Red Sparrow Review: 5 Ups & 5 Downs
A middling effort for J-Law.
Considering how ubiquitous Jennifer Lawrence's presence seems to be in Hollywood, it's pretty surprising that she's only starred in four movies since The Hunger Games franchise ended back in 2015.
After every single one of these movies - Joy, X-Men: Apocalypse, Passengers and mother! - was met with a mixed critical and audience response, it's safe to say that she's counting on a rebound with her sexy new spy thriller Red Sparrow.
Well, she's not quite going to get it, for though the movie is certainly an enjoyable genre effort to a point, it's also handicapped by some sloppy mistakes and the fact that, well, it's really just OK overall.
It's not the home run J-Law and her fans were hoping for, but the film does at least give her space to turn in some compelling work, largely justifying the film's mixed-positive critical reception so far.
One thing's for sure, it'll get a better CinemaScore than mother! (which was just one of 19 movies to ever receive an F score)...
Downs...
5. The Messy Pacing
Red Sparrow's pacing is, from beginning to end, completely all over the place. The movie's first act is in such a rush to establish Dominika (Jennifer Lawrence) as a ballerina-turned-Russian spy that it doesn't really stop to examine her as a human being, or even make her transformation seem especially plausible.
By the mid-way point, the movie slows down to a deathly crawl and you might be left wishing it'd clip along a little faster, with director Francis Lawrence and editor Alan Edward Bell training their focus on some of the less interesting aspects of Dominika's story.
Clearly, the script and the edit both needed another pass, to spend more time on Dominika's character development while streamlining some of the more tedious elements introduced later on.
4. The Plot Is Generic & Convoluted
Though the marketing suggested that the film might be a unique spin on familiar espionage material, at its core this is a disappointingly over-familiar tale about sexy spies playing with fire, and the litany of allegiance-shifts and dead bodies that follow.
For the most part the film follows fairly conventional spy thriller tropes, and because it's eager to speed through Dominika's recruitment, the whole set-up feels contrived and a bit of a tough sell.
Spy thrillers are often over-complicated on purpose, and that's at least partly the intent here, but where it matters, the movie might have you rolling your eyes or sighing rather than marvelling at how clever it all is.
3. It Takes Itself Way Too Seriously
Considering how unabashedly ridiculous the film is at times, it's a shame that it also decides to take itself dead seriously. Granted, some of the film's more difficult themes mean that it probably shouldn't be a laugh-a-minute romp, but tonally, there's a sure disconnect between the story's overarching silliness and how severely it regards itself.
Some well-placed gallows humour would've gone a long towards ironing out the film's needlessly stern tenor, because its navel-gazing grimness ultimately feels more exhausting than engrossing by the time it's all over.
Perhaps with stronger material the oppressively harrowing mood would've worked, but considering the narrative is basically nonsense, it should've been at least a little more fun too.
2. Mary-Louise Parker's Baffling Subplot
Nothing in Red Sparrow is more bizarre and unnecessary than the wildly over-extended subplot involving the brilliant Mary-Louise Parker, who plays the aide to an American senator.
Parker appears in the movie for a single 10-minute sequence set in London, where she gets wasted on Vodka and meets up with Dominika. Parker goes full ham for the entirety of her small role, which feels like it belongs in an entirely different movie and therefore sticks out like a sore thumb.
This whole subplot could've been cut from the movie without really affecting it, and while in isolation Parker's performance is amusing, it's ultimately totally off on a tonal perspective and just further bloats out an already padded movie.
Speaking of which...
1. It's About 20 Minutes Too Long
In case you weren't aware, Red Sparrow clocks in at a hefty 140 minutes, and there's little indication from the final cut that it needed to run a minute over two hours.
The latter two acts in particular could've easily been trimmed down and reconstituted into something pacier, while perhaps giving the rushed earlier scenes a little more time to breathe.
Asking audiences to sit through an almost 2.5-hour movie that feels so familiar isn't particularly appealing, and this might prompt many to save it for a future Netflix viewing rather than block out some time to catch in cinemas. It's hard to blame anyone who does that, really.
Loaded with issues though the movie is, it certainly succeeds in several key areas. Here's what Red Sparrow gets right...
Ups...
5. Jennifer Lawrence's Compelling Performance
Jennifer Lawrence gets a disproportionate amount of hate online considering she's one of the more reliable young A-listers working today, and while the movie certainly could've offered her more to work with, she acquits herself admirably here with another totally rock solid performance.
Her Russian accent is what it is - it's mostly fine, and just about any major Hollywood star sounds ridiculous even trying it - but Lawrence commits herself physically to the edgier and more emotionally demanding aspects of the part, selling the visceral toll deep-cover espionage will take on a soul.
J-Law fans will certainly get plenty of movie for their buck, even if it's a shame that Dominika still feels like a bit of a hollow shell by the time the film wraps up.
4. The Uncompromising, R-Rated Tone
It would've been a huge mistake for this movie to be rated PG-13, but thankfully, it goes the full, R-rated hog, and largely delivers the mature content you'd expect from a story about Russian spies using their bodies as weapons.
Francis Lawrence manages to avoid gratuity for its own sake, but doesn't shy away from numerous sequences of nudity and harsh violence which befit the lurid premise.
Surely the most unsettling sequence, however, involves the torture of a character late in the movie, and though it features just a few drops of blood, the fantastic sound design sells the brutality in stomach-churning fashion.
Some will certainly have problems with the movie's approach to sexual abuse and rape - especially in the current climate - but the movie never asserts itself to be a female empowerment tale, and fully accepts the horrifying nature of Dominika's work.
3. Jo Willems' Sharp Cinematography
All flaws aside, this is quite the handsome film indeed. Cinematographer Jo Willems - who also teamed with Francis Lawrence on the latter three Hunger Games movies - ensures there's never a dull image, making the most of the chilly, bleak scenery, the remote Sparrow training centre, and all the grotesquely-lit hotel rooms and bars Dominika visits.
Willems manages to render even trashy locales in classy style, and though the overall edit could certainly use some trimming, the moment-to-moment juxtaposition of images is extremely pleasing to the eye.
Some might be wishing for something a little more grimy and disgusting-looking to compliment the perverse subject matter, but as far as glossy Hollywood entertainments go, it's extremely well-mounted.
2. The Strong Supporting Cast
Though it doesn't always make the best of them, the movie's cast is nothing short of magnificent. Aside from Lawrence, the strongest performances are unquestionably by Matthias Schoenaerts (as Dominika's slimeball uncle) and Charlotte Rampling (as the takes-no-prisoners Matron of the Sparrow School).
Joel Edgerton tries hard to elevate his fairly so-so material, but he ultimately feels like a piece of the movie's furniture rather than a full-bodied character in his own right.
Elsewhere there are solid smaller roles for Joely Richardson (Dominika's ill mother) and Jeremy Irons (a Russian General), ensuring that the screen is always awash with top-tier talent, even if they're often clearly deserving of superior material to work with.
1. The Solidly Satisfying Ending
No spoilers, of course, but as silly as the movie gets, it does still manage to conclude in mostly satisfying fashion, serving up a neat final twist which, while not exactly shocking, aptly services both the characters and the story.
The ending certainly leaves some questions dangling in the air and it probably could've handled a few things a little better, but in terms of realising the frothy spy thriller kicks most of the movie was in search of, it basically succeeds.
It's a capper that'll probably leave most audiences more entertained by the film than not, even if those aforementioned glaring issues can't readily be ignored either.
What did you think of Red Sparrow? Shout it out in the comments!