Pierce Brosnan: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Which side does James Bond fall on?

Pierce Brosnan A Long Way Down Pierce Brosnan returns to our screens this weekend in A Long Way Down, a dark comedy based loosely on the novel by Nick Hornby (About a Boy). Set on New Year's Eve, the film features four characters who meet on a London rooftop, each of them intending to commit suicide. Directed by Luc Besson protégé Pascal Chaumeil, the film could be just the hit that Brosnan could do with late in his career. It's fair to say that none of the six actors to date who have played James Bond have gone on to sustain those levels of public prominence (though with Daniel Craig it is perhaps too early to say). Some, like George Lazenby and Roger Moore, have little by little eschewed the film business and diversified their interests; others, like Sean Connery and Timothy Dalton, have taken on work that deliberately distanced them from 007. Brosnan's post-Bond career falls into the latter camp, and while he's had some stirring successes along the way, he's also done some films that have left us decidely shaken. With this in mind, here is a look back at the highs and lows of Brosnan's illustrious career both in and out of that famous tux. Panic not, there will be plenty of Bond along the way - and if you read my recent article on the Bond series, you'll have a fair idea of what's coming. We'll kick off our list, however, with a performance that's about as far from Bond as one can get...

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Gideon - Seraphim Falls (2006)

Discounting Connery's appearance in Shalako, this is perhaps the only instance where an actor who played James Bond has gone on to do a western (and no, Hot Fuzz or Cowboys & Aliens don't count). It might seem like an ill fit at first glance, but Brosnan takes to his new surroundings pretty well, turning in a good performance which rises above the film as a whole. Seraphim Falls is a tale of revenge set three years after the end of the American Civil War. Beginning in the Ruby Mountains, it follows Colonel Carver (Liam Neeson) and his pursuit of fellow soldier Gideon (Brosnan) for what happened at the eponymous Falls shortly after the war ended. The chase leads them through the mountains and across the plains, with both parties leaving death and bloodshed in their wake as they build up to the inevitable confrontation. Seraphim Falls isn't a great film by any means: it's very episodic, the narrative is derivative, its ending is very clumsy and we don't empathise enough with Neeson's character. But what is does have in its favour is Brosnan's performance, which surprises us without looking like it's trying to do just that. Having made us wince in the opening scene, where he has to dig out a bullet from his own arm with a bowie knife, Brosnan gives us a convincing portrayal of deep-rooted guilt and regret. It's a fitting place to start our countdown - and plus, the goatee rather suits him.

4. Adam Lang - The Ghost Writer (2010)

I've written quite a lot about Roman Polanski during the last few years, including a piece on this very site about how one can appreciate his films in spite of his actions outside of them. While it may be a cliché to dredge this up, The Ghost Writer is bound up in the director's controversies, being completed while hewas under house arrest in Switzerland. The controversy didn't damage the film commercially, but it's still an underrated work in the Polanski canon. The Ghost Writer (sometimes just called The Ghost) is a political thriller based upon the novel by Robert Harris. It follows a nameless ghost writer (Ewan McGregor) who is commissioned to complete the memoirs of former Prime Minister Adam Lang (Brosnan), following the death of his previous biographer in an accident. As Lang fights off accusations of war crimes, the writer begins to uncover dark and murky dealings involving illegal links to the CIA... Polanski fans will recognise many of the tropes he employs in telling Harris' story: the architecture is deeply intimidating, political corruption is at the forefront, and the ending is deeply unsettling. What is less familiar is Brosnan's performance, which is more mercurial and intimidating than many of his other post-Bond roles. While Adam Lang as a character has strong echoes of Tony Blair, Brosnan never allows him to become a cipher, imbuing him with an icy quality that constantly unsettles us. It's a taut, thought-provoking and timely performance in a thriller which deserves more attention.

3. Andrew Osnard - The Tailor Of Panama (2001)

John Le Carré is perhaps the best-known and most successful 'anti-Bond' spy writer, with his tales of bureaucratic frustration and subtle double-dealings being a welcome contrast to Ian Fleming's fast cars and one-liners. Many adaptations of his stories have become screen hits, like The Spy Who Came In From The Cold, The Constant Gardener and both versions of Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy. The Tailor of Panama has always been somewhat overlooked in this regard - and in light of Brosnan's performance, that's rather a shame.

The Tailor of Panama stars Brosnan as MI6 operative Andrew Osnard, who is reassigned to Panama after having an affair with the Spanish foreign minister's wife. Once there he befriends Harry Pendel (Geoffrey Rush), a tailor to many of the most important Panamian officials. Keen to rebuild his reputation, Osnard asks Pendel to feed him information from his clients, which he in turn passes on to his superiors. Suffice to say, things quickly get out of hand... Directed by John Boorman of Deliverance fame, The Tailor of Panama is a lively romp which is more openly satirical than many Le Carré adaptations. Brosnan is clearly enjoying himself, being let off the leash a little and developing great chemistry with both Rush and Jamie Lee Curtis. His performance has all the sophistication of Bond but is more reckless and morally compromised, which makes for a very entertaining thriller.

2. Thomas Crown - The Thomas Crown Affair (1999)

We all like to moan about remakes of classic films, and barely a week goes by without Hollywood dishing up another underwhelming monstrosity which utterly deflowers a much-loved original. But in amongst all the dross and dreck, there are a handful of remakes which are arguably better than the originals. These include Werner Herzog's take on Nosferatu, the musical version of Little Shop of Horrors, and John McTiernan's remake of 1960s classic The Thomas Crown Affair. The Thomas Crown Affair features Brosnan as the title character, a wealthy financier and thrillseeker who will do anything to stop being bored. After a priceless Monet painting is stolen from the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the insurers send in investigator Catherine Banning (Rene Russo) to discovers whether Crown was involved. What follows is a game of cat-and-mouse where the two become lovers and the missing painting's location is finally revealed. Brosnan may not have the raw, smouldering sex appeal that Steve McQueen possessed in the original, but he does bring a playful sense of devil-may-care detachment which is perfect for the part. His scenes are Russo are absolutely electric, with each party trying to test the other's loyalty and wondering how far they can lower their guard. Throw in some witty nods to René Magritte and some slick direction from the man who made Die Hard hum, and you have a remake that truly rivals the original while standing firmly on its own.

1. James Bond - Goldeneye (1995)

Brosnan's best performance comes in his very first appearance as 007. He'd waited a long time to get to this point, having been passed over in favour of Timothy Dalton at the height of his TV fame on Remington Steele. And with the Bond series being relaunched after a six-year hiatus, during which time the Cold War had concluded, the pressure was certainly on for him to deliver. Fortunately for all concerned, he did, and as a result 007 is still alive and kicking today. Setting up Bond for the post-Cold War era, Goldeneye begins with Bond and fellow 00 agent Alec Trevelyan (Sean Bean) breaking into a Soviet facility in 1986; they are ambushed and Bond escapes, leaving Alec for dead. Nine years later, Bond is tasked by the new M (Judi Dench) to find Goldeneye, a satellite system which generates an electomagnetic pulse. His search leads him to the elusive Janus corporation, run by a frisky assassin and a familiar face... Goldeneye is directed by Martin Campbell, who later made Casino Royale, and can therefore claim to be the only director to have saved Bond's bacon twice. But for all his good work behind the camera, the film ultimately works because of Brosnan's performance. He strikes a perfect balance between the rougher, dangerous edge that Dalton brought to the part and the best elements of Roger Moore's high camp wit. For all the problems with his later outings, Brosnan's first bash at Bond is still a classic, and its influence is writ large over Skyfall. Having bonded with Brosnan over his best work, now let's take a look at some of his worst...

And 5 That Sucked...

5. Stuart 'Stu' Dunmire - Mrs. Doubtfire (1993)

Between leaving Remington Steele in 1987 and landing the part of Bond in 1994, Brosnan spent a lot of his time in TV movies and supporting parts in films. As we saw from Seraphim Falls, it's possible for an actor to put in a good performance even when the film around them isn't very good. Likewise, the opposite is true, and nowhere is this clearer in Brosnan's pre-Bond career than Mrs. Doubtfire. Mrs. Doubtfire stars Robin Williams as Daniel Hillard, a talented but unemployed voice actor whose wife files for divorce after their son's birthday party. Devoted to his children but unable to see them through the custody arrangements, Hillard learns that his ex-wife is looking to hire a housekeeper. With the help of his make-up artist brother (Harvey Fierstein), he transforms into Euphegenia Doubtfire, allowing him to see his children all the time without them even knowing it. Mrs. Doubtfire is one of Columbus' better films; provided you don't find the central conceit to be creepy, it's both funny and rather touching. But while most of the cast are very well-suited to their parts, Brosnan looks somewhat out of place. He's never been brilliant at out-and-out comedy, throwing away many of his lines in the pool scene and making the choking scene in the restaurant look very laboured. It's not enough to ruin the film, but it is a rather noticeable problem.

4. Chiron - Percy Jackson And The Lightning Thief (2010)

While the thriller genre has been his staple diet, stretching back to The Long Good Friday, Brosnan has dabbled in many other genres throughout his career. 17 years after Robin Williams pelted him with limes and gave him the Heimlich manouevre, Brosnan reunited with Chris Columbus for Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief. Suffice to say, his first outing in the fantasy genre left a lot to be desired. Based loosely on the book by Rick Riordan, Percy Jackson follows its eponymous teenager (Logan Lerman), who discovers that he is a demigod, the offspring of a human and the Greek god Poseidon. He is taken to Camp Half-Blood where he meets other demigods, and is charged with tracking down a missing lightning bolt, seemingly stolen from the Gods. If it not returned to Mount Olympus before the Summer Solstice, a great war will start. In case that plot summary didn't convey it, Percy Jackson is a deeply derivative work. Its release was positioned between the sixth and seventh Harry Potter films, and its plot and characters mirror J. K. Rowling's to almost eerie degrees. Brosnan's character mainly exists to explain the mythology to Percy, but his delivery lacks enthusiasm and he seems lost in the dodgy CG landscape. In short he makes the very least of what is already a duff part, ensuring that this franchise barely got to a second (albeit better) instalment.

3. Dr. Lawrence Angelo - The Lawnmower Man (1992)

Stephen King fans have often had a rough ride when it comes to adaptations of his work. The most famous example of course would be The Shining, wherein King was so disatisfied with the changes Stanley Kubrick made that he created his own version for TV in 1997. The Lawnmower Man, however, is much more brazen in its departures from the original short story, so much so that King sued the studio to have his name removed. The Lawnmower Man stars Brosnan as Dr. Lawrence Angelo, a scientist interested in how virtual reality can potentially increase human intelligence. One summer he spots the simple-minded Jobe Smith (Jeff Fahey) mowing his lawn, and offers him the chance to play some of his 'games'. The experiment is initially a success, but soon Smith's intelligence outstrips Angelo's and he begins developing other, stranger abilities. The Lawnmower Man has something of a cult following among horror fans, and it's not hard to see why. If you can get past the sub-Tron early-1990s visuals, it does contain some interesting ideas that, in the hands of someone like Wes Craven, could have really come together. But while Fahey is convincing as the dunce who becomes a superhuman, Brosnan is completely unbelievable. Notwithstanding the Hollywood cliché of casting conspicuously glamorous people as scientists, he fails to make the techno-babble believable, and his emotional responses are flat and unengaging. And speaking of unengaging...

2. James Bond - Die Another Day (2002)

I've already bashed Die Another Day a awful lot in my Bond article, but one thing I've not dwelt on before was Brosnan's performance, in what turned out to be his final appearance as 007. There was a lot of bad press around the film's release about contract disputes and him being seen as too old for the part, and after its release it was clear that his version of the character had run its course. Die Another Day begins with Bond being betrayed and captured during a treacherous mission in North Korea. Released a year later as part of a prisoner exchange, his 00 status is rescinded, with M (Judi Dench) believing that he leaked vital state secrets under torture. Suspecting that there is a double agent operating inside MI6, Bond escapes from custody and travels the globe in search of answers, eventually falling foul of insomniac billionaire Gustav Graves (Toby Stephens). There are many aspects of Die Another Day which are both risible and despair-inducing: the invisible car, the horrible CGI wave, the all-too-blatant references to other Bond films, and of course Madonna. But what's not mentioned quite so often is Brosnan's performance, which betrays his annoyance with those running the franchise. While in Goldeneye he seemed fun, fresh-faced and highly confident, here he seems weary and jaded, trudging through his one-liners with a look of cynical disdain. But all that's highly preferable to his performance in the very worst film on this list...

1. Sam Carmichael - Mamma Mia! (2008)

I really don't like ABBA. I find their singing irritating, their songs largely mediocre, and dislike the way they've come to epitomise the 1970s zeitgeist. With this in mind, you might say that this entry is boringly predictable, and that Mamma Mia! should just be enjoyed for what it is. But even putting the music aside, that becomes very difficult with all the film's other problems, one of the biggest ones being Brosnan. Directed by Phyllida Lloyd (The Iron Lady), Mamma Mia! is based on the hugely popular musical by Catherine Johnson. The plot, for want of a better word, revolves around Sophie Sheridan (Amanda Seyfried), a 20-year-old lady who wants to marry her fiancé Sky (Dominic Cooper). Not knowing who her father is, she finds entries in her mother's diary recalling three intimate dates with different men. Unbeknownst to her mother (Meryl Streep), she invites all three men to the Greek island where she is staying to determine who should take her down the aisle. Notwithstanding Mamma Mia!'s shambolic plot, and the way in which ABBA's songs are crowbarred into it, the film is sunk by a series of awkward performances. While Colin Firth and Stellan Skargård have both seen better days, Brosnan is the biggest culprit, looking completely lost and being totally unconvincing in the part. Not to mention that his rendition of 'S.O.S.' is physically painful to sit through, making Russell Crowe's singing in Les Misérables look like Pavarotti by comparison. It's a perfect trainwreck of a film, and the perfect choice for Brosnan's worst performance. --- Disagree with my choices? Drop me a comment below or visit Mumby at the Movies for more film reviews.

Contributor
Contributor

Freelance copywriter, film buff, community radio presenter. Former host of The Movie Hour podcast (http://www.lionheartradio.com/ and click 'Interviews'), currently presenting on Phonic FM in Exeter (http://www.phonic.fm/). Other loves include theatre, music and test cricket.