Sean Penn: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Aloha, Mr Method...

Despite being a man renowned for tough, intense performances sprinkled with hair-tingling humility, it's worth remembering that Sean Justin Penn's Tinseltown calling card was a brief role in TV Western, Little House On The Prairie. Track forward four decades and he's part of the Hollywood elite, a champion of great causes, with two Oscars to his name and an award-winning director in his own right. Suffice to say, he more than deserves to be recognised as one of the best actors of his generation. Like any other thesps of Penn€™s calibre, there are roles that will garner the plaudits and groans in equal measure. While he may have avoided some of the career-denting duds that a number of his co stars on this list have put us through €“ De Niro. Fearless Leader. The horror €“ there are a few blots on his filmography that are deserved of mention. With the The Gunman due today, a film that sees Penn flex his muscles as well as his acting skills in his first action role, this feature aims to celebrate the great performances that he will be remembered for, along with those that fell short of the mark and, well, sucked.


5 Awesome Performances...

5. Jeff Spicoli - Fast Times At Ridgemont High

In only his second feature film Penn turned in what turned out to be his funniest and most memorable role to date. Rocking up in what was essentially a sideplot in Amy Heckerling's bawdy high school movie, Jeff Spicoli was an enigma; a perpetually-stoned surf junkie with an attitude so laid back he could be spirited away by the lightest of Hawaiian breezes. Remembered best for his classroom sparring sessions with teacher Mr Hand, Penn's interpretation of this freewheeling character showed some strong comic chops, uttering zinger after zinger - 'Make up your mind, dude, is he gonna s**t or is he gonna kill us?' - as he wings his way through numerous mishaps with a carefree stomp. He may have gone on to become an acting heavyweight in his own right, but in Jeff Spicoli there was still some serious method behind the freewheeling debauchery.

4. Emmet Ray - Sweet And Lowdown

As was his trait in the seventies, director Woody Allen€™s intention was to pull off his familiar one man show and helm Sweet And Lowdown with himself in the leading role. Thankfully, though, the bespectacled auteur busied himself on other features, before revisiting the project again in the nineties. Not having much luck when looking to cast his lead for this long-standing project - Johnny Depp was too busy to star - Allen ignored the advice of those around him and settled on Sean Penn to star as fictional thirties icon Emmet Ray, the second best guitar player in the world. The decision paid off. In this riveting period piece Penn had a merry riot, showing Ray to be every bit the philandering piss artist that Allen envisaged him to be. Grandstanding moments include Ray passing out on stage and a guitar-smashing finale, but it€™s the quieter moments between Ray and mute laundress Hattie (Samantha Morton showing power in silence) that lend the film its heart. Deservedly, Penn's efforts in this feature would see him receive his second career Oscar nomination. More on the first later.

3. Harvey Milk - Milk

When it was announced that Gus Van Sant was stepping out of the indie realm again to direct a biopic of renowned politician and gay rights activist, Harvey Milk, skeptics would have been right to reach for their copy of 1984's Oscar-winning documentary, The Life And Times Of Harvey Milk, and shrugged this one off as being something of a political chancer. Using this doc as one of his primary sources, Penn embodied the character and spirit of the self-styled Mayor Of Castro Street, playing the man with camp and savvy style. Aided by Van Sant's eye-catching period direction, character play - Penn's best moments include scenes where he agitates Josh Brolin's straight-laced fellow politician, Dan White, the man who would soon be his assassin - his interpretation of Milk garnered yet more plaudits and, of course, his second Academy Award. As it stands, this remains the last great Penn performance.

2. Jimmy Markum - Mystic River

In this hard-hitting offering from a career-besting Clint Eastwood, Penn managed to pull off an absolute head turner with this portrayal of a Boston father dealing with the brutal murder of his daughter. Tracing the blood and grit coursing through Dennis LeHane's source material novel, Penn's Jimmy Markum is a wounded shark, prowling around his old neighbourhood stomping grounds looking for answers. The real skill here was Penn€™s ability to bring the murk from Markum's past bubbling right to the surface, as the character's desire for hood retribution leads him to make an agonisingly off the mark decision. This culminates in the film's standout scene between Markum and his old pal Dave, played by an equally mesmerising Tim Robbins. Receiving numerous plaudits across the board for his part in this superb drama, Penn's efforts were capped at the 76th Academy Awards when he rightly took home Best Actor.

1. Matthew Poncelet - Dead Man Walking

This is the performance that will forever define Sean Penn, the one that captured every bit of his skill as an actor and displayed the range of which he is now renowned for flexing even in his lesser roles - more on those after the jump. Cast by director Tim Robbins to star alongside Susan Sarandon in his 1996 movie debate on the death penalty, Penn plays condemned Matthew Poncelot. Poncelot is the epitome of twenty something backwater rage; tattooed up with a pompadour hairdo, he skilfully controls his conversations with Sarandon's Sister Helen Prejean by never truly admitting or taking responsibility for his crime. That is until the film's closing moments, where Penn unleashes some of the most powerful acting seen in the nineties during the now classic reconciliation scene. Penn would go on to receive various award nominations for a role that essentially put him on the map. Although he would miss out on the Oscar for playing Poncelot €“ that went to Nicholas Cage for Leaving Las Vegas €“ this remains a performance that cannot be defined by silverware - it€™s simply timeless.

And 5 That Sucked...

5. Tobin Keller - The Interpreter

It's hard to pinpoint exactly why this is a Penn performance to bemoan. To make things easier, track back to when The Interpreter was released and it all becomes a little clearer. Around the time Penn got suited and booted for director Sydney Pollack€™s swansong feature, he'd strung together a hat trick of exemplary performance - Mystic River, 21 Grams and The Assassination Of Richard Nixon €“ and was on something of a hot streak. So when viewers were faced with the prospect of a talky Penn-starring thriller, where he plays secret service agent Tobin Keller, a man tasked with protecting Nicole Kidman from a Mugabe-esque dictator, expectations fizzled around around the same time the chemistry did between the film€™s two leads. There are plus points to take from this one, namely an okay shootout, but for the most part Penn underwhelms in a movie that he, let€™s face it, called one in on.

4. Jim - We're No Angels

After impressing with the likes of gothic romp, The Company Of Wolves, and gritty Brit classic Mona Lisa, helmer Neil Jordan padded over to Hollywood only to kick up a stink with the Razzie-baiting High Spirits. In need of a hit, Jordan looked towards the comic pairing of Robert De Niro and a young Sean Penn to score him a Tinseltown hit. Suffice to say, his effort, We're No Angels, did not get kind blessings from critics and audiences alike. At the time of starring, Penn was already hot property thanks to roles in Fast Times At Ridgemont High, At Close Range and Colors, so it was reasonable to assume this mix of comedic and hard-edged thesping skills would shine through in Jordan's surprisingly violent yarn. This wasn't the case and instead we got to see Penn committing not just the filmic crime of being sprung from county and going on the run, but crucial misdemeanors including dull mugging, playing sidekick to a lacklustre Bobby De Niro and singing badly in choir. One to forget.

3. Cheyenne - This Must Be The Place

There may well be a fair few people that when arriving at this entry on the list will do a double take, checking whether this is the 'awesome' part of the feature. But make no mistake, behind all the make up this one ain€™t pretty to watch. Cheyenne is and probably always will be Penn's most divisive performance, the one that some think is genius and other just plain annoying. Working with the latter, it's hard to engage in any way with this character, partly due to various contrivances - a rich Robert Smith-esque gothstar aims to spiritually reconnect with his late father... by pursuing his Aushwitz SS tormentor. Okay, the last bit was somewhat original - and the fact that Penn seems bent on playing the part in a deadpan, monosyllabic way. As the movie meanders and rattles past some familiar indie pit stops even the most ardent Penn fan will find themselves to be bored, agitated and seeking solace in the decent David Byrne score.

2. Glendon Wasey - Shanghai Surprise

Hollywood is famed for rolling out misfiring husband and wife cinematic outings; but if you think Tom and Nicole were bad in Far And Away, Liz and Dick were unbelievable in Cleopatra or even Sly and Brigitte a tad OTT in Cobra, these pompous pair ups are nothing compared to Madonna and Penn in Shanghai Surprise. Addressing the 1,000lb opium haul in the room, Penn's performance as chancer Glendon Wasey in this wartime crime caper is bad. He may not have taken home the Razzie like Madge did, but his uneven performance - part Indiana Jones, the other frat boy - fits pretty snugly into a film that, like its two leads, may be pretty to look at, sure as heckfire isn't a whole lot of fun to watch. Having starred in what can astutely be described as the Howard The Duck of the adventure comedy movie, Penn thankfully managed to dust himself off from this one and go on to forge a career in Hollywood.

1. Sam Dawson - I Am Sam

In director Jessie Nelson's soppy family drama Penn plays a father with developmental issues. While intentions are good I Am Sam is a hackneyed tale- despite affliction, father can care for his child, however, social services think otherwise - in which Penn pushes hard and heavy on the saccharine in order to jangle viewers' heartstrings. For every lukewarm moment shared between Sam and his buddies, or interactions with his daughter, there is a moment of high drama that calls for some cringe-worthy acting (why isn't Lucy going home with me?') and tortured posturing. This, and the fact a certain Kirk Lazurus dispelled Hollywood€™s reliance on mental health issues for story fodder with that killer line, is the main problem when viewing Penn€™s overwrought and massively ill-judged performance on a rewatch. Despite getting a critical pounding, I Am Sam was sort of adored at the time of its 2001 release, enough to see Penn graced with an Oscar nomination for his performance, in what remains one of the Academy's oddest decisions to date. Unforgettable for a lot of wrong reasons. Has Penn been given a fair appraisal? Or are there some classic and not-so-classic performances we've missed? Please feel free to comment below.

Contributor
Contributor

Shaun is a former contributor for a number of Future Publishing titles and more recently worked as a staffer at Imagine Publishing. He can now be found banking in the daytime and writing a variety of articles for What Culture, namely around his favourite topics of film, retro gaming, music, TV and, when he's feeling clever, literature.