Robert Redford: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked
Cowboys, politicians... and now dragons.

In a career spanning more than 50 years, Robert Redford has become one of the most widely-respected figures in American cinema. He's played some of the most iconic characters in Hollywood history, from Jay Gatsby to the Sundance Kid, all while directing a handful of acclaimed films and giving independent filmmakers a huge leg-up through the Sundance Film Festival.
Having enjoyed a mainstream revival in recent years thanks the stunning to All Is Lost and a villain turn in Captain America: The Winter Soldier, Redford returns to screens this week in the remake of Disney's Pete's Dragon. The early buzz suggests it's a return you really have to see.
And of course, it provides us with the ideal opportunity to re-examine Redford's career, from his early days on TV to his more recent offerings.
Here, then, are the highs and lows of Robert Redford's career summed up in ten performances, five good, five bad for this week's 5 Awesome Performances and 5 That Sucked...
5 Awesome Performances...
5. Joe Turner - Three Days Of The Condor (1975)

Directors often form a bond with a particular actor which leads them to work on numerous films together. Think of Ridley Scott teaming up with Russell Crowe, or Martin Scorsese's work with Robert De Niro and more recently Leonardo DiCaprio. One of the more underrated director-actor pairings is Redford and Sydney Pollack, who collaborated seven times betwen 1967 and 1990. We begin our countdown with Three Days of the Condor, perhaps their most enjoyable collaboration.
Three Days of the Condor is a taut political thriller based on the novel Six Days of the Condor by James Brady. It follows low-level CIA operative Joe Turner (Redford), who spends his days looking for hidden messages in novels, newspapers and magazines. Having made a report to his superiors about a thriller novel with several peculiar plot details, Turner returns to his office to find that his six colleagues have all been murdered. What follows is a tense game of cat-and-mouse as Turner (codename Condor) goes on the run and the CIA attempt to track him down.
Three Days of the Condor remains a well-made, twisty thriller, whose commentary on secrecy and the politics of oil still resonates today. Pollack directs with pace and dexterity, and Redford is very convincing as an agent who is out of his depth and fighting for his life. Notwithstanding the more action-packed sections of the plot, it's easy to view this performance as a trial run for his subsequent role in All The President's Men. In any case, it's a very good place to start our countdown.
4. The Sundance Kid - Butch Cassidy And The Sundance Kid (1969)

No list of Redford's best performances would be complete without the role which made him an international star. His first of two collaborations with Paul Newman and director George Roy Hill is still regarded as a classic of the western genre. Scripted by William Goldman, who later wrote The Princess Bride, it's a breezy and highly entertaining romp with a brace of great performances at its centre.
Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid is based very loosely on the lives of Wild West outlaws Roger LeRoy Parker (a.k.a. Butch Cassidy) and Harry Longabough (a.k.a. The Sundance Kid). Accompanied by their Hole-in-the-Wall Gang, the pair plan to rob the Union Pacific Overland Flyer train in both directions. The first robbery goes well but the second is a shambles, forcing Butch and Sundance to go on the run, starting a chase that will eventually lead them to Bolivia.
Redford won a BAFTA for his performance, one of six BAFTAs and four Oscars the film took home, including Best Picture at both ceremonies. On top of his undeniable sex appeal (even with the silly moustache), it's easy to see why he deserved the accolade.
Rather than just play him as a pretty-boy sidekick, Redford makes Sundance a rounded character with his own foibles and flaws, and his chemistry with Newman is impeccable. It's therefore no surprise that they eventually reunited for the next film on our list...
3. Johnny Hooker - The Sting (1973)

The huge success of Butch Cassidy at the US box office led to considerable demand for another film with Newman and Redford sharing centre stage. Audiences had to wait four years before George Roy Hill brought them back together for The Sting, but it was certainly worth it. Despite some resentment among horror fans (it beat The Exorcist to the Best Picture Oscar), it still stands as a well-crafted and all-round fun caper film.
The Sting is based on the exploits of real-life grifters Fred and Charley Gondorff. Set in 1936, it begins with small-time con artist Johnny Hooker (Redford) conning an unsuspecting victim out of $11,000. Buoyed by his success, he is advised to seek out Henry Gondorff (Newman), a former grifter currently in hiding, from whom he can learn "the big con". The pair team up to bring down vicious crime boss Doyle Lonnegan (Robert Shaw) through an elaborate old-fashioned con called 'the wire'.
Like Butch Cassidy, The Sting sees Newman and Redford going toe-to-toe for the limelight. Each get their share of intense scenes to show off their acting prowess: Newman gets the poker game on the train, Redford the encounter with the FBI in the warehouse. Redford is perfectly cast as the cheekier, less respectful party; he charms us with his sense of mischief and keeps us on the edge of our seats when backed into a corner. It may not be his best performance, but it's close.
2. Bill McKay - The Candidate (1972)

There are a great many films and TV shows which focus on the emptiness of politics, particularly the ruthless machinations of the election campaign. You only have to turn on your TV or search through Netflix for episodes of House of Cards, The West Wing or The Thick of It which cover this sort of ground. But when it comes to 1970s politics, and the creeping cynicism of the Nixon era, few films do it better than The Candidate.
The Candidate is a political drama written by Jeremy Larner, who served as a speechwriter for Senator Eugene J. McCarthy during the 1968 election. Redford plays Bill McKay, the idealistic, charismatic son of a former Governor of California, who is persuaded to run for the Democrats in the seemingly unwinnable race against popular Republican Crocker Jarmon (Don Porter). At first McKay is allowed to campaign on whatever values he likes, but soon election specialist Marvin Lucas (Peter Boyle) begins diluting his message in a desperate bid to win more votes.
The Candidate contains many elements which will be familiar to fans of the shows I cited: there's more than a little of Malcolm Tucker in the character of Marvin Lucas. But for all its prophetic moments, Redford's performance should be singled out for special attention. He brilliantly captures the mental state of a man of principle being worn down and swamped by a system that only wants power. It remains a gripping, powerful drama, anchored by a very mature and layered performance.
1. Bob Woodward - All The President's Men (1976)

This might seem a predictable choice for number one, considering the other political choices that have appeared on this list. But of all the roles that have come to define him as the actor (as opposed to a director or a sex symbol), Bob Woodward most epitomises what Redford has come to represent: a man of conscience and principle, fighting against deep-rooted interests to tell stories that deserve more attention in an approachable, intelligent manner.
All The President's Men is the true story of Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein (Dustin Hoffman), two young reporters with The Washington Post who uncovere the Watergate conspiracy. Adapted from their accounts by William Goldman (him again), the film is a twisty and intriguing affair which is as much a conspiracy thriller as it is a tribute to the power of investigative journalism. The film is directed by Alan J. Pakula, who was Oscar-nominated for producing To Kill A Mockingbird.
All The President's Men remains a milestone of 1970s cinema which still holds up to close examination. Redford co-produced the film and meticulously researched both Woodward and the environment in which he worked, right down to ordering desks from the same company that supplied them to the Post.
His performance is just as meticulous but also has a great sense of impulse and instinct which lights up the screen, particularly during his shadowy encounters with Deep Throat. It's a performance of all-round brilliance which continues to define his career.
Having given Redford a clean bill of health, it's now time to dish the dirt on some of his worst performances...
And 5 That Sucked...
5. Tom Logan - Legal Eagles (1986)

"From the director of Ghostbusters" is a phrase that would make most film fans sit bolt upright with anticipation (not me, incidentally - it's a very overrated film). Certainly expectations were riding high when Ivan Reitman's new film was announced, featuring Redford on the back of Out of Africa (we'll get to that) and Daryl Hannah, who had enjoyed a big hit with Splash two years prior. Unfortunately, the film is a bit of a mess, and Redford certainly doesn't help matters.
Legal Eagles follows Tom Logan, the Assistant District Attorney in New York City. Into his life walks fellow lawyer Laura Kelly (Debra Winger), who is defending her client Chelsea Deardon (Hannah) on a charge of stealing a painting which she claims is hers. As the case progresses, a massive insurance fraud comes to light which sees Logan and Kelly teaming up to get to the bottom of things.
Legal Affairs suffered a difficult production, and its initial theatrical run was so mediocre that additional endings were reshot for the TV broadcasts, neither of which make a great deal of sense. As a film it's very unsure of its tone, with all the potentially interesting twists of the case being hemmed in by second-rate comic banter. Redford simply looks out of place, wanting to play things straight and take it seriously while Reitman and his co-stars want to do the opposite.
4. John Gage - Indecent Proposal (1993)

Redford has been associated with the thriller genre throughout his career, and he's had his fair share of on-screen romances with glamorous women, from Katherine Ross to Faye Dunaway. But when he attempted to bring the two together in Indecent Proposal, things went badly wrong. Directed by Adrian Lyne of Fatal Attraction fame, the film is a big misfire for all involved, with each of its three stars coming across very awkwardly.
Indecent Proposal follows a young couple, David (Woody Harrelson) and Diana (Demi Moore), who come to Las Vegas in order to win enough money to start their own business. While in Vegas, Diana is seduced by billionaire John Gage (Redford), who offers the couple a million dollars if Diana will sleep with him for one night. This event shakes the couple's marriage to the core, and this only worsens as Gage continues his advances on Diana...
He's creepy enough when we first meet him, but his performance is all on one note and his character doesn't develop to a satisfying extent. Whether you blame Redford or Lyne's inept direction, this is one proposal you should definitely decline.
3. Warren Justice - Up Close & Personal (1996)

Of all the roles open to an individual in Hollywood, being a screenwriter is perhaps the most unrewarding. You can craft the best screenplay in existence, but as soon as a producer, executive or another writer gets hold of it, it can quickly turn into an awful mess. Sometimes the finished product is such a departure from the original story that it could be called offensive - and that brings us to Up Close & Personal.
Directed by John Avnet (Righteous Kill), Up Close & Personal centres on the relationship between Miami local news director Warren Justice and aspiring reporter Sally 'Tally' Atwater (Michelle Pfeiffer). Having hired her on the basis of a homemade audition tape, Justice guides Tally to having her own anchor position, all the while falling more in love with her. Things come to a head when Tally is trapped inside a Philadelphia prison during a riot, and Warren has to guide her through covering the story on national TV.
Up Close & Personal started out as a biopic of troubled but popular news anchor Jessica Savitch, with the first drafts being from Alanna Nash's biography of her. But the studios felt Savitch's arc was too downbeat for American audiences, and so watered down the script into the frothy, third-rate melodrama that remains.
Redford has very little to work with, but he still manages to screw things up, turning in a performance that borders on self-parody. If the film had been a satire like Broadcast News, this could have worked, but as it is it's downright embarrassing.
2. Denys Finch Hayton - Out Of Africa (1985)

Out of Africa is based on the memoirs of Danish author Karen Blixen, published under the pseudonym Isak Denisen. It follows the author (Meryl Streep) as she enters into a marriage of convenience with her aristocrat friend Baron Bror Blixen (Klaus Maria Brandauer). The couple move to East Africa and start a dairy farm, but Karen is unhappy due to her husband's womanising. She develops a friendship with local big-game hunter Denys Finch Hayton, which grows into something more after she throws her husband out.
Out of Africa has some huge narrative problems, most of which stem from Sydney Pollack's refusal to 'cut his luvvies', i.e. remove scenes present in the book which aren't helpful in telling the story on film. Its biggest problem, however, is the complete lack of chemistry between Redford and Streep. While Streep's performance is typically showy and preening, Redford looks almost bored in her company: his delivery is flat, his facial expressions are limited, and he seems confused or reluctant in the part. Throw in a relationship that has little or no development and you have one disappointing epic.
1. Halsy Knox - Little Fauss And Big Halsy (1970)

Considering the pedigree of his films in the period, you might conclude that the 1970s was the decade in which Redford could really do no wrong. But to find his worst performance, you have to go back to the very beginning of that decade, and a confused, pretentious and altogether irritating film called Little Fauss and Big Halsy.
Little Fauss and Big Halsy is set in the world of American motorcycle racing, with the bulk of the action taking place in Phoenix, Arizona. Redford plays Halsy Knox, a professional racer with a care-free attitude and a penchant for womanising, who strikes up a friendship with amateur Little Fauss (Michael J. Pollard). Having been banned from racing himself, Halsy re-enters the circuit under Fauss' name, with Fauss serving as his mechanic. But before long their friendship breaks down and the two men are racing each other.
Despite having a soundtrack that includes Johnny Cash, Carl Perkins and Bob Dylan, Little Fauss and Big Halsy is a corny, schmaltzy and all-round unpleasant affair. Directed by Sidney J. Furie (Superman IV: The Quest for Peace), it lacks both the cutting-edge cult appeal of Easy Rider and the insight of subsequent biker films like Spetters and Knightriders.
Redford has often dismissed the film in interviews, and it isn't hard to see why: his performance is cheesy, mean-spirited and works against all of his strengths. It's a memorably disjointed and bad performance, which still ranks as the worst of his long career.
---
Disagree? Offer your own ranking in the comments thread below.