Pixar vs Dreamworks: Which Animation Studio is Really the Best?

I am, or at least used to be a massive Pixar fan. From the first time I saw Toy Story in the cinema in 1995 when I was five years old I was obsessed... so obsessed and blown away in fact that for the next ten years of my life after this I tried to perfect my artistic skills so that one day I would be lucky enough to work in the fantastic Pixar building and help create some of my all time favorite films. Long story short, turns out I'm not exactly Picasso. If you were to ask me this question five years ago: "Which studio is better, Pixar or Dreamworks?" I would have probably laughed at you and screamed Pixar in your face. However, if I am being completely honest, Pixar has let me down over the last few years. Pixar's first six films were incredible and showed us beautifully imagined worlds like never really before on film. We were blown away by the technology and the storytelling was some of, if not the best in Hollywood at the time. But since the movie Cars, things began to change for me... I am actually one of the very few people who don't consider Cars to be one of Pixar's two worst films in its history, and the film I do believe should be placed next to Cars 2 on that list would probably shock you out of reading this article... so I will tell you at the end like a wimp. But although I enjoyed Cars and thought it was a perfectly enjoyable and even touching film, this for me was the moment when Pixar went from being revolutionary to slowly becoming pretty darn average. It was at this point where I truly believe Pixar had run out of its best ideas, and although Pixar would create a few great films after Cars, the films wouldn't be anywhere near as original as its first 6 and the best film to come after Cars was in fact a sequel. When Pixar and Dreamworks have gone up against each other at the Oscar's, most of the time Pixar is guaranteed the win. It's because of this critical success that people haven't really been paying enough attention to Dreamworks... at least not as much as they pay attention to Pixar. Dreamworks produces many more films a year than Pixar do, but Pixar's films are certainly the more buzzed and talked about. But is this fair? Is Dreamworks just as good as Pixar, or maybe even better? To find out, I am going to compare 5 Pixar films and 5 Dreamworks films to try to settle this debate once and for all. I will only pick each studios better films and try to match them to similar films within each studios catalog. Perhaps all along we have been lead to believe Pixar is far superior when in fact, deep down, we have been enjoying Dreamworks films much, much more...

5. A Bug's Life (1998) VS Antz (1998)

This particular debate has perplexed me for years, and if I am honest I am not entirely sure which film I consider to be the greatest. A Bug's Life in my opinion is Pixar's most underrated film, and probably the film most people forget was actually made by Pixar. For some reason Pixar never mentions the film when advertising its recent releases, although this is definitely one of my personal favorites. A Bug's Life is certainly more beautiful than Antz and definitely has the far superior animation... it probably also has a slightly better story but then again that story was basically a copy of The Magnificent Seven which itself is a copy of Seven Samurai. However, even though both films have pretty stunning voice actors on board, A Bug's Life doesn't have Woody Allen, and if a film has Woody Allen in it it is almost always better. Woody Allen is one of the funniest men working in film today, and the voice he lends to Dreamworks first animation film's central character Z gives him the edge over the very similar but just a little less likable Flik from a Bug's Life. Antz is probably also the more mature film out of the two, and is a film which only improves with age. Woody Allen's sarcastic and self pitying humor is perfectly on point in this movie and speaks more to the adults in the cinema than it does to the children. Whilst this isn't necessarily a criticism, A Bug's Life is the more childish film. I'd also argue, though both films have stunning and emotional moments, for example in A Bug's Life when Flik and the rest of the ants finally stand up to Hopper the evil grasshopper; I would say again that Antz probably just about edges out A Bug's Life on the emotional front. When Barbatus, Z's ant friend dies in battle this is a far more emotional moment than any singular moment in A Bug's Life. You may also be surprised to find out that critically speaking Antz just edges out A Bug's Life on Rotten Tomatoes, the former scoring a 95 percent approval rating and the latter scoring 3 points below with 92. Either way, at this point in both Pixar's and Dreamworks animation careers, both studios were on top form and with these particular films, I'd say they were just about level pegging. The only thing that really pushes Pixar in the lead at this point in 1998 was the massive success it had with it's first film Toy Story, and as Antz was Dreamworks first film, it was still really trying to prove itself and prove it could compete. Luckily the film proved that it could do just that.

4. Monsters Inc (2001) VS Shrek (2001)

These two films have admittedly less in common with one another than the last two, but they both came out in the same year and both revolve around a giant, lovable brightly colored "monster". Monsters Inc is another example of a film a lot of people forget to love when they think of Pixar. Because of recent films such as Wall-e and Up and how much they loved them, people forget that arguably Pixar's earliest films were actually a little better?- my opinion. The thing I loved about the early days of Pixar was the fact that the creators took ideas we all thought about as children, "What if our toys were real?", "What is Monster's lived in our closets?" and brought them to magnificent life on screen. Adults and children alike could enjoy these films because they could either relive their childhood fantasies or for the children, be encouraged to explore their imaginations and let it take them where ever they wanted to go. In Pixar's early days, the films had a little bit more fun than they tend to do now. Monsters Inc is a wonderful film. John Goodman and Billy Crystal are fantastic in their roles and bring great life and comedy to their characters. The whole film is a visual feats of colors and creatures than you can't help but fall in love with immediately, and the concept that monsters need children's screams for energy like we need oil is one of Pixar's finest. All this said, I still will have to give this one to Dreamworks. Shrek may look less fantastical, and may even arguably be a little less imaginative and slightly more conventional, but that film really is one of the greatest animation films of all time, and in my opinion places above Monsters Inc. Whereas many people consider Monsters Inc the more forgettable Pixar movie, Shrek is arguably THE Dreamworks movie and finally was enough to get Pixar a little scared. Despite the fact that Rotten Tomatoes places Shrek slightly lower down the chart than Monsters Inc, lets not forget that Shrek beat MI at the Academy Awards and won the first ever Academy Award for Best Animated Feature. Shrek was the more touching and more human film. We could emphasize with the main characters more than we could with any character in Monsters Inc and because of this we were overall more invested in Shrek's journey and therefore the film. And as funny as Billy Crystal is in the film, Eddie Murphy as Donkey is unbeatable.

3. Finding Nemo (2003) VS Shark Tale (2004)

Pixar needed a victory or else surprisingly Dreamworks would actually be just a little in the lead, beating out one of it's greatest films and drawing with another. Luckily, in these two similar themed films again released pretty much back to back Finding Nemo is unarguably the champion. No animated film could really compete with this Pixar classic, least of all one of Dreamworks least well received animated features. In fact, any film what so ever would struggle to go toe to toe with this giant. Finding Nemo unsurprisingly won the Academy Award for best Animated Feature and has a 100% score amongst top critics on Rotten Tomatoes compared to Shark Tales measly 30%. Now, I am going to be completely honest with you or else I'd loose all credibility as a writer. When I first saw Finding Nemo in the cinema at age 13 I wasn't all that impressed. It didn't connect with me on the same level as Toy Story did, and didn't leave as much of an impact at least initially as Shrek had either. The reason I was disappointed was probably because I imagined something far more "fun" and less emotionally mature and deep. That said, since 2003 I have probably watched Finding Nemo every single year and love it more and more with every viewing. I can say now quite honestly that I would consider Finding Nemo to be in the top 5 greatest animated films ever made. When I went to see Shark Tale in the cinema I actually really enjoyed it. I was much more familiar with the very famous voice cast (Will Smith, Renee Zellweger, Angelina Jolie, Robert De Niro) and it was exactly the kind of happy popcorn film I was looking for (plus I had the song "Car Wash" stuck in my head and on my ipod for months after the song was used in the film). That said, I have since only seen the film perhaps two more times and each time I have realized what a fool I was for not understanding Finding Nemo's genius the first time around. Shark Tale is a completely fine and passable children's movie, but it has zero emotional depth and doesn't even come almost close to capturing the magnificently breath taking beauty of life beneath the waves. Finding Nemo is even to this day Pixar's most beautiful film and probably even it's best film that doesn't begin with a "T". If Pixar had anything to prove after loosing out to Dreamworks at the Academy Awards with Shrek, this film must have made Dreamworks wet its pants with fear. Luckily for Dreamworks, Pixar couldn't really set the bar higher than they did with Finding Nemo, and Dreamworks had no where to go but up after their worst critical failure to date.

2. The Incredibles (2004) VS Megamind (2010)

At this point you have probably got to start feeling sorry for Dreamworks. Despite initially entering into this list with the delusion that Dreamworks has been getting better and better and Pixar have been getting worse and worse... it seems like perhaps both movie studios films have been suffering in recent years. Megamind isn't even a slightly bad film however, and though it wasn't as revolutionary as The Incredibles was, it was still one of the better animated films in the last ten years. That said, it certainly isn't even close to Dreamworks greatest, and Shrek set the bar at a level that Dreamworks has struggled to reach ever since. Both films take the superhero genre and decide to twist them somewhat. Megamind shows a villain who becomes a hero, and the film is completely from the villains point of view (a story that is actually very common now within animated features) whereas The Incredibles is from the point of view of aging superheroes having to come out of retirement and hiding although they had gotten so used to living pretty mundane existences. Though The Incredibles storyline isn't actually as unique as you think it is (the whole idea of coming out of retirement for one last job is somewhat of a staple within action adventure films) it had never been used this way before with superheroes, and the superhero genre is a genre which has always been in desperate need of being shaken up just a little. Both films have great voice casts however Megamind certainly edges out The Incredibles in this respect (Will Ferrell, Tina Fey, Brad Pitt). That said, Dreamworks has always been known to use big named stars to attract people away from Pixar and to their own films, and it is actually a strength of Pixar's that they are able to cast much less well known actors and people will still flock to see them regardless. Disney never used to hire stars to voice cast their characters and they were once, and still to an extent are the animation giants. Also, as much as a love love love Tina Fey... Holly Hunter is one of my favorite all time dramatic/comedic actresses so hearing her voice in The Incredibles immediately sealed the deal with me. Megamind was obviously an attempt by Pixar to appeal to a similar audience and almost directly compete (though released years apart) with The Incredibles. Despite having the benefit of being able to study its competition for 6 years, Dreamworks couldn't make a superhero film even half as memorable as Pixar's the Incredible is. I think I can already tell who is going to win this battle.

1. Toy Story 3 (2010) VS Shrek 2 (2004)

Before you start complaining that these films have nothing in common, the reason for their inclusion and comparison is that the Toy Story series of films are Pixar's most successful and most well respected, and the Shrek series of films are Dreamworks most successful and well respected. It only seemed fair that to end this battle, we compare arguably each film studios greatest ever films. Shrek 2 did the impossible- it was even better than it's original, and considering its original won the Academy Award that is really saying something. Shrek was a difficult film to create a sequel to because the fairly simple concept which every fairy tale film follows... man and woman fall in love and get married... had already been done. The reason Disney never creates actual sequels to its movies (just direct to DVD rubbish) is because by the time the first film is over, the whole fairy tale story has finished. No one cares what happens to Cinderella after the first movie- all we want to know is that she lived happily ever after the end- none of this "a twist in time" lunacy. Shrek 2 however made us actually want to know what happens after happily ever after. It introduced us to a much larger filmic world and to characters we have since all fallen in love with (Puss in Boots anyone?). It also used Jennifer Saunders to perfection as the menacing fairy godmother and the scene where Shrek rides the giant gingerbread man to the castle whilst Jennifer Saunders sings Bonnie Tyler's "Holding Out For A Hero" is one of the most thrilling, heart racing scenes in animated film history. Toy Story 3 though is Toy Story 3... perhaps the most loved film of recent years. As much as I love the film, I would actually make the argument that it is possibly the worst of the Toy Story films. It is certainly the most beautiful and also by far the most emotional , but I find the story drags in places (particularly the middle) and isn't as engaging (except for the scene where they are all almost burnt to death) as the other two. It is still one of Pixar's greatest films and one of the best animated films of all time however. I know what I am about to say is going to be controversial, but you guys love opinions different than your own don't you? (You sure seem to love telling me how wrong I am in the comments sections on my previous articles). Personally, out of these two films, I would prefer to sit down again and watch Shrek 2 than I would watch Toy Story 3. I really love Shrek 2, and probably would enjoy watching it just as much as either Toy Story 1 and 2 (which I consider my favorite animated 1/2 of all time). Although I initially began this article thinking that Dreamworks may actually end up beating out Pixar, this has clearly not been the case. As much as Dreamworks have made some truly brilliant films over the years, and a much as Pixar is slowly loosing it's touch and becoming more and more average, Pixar is still the undefeated champion of the computer animated world. For all of those that care or remember (or indeed read this far), Up is my second least favorite Pixar film. For some reason I struggle to even stay awake during that film though I know many people who consider it their favorite Pixar movie. If it wasn't Pixar and I wasn't frightened of being laughed out of all movie circles I would even go as far as to say that I find Up to be a pretty bad, unoriginal film and if it had been a Dreamworks film, I believe many people would have given it a much harder time than it got. The opening 5 minutes aren't even all that good really either are they... cheesy emotional blackmail if you ask me. This article has been much more about starting a conversation than really anything else. My winner is Pixar, but I could still be persuaded to turn to Dreamworks (especially if you bring up Cars 2). Please, I'd love to hear your favorite animated film studio and your reasons why below in the comments section. If you manage to change my mind I will be sure to tell you...

Contributor

I am a recent Screenwriting for Film and Television graduate from the UK. I am an unashamed geek who loves everything Marvel, and anything Joss Whedon has ever touched (except for maybe Alien Resurrection and Titan A.E). My current favorite TV shows are Breaking Bad, Family Guy, House of Cards, Game of Thrones, American Horror Story, Homeland and Glee. I look forward to debating things with all of you in the future. (As of January 2013 I have had over 1 million views since joining WhatCulture in September 2012. You can reach me at danieljamesbowen@hotmail.co.uk)