RoboCop: 4 Things That Worked (And 6 That Sucked)

The good, the bad, and the Robocop.

The RoboCop remake had a turbulent journey from the initial announcement that a reboot of the 1987 classic was in the works. Once production started and the marketing department tried to sell the film to the public, almost every released teaser resulted in a torrent of negativity being RSVP€™d back to the studio. Everything from the new suit, the story, the leaked script and RoboCop€™s new human hand was met with internet vitriol. The public was hostile to anything that dared to change what had been established by Paul Verhoeven in the original. The biggest problem facing the studio was that no one saw any need to redo the original RoboCop, a follow up film that ignored the third sequel and TV series would have been fine. Jose Padilha had a tough job rebooting what is one of the best movies to come out of the 1980€™s. Hiring the credible and highly-rated director was one of the only decisions that most people agreed was a good thing. But even he was feeling the pressure if reports about his miserable time on the shoot are to be believed. Sony moving the release date back by six months didn't help, it sent out a signal that the new RoboCop was going to be a disaster. After all, if the studio is moving release dates and ordering reshoots, they can€™t have much confidence in it either. All in all, the chips were stacked against the remake. The expectation was that even with Padilha directing the hell out of it, RoboCop couldn€™t work without Verhoeven€™s ability to marry killer satire with over-the-top violence. Many have tried, and the results are always lacklustre. The original RoboCop sequels are testament to that as is the other recent Verhoeven remake, Total Recall, that was a massive flop with the critics and the public alike. Now that it€™s finally released, we can watch the film and pass judgment. Did it manage to escape the shadow of the much loved original? In truth, the end result is something of a mixed bag. While it is not terrible, it€™s not great either. Padilha and some of the cast do a good job of elevating it above your standard reboot trash, but a weak script and pandering to a family audience drag it back down. So while it€™s not as bad a people were expecting, click next to see what worked and what didn€™t in RoboCop, the remake that no one wanted. And beware, spoliers ahead.

The Good

10. The Novak Element

As you all know, Samuel L. Jackson is in RoboCop playing Samuel L. Jackson/Pat Novak, a right wing TV commentator who has been modelled on the likes of Bill O'Reilly and Rush Limbaugh. He can€™t understand why America is so hostile to idea of robots walking the streets and protecting Americans from crime. €˜€™Why is America so Robophobic?€™€™ he asks while showing all the good robots are doing in bringing €˜€™peace€™€™ around the globe.

Sporting an awesome hair piece, Novak rants to the American public about how they should be more open to the idea of being policed by robots. And he is more than happy to spin the evidence for his own agenda. These sections have more than a few similarities to the way Fox News presents its version of current affair €“ the right wing agenda of the station is always looming over whatever news is being reported.

Samuel L. Jackson relishes every line and is clearly enjoying playing the part and it shows. To see him cut off a senator who doesn€™t agree with his idea of policing and then spin it to make it look like the US Senate is €˜€™pro-crime€™€™ is a joy to watch. Anyone who has ever got annoyed by Glenn Beck will love the way these segments satirize the way right wing talk show hosts conduct interviews.

While it might not be Media Break from the original RoboCop, 'The Novak Element' is one of the few instances when the script is firing on all cylinders. Watching Novak desperately try and get America to be more accepting of robots when public and political opinion is against him serves as a brilliant analogy for the way Sony tried to sell the RoboCop remake to the general public.


9. The Opening Sequence

The leaked RoboCop script mentioned a sequence that takes place in Iran. I have to admit that when I first learned that some of the film was to take place away from Detroit, I was one of the people who screamed sacrilege. But as it turns out, the scene in Tehran is one of the best in the whole movie.

According to Novak, the ED-209€™s and EM-208€™s are bringing justice and peace to the streets of Tehran. A blonde reporter on the ground beams back pictures of the Iranian citizens being ordered to put their arms up so they can be security checked. Novak spins it a positive news story and interviews an army general who comments that they have learned from the mistakes of Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan and thanks to the mechanization of the army, American blood will be spilt no more.

But like in real life, the other side of the coin tells a different story. The Iranians are less than happy to be aggressively ID-checked by a robot and a group of men decide to take matters in their own hand to make a point. Led by a father, the group put on suicide vests to take on the ED-209€™s and EM-208€™s with the goal to die in front of the TV audience. What follows is a pretty dramatic sequence that ends with an ED-209 shooting dead a child holding a knife.

With obvious comparisons to the controversies surrounding the use of drones, the current events in the middle east and the way filtered news that is fed to the American public; the whole scene highlights the relationship between the government and media manipulation. Just as the action kicks off in Tehran, the feed to Novak and the American public is cut, due to €˜€™security concerns.€™€™ The only news they want to show is what benefits their agenda, everything else is censored.

Tense and perfectly executed; not only does it demonstrate the weaknesses in the Omnicorp Robot program, but it does it in a way that is relevant to what is going on today. And as this all happens before the opening titles, it gives you an impression that the RoboCop reboot has brains behind it.


8. Gary Oldman & Michael Keaton Save The Day

To say that Gary Oldman and Michael Keaton saved this film is not an exaggeration. Had these two not been in the RoboCop remake, the film would have struggled to be classed even as watchable. They carry the movie and push the script along while the rest of the cast do their best to fumble through or drag it down altogether. Michael Keaton replaced Hugh Laurie as Raymond Sellers, CEO of Omnicorp. Less formal than the 'old man' in the original, Keaton comes across more like your nice uncle playing boss of a multi-billion dollar company. While in the back of your mind you struggle to separate Raymond Sellers from Bruce Wayne, Keaton€™s unique delivery is always fun to watch. As for Gary Oldman, he's easily the best actor in the film. Putting in the real emotion that€™s missing from Joel Kinnaman's mediocre performance, you see Oldman struggle with his ethics as he fuses man with machine. If this RoboCop was supposed to be all about Murphy€™s transformation from man to machine, it is Gary Oldman that does the majority of the work of translating the human struggle to the audience. The scenes that have Oldman and Keaton debating the ethics of putting a man in a machine are some of the best in the film.

7. The Suit €“ It's Not That Bad

We all despised the suit. As soon as the first pictures were released, everyone hated the suit. Why was it black? Why did it look like rubber? What€™s with the human hand? Comments such as RoboBat, RoboCrap and RubberCop were thrown around in forums to describe the redesigned suit. The original is a design classic. You show it to anyone and they will tell you it€™s RoboCop. And not only has it stood the test of time, it still looks cool and modern. So the decision to totally redesign it was a brave one. It€™s akin to someone radically redesigning the Batsuit. RoboCop is the original RoboCop suit. The film begins with Murphy in a silver suit, it doesn€™t look anywhere near as awesome as the original but it is a fair, modern-day reworking of the classic design. Later, after receiving feedback from a focus group, Raymond Sellers orders the suit to be altered to be more €˜€™tactical,€™€™ and by tactical he means make it black. I was hiding behind gritted teeth in anticipation of the reveal of the black version of the suit. As the camera panned up from the legs, to the torso, neck and head, I was fully expecting to hate it but I surprised myself. Honestly, I didn€™t mind it. I€™m not saying that it€™s a brilliant redesign but instead that it didn€™t generate the convulsions and uncontrollable retching that I was expecting. It didn€™t look rubbery and Kinnerman€™s robotic actions did a lot to make it look robotic. The flip down visor was annoying though €“ you just wish it would stay down permanently because when it€™s up, Kinnaman looks like he is about to go deep sea diving. Even the human hand didn€™t present itself as much of a problem as originally perceived. You barely notice it. It would have been better if it wasn€™t there but it€™s not the cinema crime of the century that I was expecting it to be. The film has an annoying habit of taking place in daylight which isn't flattering to the suit, it looks better at night. At the end of the movie, RoboCop goes back to being silver. I imagine that must have been the studio ordered reshoots that were a response to the negative reaction to the black version. Sadly they kept the flip down visor and human hand. Now, click Next to see what sucked about RoboCop.

The Bad

6. EmoCop €“ What's He Complaining About?

RoboCop throughout this remake is a miserable, self-pitying emo-bot. Granted, he€™s got a lot to be annoyed about €“ it can€™t be too pleasant to survive a car bombing and find out that you are nothing more than a face, brain, lungs and an unloved hand. But after half an hour of watching Murphy coming to terms with his situation, I was internally screaming that enough is enough and that he should accept it like a man, fourth-degree burns be damned, As a full human, Murphy starts the film angry and annoyed at an investigation going wrong. He is then annoyed and angry at being turned into RoboCop. That follows an extended sequence where he is angry and annoyed while he solves his own murder. He is then angry and annoyed at the police sergeant for setting him up. And after he is switched off by Maddox, he awakens very angry and annoyed as he takes on Omnicorp directly. I fully accept that he has a lot to be unhappy about but watching him drive around on his motorbike like a teenager throwing a tantrum only brought it home how petulant his behaviour was and how ungrateful he was at being given a second chance at life. The fact that the film gives very little reason to actually feel sorry for him doesn€™t help. In the original RoboCop, Murphy dies a slow and horrible death that involves his hand and arm being blown off. He then awakes as a machine and has lost all his humanity. He€™s encased in a metal shell that gives him superhuman strength, a CPU in the brain and invulnerability to bullets but given the choice, it€™s not desirable. He€™s a Frankenstein€™s monster. At no point do you think that he€™s better as RoboCop than Alex Murphy. And to top it off, he's lost his family. Compared to the new RoboCop who awakens with all his memories intact, the ability to jump enormous distances, run really fast and indulge in feats of cat-like agility; he's more of a superhero than a tragic victim. Physically he is better in every way than when he was a mere human. Once he€™s got over the shock, what exactly does he have to be upset about? Considering the state he was left in after the explosion, he should have been on his knees thanking Dr Norton for the body he woke up in. But instead we get scene after scene of him running or riding away from his problems and with the same look on his face that you see on any toddler who hasn€™t received the Christmas present they wanted. He can still have a family life, and sure, it might not be how it was but it€™s better than being dead. His wife hasn't rejected him, his son still calls him dad. The suit and the powers it gives him are awesome. He's not confined to a wheelchair or facing years of rehabilitation that other people who have limbs blown off. So what's his problem? Jose Padilha wanted to focus of Murphy's transformation while the public wanted to see RoboCop take down bad guys. The 1987 movie got the balance right between the two but this RoboCop is obsessed with Murphy's internal issues and that doesn't make the most interesting RoboCop movie. A lot of the blame has to go to the script and Joel Kinnerman who is instantly forgettable as Alex Murphy and only tolerable as RoboCop. The only time you get a rest bite from having to experience his facial acting is when the visor comes down, unfortunately that is not as often as you like.

5. More Violence Please!

With the original€™s reputation for exploding so many blood squibs that they should have got a credit in the end titles, the news that this RoboCop was aiming for a PG-13 rating was a firm kick in the nuts. Ultra-violence and RoboCop go together like booze and a kebab. Is it possible to make a tame RoboCop film? They tried with RoboCop 3 and the TV series, and look how successful they were. There were a lot of reassurances that you can get away with a lot in a PG-13 movie and anyone who was worried that the RoboCop remake was going to be kid friendly can relax. There is nothing to worry about we were told. But sadly, that's not the case. The lack of actual violence is more than noticeable and you begin to miss it as the film goes on. After the promising opening where we see a child get gunned down in a shower of bullets from ED-209, even though the gore is hidden behind a cloud of smoke, the implied violence does the trick and you are left optimistic for what€™s to come. However, as the film drags on, you witness RoboCop shoot lots of other robots but almost all humans are PG-13 tasered. No blood splatters anywhere unless they're from a far off distance. Even the final confrontation with the ED-209s looks like a trailer for a new Crisis game. While usually the lack of gore and violence isn€™t enough to break a movie, it€™s difficult to accept a RoboCop movie that€™s made safe for children. It feels patronising the see the camera turn away as someone gets shot. RoboCop should be a franchise for adults, and the OTT violence was what made the original so appealing to 80€™s kids. Like the Total Recall remake, the pressure from the studio to make this film family friendly is one of the main reasons no one will care about it in a year€™s time.

4. Robovision

RoboCop in this remake is force-fed all the Detroit Police Department records and given access to all of the cities CCTV cameras. It€™s a voyeur and stalker€™s dream as RoboCop hacks into various CCTV cameras to spy on villains and his own family. But if that wasn€™t enough, the new RoboVision allows Murphy to reconstruct crime scenes, diagnose medical problems and read people€™s emotional states. You get the impression that whatever hurdle there was in the script, RoboVision was on hand to come to the rescue. In one snigger inducing scene, RoboCop is on another angry motorbike ride and he uses CCTV to zoom in on his son. His son looks miserable but RoboVision still has to write €˜€™Emotionally distraught€™€™ under his unhappy face. And it even comes with a sense of humour. When RoboCop busts a drug factory, his RoboVision tells him that one of the bad guys is €˜€™totally stoned.€™€™ Rather than it being a tool for Murphy, this RoboVision is used to feed the audience information and fill in gaps in the script. It€™s heavy-handed and obvious. And more often than not, it makes you laugh at the absurdity of it rather than being in awe of how awesome it would be to have. One thing that didn€™t make sense, why did they decide to upload all the Police files into his memory, two minutes before he was going to be unveiled to the public for the first time? It€™s hardly surprising that something went wrong, surely a major installation like this would be done before and tested. But luckily Kinnaman is on hand to distract you from the bad script with his face-acting. As he's overloaded with information and starts to have a seizure, his eyes start rolling back to show the audience that he€™s not operating normally. It's unfortunate, the close up of Kinnaman€™s face made him look like a man in deep ecstasy trying to access his Robo wank bank. Less would have been better.

3. Detroit Is Quite A Nice Place

Detroit in the original RoboCop was a crime ridden, economically deprived, pit of a city. Sadly in real life, the current state of Detroit is not far off from Verhoeven€™s depiction. Detroit even filed for bankruptcy in 2013 and there are very little signs of recovery anytime soon. So you would think that with RoboCop being set in Detroit, it would be a no brainier for any writer or director to use Detroit€™s plight as the backdrop for the movie. It would make a far more interesting setting than the €˜off-the-shelf€™ city that Jose Padilha went with. Crisp and clean, Detroit could have been LA, Chicago or a futuristic London. It was Detroit because the subtitle told us. Showing us that crime was rampant would have given the pro-robot argument in the film an extra dimension. Other than corporate greed, the viewer would have been challenged that maybe robots are necessary and that Omnicorp might be thinking about their profit margin, but maybe deploying robots is just what a city like Detroit needs. It would also have given RoboCop a few more interesting criminals to take down rather than the couple of dull scenes we were presented with. Detroit in this RoboCop looks like a pleasant place to live. We don't see any street crime take place, it's mostly sunny and it appears to have had a lot of investment. So why would Detroit need a RoboCop? A boring, clean and bland Detroit renders RoboCop unnecessary. That might be why we see RoboCop do very little in actual crime-fighting in the film. Jose Padilha missed an opportunity to make a statement about the current dire situation that some parts of America finds itself in and how big corporations can exploit that for profit. Instead we get told that America needs a robot police force but are not explicitly shown why.

2. Annoying Family

In the 1987 movie, we got a slight glimpse of Alex Murphy€™s family in the heart breaking sequence when he goes back home to find an empty house and flashbacks. As he remembers his wife and son, you feel for him. Murphy, due to no fault of his own, has had everything taken from him. It motivates him to go after Clarence Boddicker even more. The 2014 film puts his family in a more prominent role. They are at the centre of Murphy€™s struggle and he has far more interaction with them. It€™s just a shame that any chemistry between Joel Kinnerman and Abbie Cornish is non-existent and the scenes with his son are pure cheese to the point you are not sure if you are watching a scene from Bicentennial Man. Having his family involved so closely robbed RoboCop of one of the big reasons why his situation is so tragic. In this new film, apart from being encased in a new body, there is little reason why he couldn€™t continue to be a father and husband in some capacity. In RoboCop 2, we find out that Murphy has been stalking his ex-wife and child. This prompts OCP to humiliate him into rejecting his wife so she can move on. That feels like a real consequence. There is more emotional impact in that one scene than there is in the whole RoboCop remake. In the new RoboCop, his family also have a habit of being shoehorned into scenes and disrupting the flow of the film. In one ludicrous moment, RoboCop is on another angst bike ride and is confronted by his wife in the middle of the street. Not only did she manage to fight through a police cordon, she also somehow knew the route RoboCop was taking in order to talk to him so she can tell him to go see their son. It was so silly. The same goes for the ending where they happen to get themselves held hostage on the roof of Omnicorp towers. Some folk just can't catch a break, so they need to stay in the goddamned house. To explore the family dynamic, the film needed to be longer to do it properly. Unfortunately his family become nothing more than a nuisance in the film because they are a couple of characters you don€™t care about.

1. No Proper Villain

One of the biggest problems in the film is the lack of a proper villain. There is a massive Clarence Boddicker-sized hole that becomes distracting the more the film rolls on. Antoine Vallon is identified early on as being a crime boss in Detroit, and when Murphy gets too close, he has him killed via a car bombing outside his home. So there are some similarities between Vallon and Boddicker as both are the catalyst for Murphy€™s transformation into RoboCop. But that is where the similarities end. The problem for Vallon, he isn€™t given enough screen time for the audience to develop any sort of feelings towards the character. The bombing isn€™t gruesome enough for you to hate him and when it happens, you don€™t really have any sort of an emotional attachment to Alex Murphy so again, you don€™t really care. You know at some point, Murphy will go after Vallon and that happens at the end of the second act. But because you know next to nothing about Vallon apart from him being responsible for Murphy€™s death, the eventual confrontation lacks the emotional payoff it should have had. You know none of his gang members and as they are dispatched, it means nothing to you. Then as the film rushes towards its conclusion, Sellars jumps into the bad guy role and the transition is jarring to say the least. We knew Sellars was motivated by money, but where did we see that he was a man that would happily shoot a family if needed? It's not so much a shock, but more of a cheap trick (no, not the band, never the band). Films like these need a central villain for the hero to overcome. It would have acted as a balance against Murphy€™s not very interesting personal story. But not only was it a missed opportunity, it also gave the second half of the film no sense of direction or focus.

Contributor
Contributor

Child of the 80's. Brought up on Star Trek, Video Games and Schwarzenegger, my tastes evolved to encompass all things geeky.