Razzies 2017: 8 Winners That Make No Sense
If you hate Batman v Superman that much, you need to watch more movies.
As is annual tradition, the Golden Raspberry Awards (aka the Razzies) were announced the day before the Oscars, and in some respects will prove to be almost as divisive as the Academy Awards themselves.
If there's one thing the Razzies always gets wrong, it's that they pander too much to what's fashionable to dislike, skewering certain franchises, demographics, actors and directors far more mercilessly than they deserve.
This year wasn't much different, and while the Oscars is on a clear mission to diversify itself, the Razzies basically feels like the same old one-note joke where mean-spirited people mock a bunch of movies, many of which aren't even that terrible, but simply disappointing or underwhelming.
As such, these 9 winners don't make a lick of sense in any logical realm of critical taste, but at least there are some far more sensible nominees in each category that are undeniably worthy of your derision...
8. Worst Prequel, Remake, Rip-off Or Sequel - Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice
Why It Makes No Sense: Of the six nominated movies (also including Alice Through the Looking Glass, Fifty Shades of Black, Independence Day: Resurgence, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Out of the Shadows and Zoolander 2), Batman v Superman in fact had the highest average score from Rotten Tomatoes critics.
This is lent even more weight by the fact that BvS received far more reviews than any of the other five movies in competition, which bolsters its credibility in this regard.
What Should've "Won": Fifty Shades of Black is by far the worst movie here, an unfunny send-up of an already terrible movie that was just fortunate enough not to bring a ton of fanboy baggage with it, unlike Batman v Superman.
7. Worst Supporting Actress - Kristen Wiig (Zoolander 2)
Why It Makes No Sense: Only Kristen Wiig and Aubrey Plaza (Dirty Grandpa) actually gave remotely memorable performances in this category, and both actually wrangled a few laughs from their parts despite the movies themselves being not-so-great.
Who Should've "Won": Take your pick. Julianne Hough (Dirty Grandpa) was incredibly forgettable but hardly offensive, Kate Hudson (Mother's Day) was much the same, Jane Seymour (Fifty Shades of Black) thoroughly embarrassed herself in a slumming role, and Sela Ward (Independence Day: Resurgence) was pretty much a non-entity.
Seymour's the only memorably bad, misjudged turn of the bunch, so she "wins".
6. Worst Supporting Actor - Jesse Eisenberg (Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice)
Why It Makes No Sense: Look, there are plenty of valid reasons why a lot of fans didn't like Jesse Eisenberg's Lex Luthor, but at least the guy clearly tried to do something different than the usual A-list ham acting the role invites, and at this point it's just become popular to hate his role because people don't like the movie.
Who Should've "Won": Honestly, nobody in this category is absolutely terrible (Will Ferrell and Owen Wilson for Zoolander, Nicolas Cage for Snowden, Jared Leto for Suicide Squad and Johnny Depp for Alice Through the Looking Glass), but Depp gave the most tediously phoned-in turn of the bunch.
Depp is to an extent disadvantaged by a lot of fans getting tired of his quirky shtick, but he didn't even touch the sides in the second Alice movie, and was frequently upstaged by Sacha Baron Cohen's villainous Time.
5. Worst Actress - Rebekah Turner (Hillary's America: The Secret History Of The Democratic Party)
Why It Makes No Sense: Rebekah Turner plays Hillary Clinton in a handful of re-enactment scenes in Dinesh D'Souza's rancid propaganda documentary, but that doesn't automatically mean she gives a Razzie-worthy performance.
The main argument here is that she's barely in the film, appearing for a few minutes at the absolute most and not really qualifying as a lead actress by any tangible measure.
As such it's hard to be too infuriated by her performance, especially as Turner's IMDB profile is pretty barren and it seems excessively mean-spirited (even for the Razzies) to pick on a jobbing actor just trying to make a few bucks.
Who Should've "Won": There are a few simply boring performances here (Julia Roberts in Mother's Day and Shailene Woodley in Allegiant), a few suspect ones (Megan Fox in Turtles 2 and Tyler Perry in Boo! A Madea Halloween), but the real stand-out is Naomi Watts' barrel-scraping work in the widely-panned thriller Shut In.
Watts was also co-nominated for her forgettable supporting performance in Allegiant, so we'll take that in the bargain. But Shut In wins her the award by itself, because it's a horrible movie, she gives a terrible performance in it and as an Oscar-nominated actress she absolutely should know so much better.
4. Worst Screenplay - Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice
Why It Makes No Sense: No matter how much you may dislike what David S. Goyer and Chris Terrio did with Batman and Superman, do you honestly think Dirty Grandpa, Gods of Egypt, Hillary's America, Independence Day: Resurgence and Suicide Squad all had better screenplays?
Plus, consider that the movie's Ultimate Edition does fix a lot of the gaping plot holes and logic issues, and it's clear that the problem was more with Warner Bros' scissors-happy executives than the script (not that it was anywhere near perfect).
What Should've "Won": A lot of good-bad contenders here, but the insidious intent of Hillary's America, with its malicious manipulation of facts and repugnant right-wing agenda, has by far the most objectionable content of any of these films. Some of the other scripts got pretty close, but hateful bile rises to the top in the end.
3. Razzie Redeemer - Mel Gibson
Why It Makes No Sense: It's not so much the idea of Mel Gibson winning the coveted Razzie Redeemer award that makes no sense, but the means through which he's been awarded it.
Gibson won it for venturing from the apparent low of his Worst Supporting Actor nomination for 2014's The Expendables 3 to being nominated for a Best Director Oscar for his work on Hacksaw Ridge.
The logic is off because Gibson was easily the best thing about The Expendables 3 and gave the movie's only particularly interesting performance.
Who Should've "Won": There are two very good options here: Natalie Portman (from three Razzie nominations for the Star Wars prequels to an Oscar win for Black Swan and a further nomination this year for Jackie) and Nicole Kidman (from a 2012 Razzie nod for Just Go with It to an Oscar nod this year for Lion).
2. Worst Screen Combo - Ben Affleck & Henry Cavill (Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice)
Why It Makes No Sense: Sure, Batman and Superman's pairing was largely underwhelming on the whole, but was it really worse than the CGI robot Gods in Gods of Egypt? Than the horribly squandered cast of Collateral Beauty? And Tyler Perry and his damn wigs in A Madea Halloween?
At least the central fight provided some cool moments of fanboy wish fulfillment, which is more than can be said for the other aforementioned movies.
Who Should've "Won": Collateral Beauty is such an embarrassing waste of brilliant Oscar darling actors that it really has to win out here. While the other teamings weren't exactly splendid, none of the nominated screen combos invited quite so much audience disbelief.
1. Worst Director - Dinesh D'Souza (Hillary's America: The Secret History Of The Democratic Party)
Why It Makes No Sense: Bear with this one. Yes, Hillary's America is a horrendous, offensive movie, but it's actually not the worst-directed film of the year, even if its Worst Picture Razzie win feels thoroughly deserved.
For one, some of the visuals are actually pretty decent, and though thoroughly misguided, Dinesh D'Souza at least has a consistent tone and directorial vision throughout that never waves.
He is by no means a good director, but he's definitely not the Worst Director.
Who Should've "Won": Alex Proyas for Gods of Egypt. His CGI-assaulted mess of an adventure epic is tonally jarring from beginning to end and wholly plays out like a director who has lost complete control of his production.
And let's face it, screwing up a $140 million movie is much more embarrassing than a $5 million one, especially as D'Souza's movie actually made more than double its budget back at the box office, scarily enough.
Proyas has at least proven himself a talented director in the past through his work on The Crow and Dark City in particular, so he could always end up a Razzie Redeemer some time in the future.
What did you think of this year's Razzies? Shout it out in the comments!