Ranking The Potential Of Each Streaming Service
Does any streamer have the chance of toppling Amazon Prime Video, Netflix or Disney Plus?
Streaming has rapidly become the norm for television viewing over the last few years, with the once pioneering and unchallenged Netflix now jostling with countless competitors.
Each of the ‘big 5’ Hollywood studios with the exception of Columbia (Sony) now has their own offering in the United States and whilst just one of these is currently available in the United Kingdom, their arrival here and in other major markets such as Canada and Australia can’t be too far off.
With each of these services investing in countless hours of original programming to supplement their vast back catalogues of film and television properties and tempt subscribers, the market is rapidly saturating and becoming a bubble ready to burst.
Customers only have so many viewing hours to dedicate and dollars/pounds to spend and as the general entertainment platforms battle not only with each other but with the vast multitude of specialist streaming services focused on the likes of anime (Crunchyroll), sport (ESPN+), documentaries (CuriosityStream), reality (Hayu) and horror (Shudder), casualties will inevitably soon ensue.
What is the outlook for each of these based on their current market share, the strength and depth of the franchises and characters that they hold the rights to and their announced plans for the immediate future?
Let’s critically analyse and determine who is the most likely to be standing tall in a few years’ time.
12. Facebook Watch
Estimated Subscribers – N/A
You’d be forgiven for not knowing that Facebook even had a streaming service. Facebook Watch launched in 2017, making Mark Zuckerberg’s social networking behemoth the fourth of the ‘big five’ tech giants, after Amazon, Apple and Google (in the form of YouTube Red/Premium), to launch a platform.
Microsoft have yet to follow suit, a decision that is probably wise given their games console rival Sony’s decision to step away from Crackle and Google’s cessation of original scripted content purchases for YouTube (of which little stood out bar the now Netflix-backed Cobra Kai).
Facebook itself, though still strong from a commercial standpoint, is gradually losing its follower base in key demographics (with fewer and fewer under-30s opting to actively maintain profiles) and suffering from reputational damage through its involvement in the facilitation of ‘fake news’ (particularly relating to recent elections and the Covid-19 pandemic) and scandals such as the Cambridge Analytica affair.
All of this combines to paint a bleak outlook for Facebook Watch, which has little in the way of brand recognition even amongst the social network’s most prolific users, despite it being free. The fact that they aired just two original commissions in 2020 after more than fifty in 2018 would indicate that they’ve given up on it already.
11. AMC+
Estimated Subscribers – 1m
When the concept of ‘peak television’ began to emerge in the late 2000s, two American cable networks were at the forefront. HBO was well-established as the home of quality dramas such as The Sopranos and The Wire, whilst AMC, formerly a channel dedicated to classic cinema, burst onto the scene with the trifecta of Mad Men, Breaking Bad and The Walking Dead.
Though many have criticised the former as overly pretentious and the latter as well past its best as it approaches its eleventh and final season, few can deny their appeal.
Whilst HBO has always been under the umbrella of a major Hollywood studio, AMC is independent, having been divested from parent ownership in 2011. Though they have continued to invest heavily in new programming, nothing has quite managed to reach the heights of their holy trinity, despite the plaudits earned by the likes of Halt & Catch Fire.
Without an extensive back catalogue to lean upon, AMC+ is severely lacking in depth even with the addition of content from the likes of BBC America, Shudder and Sundance Now (independent films), which has only been sufficient to take subscriber numbers into seven figures.
A better option for the network going forwards will almost certainly be to sell the streaming rights to the properties that they still own for sizable amounts rather than trying to use them to swim amongst the sharks themselves.
10. Hulu
Estimated Subscribers – 39m
Along with Netflix, Hulu was one of the first companies to capitalise on the streaming bandwagon in 2008. Having been owned by a ‘who’s who’ list of media giants throughout its history, the combination of Disney, Comcast (parent of NBC/Universal), News Corporation (parent of Fox) and AT&T (parent of Warner Bros) all held stakes when Disney acquired Fox and assumed majority ownership.
AT&T subsequently sold their 10% share, whilst Comcast have committed to selling theirs in 2024 to give the House of Mouse full control.
Only ever available in two countries (the USA and Japan, where it exists in name only with the platform having been sold to a domestic company in 2014), Hulu currently exists in a strange bubble.
Outside of the States, much of its content has recently been incorporated into the ‘Star’ module of Disney+, but inside them, it continues to be the home of the less ‘family friendly’ properties that Disney acquired in the Fox deal, maintains a growing subscriber base and has attracted plaudits for its original creations such as The Handmaid’s Tale.
It would be disorganised for Disney to maintain two entertainment streaming services indefinitely though. Though US customers can currently access bundle packages that give them access to Disney+, Hulu and ESPN+, the fate of Hulu seems sealed as its properties becoming bargaining chips to grow the more lucrative Disney+ platform further.
Expect a swift merger once Comcast are removed from the equation.
9. Discovery+
Estimated Subscribers – 11m
The Discovery Channel is one of the most well-known cable networks out there, maintaining a global presence. Though traditionally associated with nature and science programming, its modern slate is more reality-focused, making it more generalist than specialist.
Its sizable portfolio of sister channels includes Animal Planet, the Food Network, the Learning Channel), HGTV (focused on home improvement), the Travel Channel and the Oprah Winfrey Network, as well as Eurosport’s weird and wonderful collection of things not quite high profile enough for Sky in Europe.
Discovery+ is a new creation, having only launched in territories outside of India (where it was piloted) at the beginning of 2021. It brings together content from the aforementioned channels as well as other factual ones, such as the A&E Networks-owned History Channel, creating one huge collection of factual and reality programming in every conceivable subgenre, with one notable exception.
That exception is general entertainment programming in the form of dramas and comedies, the backbone of television that will be the primary driver of most customer purchasing decisions.
With Netflix boasting a sizable volume of non-fiction programming (signing up the likes of David Attenborough) and Disney+ showcasing Discovery’s long-time rival National Geographic as one of their modules, you’d have to think they’d be better placed partnering with another service looking for equivalents.
8. Apple TV+
Estimated Subscribers – 10m
Apple is one of, if not the world’s most recognisable brand, boasting massive market shares in the computer/laptop, tablet and smartphone markets and an estimated value of over $2 trillion. Apple TV has been around since 2016 as a video-on-demand service, but their first foray into original streaming content, through Apple TV+, didn’t occur until three years later.
Despite the fact that it is the cheapest of the streaming services (costing just $4.99/£4.99 a month), Apple TV+ has struggled to make an impact. The vast majority of its userbase are free triallists (one year being available to all owners of Apple devices) that do not ultimately renew, whilst a lack of first party hits to draw viewers in has forced an increasing focus on securing the rights to third party content.
Such a strategy will become more difficult as the owners of said content opt to use it instead for their own services, whilst Apple’s decision to limit the availability of their app on certain devices (such as all but the newest models of smart TVs by their rivals Samsung), is a baffling one.
Though they recently won their first Golden Globe for the delightfully hilarious and heart-warming Ted Lasso, Apple’s journey into the world of television looks increasingly fruitless. The fact that streaming isn’t their core business will insulate them, but it’s hard to see them ascending anywhere close to the heights of Netflix and company.
7. Paramount+
Estimated Subscribers – 8m
Though it was announced just few weeks ago, Paramount+ is actually just a rebranding of Viacom’s existing streaming platform, CBS All Access, with the branding and name value of their film studio deemed more marketable than that of their TV network.
Given that it launched in its previous guise more than five years before any of its counterparts from rival Hollywood studios, the fact that it has already been far eclipsed by all of them in terms of subscriber numbers in less than eighteen months is a worrying sign.
The renaming and announcements of original content that came with it certainly represent a significant gamble for the company that has the smallest overall share of the American film market (5% versus double digits for each of their four rivals), but also reflects a sense of confidence in their properties.
These include much of CBS’ back catalogue (though their biggest hit, The Big Bang Theory, has been sold elsewhere until 2028) and material from other Viacom properties such as MTV, Nickelodeon, Comedy Central and Showtime.
The only property that All Access/Paramount+ has really attempted to capitalise on thus far has been Star Trek, however, with Discovery the largest pull the service currently has.
With an uphill battle ahead of them to combat the growth of rivals, Paramount+ will need big hits sooner rather than later to avoid becoming lost in the shuffle.
6. Britbox
Estimated Subscribers – 2m
BritBox is something of an anomaly on this list given that it’s the only service not run by an American entertainment or technology giant. It could even be argued that is a service specialising in a ‘niche’, namely British programming, even if that does count as general entertainment.
Bringing together the BBC, ITV and Channel 4 is a smart move, enabling a ‘strength in numbers’ approach, and BritBox is certainly attractive to Anglophiles in the United States and Canada who have a penchant for the period dramas and sharp sitcoms that can only be done justice on the other side of the pond.
Outside of original programming such as a revival of Spitting Image though, it has less appeal to domestic customers who can stream the bulk of the three companies’ offerings for free through iPlayer, ITV Hub and All4.
The prospects of Britbox are also somewhat hampered by the fact that the larger streaming services, such as Netflix and HBO Max, have picked and chosen what they feel to be the biggest draws for their own services.
Given that the platform is already profitable (always a plus for a company that cannot profit from advertising revenues) ahead of expansion to other large markets for British programming such as India and Scandinavia, Britbox should persevere.
5. Peacock
Estimated Subscribers – 33m
Given that Peacock is the newest major entrant into the streaming game, having only been on the market for eight months, you'd expect them to be playing catchup. NBCUniversal have employed a few aces up their sleeve, however, and seem quickly poised to make an impact.
The first of these is the strength of their programming. Though NBC don’t hold the streaming rights to Friends, arguably their biggest success story as a network, they have paid $500m to pick up one of their others, The Office, which has significant pulling power, alongside other heavily binged shows, for those wanting to rewatch their old favourites for the 57th time.
The second of these is their employment of tiers. Peacock offers free and premium versions, with the former designed as hook to entice payment for the latter.
Diverse appeal is also being sought through the addition of NBC Sports (the American home of the Premier League) and the WWE Network, the latter of which should pull in the majority of Vince McMahon’s existing subscribers given that the whole Peacock package is being offered at half of the standalone network’s price.
Throw in Universal’s slate of films, which are significant enough to compete with Disney in the theme park arena, and the future looks relatively rosy for Peacock, assuming that their pricing strategy doesn’t see them haemorrhage a non-recoupable amount of money.
4. HBO Max
Estimated Subscribers – 37m
Given that they own the rights to Harry Potter, DC Comics and Game Of Thrones, three properties that are renowned around the world, it’s hard to see how HBO Max could be anything other than a success, particularly given the reputation of HBO in the world of television that prompted AT&T to use its brand, rather than that of Warner Bros, for its streaming service.
Despite being less than a year old, HBO Max has already garnered significant attention within the entertainment industry. Much of this relates to their decision to concurrently release blockbuster films on the platform in tandem with their cinema releases, to the consternation of filmmakers and cinema purists.
Whether this strategy persists once cinemas are permitted to reopen is anyone’s guess, but it’s a ballsy move that is sure to attract mainstream film fans.
The biggest issue that HBO Max is likely to face stems from its pricing strategy. At $14.99 per month it is almost twice as expensive as any of its competitors, which is particularly egregious given that outside of a 50% stake in the CW, Warner Bros lack a ‘traditional’ presence amongst the major television networks to draw content from.
Throw in the rights to Friends (important enough for Netflix to pay $100m in 2019) and content from subsidiaries and contributors like Cartoon Network, New Line Cinema (the Lord Of The Rings film trilogy), Studio Ghibli and the Criterion Collection, however, and they have plenty to lean on for now.
3. Amazon Prime Video
Estimated Subscribers – 150m
If Prime Video was a solely a streaming service, it’d probably be in trouble. Though Amazon have attracted plaudits for the likes of The Boys and The Marvellous Ms. Maisel, the vast majority of their originals have been of middling quality.
Upcoming series based on valuable properties like The Lord Of The Rings, The Wheel Of Time and Jack Reacher could tilt the balance, though they could easily end up being as solid yet unspectacular as their Jack Ryan adaptation.
Amazon’s strength lies in their bundling strategy. No matter how often they are criticised for their inhumane labour practices, non-payment of taxes or systematic destruction of the high street, they are the world’s biggest retailer and consumers have become indoctrinated to using them to shop for everything imaginable. By bundling Prime Video with the Prime next-day delivery service, they have a unique offering that nobody else can match, even if only a fraction of their subscribers regularly watch programming.
Amazon’s dominance of the retail market has and will continue to rise. The average user of the site puts more than $1000 into Jeff Bezos’ juggernaut each year, giving it almost free reign to pump as much money as it likes into original and acquired programming alike.
Several ‘alternative’ investments’, such as live Premier League coverage, have also proven a smart move, enabling the gap to be gradually closed upon Netflix, who must rely on programming alone without hundreds of other revenue streams backing them.
2. Netflix
Estimated Subscribers – 203m
Blockbuster once turned down the opportunity to buy Netflix for the small sum of $50 million, seeing no viability in its business model or threat to their long-established rental platform.
Fast forward two decades and Blockbuster has been wiped off he face of the earth with Netflix, the pioneer and undisputed market leader in terms of subscription numbers, valued by the market at a whopping $227 billion.
At no point should Netflix ever consider themselves ‘too big to fail’, as complacency and a reluctance to innovate and adapt to the market is the root cause of most large business collapses, but their brand name has become so embedded into contemporary culture that it can be used as a byword for streaming in general by itself – nobody ever proposes to ‘Amazon Prime and chill’ now do they?
A fair criticism of Netflix’s original content strategy is that it has emphasised quantity over quality. Over the last couple of years, they have purchased enough material to have multiple new releases per week, but how much of this is truly memorable? Aside from obvious standouts with staying power such as Stranger Things, Queer Eye and The Crown, most of their productions have quickly fallen into obscurity and cancellation after one or two seasons.
Such properties are powerful building blocks though and whilst Netflix continues to have huge pockets and a subscriber base that dwarfs any of their competitors, they’re going nowhere anytime soon.
1. Disney+
Estimated Subscribers – 100m
Disney+ reached 100 million subscribers in less than a year. Though that is less than half of Netflix’s total, it is a staggering accomplishment, but hardly surprising given the sheer dominance that Disney have established across the entertainment industry.
They’ve always been a major player, with their animated classics a huge part of the upbringing of most children, but their gradual acquisition and capitalisation upon the Marvel, Star Wars, Pixar and Fox brands has seen them ascend to unfathomable heights, covering almost every imaginable demographic.
Disney+ has barely scratched the surface with regards to original content as of yet, though the quality and immediate popularity of the Mandalorian and WandaVision speak for themselves.
It could be argued that they’ve gone overboard with the sheer amount of new Marvel and Star Wars series announced for the next few years, but given that the two are the highest-grossing cinematic franchises of all time, with total worldwide receipts of $32 billion, they know that there’s a wide global audience just waiting to throw money at them.
As more and more content from the ABC Television and 20th/21st Century Fox film catalogue is added (assuming Hulu is eventually folded into it in the United States), Disney+ will continue to aggressively chase Netflix in pursuit of its crown.
What Disney want, they usually get, and with the enviable combination of seemingly unlimited funds and endearing customer brand appeal, you have to wonder who could possibly stop them.
Watch Next
The Impossible Netflix Quiz: How Well Will You Do?