Prometheus 2: 10 Questions The Film Needs To Answer

A sequel's been announced, but will it tie up the many, many loose ends of its predecessor?

In space, no one can hear you scream. Well, unless it's the collective groans of about a million Alien fans when promised prequel Prometheus delivered itself to the cinema, only to tell a 99% standalone story told practically adjacent to the mythos and story of the ill-fated Nostromo. That sound was practically heard in every part of the cosmos. Ridley Scott, a talented director, broke ground with the claustrophobic space thriller Alien that introduced body horror and Cthulu-esque terror to a whole new generation, and delighted fans around the world when he announced new film Prometheus would deal with the story before his previous effort. Not everyone was satisfied, expecting Scott to pull out all the stops to craft a dark, thrilling prologue that upon its finale would lead directly into the events that preceded Alien. Not every question was answered - far from it - but a larger, more daring mythology was hinted at, and with the news that Prometheus 2, a sequel to his 2012 film, is in development with the original cast of Noomi Rapace and Michael Fassbender as Christian scientist turned heroic survivor Elizabeth Shaw, and morally grey android David, fans were given a light at the end of the tunnel. Scott has some work to do in order to regain the trust of his fans, many of whom felt let down by the lack of answers in Prometheus, but fortunately we've compiled a list of ten of the most mythological, meaningful and important questions Scott needs to answer from Prometheus in the sequel...

10. What Was The Engineer Actually Doing In The Prologue?

One of the biggest and most ambiguous questions that was never answered in Prometheus is what on Earth - or not as it may be - is going on in the eerie prologue to Prometheus, and what effect does it have on the rest of the film? In case you're stumped trying to remember the opening sequence, several Engineers land on a terraformed planet - foliage, waterfalls, the works - and one of them voluntarily ingests a vial of black liquid in what appears to be a ritual of sorts, evoking a post-modern take on Aztec and Mayan sacrifices. Soon after the Engineer dissolves into a pool of fluid that begins to affect the organisms in the water. While it's clear that the Engineer is hinted at starting life on Earth, the writers and director have never explicitly confirmed that it is indeed Earth, and the way that the sacrifice is framed - affecting the microscopic life rather than bigger lifeforms - questions whether or not Earth is the planet, given that it's believed that the Engineers specifically saw potential in humanity, rather than other lifeforms. Interestingly, Jon Spaihts' original script has the black liquid become beetles who bite primordial humans, granting them an alien intelligence in the same way Prometheus gave humanity fire and providing a stronger way of confirming that the prologue takes place on Earth. Even the question of why the Engineer was willing to sacrifice his life in order to affect a massive ecological and genetic change remains murky. At best his actions are a beautiful self-sacrifice and the Engineers appear as graceful, advanced, benevolent beings, and at worst it's a cruel experiment of literally playing God. Scott would earn himself a lot of brownie points from fans by officially clearing up the prologue scene once and for all.

9. Will Damon Lindelof Be Involved?

Let's face it, a lot of the media attention around Prometheus wasn't just about Ridley Scott's return to sci-fi or his re-emergence into the Xenomorphic mythos he'd helped create; it was the fact that 'LOST' co-showrunner Damon Lindelof was helming the final script. This news was met with a general cry of 'huh?' and soon the film's open-ended questions and plot left a lot of fans feeling rather... well, lost. The news that Prometheus will have a confirmed sequel has sent parts of the Internet into a spin, particularly given that Lindelof hasn't confirmed one way or another whether or not he will have any involvement in the film's script, story, or characters. While a lot of fans will no doubt decry that Mr Lindelof should keep his mitts away from the Alien world, and he has since claimed he will not be involved in the film, the guy did no doubt help provide tantalising leads and theories that have kept Prometheus fans debating and wondering about how this story will connect to the wider universe. Even if Lindelof has absolutely no involvement - and we're suspecting he may well end up having some kind of advisory or producer role down the line - the big overarching mysteries will be part of his mark on the universe regardless.

8. How Did The Murals Actually Get There?

This one is much more of a smaller note, and is a possible MacGuffin, but still €“ how did the murals around the world get there in the first place? In Prometheus, Shaw and Holloway present documented symbols, glyphs and pictograms from across the globe that all share common factors, in particular a series of points that indicate a star system and planet, as well as humanoid figures pointing to it. However, even when the rest of the film and the surrounding fan theories are taken into account, no concrete way of confirming how these murals came to be has been verified. If every culture featured experienced the beings at one point or another, then not only would this suggest the possibility of the Engineers helping to bring about the human race, it would also suggest they also maintained contact with them for thousands of years. Now, if we're talking about the whole Xenoverse and not just the world of Prometheus, then human civilisation has long since been given a helping hand by extraterrestrials (as shown in Alien vs Predator wherein humanity helped Predators hunt Xenomorphs for sport in exchange for new technology). This might not be anything new to the Xenoverse, but it still requires that several factions of extraterrestrials had a hand in humanity's development at some point in time. Either way, the murals indicate a passage of knowledge from generation to generation and that the Engineers were somehow capable of demonstrating to older civilisations methods of finding them through a rudimentary ephemeris (star map), right before the Engineers decided humanity wasn't worth surviving and planned to have us all eradicated off the face of the planet. At quite what point the Engineers did this remains unclear, but if Scott and the team behind Prometheus 2 could give us a definitive answer €“ somewhat easier given the film will probably be about the Engineer homeworld €“ it'd clear up a big plot hole in the original film.

7. Will Shaw Survive Her Caesarian?

One of the most gruesome scenes in Prometheus didn't involve menacing assaults or the murder of the ship's crew and all but confirmed Shaw's role as badass survivor heroine; it involved Shaw, after being impregnated with the alien spawn of her unwittingly infected boyfriend rushing into a bio-pod and extracting the foetus in excruciatingly gory detail. This self-performed Caesarian-meets-abortion stood out as a horrific highlight of the film and helped allay moviegoers' fears that the deeply religious, scientific and sweet Elizabeth was nothing more than a bit of a wimp. In the original script, the scene actually plays out in an even more gruesome fashion with the lead heroine wrenching the alien out of her womb, only to collapse due to blood loss and to find the newly-grown creature tearing the spaceship apart hours later once the bio-pod has finished reassembling her organs and patching her up, as it had to crack her chest open to extract the foetus. One rough labour and a half. The real question for Elizabeth, however, is whether or not her still-healing injury will play a role in her survival. Given that she managed to run across hard stone to escape the exploding Prometheus vessel as it crashed, fight off an Engineer, and was mobile at all, it seems as though Shaw is pretty indestructible; however, a massive injury like that needs to be referenced at some point, as well as the possibility that being an alien incubator has done something to her body.

6. What's With The Massive Human Head?

In the weapons chamber that the expedition team discover, the most prominent feature - aside from the hundreds, perhaps thousands, of unhatched Xenomorph eggs of black goo - is the massive humanoid face that takes pride of place in the centre of the room. The head is distinctly human and even seems to reflect Neoclassical architecture, as if it comes off the head of a gigantic statue of a Grecian or Roman god, and yet it is barely commented on. The head does not necessarily need addressing, given that the moon it resides on has since been all but abandoned by Shaw and David, but given that the sequel looks set to be even further entrenched in Engineer culture, another chance to explore the significance of these heads would be a good tie to the original Prometheus film. The head itself seems to represent the head of the Engineers, but what purpose does it serve, if any? Admittedly, it could all just be an ultra-cool, stylistic touch and part of the marketing campaign, but given that Ridley Scott is a talented, conscientious filmmaker, it makes more sense that the head is something reflective and worth commenting on in the sequel as part if a world-building exercise. Don't even get started on the mural that changed when the humans entered...

5. What Exactly Happened 2000 Years Ago?

The ship's crew, upon entering the abandoned Engineer temple they discover, find themselves searching through the catacombs of the abandoned place. During this, they enter a chamber which fans have dubbed the 'egg chamber', filled with capsules of the black goo weapon. During this scene, the crew members remark upon discovery that 2000 years ago an incident occurred at the temple just as the ships across the planet were set to journey to Earth, killing virtually everyone at the outpost and preventing humanity from being killed by the black goo. The question is, what happened two thousand years ago that made the Engineers want to wipe humanity out? Now, given that we're dealing with a mythos that has recently become intertwined with that of the rest of humanity, it seems extremely coincidental or prominent that the writers would choose 2000 years ago for the last time the Engineers operated as they did and suffered the biological weapon-induced catastrophe. However, it seems as though something on Earth may have caused them to weaponise the goo before things went awry. Plenty of fan theories around the Internet have speculated that Prometheus is confirming the 'ancient astronaut' theory postulated - which suggests that humanity was given an evolutionary head-start by aliens from another planet - and that the hint of something occurring 2000 years ago has suggested to some fans that the idea of the Christian Messiah being an otherworldly emissary could be a big, hinted-at plot point for the film. Whether or not it's right or not, it'd be fantastic to get confirmation on way or another about that 'Space Jesus' theory...

4. What Will Shaw Do On The Engineer Homeworld?

The end of Prometheus sees Elizabeth, with David's severed head in her possession, pilot an abandoned Engineer spaceship in an attempt to go and seek answers about why the Engineers would want to extinguish all of humanity in the first place. In talks about the potential for a sequel, and Scott hinted that what Shaw might find would be horrific, particularly given that her religious faith has already been severely shaken by the fact that the beings who helped bring about the human race are actively opposed to humanity and wish to destroy it. Ouch. Therefore, Scott has promised that the sequel will be centred around the idea of 'Paradise' and what it means for Shaw and David, who represent religious faith and existentialism in equal measure. Religion has played a huge part in Prometheus and the idea of searching for the Creator was what inspired Shaw in the first place to go on the journey; clearly Scott will incorporate the idea of Shaw's faith being shaken, destroyed, or even surviving the horrors she's endured, into the film which may even carry the title of 'Paradise' (an original title for Prometheus during production). What is at the end of Shaw's rainbow? Given that the biological goo weapon seems poised at any moment to birth a race of monsters created purely to destroy and eradicate, it's a distinct possibility that Shaw and David will find the Engineers' home planet destroyed, particularly given that two millennia have passed since the outpost became overrun by the infection.

3. What Exactly Is The Black Liquid?

The big catalyst for a lot of the mayhem that occurs to the hapless crew of the Prometheus is the discovery of the black goo that soon spells doom and sets off a chain of events which sees most of the cast bite the dust. However, aside from the fact that the black goo is a biological weapon designed by the Engineers, very little is actually known about it. One of the most interesting things of note about the black liquid is that it has completely different effects on those who ingest it; when the Engineer in the mysterious prologue voluntarily swallows it, it disintegrates his body and kickstarts life on the planet, but when a human is exposed to it, the human becomes a monster €“ Holloway and Fifield transformed into sinister, villainous creatures after contact. However, Shaw is not affected and instead becomes an incubator for a primordial version of the Xenomorph, suggesting that the black goo is not a sexually transmitted infection. Scott will no doubt feature the black fluid in some capacity in Prometheus 2 and confirmation as to its true nature needs clarifying. Is it a weapon that changes depending on its host? Are there two fluids altogether, one the Engineers use for creation and advancement, and another for destruction? Regardless, the black goo played such a major role in Prometheus, and answering what it is, is something that deserves to get answered definitively in the sequel.

2. What Is Up With David?

The most startling standout performance of Prometheus came to Michael Fassbender's morally ambiguous android David, who helped decimate the crew under the orders of Weyland, the aged philanthropist who is funding the space mission. However, David showed more than a slight cunning streak, engineering the death of Holloway by deliberately stealing a sample of the black goo and spiking it into a drink of his, effectively endangering the lives of the entire crew. David is the most enigmatic member of the crew, Fassbender infusing humanity and a calm menace into his role that sees him ape Peter O'Toole and feel belittled by his superiors, the human crew, but the exact nature of his evolving intelligence and arrogance is never addressed within the context of the film. Is David acting solely on Peter Weyland's orders, or is it something more? David's nature needs exploring throughout Prometheus 2, given that he is all but the male lead opposite Shaw, and the true nature of the android deserves to be addressed - is he similar to Ash in the original Alien movie, or is he a more sophisticated model, one who harbours these grudges with a winning smile and later offers you a literal poisoned chalice in a way that fulfils the goals of his master as well as settling a petty score? Shaw had best watch her back.

1. How Does This All Connect To Alien?

The biggest thing that sold Prometheus as a film and a viewing experience was the fact that Ridley Scott confirmed that it would take place in the Alien universe, and would be a prequel to one of the best science fiction horror thrillers of all time. This rejuvenation of a franchise that seen epic highs (Aliens) and huge lows (Alien: Resurrection, sorry Joss Whedon) caused mass fan hysteria and jubilation. However, while Prometheus were certainly playing in the sandbox of Alien, it only hinted ambiguously at plot elements and parts of the overarching mythology, rather than giving the fans what they wanted: answers. There are several deliberate plot elements established in Prometheus that not only hint at the connective story to Alien, but all but confirm it without actually doing so - the Prometheus lands on LV-223, a sister satellite moon to LV-426, the moon on which the 'Nostromo' touched down on, the Space Jockey's backstory is revealed but only partially and through inference and the viewer using their own nous to bring the threads together. However, it's also been left so open-ended that it affected the narrative payoffs of the story. Prometheus 2 needs to connect, one way or another, closer to the Alien story, and give people the answers they deserve as ardent fans and moviegoers. Scott and his team have to give the viewers and fans enough information and resolution to those answers so that it not only fulfils their need for a compelling story also properly connects to events that have already happened in the moviegoers' eyes, like connecting jigsaw pieces together until it resembles a completed picture. This doesn't have to be a big expansive two-hour exercise in filling in every gap left - Scott is a master at science fiction horror, suspense, and the exploration of intelligent themes - but Scott also has a fantastic opportunity to set the stage for his first great masterpiece, fitting everything in so that the universe he created in Alien makes sense and does so in a fantastic, terrifying, utterly genius way. He just has to do it now. Over to you, Ridley. Make us proud.

Contributor
Contributor

Leeds native, film fanatic, TV obsessive and relentless pop music fan. Sings off-key at any chance.