Sonic The Hedgehog 2 Review: 6 Ups & 4 Downs
Sonic returns for a bigger, more bloated sequel that should please most fans.
It can't be understated quite what a surprise success story 2020's Sonic the Hedgehog film was.
Arriving in cinemas following a lengthy delay while Paramount fixed the title character's horrifying original design, audiences were still largely expecting another forgettable video game adaptation.
But Sonic was ultimately a fair box office success and even scored a scarcely-Fresh rating from critics, too, ranking it among the few video game movies that wasn't either a critical or commercial dud.
And barely two years later Sonic the Hedgehog 2 is here, releasing amid a considerably higher set of expectations as director Jeff Fowler seeks to introduce a bevy of fan-serving elements - namely iconic franchise characters Tails and Knuckles.
Sonic 2 is a bit of a strange beast all things considered - in many ways a better film than the first, especially where the aforementioned fan service is concerned, but also bloated to its detriment and lacking the breezy, mile-a-second appeal of its predecessor.
It should satisfy most who enjoyed the original, even if you might be left hoping for a more disciplined, less-indulgent third film. And so with that in mind, here's what Sonic 2 doesn't quite get right...
Downs...
4. The Excessive Two-Hour Runtime
The first Sonic film clocked in at a spry 99 minutes, and to that end felt like a pacy sprint to the finish - there wasn't an ounce of fat on it as it leapt from one ridiculous scene to the next.
But in the vein of so many sequels to successful films, Sonic 2's attempts to up the ante result in a wildly over-indulgent follow-up that feels as exhausting as it is entertaining at times.
There's no way that any Sonic movie needs to be 122 minutes long.
The key issue is that there's just so much crammed into this film, from the new characters to the balletic action sequences, overabundance of human characters - which we'll expand upon shortly - and also an overbaked attempt to expand the series' overall lore.
Sometimes less is more, but in this case it feels like Paramount saw how surprisingly well-received the original film was and basically let director Fowler do whatever he wanted.
3. The TERRIBLE Wedding Subplot
There's one standout culprit for the film's egregious runtime, and that's the head-smackingly overlong wedding subplot.
Early in the film, Tom (James Marsden) and his wife Maddie (Tika Sumpter) are whisked away to Hawaii for the wedding of Maddie's sister Rachel (Natasha Rothwell).
We cut briefly back to Tom and Maddie several times throughout the film, culminating in an absurdly unnecessary mid-film sequence where the wedding descends into sheer chaos.
For the better part of 15 minutes (seriously), we're left to watch this subplot play out all while Sonic (Ben Schwartz), Tails (Colleen O'Shaughnessey), and Knuckles (Idris Elba) are mostly kept off-screen.
It's a real head-scratcher of a decision, and this is the material that most blatantly should've been trimmed down. This is cutting room floor fodder if it ever existed, and ditching most of it would've helped the film maintain a greater sense of momentum.
That's no disrespect to any of the cast involved, who all do fine with what they have, but this isn't why anyone came to see a Sonic movie, despite what studio executives might apparently think.
2. The Plot Is A Total Bore
Look, nobody's expecting miracles from the plot of a Sonic movie - based on a video game with a scarcely memorable story itself - but this is shockingly low-effort stuff regardless.
If the first film more-or-less survived on the strength of its road movie dynamic and Robotnik's (Jim Carrey) repeated attempts to wreck Sonic, the sequel ups the scale of the story but not the nuance.
This is basically a garden variety fetch quest as Sonic and Tails attempt to track down the all-powerful Master Emerald before Robotnik does, hopping from one location to the next in pursuit of it, as provides an excuse for various set-pieces.
It's threadbare stuff, and sadly the earnest attempt the movie makes to invest viewers in its lore - namely an ancient feud between the Owls and the Echidnas - isn't much more interesting.
While the first film was smart to barely linger on its narrative at all, there's way more dwelling on it here and not for the better.
1. It's Not As Funny As The Original
One of the big highlights of the first film was its shamelessly goofy humour, both in terms of Jim Carrey's relentlessly funny mugging as Robotnik and the genuinely hilarious banter between Sonic and Tom.
Sadly the script's gags are considerably more hit-and-miss this time around. The decision to basically fashion Knuckles as this series' answer to the Guardians of the Galaxy's Drax - a sandpaper-dry, sarcasm-averse brute - is smart, though there's ultimately only so much that can be done with it.
Robotnik's one-liners and physical gags don't feel quite so fresh this time around, and the script relies far more heavily on pop-culture references than its predecessor. This, does, however result in a gut-bustingly funny line about the feud between Vin Diesel and The Rock.
All in all, though, the humour lacks the quirky inspiration of its predecessor. But now, accepting these issues, here's why Sonic 2 is absolutely worth watching...
Ups...
6. The Fantastic Sonic/Tails Dynamic
The first film's mid-credits scene delivered extremely crowd-pleasing sequel-bait with the reveal of Tails, and for its flaws Sonic 2 absolutely delivers on the promise of bringing the beloved sidekick into the fold.
Tails' dynamic with Sonic is a sheer joy throughout: initially a Sonic fanboy who becomes his equal over the course of the story, their fast-growing friendship should prove heart-warming to both fans of the games and newbies alike.
Much of this is the result of a fantastic vocal performance from Tails actress Colleen O'Shaughnessey, who has been voicing the character for the better part of a decade across both video games and animation.
In many ways Tails is the heart and soul of the film, as seeing Sonic expand out his unconventional "family" with his new pal in tow is really quite sweet.
5. Knuckles Steals The Show
Yet arguably the greatest addition to Sonic 2 is Knuckles the Echidna, voiced with gruff glee by the great Idris Elba.
Elba, who splits the difference between an American accent and his native Brit twang, brings both menace and aloof humour to the role of the red echidna warrior, translated so perfectly to the big screen here.
As much as his stoicism is mined for laughs, the film ensures not to make Knuckles a sheer laughing stock, either: he's a total ass-kicking brute, and we're never in doubt that Sonic's dealing with a mighty match.
Knuckles' arc throughout the film won't surprise anyone, but more crucially it captures his video game essence wonderfully.
4. There's TONS Of Fan Service
While the first film was a little restrained on the fan service front, perhaps for fear of alienating general audiences, it feels like the success of the original emboldened director Fowler to basically double down on the Easter eggs and wink-wink references this time.
Sonic 2 is absolutely jam-packed with nods to the video game series and beyond, such that the hardcore crowd are sure to have a blast pointing them all out.
Some Easter eggs are totally obvious, like Agent Stone (Elfina Luk) now working at a coffee shop called the Mean Bean, while others are a tad more subtle, like Sonic mentioning how much he hates water (as will surely be triggering for anyone who's played the games).
This is certainly one of those films that begs to be freeze-framed once it hits streaming, because it feels like just about every scene has some sort of a nod to aspects of the existing Sonic franchise.
3. Jim Carrey's Loony Performance (Again)
Jim Carrey's wacky, off-the-wall performance as Dr. Robotnik was one of the first film's easy highlights - with his rubber-faced mugging and unrestrained physical comedy, it felt like a throwback to the '90s Carrey we all know and love.
And while Sonic 2 sadly doesn't afford him material of quite the same caliber, Carey is still an absolutely electrifying presence any time he appears on screen.
With his comically OTT mustache and shaved head, Carrey naturally looks considerably more like the Robotnik of the video games than in the previous movie, and he clearly relishes the opportunity to disappear completely into the character.
Again, the script could be better, but nobody's going to accuse Carrey of just phoning it in.
2. The Epic Final Battle
There are some relatively decent action sequences leading up to the big finale, but that climactic battle against Robotnik and his gigantic, Death Egg-style mech is the movie's easy highlight set-piece.
It's clear that a sizable chunk of the film's budget was saved for this gonzo, high-wire showdown, which basically feels like one of the series' epic video game boss battles brought to cinematic life.
It's certainly a fitting scale-up from the more modest final battle between Sonic and Robotnik at the end of the first film, making the most of the extra $20 million-or-so that Paramount gave Fowler for the sequel, while also invoking some crowd-pleasing elements from the games.
1. The AWESOME Mid-Credits Scene
No spoilers here, but Sonic 2's mid-credits scene is a real doozy alright.
Just as the first film dropped that glorious Tails tease, the sequel briefly nods towards the direction for the third film, introducing a certain fan favourite... thing... that's going to immediately get fans hype for Sonic 3.
No matter what you make of Sonic 2, the mid-credits tease is a fist-pumping moment for sure - it is a classic case of giving the fans exactly what they want.
And no, there isn't a post-credits scene to wait for afterwards, so you're free to bail once this jaw-dropping reveal is over.