Ranking Every De-aging Movie Effect Ever
The good, the bad, and the ugly.
Digital de-aging has become the hot new trend in Tinsel Town over the last few years. As digital effects grow increasingly sophisticated, the line between what is and is not possible for films to accomplish has become practically nonexistent.
Where once a young and lucky River Phoenix was catapulted to stardom by landing the coveted role of a young Indiana Jones in a flashback at the start of Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade, studios now opt to simply de-age the actor playing the role and allow them to fill the part. On the one hand, this offers greater consistency between portrayals. But on the other hand, the effect has to not be jarringly noticeable in order for the scene to work.
With the recent news that both Samuel L. Jackson and Clark Greg will spend the entirety of the '90s-set Captain Marvel being de-aged by a couple of decades, audiences can expect to be seeing a lot more of this effect in the future.
So let's take a look at the history of digitally de-aging actors; the good, the bad, and whatever that atrocity was in the opening of X-Men: The Last Stand.
13. Jeff Bridges (Tron: Legacy)
Released in 2010, Tron: Legacy was touted as a blockbuster sequel to the cult classic that was destined to change the way people viewed digital cinema. And granted, seeing the incredibly aged effects of the original film updated for a new generation was thrilling. However, one particular effect stood out like a sore thumb.
Bridge's de-aged face looks about as convincing as a rubber mask on top of a mannequin, with ever emote or movement causing cringe-inducing CGI motion.
The film begins with a scene set in the eighties, of a young Jeff Bridges telling bedtime stories to his son. Here, Bridges de-aged face is shrouded in enough shadow that the shoddy effect isn't all that noticeable. Even later on, when the evil clone of the younger Bridges, Clu, is introduced the movie can kind of get away with it because he's a program so his funky-looking facial features are somewhat excusable.
But then the movie gets high on its own effect and doubles down. In a flashback midway through the film, we see the real Flynn forming Clu for the first time, and the movie shows us not one but two attempts at de-aged Jeff Bridges in full on lighting. Gone are the well-placed shadows or the convenient narrative excuse, and all that's left is a piss poor attempt at de-aging the Dude.
How could anyone have abided by this?
12. Patrick Stewart/Ian McKellen (X-Men: The Last Stand)
In the first-ever recorded attempt of this kind of de-aging technology, X-Men: The Last Stand tried it out for their opening sequence. And with such groundbreaking and potentially medium-changing technology at play, who better to carefully and efficiently deliver the precision necessary than noted auteur, Brett Ratner?
As Stewart's Professor X and McKellen's Magneto go to visit a young Jean Grey, the film opted to utilize the tech in an attempt to allow the same actors the chance to still play the roles. And while that's certainly admirable, the CGI work is not.
The results are horrifying to look at, especially because Ratner has no shame or modesty. The sequence opens on an extended shot which forces the audience to look at Stewart's CGI face for way too long and only gets worse from there. The primitive work done here is a far cry from the more nuanced and sophisticated de-agings modern audiences have grown accustomed to, basically just digitally erasing the actors' skin on their faces, leaving nothing but shiny and plastic-looking surfaces.
The producers behind the X-Men films in the mid-2000s also get bonus points for apparently feeling that this effect was so convincing that they used it again on poor Patrick Stewart, in X-Men Origins: Wolverine.
Captain Jean-Luc Picard deserves better than this.
11. Dwayne Johnson (Central Intelligence)
In another crude example of the tool's misuse, the Dwayne Johnson/Kevin Hart comedy Central Intelligence utilized it for a flashback. In the scene, a younger version of Johnson is serenading himself in the high school locker room showers when the younger Kevin Hart leads a group of bullies to his location to bully him. The gag here is that this younger version of Johnson is obese.
The effect itself is played for laughs, but it's still inexcusably terrible. Johnson's facial features are essentially just expanded and pasted onto the obese body, resulting in some truly horrifying effects when the body moves and Johnson's face doesn't move quite in sync with it.
It's also just kind of mind-boggling as to why the de-aging tech was used here. First off, the gag isn't that funny. Secondly, it would have been much less expensive to simply either put a practical fat-suit on Johnson or have another actor in the role. They didn't de-aged Kevin Hart for his character's role, so why waste money and resources to have Johnson de-aged for it?
It was all just for a cheap 'look, The Rock is fat!' gag, wasn't it?
10. Johnny Depp (Pirates Of The Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales)
https://goo.gl/images/pbqaeD
In the fifth installment of the Pirates franchise, audiences got to see a flashback sequence detailing how Jack Sparrow became a captain in the first place, condemning Javier Bardem's Salazar in the process.
For the sequence, the movie de-ages franchise veteran Johnny Depp substantially, and at first, it works stunningly. The first shot of the de-aged Depp is a near-flawless recreation of 21 Jump Street or A Nightmare on Elm Street-era Depp, with the digital artists making great use of archive footage.
But then he opens his mouth.
Not only is the voice just Depp's own but pitched-up to sound younger, the second his lips move, the entire effect falls to shambles. Everything about the lips, the chin, and the cheeks look inhuman in their movement. He even turns his face a different way as he speaks, and suddenly the lighting makes all of the skin on his face uber-shiny and uncomfortably smooth.
What started out as stunning at first, quickly dissolved into unwatchably awful territory, just like Depp's performances in these films.
9. Orlando Bloom (The Hobbit Trilogy)
Peter Jackson's The Hobbit trilogy was, by all accounts, a trainwreck both on and off of the screen. Because of the exceedingly late-in-game decision to expand it from two films to three, Jackson and his crew had to work overtime to fill the story with enough fluff to fill a full more three hours of footage.
One of those late additions was tacking on Orlando Bloom's Legolas to the latter two films. But seeing as Legolas is an elf (creatures that have much longer lifespans than hobbits), Bloom needed to not only look as young as he did in the Lord of the Rings trilogy, he needed to look even younger. To cope with this, they used de-aging technology on the entirety of Bloom's performances in both The Desolation of Smaug and The Battle of the Five Armies.
On the one hand, you can hardly notice it. But on the other hand, you can hardly notice it. The effect isn't egregious, it's hardly even there. Bloom doesn't look as young as he did in Fellowship, he looks significantly older. His face is wider, his chin line more defined, and his eyes have this off-putting glazed-over appearance for the entirety of his role.
If the film wasn't going to actually utilize the tech to make a difference, they should have just cut their losses and left Bloom as he was, because that's essentially what it looks like anyway.
8. Paul Reubens (Pee-wee's Big Holiday)
After decades away from the role, Paul Reubens returned to his iconic character of Pee-wee Herman for a Netflix film in 2016. But in Reuben's own words, his biggest concern was his age, so the production implemented de-aging technology. As Reubens said;
"I feel I’m too old to be in a Pee-wee Herman movie without that, Pee-wee doesn’t work, to me, with age mixed into it. So I knew I wanted digital retouching, and that was my biggest concern from the get-go, with Judd, when it came to budgeting, because it costs a fortune. I could have had a facelift and we would have saved two million dollars."
Throughout the entire film, Reubens' face is digitally touched up. Considering Pee-wee's childlike behavior and the fact that Reubens' had originally played the role nearly forty years prior, this had to be done to keep Pee-wee being Pee-wee.
And for the most part, it works remarkably well. There are certainly moments here and there where it enter uncanny valley territory, but overall, the CGI work is minimal and Reuben's performance is all the stronger because of it.
7. Arnold Schwarzenegger (Terminator: Genisys)
Let's get this out of the way up top: Genisys is a terrible film, even when it's utilizing cutting-edge effects. The sequence in which Arnold is de-aged is a terribly staged fight scene that is nothing but the worst kind of fan service, but the effects are pretty solid.
Here, the film returns to the opening of Cameron's original Terminator film, with a circa-1984 Arnold Schwarzenegger arriving from the future. Just like the original film, he proceeds to terrorize three exceedingly '80s gangsters for their clothes but then, modern-day Arnold shows up to do battle with him.
When young Arnold first arrives, the effects are pretty wonderful. Through the use of repurposed footage from the original film and some CGI touch-ups, it really does look like original recipe Arnold. Once he starts interacting with the gangsters, things get a bit more uneven. Seeing as this is all-new footage, young Arnold's face is now entirely CGI and the seems are much more obviously evident.
As he talks to the gangsters, he is incredibly dead-behind-the-eyes, which might seem fitting for a T-800 but it isn't in keeping with Arnold's original portrayal in that first film.
6. Robert Downey Jr. (Captain America: Civil War)
In one of Marvel's first forays into de-aging their stars, Captain America: Civil War places all of its chips on the table. Tony Stark's introduction into the film is through a digital recreation of a memory, showing a de-aged Robert Downey Jr.
The boldness of this comes from the fact that it's all done in one shot. Audiences spend several minutes looking at the CGI face, and the sequence is a crucial one. It's Stark's last interaction with his parents before their death, planting the seed for the big emotional payoff during the climax. Yet, it works spectacularly well. The effect has a few bugs here and there, like the hair not looking quite natural, but overall the Russo's use of staging, their confidence in the tech, and Downey's performance all sell the effect.
The film also cleverly builds an in-narrative backup in case the effect doesn't stand the test of time, seeing as it is conjured by the use of Tony's experimental B.A.R.F. tech. Much like Tron: Legacy, this is a meta way around the issue. And unlike Tron: Legacy, this film stays within it's own rules to keep that meta approach consistently applicable to the effect.
5. Sean Young (Blade Runner 2049)
As has become evident over the past few years of this de-aging tech growing increasingly popular in its use, a huge variable in the effectiveness of the technology is how a filmmaker decides to use it. Much like anything else in filmmaking, it is a tool that can be used or misused.
So in the hands of Brett Ratner, it's probably not going to work too well. But in the hands of an auteur like Denis Villeneuve? That's a different story.
In the midst of Blade Runner 2049's most emotionally charged sequence, wherein Niander Wallace is trying to break Rick Deckard's mind, Wallace introduces a new challenge. From the shadows emerges Sean Young's Rachael, Deckard's love interest from the original film, looking precisely as she did in that film.
Villeneuve and cinematographer Roger Deakins brilliantly build up the reveal, at first just framing her silhouette against revolving lighting in the room before allowing her to emerge fully. The other strength of this effect is its brevity. She spends so few shots in the movie that there was considerably less effects-work to be done to render her as a photorealistic character.
Also, Ford's performance is what positively sells this moment. His distress and anguish is palpable and it makes the effect all the stronger.
4. Kurt Russell (Guardians Of The Galaxy: Vol. 2)
After using the de-aging tool to great success in both Ant-Man and Civil War, Marvel opted to open their Guardians of the Galaxy sequel with their most stunning use of the technology yet.
Kurt Russell plays the role of Ego in the film, the father of Peter Quill, and the one who is ultimately revealed to be the villain in the film. In the opening, the film flashes back to 1980 to give viewers a glimpse into how Ego initially wooed Peter's mother.
The opening shot teases Russell's younger appearance, as the camera carefully teeters around the edges of the car he's driving, partially obscuring his face. Once he's fully revealed, he has full-on circa-1980s Kurt Russell hair, is wearing aviators, and is smiling broadly. The effect is incredible.
Part of this is certainly due to the aviators covering his eyes, but Russell looks exactly like he did then. And considering what difficulties this tech has had before with replicating believable lip movement or smiles, it's stunning how natural and realistic Russell's huge, teeth-baring smile is.
This is all thanks to Gunn's carefully planned camera-movement, Russell's immediately magnetic performance, and the glowing and comforting lighting choices that serve to accentuate the effect rather than hamper it.
3. Carrie Fischer (Rogue One: A Star Wars Story)
Rogue One is chock-full of mind-bending CGI technology. There's the typical Star Wars stuff, there's the digital resurrection of Peter Cushing as Grand Moff Tarkin (not quite the kind of de-aging we're talking about here, so it doesn't quite count), and then there's the de-aging of Carrie Fischer.
This is a moment that works so well because of both the careful structure and placement, as well as the brevity. After spending hours with the crew of Rogue One only to watch them all tragically give their lives to ensure the success of the mission, the film closes out as the Death Star plan's just barely escape the hands of Darth Vader himself.
As the camera soars through the halls of the Tantive IV, it settles on the white cloaked figure who is clearly Leia Organa. And just a few years earlier, this is where the film would have had to end, teasing the inclusion of a young Leia and it would have been more than enough. But here, the film goes the extra mile. Leia turns and faces the camera to speak a single line; "hope".
Upon first viewing, it felt flat-out unbelievable to see circa-1977 Carrie Fisher showing up at the end of the movie. Considering the fact that Fischer herself adored the cameo and that she would go on to die just weeks after the film was released, this moment has taken on all the more significance.
2. Brad Pitt (The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button)
It's strange that one of the earliest uses of de-aging technology has stood the test of time and remains one of the most powerful examples of how to use it well, but it just goes to show the value of a director who knows how to properly utilize cutting-edge technology.
David Fincher's The Curious Case of Benjamin Button was released ten years ago and yet it remains arguably the most extensive use of the technology to date. Throughout the film, Brad Pitt plays Benjamin Button (a man who ages backward) through every stage of his life. From his senior years to his teenage ones, Pitt's performance as Button is consistently a remarkable feat of both digital effects and acting.
All the more impressive is the fact that Button is the film's lead. The entire film's success or failure hinges on whether or not audiences can empathize with Benjamin Button. To gamble the entire film's success on an untested effect is the exact kind of crazy thing that only a director like Fincher would risk, but it pays off in spades.
Fincher's visual precision, use of digital cameras, and well-established lighting techniques all establish an aesthetic that lends itself to accommodating the CGI performance. Sure, there are hiccups here and there, but the overwhelming majority of the work here remains game-changing to this day.
1. Michelle Pfeiffer (Ant-Man And The Wasp)
In the first Ant-Man movie, Michael Douglas got the de-aging treatment for one quick scene at the beginning, marking Marvel's first-ever use of the tech, and it worked pretty wonderfully.
But the real showstopper came in the recently released follow-up, Ant-Man and the Wasp. Once again, the film opens with a flashback that features a de-aged Michael Douglas. And once again, it's fairly impressive. But then, de-aged Michelle Pfeiffer appears and completely steals the scene.
Director Peyton Reed doesn't shy away from giving the audience extended looks at Pfeiffer's CGI face and the results are insane. It is as if the filmmakers traveled back in time themselves and brought Batman Returns-era Michaelle Pfeiffer to the modern day.
Even the performance is all there. With the scene being an emotionally-charged farewell between Pfeiffer and a young Hope, Pfeiffer's face has to do a whole lot of emoting and facial movement, and the effect holds up through it all.