Robert De Niro: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

2013 The Family Screen 2 Rightfully considered one of the greatest actors of all time, Robert De Niro has had a lengthy and storied career that has spanned six decades and seven Academy Award nominations. Most notable for his legendary collaborations with Martin Scorsese, De Niro has also worked with great directors such as Francis Ford Coppola, Sergio Leone, Terry Gilliam, Brian De Palma, Quentin Tarantino, Michael Mann and Alan Parker. Incredibly versatile, but most notable for his portrayal of brooding masculinity within deeply flawed and complex young souls - De Niro, has in recent years veered more towards comedy and light-hearted fare with mixed success at best and it has been sad to see the great director in some truly awful movies over the last 10-15 years. When not trading in his dignity for a paycheque, De Niro has proved he still has it, as proved in his recent Oscar nominated turn in Silver Linings Playbook. It's an astonishing task picking only five great Robert De Niro performances and his magnificent turns in films such as Goodfellas, Once Upon A Time in America, Heat, Casino, Jackie Brown and Angel Heart aren't included here. Sadly, on the flip side of the coin, there were far more than 5 awful performances in De Niro's career, and the films selected here truly do represent the nadir of his professional life. One of cinema's enduring greats who has made iconic so many great characters, his heyday may be long behind him, but it's good to see a man wanting to work, even if much of that work is borderline unwatchable. To celebrate the US release today of his latest starring vehicle The Family, Robert De Niro is the latest actor to run the gauntlet of our 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked column...

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Johnny Boy - Mean Streets

Robert De Niro Mean Streets Mean Streets unleashed Martin Scorsese, Robert De Niro and Harvey Keitel to audiences, and none of them have looked back since. The film is impossibly electric and shows the lure of crime through a groovy soundtrack that features The Rolling Stones at their finest and an array of sharp suits. Depicting criminals at the bottom end of the ladder, Mean Streets has a sweaty desperate atmosphere that is a constant cause for unease - no doubt thanks to De Niro's Johnny Boy, an unpredictable wannabe Mafia star. It's clear De Niro has charisma and a magnetic ability from the second he walks on screen. Harvey Keitel is a formidable screen presence in his own right, but it's De Niro we remember from the movie. We remember his destructive impulses, his raw volatility and foolish bravado that eventually leads to his downfall. De Niro was 30 at the time but Johnny Boy feels so much younger, and in many ways he is childish, lacking the maturity it takes to be a member of the fraternity he is so desperate to join. It's a more gritty and less polished collaboration than their later films, but it has as much power as any of them.

4. Rupert Pupkin - The King of Comedy

king-of-comedy-001

The perennial underrated Martin Scorsese-Robert De Niro collaboration. It features both men in scarily sharp form ten years on from their first film together. It's the blackest comedy you'll ever see and features a mutated De Niro as a fame hungry comedian who resorts to kidnapping Jerry Lewis in a desperate attempt at stardom. It's ingenious, and is overlooked because it doesn't really fit in with the rest of Scorsese's filmography. The devastating portrayal of fame is as resonant now as it was then, but it's still as underrated now as it was then. De Niro is funny, sinister and surprising as the enigma that is Rupert Pupkin. One of the most intelligent things about the picture is that until the final few minutes you don't know if Pupkin is actually a great or terrible comedian - and it turns out he's somewhere in between. The film, like De Niro surprises us throughout, and is absurdly surrealist in parts. Searing, daring and devastating, De Niro shows us another side in The King of Comedy, a side that would be revelatory and unforgettable.

3. Vito Corleone - The Godfather Part II

284853-the_godfather_movie_image_robert_de_niro_super

Following his enigmatic breakthrough in Mean Streets and his failed, but impressive audition as Michael for the first Godfather movie, Francis Ford Coppola decided to cast De Niro as the young Vito Corleone in his sequel. De Niro was a star from here on in, and his run from 1973 to 1983 is as close to perfection as any actor can get. De Niro had the hardest task of all in The Godfather Part II - he had to portray a youthful, but maturing version of the character Marlon Brando made so iconic just two years previously. The Vito of De Niro had to be different but fundamentally similar to the Vito Brando created, which is no mean feat. The young Vito is humble, calculated and distinctly more vulnerable than the Vito we came to know in the first movie. With most of his dialogue in Italian, it's even more surprising that the Academy awarded De Niro the Best Supporting Actor award, but he thoroughly deserved it, and he would win again six years later, whilst being robbed a couple of times in between. Coppola's masterpiece (and my favourite film) is perfect, with much credit going to the performance of De Niro, who achieved the impossible in creating a Vito that was his own, yet obviously from the same DNA as the elder man played by Brando.

2. Jake LaMotta - Raging Bull

raging bull de niro

The finest example of the great actor's method acting - to embody the legendary boxer, De Niro brutalised himself to achieve the desired effect. His weight flummoxed dramatically so he could play LaMotta through the ages, which actually affected De Niro's posture and health quite radically. De Niro also proved to be a natural at boxing, which he discovered after taking lessons for the part. De Niro's method acting is the stuff of Hollywood lore and deservedly so, that kind of manic commitment to a role deserves its own legend. But as impressive as the physical feats are, the genius in the performance is within. The animalistic and rage-filled boxer is a Molotov cocktail of doubt, and whilst being quite a nasty person, De Niro humanises him and makes him a uniquely sympathetic being. LaMotta is a man crippled by doubts, paranoia and anger and he destroys everybody he loves. Co-written by De Niro, and it shows as he gets right into the psychology of the character, from the opening scenes to the perfect closing shot. Rarely have Academy Awards been this deserved.

1. Travis Bickle - Taxi Driver

The quintessential Robert De Niro performance will always be his haunted depiction of self-righteous loner Travis Bickle, who falls in love with an underage prostitute and attempts to assassinate a politician. In Taxi Driver, De Niro takes us into the dark heart of New York, enveloping us into the suffocating sleaze of the city. Bickle is appalled with the world he lives in and wishes to improve the conditions of the city, ridding it of corruption and exploitation. It would be easy for De Niro to play Bickle as a hysterical mad man, but the way he subtly displays his changing emotions prove why he is arguably the greatest actor of them all. Taxi Driver stands out for its individual scenes, most famously the scene where Bickle talks to himself in the mirror, continuing his mental downward spiral as he does so. Bickle, haircut aside, is an unremarkable and quiet man, but it is De Niro that makes him such a magnetic presence. It's a sad, humane performance of a man and the darkest creation of Scorsese, Schrader and De Niro.


And 5 Performances That Sucked...

5. Jack Byrnes - Little Fockers

Film Title: Little Fockers Meet the Parents was just about bearable, Meet the Fockers was annoying but had a few laughs, but Little Fockers was an unholy, miserable cash-in that had everybody leaving the cinema looking like they'd just suffered a colonoscopy. Robert De Niro was the only funny thing in the previous two films, but by the third it was drastic overkill as he spends the duration of the movie trying to get us to laugh at his erectile problems. De Niro appeared to forget about his legacy, and more importantly, his dignity when he agreed to be in the movie. The film still made a boat load of money so the chances of another sequel remain high, but please, for the sake of all that is holy, don't make another one. There's not a single laugh to be found, and you almost feel sorry for De Niro, but then you realise that he's been made in excess of seven figures to appear.

4. Det. Mitch Preston - Showtime

Showtime Showtime stars Robert De Niro and Eddie Murphy as a buddy-cop duo, which somebody, who clearly didn't possess a single brain cell, thought would be absolutely hilarious. Unsurprisingly, the end result was unmitigated tedium. The only even remotely sane reasoning for pairing De Niro together appears to be that some studio suit thinks a black guy and an old white dude paired together is the height of comedic entertainment. It's awkward (certainly not in a funny way), tiresome and a tiny little bit strange. By this point, we knew De Niro couldn't really do straight out comedy, and it's depressing to see him persist with it, especially in a movie as turgid as this.

3. Turk - Righteous Kill

Righteous Kill Righteous Kill is perhaps the most disheartening movie ever made. Finally a movie starring De Niro and Al Pacino as the two leads, yet they end up both appearing inferior to Fiddy and a member of New Kids on the Block. In truth, putting De Niro and Pacino in the same film after The Godfather Part II and Heat was always a recipe f0r disaster, and would inevitably be disappointing, but nobody expected something quite as awful as Righteous Kill. It's incredibly boring and De Niro and Pacino have the most ridiculous names - Turk and Rooster respectively. It's generic and dumb stuff, and there's not even fun to be had with the novelty of watching De Niro and Pacino working with each other. This will go down as a great opportunity wasted, it's not even interesting enough to annoy people. Lazy, predictable and tired - and that's just Robert De Niro's performance.

2. Richard Wells - Godsend

Robert De Niro Godsend To give De Niro his credit, there is nothing he won't try his hand at. Pretty much every caricature, every stereotype and every cliché have been explored by De Niro in his later years and in Godsend, he tries his hand at mad scientist. Of course he plays the mad scientist in a ridiculously melodramatic way that is unintentionally hilarious. The whole movie is implausible trash that should have been sent straight to a bargain bin rather than actually get a cinematic release - it surprisingly grossed $30 million at the box-office. In Godsend, a grieving couple go to De Niro's mad scientist in attempt to clone their dead son back to life - and the film is exactly as bad as it sounds - and far less fun. Poorly made and mostly forgotten, De Niro surely can't look back favourably on this one, even though he's not the worst thing in it. That dubious honour goes to the boy, who is about as likeable as a chainsaw-wielding Fascist.

1. Fearless Leader - The Adventures Of Rocky And Bullwinkle

The Adventures of Rocky and Bullwinkle

There's a reason The Adventures of Rocky and Bullwinkle routinely features on the 'Worst Movies Ever' lists - and that's because it's an embarrassing farce that leaves everybody involved looking shamed. And worse of all, De Niro is the worst offender. In amongst the shoddy CGI and the anaemic jokes is a performance so embarrassing it's a miracle De Niro ever worked again. In fact, if the actor in question wasn't Robert De Niro, then there is a good chance they would never have worked again. The performance just leaves a bad taste in the mouth, and whilst camp is often good fun, here it is the most irritating thing imaginable. Doing a stupidly exaggerated European accent whilst acting hysterically in ways you've never even thought of genuinely make this one of the worst movie performances of all time. Sadly, this wasn't the first or the last time De Niro let his dignity at the door when agreeing to be in a movie. He somehow manages to come across as Dr. Evil parody, who himself is a parody of Blofeld - and when you're doing a parody of a parody, you know you've gone wrong somewhere. Just don't even get me started on the recreation of *THAT* Taxi Driver scene.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.