Prometheus: 6 Answers To The Key Questions

In the first of a series of 3 Prometheus ‘Answering the Titan’ articles, Benji Taylor attempts to solve the Prometheus conundrum.

You could feel it happening even before Prometheus announced itself on our cinema screens €“ as anticipation for the movie reached fever pitch, Prometheus was dividing the disparate Alien fanboy collectives into variant factions. Your inclusion depended on which side of the fence you sat with regards to how you believed the movie would answer the Alien connection question... Was it an Alien prequel, or wasn€™t it? Was the xenomorph going to appear in the movie, or not? And yet all that tension pales into insignificance next to the spats that have arose since Prometheus exploded at the box office, as vitriolic posts either in defence or in support of the film are spewed onto blog and forum alike. There appear to be two key camps: i) those that view Prometheus as an existential work of soul-searching genius that has delivered the sci-fi genre back from the nadir it reached with Alien Vs Predator, and ii) those that consider it a plot-hole ravaged carcass masquerading as a masterpiece that may very well have damaged Ridley Scott€™s film-making legacy as he moves into the twilight of his years. In space, it seems, there is no middle ground from where people can hear you scream. Chief to the creation of these divisive splits is the failure of Prometheus to provide answers to the grandiose questions that it poses. Though the movie is rather heavy-handed and far from subtle when dealing with its underlying themes and motifs, it relies on a heady mix of ambiguity and enigma when it comes to hinting at answers. Deliberate ambiguity applied to film can be a wonderful thing- a kind of magic employed by the expert film-maker who can use it challenge and stretch their audience. However, in order to achieve this rare feat the fundamentals of the film must be strong: a movie that utilises ambiguity and enigma to satisfying effect should do so skilfully and sparingly, and whether Prometheus actually does this is seriously open to question. The myriad plot-holes and other screenplay issues are certainly causing many people to see what purports to be deliberate opaqueness as sheer ineptitude. Ironically, Ridley Scott was previously considered an expert when using ambiguity in the science fiction field- people are still debating today whether or not the principal character of Blade Runner, Rick Deckard, is a replicant. And, prior to Prometheus, the plot point on which many people continued to dwell after watching Alien was the enigmatic character of the Space Jockey, the giant extraterrestrial humanoid who appears- momentarily but very memorably- as the long-dead pilot of the derelict spacecraft on LV-426. To silence the critics and to vouch that Prometheus is not just a melting pot of quasi-philosophical posturing designed to short-circuit your small human brain, Prometheus screenplay writer Damon Lindelof has stated that the triumvirate behind the movie- himself, Jon Spaihts and Ridley Scott- do indeed have a set of pre-defined answers: €œRidley wanted to know what the answers were as well, and we talked about those at great length,and then he determined what it was he wanted to put in the movie€ those answers are not definitively presented in Prometheus, though if you look through all the materials, I think that the evidence is all there to form a very informed opinion as to what happened€€ After my third viewing of Prometheus I believe that the film does indeed present clues to potential answers, but- as per Lindelof€™s comments above- few if any are definitive. Here I seek to offer my interpretation of the events of the movie. For the sake of levity and brevity this €˜Answering the Titan€™ series will be divided into three articles: this particular article will focus on what I believe are the answers to the Prometheus conundrum, whilst the next two articles will delve into the mythological and thematic motifs explored within the Prometheus narrative. Whether or not I am a victim to the genius of Damon Lindelof or am a sucker who spent several hours of his life trying to make sense of an empty shell of a movie€“ you can let me know your opinion below€ And so here we go€“ let€™s answer the titan!

1. What Are The Murals?

Mural one: on the first trip to the Engineer€™s dome-like structure the crew of the Prometheus encounter several murals/ designs that appear to have been created by the Engineers. The first mural shows a xenomorph-like figure in an almost Christ-like/ god-like pose, and the physical form depicted is not dissimilar to the alien that we see emerge from the dead Engineer at the very end of Prometheus. At the base of the mural is what appears to be an altar, which contains a glowing green crystal. The key point that I took from this scene is that it conveys that the xenomorph, at least in the form shown here, existed and was known to the Engineers long before the events of Prometheus and Alien. Also, and perhaps most importantly, the style and positioning of the mural conveys that the Engineers hold this creature in high esteem- it's entirely plausible that they may even ascribe to it some sort of religious significance. Mural two: the other mural appears to show an Engineer giving life to / creating something akin to a xenomorph hybrid. The layout of the mural is hauntingly reminiscent of Michelangelo€™s Creation of Adam in the Vatican€™s Sistine Chapel. The subject of the creation lacks the grace and elegance of the original xenomorph in the first mural- it is stumped over and hunched and certainly different in style- which is why I term it a hybrid. My theory: the first mural depicts a creature that the Engineers encountered in eons past. They revere the creature- viewing it in the same way that Ash talks about the titular antagonist of Alien - €œa perfect organism€its structural perfection is matched only by its hostility..." The Engineers are lovers of biotechnology and an organism that they considered genetically superior to themselves is clearly something that these lovers of genetic manipulation would revere and hold in awe. In their search across unimaginable distances of space and time this ancient €˜true€™ xenomorph may well have been the only type of life that the Engineers had discovered that they themselves had not created. The green crystal at the base contains the genome/ genetic remnants of this ancient creature, rather like the €˜amber resin€™ used in the movie Jurassic Park to re-create the dinosaurs. Using these genetic remnants, the Engineers have been trying to replicate what they perceive to be the pinnacle of evolution and natural selection- they have not yet succeeded. The second mural serves to illustrate that the Engineers are indeed cosmic creators and superior genetic engineers: the exceptional genetic code of the original xenomorph has been used by them at length to further enhance their existing biotechnology, utilised in i) their bio-suits (which show xenomorph style markings and structures), ii) in their croissant-shaped ships (which appear to exhibit some bio-mechanical attributes), and iii) in their bio-weapons: most noticeably the €˜black liquid€™...

2. What is The Black Liquid?

The Engineers are cosmic creators who revere structural perfection, with a worldview that is intensely corporeal. The €˜black liquid€™ is a genetically engineered super fluid that, at its core, utilises the potent genetic material of the ancient and now presumably extinct xenomorph. The seemingly subjective nature of the liquid has been the subject of much speculation. I think that there are 2 variants, and the ultimate function of this super fluid can best be summed up by the statement that David provides to Shaw when assessing why he thinks the Engineers want to return to Earth with container after container of the liquid: €œsometimes, in order to create, you must first destroy€€ Variant 1: this variant is seen in the opening scene and is used by the Engineer to seed planets, in this case what appears to be Earth around the time of the Cambrian period. The genetic compound breaks down the cells of the consumer (in this case the Engineer), combines them with a mutagen and acts as an evolutionary expedient, with the resulting product ultimately evolving to exhibit the characteristics of the species that initially consumed this black liquid variant. This is why we resemble the Engineers. Variant 2: as seen used on LV-223 in large quantities. This genetic concoction €“rather than breaking down the cells of the consumer- moves directly to the mutagen/ evolutionary expedient phase. The consumer€™s cells combine with and are acted upon by the evolutionary expedient, with the resultant product ultimately taking on the characteristics of- and note the crucial difference to variant 1- the xenomorph. Key variables that will impact the properties exhibited will be the manner of ingestion, and the amount of fluid ingested. During the course of the movie we see various examples of organisms reacting to this variant of the fluid: the worms become large, strong and develop acidic blood; Fifield appears to gain super strength. The fluid also appears able to revitalise dead cells- eg: Shaw€™s reproductive organs. Other thoughts: I can't lie- my nagging doubt is that the black liquid may well just be a cheap plot device used to steer the narrative of the movie in the required direction and help things progress from scene to scene. Ridley and Damon may well have no idea what it is and are hoping that some geek like me comes up with a not-too-ridiculous answer prior to the Prometheus sequel moving into pre-production: it may well be the Lindelofian €˜smoke monster€™ of Prometheus! Obviously I hope that the former and not the latter is the case...

3. Why Were The Engineers Returning To Earth?

Shaw€™s carbon dating of the decapitated Engineer registers its death at around 2000 years prior to the mission, placing the Engineer€™s planned visit to Earth at just after the time of Jesus Christ if we consider that the events of Prometheus occur around 2093 (not counting for any potential time dilation that might result from faster-than-light travel). First things first then- let€™s discount the €˜Jesus was an Engineer/ Jesus was a human-Engineer hybrid€™ theory€ When asked if the Prometheus team ever considered going down the €˜Jesus Christ: creation and emissary of the Engineer€™ route, Ridley Scott has said that they considered it, but then added that the Prometheus team €œthought it was a little too on the nose ..." I for one am very happy about this- using the above as a plot device would not only be tried and clichéd, it would have presented a whole other set of issues: all in all opening up one huge can of LV-223 space worms. Additionally, anything that would connect the movie to the worst Christmas song of all time- Chris De Burgh€™s A Spaceman Came Travelling- is not something that should be forming the basis of a film that fancies itself as an intellectual sci-fi magnum opus! My suspicions hinge on the Engineers taking offense at the spread of monotheism, and the associated implications that we had stopped worshiping them as gods. If they had created us to worship them, then the fact that we turned away from them to pray to an abstract, non-corporeal deity may have just been a step too far away from their world view: which appears to be set in the physical world as evidenced by their love of bio-mechanics and genetic engineering. Whatever happened, the holographic replay suggests that Earth was their destination, and the fact that the ship the Engineers would pilot was loaded with the black liquid seems to indicate that their intentions were not particularly altruistic. Other thoughts: A friend and I recently discussed the possibility that the Engineers may have suspected that humans might one day create synthetic non-DNA based life, which they considered anathema - a mockery of their own worldview, as evidenced later in the film by the awakened Engineer€™s reaction to David. If you remember, the Engineer at first seems captivated by David (who speaks to him in his own language), but when he realises that David is synthetic he rips off his head. We speculated that eons ago the Engineers may well have dabbled with non-DNA based synthetic life themselves- resulting in a turbulent war- hence why they now despise it.

4. Why Did They Create Us?

This is a tough one. The answer may well be as simple as the one that Holloway arrogantly provides to David: "because they could...." They considered themselves creators, and so that is what they did... they engineered because they considered it their duty to engineer. Perhaps they had spent so long in the universe that, in the absence of their own answers, they created beings that would consider them gods. Creation filled the voice resulting from their own questions- a true existential paradox! More of this in part 2 exploring the motifs and themes.

5. What Happened To The Engineers On LV-223

Some time 2000 years ago the Engineers were preparing for another visit to Earth. What we do know is that the black liquid that they were carrying to use on Earth's inhabitants was unleashed on the group of Engineers on LV-223. At least one Engineer was initially infected- we see this on board the Prometheus when the decapitated Engineer€™s head is reanimated by Shaw and Ford. This calamitous outbreak resulted in several Engineers being impregnated and having Alien-style chest-bursters emerge from them- evidenced by the mound of dead Engineers that Fifield and Milburn find with holes in their heads and abdomens. We can picture a resulting manifestation of total chaos and, in the carnage, I suspect that several Engineers tried to escape by going into cryogenic stasis. In the map-room we can see several cryo-pods: the inhabitant of one of them was not infected (the living Engineer that is awakened by David later). However, the other Engineers that tried to escape in this way were infected €“ we see this because, if you look carefully at the cryo-pods that are shown in the map-room, three of the four are damaged and show holes around their chest sections. This is down to newly born xenomorphs (not the same as the pure form of the revered xenomporh since these ones are derived from the black liquid)... The Engineers are running from these newly created xenomorphs in the holographic replays. Only the Engineers would be shown in any future replays since they are €˜plugged in€™ to the network via their bio-suits. Non-Engineers would not be displayed- which makes the absence of the antagonists in the replay scenes all the more eerie and disturbing. The burning question then is how did a race of supposed super-beings find themselves screwing up in such spectacularly catastrophic fashion? The Engineers presumably possess vastly developed intellects, and what occurred here is a screw-up of monumental proportions. So what exactly happened there to set this chain of catastrophic events in motion? The answer€ Deception. One of the LV-223 Engineers resented the mission to go to Earth to change the course of human history. He was probably a member of the group that had interacted with humans in the past (and been depicted on the Lascaux-style cave paintings we see early on in Prometheus). He therefore caused the mayhem as a way of preventing something that he did not agree with, and what he did with the black liquid resulted in the outbreak and the associated cataclysm on LV-223. And this brings us nicely to the tie-in to the events of Alien.

6. The Tie-in To Alien

One Engineer did make it out from series of tumultuous events that transpired on LV-223. The Engineer who had intervened to save humankind managed to suit and up and escape via another ship €“ but he was already infected/ impregnated. Midway through his flight (probably to the Engineer homeworld to explain that events had just taken a massive turn for the worse) he ran into difficulties. He landed his ship on the moon LV-426 (a moon apparently in the same star system as LV-223) and a xenomorph ripped it's way from his abdomen. This Engineer- benign, and truly altruistic to humankind- is the €˜space-jockey€™ that appears in Alien. By the time he was found more than two thousand years later the odd mix of flesh and synthetic material that comprised his body and his bio-suit took on the appearance that Dallas would confuse as being €˜fossilised€™. This interpretation is given credibility by the fact that around the time of Alien Ridley Scott went on record to say that he considered the character aboard the derelict ship on LV-426 to be benevolent. He was one of the good guys! Which makes the irony even more beautiful €“ our intended saviour 'gave birth€™ to our prospective destroyer. Other thoughts: If Ridley considers that the events of James Cameron€™s 1986 sequel to Alien €“ Aliens €“ are canonical, then only queen category xenomorph can lay eggs. That means that the xenomorph that emerged from this Engineer was a queen. It laid its eggs- which managed to survive 2000 years of solitude- and died. 2000 years later the ship was found by the Nostromo. And there you have it! My interpretation of what happened in Prometheus, cobbled together from the tidbits of clues that Mr Lindelof and co. were kind enough to leave us with! You can read PART 2 of this series HERE.You can read PART 3 of this series HERE.Follow me on Twitter: @BenjiTaylorWins

Contributor
Contributor

Relentless traveller whose writing encompasses music, film, art, literature & history. ASOIAF connoisseur.