Pet Sematary Review: 4 Ups & 4 Downs

The franchise has been resurrected, but sometimes: dead really is better.

pet sematary
Paramount

Stephen King's Pet Sematary has risen from the dead once more, but just like it's on-screen counterpart, it hasn't come back the same. The old campy movie and chilling source novel have been rehashed without that sense of specialty that made them unique the first time around - instead leaving us with a campfire story we've heard plenty of times before.

For those unfamiliar with the premise, we follow Dr Louis Creed and his wife Rachel as they decide to move from the bustling city of Boston into rural Maine, thinking life will slow down and they can spend more time with their children. But when the countryside escape reveals itself to have a sinister secret hiding in their backyard in the form of a gruesome pet cemetery, they realise the land isn't the fresh start they'd hoped. Tragedy strikes, and the desperate father is lead down a path in the woods that would be best left forgotten.

To be honest though, that description means nothing if you've seen the trailer since all the story is in there anyway. This isn't the next great King adaptation of our time even though it has its merits, and whilst the franchise has been dragged from its resting place, sometimes- dead really is better.

8. DOWN: The Trailer Gives Everything Away

Pet Sematary
Paramount Pictures

Absolutely the biggest failure of this movie lies in its marketing. Anything that had potential to give you chills, right down to the movie's biggest and most intense climactic moment, has been stripped of authenticity by the decision to sell the film on its big hitters. For those of you that haven't seen anything in the run up to this feature, you'll be in for far more of a treat than those that have diligently kept up with the movie's derailed hype train - as the third act is all but shown in its entirety before you even get your arse in a cinema seat.

Whilst some could argue that we already know this story from its original 1989 release, the film absolutely blows its load for any casual fans by showing the damn dead person walking around looking all creepy as if that wasn't where the whole narrative builds to. And yes, this was a different character 30 years ago, so they also ruin their 'same but different' strategy, where they do the ol' bait and switch throughout the film's most iconic moments.

There are no stakes to this film if you've been anywhere near its campaign, which is the sad truth of the situation.


7. DOWN: The Struggle To Justify Its Existence

Pet Sematary cat Church
Paramount Pictures

In short, this is not a movie that needs to exist. It's a great interpretation of the novel that updates an older movie for modern audiences, but nothing is markedly special or different from what we've seen before. Yes, there's some key moments where fans of the original movie will have their expectations toyed with and the ending deviates from expectation, but we never get to see that real, hot fresh take on this treasure trove of a concept.

The film plays out in almost exactly the same fashion as its original, and skips across plenty of interesting side steps it could have taken from other threads of the novel. Obssa Ahmed feels wasted as the spooky Victor Pascow, for example, and the spiritual nature of the movie is all but lost in the classic zombie showdown it presents instead.

Digging this movie up in this very straight-laced remake style doesn't feel at all rewarding.


6. DOWN: The Pacing

Pet Sematary Ellie
Paramount Pictures

Whilst the pacing feels decidedly great at the beginning of the movie as we zip through exposition, by the time we get to the titular area of undead scariness - the investment just isn't there. Pet Sematary's fast pace means that we don't really get a grip on why everything is happening, with certain elements of the movie falling to the wayside that would have done wonders for some audience investment.

The most disappointing part of this is that the presence in the woods, which I won't spoil here, could be much further compounded on to make the film both different and engaging - as the two small hints we get towards something more than 'ancient indian burial ground' are washed away by the film's snappy pace. There's also never really a feel for how this family spiral in the wake of grief, with Louis Creed switching from rational doctor to supernatural enthusiast in the blink of an eye.

The film doesn't feel too long, or too short admittedly - just that it's more of a skeleton than a fully fleshed experience as we're hurried through each event that we know we're going to see.


5. DOWN: The Adherence To Convention

Pet Sematary
Paramount Pictures

Pet Sematary isn't going to blow you out of your seat if you're a big horror fan. In essence, it's a fine enough movie with some solid jump scares, and is produced in typical large-scale Hollywood fashion befitting of Blumhouse's style of blockbuster movies. This is a film that is at home with the Ouija: Origin of Evil and Truth Or Dare films of the world, that functions well as your average scary movie but don't really break free of genre trappings.

What makes this a Down rather than an Up is that it had all the potential to do otherwise. When 2017's It took the world by storm, it was because it was a classic horror story span itself into childhood and nostalgia, bringing horror to another dimension that was aptly appealing.

Pet Sematary has the chance to do this with its representation of death and grief, unpicking the desperation of a family being permanently scarred by loss and the devastating consequences of what it means to cheat the natural order of the life cycle. We got the surface level to that which functions as the 'scary', but the clout behind it was notably lacking.


4. UP: The Atmosphere

PET SEMATARY
Paramount Pictures

Whilst the visuals of the film definitely fall into that 'everything is blue, black, and misty' aesthetic that we see so often in horror, Pet Sematary does manage to establish a great sense of unease from the very outset with its attention to detail. The cemetery itself is suitably creepy, bringing to life a rustling woodland behind the house that feels like a living entity in its inaudible whispers and eerie movements. It's not somewhere we want to be taken too, yet are forced to tread further and further into this barren - but not empty - wasteland.

The tone of the movie is at its most effective when we're taken back to Rachel Creed's childhood, where we witness a traumatising past that ekes in to the present with each terrifying thump from the attic. Though these moments are short, and in essence conventional, there's nothing wrong with the good dose of well-executed terror running through the heart of this movie - even though we've seen similar to it plenty of times before.


3. UP: The Cast

Pet Sematary
Paramount Pictures

Of course, any movie with the excellent John Lithgow in a major supporting role is going to have a saving grace, and his version of Jud is done with as a perfect balance between caring neighbour and disturbed old man. Jason Clarke is also fine as Louis Creed, and Amy Seimetz Rachel Creed does a great job of conveying a woman haunted by death and unable to come to terms with her childhood trauma.

It's just a shame they're all sped through their character arcs so quickly, as otherwise their dives into the emotional repercussions surrounding the characters could have been all the more impactful.

As for Jeté Laurence as Ellie Creed, she starts a little too sickly-sweet as a little girl, before turning and channelling that into her undead tween that's suitably terrifying. It's hard to find good child actors that can really sell themselves, so Laurence does an excellent job of convincing us she's good girl gone bad, if a little on the nose at times. I'd argue that its the script over Laurence's badass performance, however.

And of course, Church, played by Tonic and his furry friends, is brilliantly depicted and gets the gold star.


2. UP: The Ending

Pet Sematary
Paramount Pictures

The ending of this movie is one that's cheesy as anything - but it's a fun way to finish on an unexpected note where everything else has felt so predictable. Without giving anything away since it's the only real surprise in the entire movie, the final act of the film takes some big liberties with the plot that prove the directors could have easily extrapolated something new and different for the rest of the narrative, and ran with it.

It doesn't quite fit with the sour dread that's planted throughout the rest of the story, and leans almost into comedy by its ridiculous premise - but that's exactly what a new take on the movie should have been. Where the rest of the film focuses on redoing in serious, dour tones, the end goes a little wild and shows some soul that's missing from the rest of the runtime.

The 1989 Pet Sematary is a campy mess, but it's beloved for that too. Horror works best with a little nod to its farcical side, so it's a shame to see that gone to waste throughout this new take on the old material. At least the ending decides to take its own direction, though this will be a turn off for some fans instead.


1. UP: The Scares

Pet Sematary
Paramount Pictures

This is somewhere down the line - as the scares it does offer are well measured and not over populated for the sake of making it as over the top as possible, instead picking and choosing its moments carefully to imbue true unease into the narrative. When we're given jump scares, as we have to bear in any horror movie ever, they're carefully stipulated against an already disturbing tone so as to not feel cheap - with one certain foot-based moment coming to mind as cleverly dancing around what you'd expect.

The previous inhabitants of the graveyard are also well put together, with the cat's matted fur and milky eyes that define him as the poster boy for the film being particularly well done.

All in all, there's no quibbles with the horror of this horror movie, it's just that they'd be better put to use in something with a little more emotional investment and building around the edges.


Contributor
Contributor

Horror film junkie, burrito connoisseur, and serial cat stroker. WhatCulture's least favourite ginger.