timothee Chalamet is, and worst of all an ill-advised segment where Hall mimicked sexually harassing Jason Momoa under the guise of a "COVID test."

Though Amy Schumer fared far better when monologuing on her own, for the most part the show's jokes felt like bad gags discarded by the SNL writers room.


6. The Power Of The Dog Only Wins Best Director

Oscars 2022 Jane Campion
ABC

Up until the last few weeks, The Power of the Dog seemed like a solid gold lock to win the Best Picture Oscar, with probable or highly possible wins for Best Director, Best Adapted Screenplay, and Best Supporting Actor (Kodi Smit-McPhee) also.

Yet the acclaimed western drama had one of the most shocking fizzles of any massively nominated film in recent memory, scoring just a single Oscar win from its 12 nominations.

Despite being the most-nominated film this year, The Power of the Dog won only Best Director for Jane Campion, an extremely rare circumstance given that the Academy rarely rewards a director without any of the film's other elements.

This makes it the first film since 1967's The Graduate to win only Best Director, and while it was certainly great to see Campion scoop a well-deserved second Oscar, it's hard not to see the film's overall performance at the show as a colossal disappointment.


5. The Show Was STILL Insanely Bloated

Oscars 2022 Encanto
ABC

Despite all the promises that this year's show would be the most entertainingly fast-paced Oscars in years and clock in at a reasonable three hours, it was ultimately just the same old slog it's always been, and maybe even worse.

Even with only 15 awards being given out live, the show still got dangerously close to the four-hour mark, padded out as it was with cringe-worthy skits, tangential montages, and a musical performance from a song that wasn't even nominated (Encanto's "We Don't Talk About Bruno").

We also had commercials for the Academy's fancy new museum, a new look at the Pixar film Lightyear, and a bizarre series of Crypto.com ads expressing support for the people of Ukraine.

And yet, the producers had the nerve to try and play numerous winners off the stage, such as Drive My Car director Ryusuke Hamaguchi while picking up his Best International Film Oscar, who thankfully weren't having it for the most part.

The Academy's attempts to produce a more dynamic and free-flowing show backfired spectacularly, and it'll be interesting to see how next year's show is organised in response.


4. Flee & The Worst Person In The World Go Home Empty-Handed

The Worst Person in The World
Neon

Of course not every nominated film can win an Oscar, but it was disappointing to see two of the year's most acclaimed films receive no Academy gold at all.

Flee, despite being nominated in the improbable trifecta of Best International Film, Animated Film, and Documentary, failed to win any of these three awards, no matter that it's received universal critical praise.

Joachim Trier's brilliant drama The Worst Person in the World, which if we're honest should've been nominated for Best Picture, also flamed out by failing to win either of its two nominations - Best International Feature and Best Original Screenplay.

The former was always going to go to Drive My Car, but did Belfast really have a better screenplay than The Worst Person in the World? Not a chance.


3. Will Smith Slaps Chris Rock & Derails The Show

Oscars 2022 Will Smith
ABC

Roughly two-thirds of the way through the show, something happened that not a single person watching could've ever seen coming.

While up on stage to present an award, Chris Rock made a crass joke about Jada Pinkett Smith's shaved head - a result of her suffering from alopecia - prompting her incensed husband Will Smith to walk to the stage, slap Rock around the face, and sit back down, before shouting at him, "Keep my wife's name out your f**king mouth."

Though at first many suspected the moment was a misjudged gag, it quickly became clear that the altercation was real, and in turn sucked all remaining air out of the rest of the ceremony.

Social media was alight with discussions about the slap, with even the most diligent of viewers likely struggling to pay attention to acceptances speeches from the likes of Jane Campion, Jessica Chastain, and the CODA team.

Whatever your own stance on the slap itself, it led to what is surely the most awkward Oscar acceptance speech in history when Smith won the Best Actor award for his performance in King Richard.

Smith's rambling, scarcely coherent, tearful speech was a clumsy attempt to win the audience back following the assault, stating a desire to protect his family and apologising to the assembled Academy members but notably not to Rock.

Since the broadcast the LAPD has stated that Rock opted not to press charges and the Academy has condemned violence at the ceremony. It ultimately seems that Smith has more-or-less gotten away with something few others could: committing assault on live TV and then winning an award 30 minutes later.

It's just unfortunate that such a childish moment of Drama detracted from the actual reason everyone was assembled in the Dolby Theatre in the first place, with Smith's unforced error totally undermining what should've been the greatest moment of his career. Terrible.


2. The In Memoriam Segment Forgets Bob Saget, Ed Asner & More

Oscars 2022 Tyler Perry
ABC

This year's In Memoriam segment unfortunately had to follow the slap heard around the world, and as usual many took to social media to complain about a number of beloved late actors omitted from the montage.

The most-criticised exclusion was comedy legend Bob Saget, who while certainly better known for his TV work, had a number of film credits to his name and won a Student Academy Award back in 1978.

Elsewhere the inimitable Ed Asner, a titan of the industry with more than 400 acting credits to his name across TV and film, was conspicuously absent, and comedian-actor Norm Macdonald also failed to make the cut.

Perhaps the most surprising omission in terms of young actors working right up their deaths, however, was French actor Gaspard Ulliel.

Considering that the Academy made such a big deal about this year's reworked show allowing more time for non-awards segments, these exclusions really stuck out.


1. CODA Wins Best Picture & Suffers Instant Backlash

Oscars 2022 CODA
ABC

Though The Power of the Dog was the odds-on favourite to win the Best Picture Oscar for basically the last few months, a late surge of support for CODA allowed it to storm ahead and take the gold.

And while its victory here is certainly a great win for representation in cinema, it also feels like it may ultimately be the worst thing that could happened to the film legacy-wise.

Many have already taken to social media to lump CODA in with the likes of Crash and Green Book as frothy, crowd-pleasing movies that had no business winning Best Picture.

While CODA is a considerably better film than either of those divisive Best Picture winners, the bitterness from those who felt The Power of the Dog deserved to win is understandable - it's certainly the more artistically accomplished of the two films.

As a result it's a bittersweet victory for CODA - an incredible underdog story for its cast and crew, even if long-term the Best Picture win may ultimately harm its reputation in the annals of film history.

These many gripes accepted, though, the show certainly wasn't all bad. Here's what the Academy got right...


Ups...

7. Dune Cleans Up In The Technical Categories

Oscars 2022 Dune
ABC

Though CODA won Best Picture, the true big winner of the night was Dune, which won the most awards of the show with an impressive six - that's three more than second-place, CODA.

Denis Villeneuve's gorgeously mounted sci-fi film unsurprisingly mopped the floor with most of the technical and crafts categories, winning Oscars for Original Score, Sound, Film Editing, Cinematography, Production Design, and Visual Effects.

It's tough to argue with any of these wins, really, no matter what you might make of Dune as a piece of storytelling. Now we wait to see if Villeneuve can repeat or even exceed this success with the impending sequel.


6. Riz Ahmed Is Now An Oscar Winner

Oscars 2022 Riz Ahmed
ABC

Riz Ahmed may not have won the Best Actor Oscar he was nominated for last year (for his work on Sound of Metal), but he won his first Academy Award this time for co-writing and starring in The Long Goodbye, which won the Best Live-Action Short film Oscar.

Though short films starring A-list actors always have a natural advantage in this category, it's a well-earned win for a film that draws shocking attention to a divided modern Britain.

Ahmed's classy speech, calling for greater inclusion and unity, was a welcome cherry on top. Hopefully we'll see him competing for acting Oscars again soon enough, though.


5. Zack Snyder Fans Troll The Fan Vote

Zack Snyder's Justice League The Flash
Warner Bros.

Another widely maligned aspect of this year's show was the decision to include awards decided by the general public on social media - the Oscars Cheer Moment and the Fan Favourite Film.

It felt like desperate pandering from the Academy in an attempt to garner greater audience interest in the ceremony, just as when they tried to introduce the nixed Best Popular Film Oscar a few years ago.

Yet the two awards ended up backfiring in hilarious and totally predictable fashion, largely courtesy of Zack Snyder's cult of die-hard fans.

The Oscar Cheer Moment, where bafflingly three of its five nominated moments took place from films released since 2019, went to The Flash entering the Speed Force from Zack Snyder's Justice League, inexplicably beating out The Matrix's bullet time and Avengers: Endgame's climax.

It got even better, though: while the Fan Favourite Film was widely expected to go to Spider-Man: No Way Home, it was in fact won by Snyder's Army of the Dead, with second and third place absurdly taken by Cinderella and the little-seen Johnny Depp film Minamata.

If nothing else these wins underlined how utterly inane the idea of a fan vote, especially one conducted over social media, actually was. One suspects the Academy probably won't try this again.


4. Troy Kotsur Becomes The First Deaf Man To Win An Acting Oscar

Oscars 2022 Troy Kotsur
ABC

Whether it was your favourite performance of the five or not, it was tough not to be thrilled for CODA's Troy Kotsur when he won the Best Supporting Actor Oscar.

This was an historic win, making him the first deaf male to win an acting Oscar and only the second deaf performer in history, behind his CODA co-star Marlee Matlin who won Best Actress for her performance in Children of a Lesser God back in 1986.

Kotsur's speech was surely the most heartfelt of the night, enough that even his translator struggled to maintain his composure. On top of all that, presenter Youn Yuh-jung stood close to Kotsur during his speech and beamed with joy as he spoke.

In a ceremony unfortunately destined to be best remembered for an act of violence, this is what people should really be talking about.


3. Amy Schumer Steals The Show

Oscars 2022 Amy Schumer
ABC

Though a lot of people groaned when divisive comedian Amy Schumer was announced to be co-hosting the Oscars alongside Wanda Sykes and Regina Hall, in some respects she ended up being the show's saving grace.

While she had to suffer through some of the bland aforementioned material alongside her co-hosts, she fared much better when working on her own and delivering a number of catty quips to the assembled Academy members.

Surely Schumer's highlight was returning to the Dolby Theatre after Will Smith's slap and feigning ignorance, wondering why the atmosphere of the ceremony had changed so drastically.

She made a valiant effort to try and cut through the tension, and her barbed gags during her solo monologues served as a welcome reminder that she's a damn talented roast comic.


2. Kenneth Branagh Finally Wins An Oscar

Oscars 2022 Kenneth Branagh
ABC

Unless you pay supreme attention to the Oscars, you'd be forgiven for assuming that Kenneth Branagh already had an Oscar or two to his name, whether for writing, directing, producing, or acting.

Branagh holds the record for being nominated in the most separate categories at seven, and yet hadn't ever been able to take one of his nods all the way, until this year that is.

While there's a strong argument to be made that the Best Original Screenplay Oscar should've gone to The Worst Person in the World, it was nevertheless a thrill to see the prodigiously talented artist finally take home a gold statue.

Some 32 years after his first nomination, the man everyone just assumed had a couple of Oscars finally got one.


1. A Streaming Service Wins Best Picture For The First Time

Oscars 2022 CODA
ABC

There has been considerable pushback in recent years about the prospect of a direct-to-streaming film winning the Best Picture Oscar, but this year for the first time it finally happened.

While many expected Netflix to be the first streaming service to scoop Best Picture with The Power of the Dog, it of course actually went to Apple TV+ for CODA.

It's fair to say that the barrier of prejudice against streaming films has now been categorically broken down, reiterating that great films are great films no matter where they're shown.

There's little denying that pandemic-related changes in viewing habits have helped normalise streaming films as being just as refined as movies you'd watch on the big screen, and this year's two-horse battle between Netflix and Apple feels like the final word on that.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.