Simon Pegg: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked
5 Awesome Performances...
5. Montgomery Scott Star Trek: Into Darkness
Pegg effectively hit geek Shangri-La when he was offered the role of Montgomery Scotty Scott in J.J Abrams reboot of the Star Trek franchise. A dedicated Trekkie, he was no doubt utterly thrilled with the prospect of taking on one of the most famous Scots in geek culture. Yet for my money, the first Star Treks Scotty didnt thrill me like I thought it would. Yet quixotically, Abrams solved this with a counter-intuitive solution he gave us more Scotty, but in a different way. I believe Peggs performance in the sequel was made better by the more serious tone which dominates Into Darkness. Of course, you can have light-hearted moments in a Star Trek film, but when that film gets dominated by a broody Benedict Cumberbatch and a plot about shady war-dealing, comedy goes by the wayside. Its a decision that worked well for Pegg, who either spends his scenes pissed off, in mortal peril or in the company of Cumberbatchs John Harrison. The constantly furrowed brow and sense of grim fury he brings to the role meshes perfectly with this darker narrative and allows the Gloucestershire-born actor to knock it out the park in a rare big-screen non-comedy role. He gets to be conflicted, and even resigns in the first act on moral grounds, and this conflict with Chris Pines Kirk is brought to life well by Pegg, who makes a good job of showing Scotty wrestling with inner demons before coming back for some awesome moments later on it the film, which the actor rocks in once more.
4. Sidney Young How To Lose Friends And Alienate People
Some people thought this film was a bit lightweight and throwaway, but Im not among them. In my opinion, Peggs role as luckless protagonist Sidney Young a representation of author Toby Young hit the sweet spot of Pegg-related roles, that of endearing ridiculousness. Perhaps it helps that Im a writer myself, but watching Pegg affect Sidneys misplaced too-clever-for-the-room hauteur was something I find gut-bustingly funny. The masterstroke in this performance was that Pegg managed to find the correct balance between making Sidney a pompous ass without making him seem unlikeable. Though at times he was just absurdly pretensious, he was also able to give off the is-it-just-me impression that a Brit abroad especially one as crass as Sidney must get when confronted with the airbrushed, glamorous world of American celebrity, and this was helped enormously by Peggs persona as just a normal bloke. Through a combination of mannerisms, demeanour and just plain old-fashioned acting, he actually made me care for what couldve been throwaway material, ably convincing later on as a renegade writer who abandons his up-yours attitude for success yet still doesnt feel comfortable at the top table. It must be noted how big and accomplishment this is if Pegg didnt convince, this whole film wouldve been one colossal misfire. To his credit, it isnt.
3. Graeme Willy Paul
2. Sgt. Nicholas Angel Hot Fuzz
Its odd to watch Pegg take on the straight-man role after his many years dedicated to clowning around on British TV, but Nicholas Angel isnt exactly your typical straight man, and the actor sells quirk this with aplomb. For my money, its a great performance hidden by the fact this is a comedy film Peggs Angel is an action movie cliché trapped in a humourless body, and the actor puts this across perfectly. Pegg knows hes not the real star of the show here that honour falls to Nick Frosts constable Buttterman and he acts as a perfect comic foil the tubby buffoon, his caricature-esque seriousness blending well with Frosts earnest idiocy. Yet despite this potential overshadowing, he manages to put in a great shift, even under the burden of playing such a buttoned-down character. Of course, you all know that this is only half the story in Hot Fuzz the other half is one of glorious, wanton violence, all tremendously shot and choreographed and invoking the finest clichés and vignettes of action film history. Though hed cut his run-and-gun teeth in Mission Impossible III, he hadnt been called upon to pull off just this much Hard Boiled-esque tomfoolery before, and to his credit, Pegg ticks all the boxes and ticks them well. Its a glorious performance from start to finish, utterly vital to the film we wouldnt know how ridiculous Sandford was if we didnt have Angels bemused/incredulous reactions to guide us and Pegg well and truly hits the heights.
1. Shaun Riley Shaun of the Dead
Well, it had to be on here, the film where Pegg puts on a masterclass in in-over-your-head earnestness. It helps that he looks like an average bloke, but thats totally the point and it just adds to the char of normality. Of course, theres also a little off-kilter sentiment to proceedings how could there not be but everything Shaun does is rooted in what you imagine you, or at least a late 20-something with an arrested development complex, would do. Its touching, sad, realistic and downright hilarious, whether hes bashing in zombie brains or quoting Bertrand Russell off the back of a beer mat. The killer detail is his facial expressions and mannerisms throughout witness when he sits down after beating a zombie in his garden and look at his face, and youll see perfectly normal what-the-hell-is-all-this bewilderment. Couple that with the almighty shock he gets awhen confronted with a one-armed zombie in his living room and we see Pegg just nails the everyman charm. Theres also a little weirdness apparent too (who goes to a pub to survive flesh-eating hordes?) but that just makes the whole thing even more endearing. After all, theres an odd charm to a man who sees a romantic hotspot and an impenetrable fortress as one in the same thing, but hes always kept in the realms of believably by the human cost of his quest. Really, I defy you to watch the scene where Shauns mother dies and not be slightly affected by Peggs performance. Click "next" below to see the performances that sucked...
5. Montgomery Scott Star Trek
Ive already touched on this within the article, but in my opinion, Peggs first crack at Scotty was a little underwhelming. Maybe its because he was sidelined in favour of the necessary world-building Abrams reboot movie had to make, maybe it was because they had to focus more intently on these incarnations of Kirk and Spock, but whatever it was, Scotty suffered in this film from being comic relief and little else. Of course, if youve got Pegg in your film, its stupid not to use him for some comedy, but to keep him resigned to wise-cracking on tap does him a disservice hes a talented actor whos capable of more, as the sequel showed. Yet in the original he was overshadowed by his own Scottish accent and his sidekick with a face like a cats back-end, and that wasnt right. Ah yes, the accent. Pegg can do good Scottish accents, so maybe when asked to play one of the most famous film Scots he embraced his inner comedian and hammed it up to compensate. Whatever it was, I think it was a poor choice that one tic overshadowed the rest of his performance, and we all seemed painfully aware that this wasnt Scotty, this was Simon Pegg in his Scotty Halloween outfit. Yes, he was probably having a ball, but it was a distracting ball.
4. Run Fatboy Run Dennis Doyle
Run Fatboy Run was the very definition of throwaway. It was an OK film, but absolutely nothing stood out about it and probably fittingly for a fillm featuring dieting there was very little to sink your teeth into. It was formulaic and predictable, a charge that can be levelled at both at the script and the actors. In the middle of this slice of vanilla film-making was Simon Pegg. You can see why hes there his appearance as an everyman compliments the underdog nature off this story extremely well. Yet I just couldnt figure out a reason to root for him, something that wasnt helped by his decision to run out on the adorable Thandie Newton at the films beginning. In my opinion, such an opening gambit was just too much for anyone to come back from, even for such a likeable screen presence as Pegg. Despite his nice nature, hes simply given too much to do within the films run-time, and running the London Marathon doesnt somehow give him a good enough redemptive arc to atone for his wedding-bolting act. So while he tries manfully to make the film more than the sum of its parts, Pegg unfortunately became part of the problem, creating a headache which the whole thing never quite recovered from.
3. Jack A Fantastic Fear Of Everything
This just seems like it was an impossibly bad idea in a way only a film featuring stereotypical accented Vietnamese women and outrageously flamboyant homosexuals can be. Intentionally low-budget, A Fantastic Fear of Everything featured Pegg as Jack, a childrens author turned crime novelist who becomes totally obsessed with serial killers until he's scared to do anything. As befitting the role, Pegg invests in several neuroses and becomes pretty much afraid of everything. However, the role is just too one-note. The idea of somebody being afraid of something in just about every situation he encounters (seriously, whos scare of launderettes?) can become grating rather quickly, and youre overloaded with too much slapstick from the word go. Couple this with an extremely fraught persona and a hodgepodge of a plot and youve got something of a disaster on your hands. Basically, Peggs on a hiding to nothing in this role the character is unsympathetic, he doesnt get any good lines and any chance he had of shining as a pratfaller is taken out back and shot within the opener. Its a simple case of overkill watching a character be neurotic can be funny if its part of a unified whole, yet with Jack it appears as if thats all there is to him, and this results in something painful to watch.
2. Gus Big Nothing
Really, I think that Simon Pegg should always have a British accent. It should be an immutable rule, like gravity. His best roles involve him either evoking a Scottish accent or using a variation upon his own, and it seems to be a formula that works well for him. Hes effectively taken on the mantle of the stereotypical British clown, and thats not a bad thing as his collaborations with Edgar Wright show, theres plenty of mileage and interpretation in such a role. However, Pegg is an actor and its an actors prerogative to experiment with new roles and personas. Normally I would applaud this, but when you end up with something as incongruous and strange as Big Nothing, all I can do is cock a sceptic eyebrow. In the film, Pegg plays Gus, an American scam artist with a dark streak. Its an interesting idea, but to my mind he never quite convinces in his new role, and the accent doesnt help matters. Hes buffoonish and over-the-top yet lacks the ability to truly sell the scene because he doesnt quite convince as an American. Its a strange one because it almost works his comedic timing is just as fine as ever and hes his usual spectacular self with physical comedy. But this nasty, against-type character just simply doesnt come across well for me. It doesnt help that hes somewhat overshadowed by the earnest performance of David Schwimmer either.
1. William Burke Burke and Hare
Burke and Hare was just a colossal disappointment from start to finish, and thats a shame. I would have dearly loved it if John Landis returned to form for this effort, and he appeared to have all the parts he needed. There was a credible story the story of two Edinburgh body-snatchers who committed one of the most notorious murder sprees in the 19th century and credible actors in Pegg, Andy Serkis and Isla Fisher. Theres even cameos from Paul Whitehouse and Tim Curry, for god's sake. Yet despite all this, the finished product was ust terrible and unfunny. It doesnt help that Peggs role is schizophrenic at best. As I mentioned in the earlier appraisal of Run Fatboy Run, the actors likeability means you cant really stick him in a villainous role, and this can causes problems when his characters perform dickish actions; Much like David Schwimmers debut, Burke and Hare falls into this trap, and in a massive way. The problem is that its very difficult to make a mass-murderer likeable, and no amount of slapstick was going to change the creeping unease surrounding this spectacle. Put Pegg in the right role and he can knock It out the park, but in this, he wasnt even in the park the set-up of the film is conspiring against him, and when the screenplay itself is this bad then theres really nothing he can do. Agree or disagree? Can you think of any else? Feel free to comment!

