Sandman: 10 Actors Who Should Appear

JGL needs to give these guys and girls a call.

Active development continues on the Joseph Gordon-Levitt produced film adaptation of Neil Gaiman's seminal comic book fantasy Sandman. After The Dark Knight trilogy and Man of Steel writer David S. Goyer wrote an outline, the upcoming film now has a writer permanently attached. Skins and This Is England '86 and '88 writer Jack Thorne is better known for his work in British TV than large scale features, but he received plenty of critical plaudits for his small screen work including his previous foray into dark fantasy, The Fades, which won a Best Drama Bafta. As yet Thorne is the only other name attached to the project with no director or cast officially signed up, not even JGL himself in any role beyond producer. Last month I made ten suggestions for potential actors for the lead role of Dream. On this list I will put forward possible casting choices for the rest of the roles that a Sandman movie is likely to have. Assuming that Warner Brothers, Gordon-Levitt, Goyer and Thorne are looking for a film that functions well as a set up for the character and a potential franchise that tells the whole story, but also as a standalone story if this is the only Sandman movie that we get, I have presumed a plot that is primarily a combination of the first two volumes: Preludes and Nocturnes, and A Doll's House and cast ten potential roles accordingly. Having said that, I will begin with suggestions for the six other Endless, even those that don't really appear in those first two story arcs.

10. Death - Anna Kendrick

The most loved, most popular character in the whole Sandman universe, including the eponymous Dream, is Death. Far from the implacable grim reaper of other personifications of life's end, Death of the Endless is the one of Gaiman's immortals to display a constant supportive, empathetic attitude towards humanity. She also represents a kindly and wise listener and adviser to her siblings, Dream above all, and all this in the body of a cute goth girl. Anna Kendrick is an Oscar nominee and has plenty of experience in big hit movies thanks to the Twilight series, but is only just becoming a well known name in her own right. With six films coming out this year, culminating in the part of Cinderella in the Disney adaptation of Stephen Sondheim's musical fairy tale mash-up Into the Woods, Kendrick is set to become more of a familiar star by the time Sandman goes into production. Kendrick has a likeable, down to earth persona that extends from lo-fi indies and comedies like 50/50 (in which she already displayed good chemistry with Gordon-Levitt) and Drinking Buddies, to her popular social media presence. In the role of Scott Pilgrim's Stacey she has already embodied a comic book character's more mature sister, judging and advising on her brother's messy life in a way not unlike Gaiman's Death. Other options: Gaiman fan Claire Danes (the star in Stardust and the Princess in the Gaiman penned dub of Princess Mononoke) wrote the introduction to the spin-off comic Death: The Time of Your Life, but would perhaps have been a more appropriate choice in her My So Called Life era than while currently starring in Homeland. Gaiman tried to get a film of Death made with Guillermo del Toro during the 00s at which point it was rumoured to star Return to Oz and The Craft's Fairuza Balk, perhaps no longer a big enough name. Stars like Ellen Page and Natalie Portman have also been mentioned in the past.

9. Desire - Natalie Dormer

With Thorne now attached as Sandman's writer, it is quite possible that he could bring some of his The Fades cast with him. Many of the British cast have gone on to bigger things in American TV and film, but one in particular is a major rising star: Natalie Dormer. A series of regal roles from The Tudors' Anne Boleyn to Game of Thrones' Margaery Tyrell (and, slightly more oddly, the Queen Mother) have shown Dormer as adept at playing characters that are ambitious, cunning and manipulative as well as not above using their seductiveness and sexuality to achieve their ends, perfect for the role of antagonistic Endless sibling Desire. As The Fades' angelic Sarah she has experience of playing a powerful supernatural being and has also worked on a Gaiman adaptation after featuring as Door opposite James McAvoy and Benedict Cumberbatch in the radio version of Neverwhere. The prettily feminine Dormer might not instantly seem a fit for Desire's other defining characteristic, his/her androgynous gender switching, but her role as The Hunger Games' Cressida not only looks like giving her the step up from TV star to movie star but also showcases her half shaved head, half long tresses appearance that definitely suggests an ability to flip between androgyny and femininity. On top of that, Dormer is an actress who can quite confidently play both Irene Adler and Moriarty, so this gender flip shouldn't be beyond her at all. Other options: I've deliberately not opted for any of the actors on my shortlist for Dream to appear in any other roles on this list, but many of them would be equally good Desires. The majority of my Dream selections have some background in playing gender flipped or transgender roles on film or other media, including: Tilda Swinton (many people's favourite for the part), Cate Blanchett, Lee Pace, Cillian Murphy, James Franco and Johnny Depp.

8. Delirium - Dakota Fanning

Once the happy-go-lucky Delight, turned to Delirium by the stresses and strains of the adult world, the character of Delirium won't become a major player in the story until Brief Lives (a decent story possibility for Sandman 2, assuming the first movie is a success), but that doesn't mean it's not worth casting the random, non-sequitur spouting girl at this stage. Dakota Fanning is an actress at a crossroads between the child roles that made her name, like I Am Sam and Charlotte's Web, and more provocative adult parts like The Runaways. This makes her an ideal choice for the mixed up Delirium, trying to associate with the more adult Endless, while they view her as more of a child to be protected or ignored as a distraction. The audience association of Fanning as a former child star and her still childlike appearance would go some way to suggest this. Her years of child roles means Fanning has more big movie experience than most 20 year olds and has already demonstrated sufficient range to play a character this innocent yet damaged. She also has some previous experience at translating Gaiman's work to the big screen, voicing the eponymous lead role in Coraline, comfortably the best Gaiman adaptation there has been. Other options: Another actress that, like Dormer, has worked with Thorne on British TV before going on to appear in Game of Thrones is Hannah Murray (Skins' Cassie), an actress with a distant, waif-like fragility and disconnect from her surroundings in previous roles that she could bring to the part of Delirium if JGL and co were looking for less of a big name. Summer Glau's unhinged River in Firefly, alternating randomness with lucidity, displayed many Delirium-esque qualities, making Glau a popular choice online.

7. Despair - Gabourey Sidibe

Overweight, grey, self-loathing, self-harming Despair is a role that will require any actor to work under a lot of make up or prosthetics or performance capture. Therefore there is no real need to find an actor that is a good physical match, especially given the scarcity of larger actresses in Hollywood, and more need for someone who can display the right level of pain through all that, someone with expressive eyes essentially. Gabourey Sidibe has demonstrated her ability with dark fantasy material on the Coven series of American Horror Story. It is her breakthrough role in Precious, though, that shows the qualities needed to be the perfect Despair. As Precious, Sidibe showed a capacity for conveying a mix of angry self loathing and yet continuing defiance, while playing a repressed, troubled and overweight young woman. These are all elements that she could definitely return to in the part of Despair, even if they have not always been so much a part of her performances since. Other options: Given casting speculation has focused on finding an overweight woman who is a talented actor and relatively big name, Sidibe's American Horror Story co-star Kathy Bates is a name that comes up a lot. However, she doesn't quite have the right feel of bleak depression necessary. Some more interesting online speculation has suggested anyone from Judi Dench to Catherine Tate, who are definitely unusual choices but both could completely immerse themselves in the role.

6. Destiny - Hugo Weaving

You may have noticed on the previous list for Dream casting I went for a number of elf and fairy monarchs to bring the appropriate mix of ethereal detachment and gravitas and once again that model holds true for the eldest Endless. Destiny is possibly the least interesting, complex character of the seven with little for an actor really to sink his teeth into. This is because he is less of a character than a presence, not engaging in the squabbles of his siblings, always keeping calm, his face covered by a hood, reading from the book of all past and future events that is chained to his wrist. The actor who plays Destiny, then, will need to have an imposing physical stature, but not mind about keeping their face covered and must have a rich, resonant voice as this is where most of his performance will come from. Hugo Weaving has plenty of experience using his talents as Shakespearean stage actor in large scale fantasy or comic book blockbusters, so would easily step into the role of Destiny. The Lord of the Rings' Elrond saw him assume a position of calm authority with a hint of a dark edge, while in V for Vendetta his performance was all through voice and physique with his face never seen. Other options: Destiny is never going to be more than a cameo, but that may suit some of the usual selection of experienced actors with good voices who want a quick easy payday before devoting themselves to stage work or similar. Fellow Middle Earther Ian McKellan would do and a younger Christopher Lee would have been ideal but is maybe too old to do more than provide the voice as he did with Discworld's Death. Goyer and Gordon-Levitt worked with Morgan Freeman on Batman, so he's a possibility.

5. Destruction - Idris Elba

Destruction is the absentee Endless, the one that quit his role to walk the earth. As a result he is unlikely to feature particularly in the first Sandman movie, but the promise of a much expanded part in a Brief Lives sequel should be enough to secure the services of an acting talent like Idris Elba. Elba has appeared in Pacific Rim, Prometheus and Thor as he has attempted to move from critically acclaimed TV actor to movie star, but none of those roles have made quite enough impact to establish him on the big screen. Constantly rumoured for and a fan favourite for almost any fantasy casting session at the moment, Sandman's Destruction could be the memorable movie part that Elba has been looking for. On TV shows like The Wire and Luther, Elba has demonstrated a physicality that is crucial to the part, along with the necessary ability to be calm and laidback, but like a coiled spring that could deliver incredibly destructive violence if overly provoked. His role in Thor has never been significant, but shows he is quite capable at embodying a mythical comic book warrior figure. Other options: Another of Warner Brothers and David Goyer's former Batman stars to be linked with the project is Aaron Eckhart, who could easily bring a light world weary charm and capacity for violence to the part. Sean Bean has also been mentioned.

4. Rose Walker - Ellen Page

That's the Endless covered, but what about the more earth-bound elements of a potential Sandman cast? Presuming that the film will draw heavily on The Doll's House, the second arc collected in a trade paperback volume and the first longer story with beginning, middle and end, then Dream might not even be the protagonist in his own movie. That honour would fall on The Doll's House's lead Rose Walker. Rose's story ties in with the imprisonment and release of Dream that kicks off the whole Sandman saga, but her arc, a normal seeming girl discovers she has links to a magical world of mythical beings, is more conventional and would provide a good way in to the Endless' world. Dream himself is a hard character to get to know, a film using Rose as an audience surrogate would perhaps be an easier way of giving exposition about him. Her story would also be easy to tell in one standalone film, leaving a satisfying whole if there are no sequels, while if there were further installments Dream could become the sole protagonist. Ellen Page has been put forward before as a possible Death, but her screen persona, likeable but a little cool and detached, lacks the warmth that someone like Kendrick could bring to that part, but is perfect for Rose. Rose is a character who has the kind of perpetually youthful looks and vaguely teenage attitudes even in a woman in her 20s that is perfect for the Page of Juno and Whip It, while her increasingly significant role in X-Men shows she is able to take the lead in a comic book fantasy. Other options: Aubrey Plaza impressed with her first movie leading role in Safety Not Guaranteed after a part in Scott Pilgrim. She shares Page's indie style and a sense of a 20 something woman trying to establish herself as an adult not a perpetual teen.

3. The Corinthian - Paul Bettany

One more reason to make The Doll's House the basis of the first Sandman movie is that it has the most memorable one-off villain of the series: shark smiled psychopath The Corinthian, whose white toothy grin is the same as the ones in the eye sockets behind his dark glasses. The rogue, uncontrollable nightmare is a genuinely scary threat who needs an actor who can look smooth, charming and totally sinister. Paul Bettany is an actor who does not seem to get the kind of parts or films that his obvious talent deserves. The likes of Legion and Priest show Bettany's ability to impress even in low quality dark fantasy actioners, think of how he might do with a more interesting part in a more interesting movie. Bettany is committed to the Marvel Cinematic Universe, but as his role as Tony Stark's computer J.A.R.V.I.S. is a voice part, meaning that he will have more time to work on other projects than his fellow Marvel stars. Bettany is an affable and charming star, but by far his most commercially successful film, The Da Vinci Code, saw him as an unstoppable psycho killer. If any doubt remains about Bettany's suitability for the role of The Corinthian, people just need to remember his breakthrough role as a sharp suited murderous gangster and young Malcolm McDowell in Gangster No. 1. Other options: Timothy Oliphant has never had the same quality of role on film as he has on TV, but has the perfect look for the character and can be completely convincing as a psycho who enjoys tormenting people. Gary Oldman has long been a popular choice, hence this gif, but is perhaps getting too old for the part.

2. Lucien - Bill Nighy

Dream is surrounded by a team of strange supporting characters and, while we're interested to see the movie's take on ever murdering Cain and Abel, jaded janitor Merv Pumpkinhead, and Matthew the raven, it is the librarian of the Dreaming, custodian of all the books that never were, that is probably the most significant character to see Dream interact with at home. Lucien has a typical librarian-ish appearance, skinny, wiry, dressed in glasses and a bow tie and his hair always in a mess. It is hard not to picture Bill Nighy like that. Wise, loyal, a little bit sardonic, but always essentially likeable and trustworthy, Nighy brings a lot of classic qualities from many previous roles that would be ideal for Lucien. With anything from Pirates of the Caribbean to Underworld demonstrating Nighy's ability to work in large scale fantasies with huge amounts of CGI and performance capture elements, he should be at home amongst the largely artificial world that is likely to make up the Dreaming. Other options: Hugh Laurie might work well as the long limbed librarian now that he is back doing bigger film work. Anthony Head, the classic TV mystical librarian, might be a little too obvious. Given the part is slightly Dream's Alfred, Michael Caine has worked with the production team before in a similar part.

1. Lucifer - Michael Sheen

Over the years Gaiman worked with a huge number of artists on Sandman, but none more significant than long term collaborator Dave McKean. McKean is also a film director and, although it might be optimistic to hope he will be in the director's chair for the Sandman film, he is likely to have some input like his work as a concept artist on the Harry Potter series. One of McKean's previous movie projects was the film of Michael Sheen's Port Talbot passion play. Could this help Sheen get a part in Sandman? Having already played a McKean Jesus, it might make symmetrical sense to see Sheen go the other way and play Sandman's Lucifer. He has already a vampire aristocrat in Twilight, this is not too far of a stretch beyond that. Gaiman has previously remarked in no uncertain terms that his Lucifer was entirely drawn from David Bowie. With the Thin White Duke himself unlikely to be available, Sheen should have the quality to bring a Bowie-esque performance. After all his Castor in Tron: Legacy was nothing but Ziggy Stardust in a CGI fantasy world. Other options: Once again, many of the actors earlier suggested for the role of Dream are also popular online choices for the fallen angel, including Tom Hiddleston, Cillian Murphy and, because her name comes up whenever Bowie is mentioned, Tilda Swinton. But what do you think? Let us know in the comments who you want to see in a Sandman movie now it seems like it is really going to happen.

In this post: 
Sandman
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Loves ghost stories, mysteries and giant ape movies