Sonic The Hedgehog Review: 6 Ups & 4 Downs
A video game movie miracle.
It's taken almost three decades for Sonic the Hedgehog to finally make his way to the big screen, and despite the obvious entertainment potential of a Sonic movie, you'd be sensible to approach the film with middling expectations at best.
After all, in addition to being a video game movie of all things, Sonic the Hedgehog suffered through the embarrassment of audiences rejecting the hideous original design for its protagonist en masse, resulting in the film being delayed as VFX artists scrambled to offer up a more source-accurate redesign.
Between this, a set of fairly ho-hum trailers, and the fact that reviews were held until close before release, there weren't many reasons to be hopeful that Sonic would be a fun, family-friendly romp, let alone break the famous "video game curse."
And while gamers are still left waiting for the first great video game movie, Sonic the Hedgehog is nevertheless a surprisingly sturdy and enjoyable film, leaning into its silliness and ensuring that, despite its many flaws, it's a far cry from the depressing dud many were expecting.
Between this and Bad Boys for Life both turning out surprisingly solid, 2020 is off to a bizarrely pleasant start indeed...
Downs...
4. The Embarrassing Product Placement
By far the worst thing about this movie is its absolutely shameless and cringe-worthy approach to product placement.
Despite the production having a relatively sensible $95 million budget, Paramount decided to stuff the film with excessive and embarrassingly obvious shilling for various name brands.
The worst offender by far is Olive Garden, which not only has its slogan name-dropped early in the movie, but literally has its menu praised by a character later in the film.
Though these placements are somewhat tongue-in-cheek, that doesn't really excuse the fact that they don't belong in the film at all.
Elsewhere, there are shockingly on-the-nose callouts for Puma, Fitbit, Optical Illusions, Zillow, and many, many more, giving the film an unfortunate whiff of commodity as much as entertainment.
3. Too Many Humans, Not Enough Sonic
This was always likely to be an issue in a live-action Sonic movie, and as expected, the film pays a little too much attention to its relatively forgettable human characters, sometimes at the expense of Sonic himself.
James Marsden is perfectly likeable in the role of human protagonist Tom Wachowski, though the film wastes at least a scene or two too many indulging in his personal melodrama, which results in Sonic occasionally spending more time off-screen than he probably should.
When you factor in that Tom has a wife (Tika Sumpter), and several scenes are also focused on his sister-in-law and her daughter, the balance feels a little uneven in favour of the humans, possibly in order to keep the movie's budget down.
2. The Totally Generic Plot
Adapting the Sonic the Hedgehog games into a live-action movie was always going to be extremely challenging from a narrative perspective, and so writers Pat Casey and Josh Miller have basically decided to de-emphasise the plot almost entirely while instead focusing on characters, jokes, and action.
The plot is, to be totally honest, complete nonsense, with the focal road trip bromance between Sonic and Tom set in motion after Sonic oh-so-conveniently drops his rings through a portal, causing them to land on top of a skyscraper in San Francisco. And so, a road trip ensues.
Dr. Robotnik is meanwhile drafted into the story totally out of nowhere by the U.S. government, and while there's virtually no nuance or intrigue to either of these main plots, at least the film doesn't bombard the viewer with heaps of over-written narrative and keeps it unpretentiously simple.
Even then, though, the story feels like first draft filler which probably could've been fleshed out a tad before shooting started, no?
1. The Hit-And-Miss Humour
Though Sonic is certainly a fun movie, its sense of humour is juvenile and scattershot enough that it doesn't always land.
For starters, a lot of the incessant pop-culture referencing is going to feel colossally dated a few years from now, and some of the occasional toilet humour just feels insanely low-effort, even for a freaking Sonic movie of all things.
Sure, this is a film aimed primary at children, but even so, the gag-rate is a little spotty at times, settling for the easy, obvious joke when it's clear that something far smarter and more inventive was definitely possible.
When Sonic shows up in a bathrobe and rips a fart, for instance, the kids are sure to love it, while the grown-ups will probably be left groaning.
Sonic the Hedgehog has plenty of issues, then, but they're ultimately outweighed by the unexpected array of positives. Here's everything it gets right...
Ups...
6. It's Surprisingly Faithful To The Source Material
Despite all the pre-release kerfuffle about Sonic's original design suggesting that this movie wasn't really interested in representing the character or his games in a faithful fashion, it's a pleasant surprise to report that the film is an unexpectedly reverent adaptation of the hit video games.
For starters, Sonic looks fantastic. Sure, the CGI could be better, but from a design perspective, he is totally recognisable as the same character fans know and love from the games, and the brief early glimpse of Green Hill Zone is brilliant enough to make fans wish more of the movie was set there.
Beyond pure aesthetics, though, the film understands the essence of Sonic as a character, while its overall goofball tone perfectly matches that of pre-existing Sonic media.
Then there are the literally dozens of Easter eggs sprinkled throughout the film, from references to other iconic Zones from Sonic games, to an unexpected nod to a certain popular Sonic meme.
But most importantly of all, fans will be relieved to know that Sonic does indeed eat some chilli dogs in the movie.
5. Jim Carrey Is Terrific As Dr. Robotnik
The casting of Jim Carrey as the iconic franchise antagonist Dr. Robotnik certainly raised some eyebrows, and the trailers made it tough to figure out whether or not Carrey was about to thoroughly embarrass himself.
But as it turns out, Carrey is one of the movie's easy highlights, giving a delightfully over-the-top, rubber-faced performance which is exactly what a live-action Robotnik should be.
It's a performance that very much feels like a throwback to the Carrey of the mid-90s, steeped in physical acting and exaggerated vocalisations, and so it just might endear the actor to a whole new generation of fans.
He's by far the most lively and energetic live-action element in the entire movie, and if Sonic is successful enough to get a sequel, there's evidently plenty of promise for Robotnik's inevitable return.
4. The Thrilling Action Sequences
Though you could argue that the movie spends slightly too long with Sonic strapped into a car in its second act, the action sequences are for the most part absolutely riveting, and certainly some of the most source-faithful of any video game movie to date.
Especially entertaining are an X-Men: Days of Future Past-style slow-motion fight in a bar, and the final battle between Sonic and Robotnik, which feels like a boss battle ripped straight from the video games and translated note-perfectly to the big screen.
While so many video game movies totally abandon the aesthetic of the source material in favour of more generic blockbuster thrills, Sonic maintains the essence of the game's visuals and mechanics while integrating them into the tentpole movie arena.
3. It's A Lot Weirder Than You're Expecting
If you were understandably expecting Sonic to be a pretty generic, down-the-line family film, another big surprise is that this is actually a much weirder effort than just about anyone anticipated.
Sure, it doesn't do anything too outrageous, but there are a number of bizarre sequences which really don't feel like they belong in a $90 million Sonic movie - in a good way, that is.
For example, there's an extended diversion where Sonic and Tom head to a bar and end up starting a bar fight, while elsewhere Robotnik has an extended dance sequence, there's a recurring nod to the "Sanic Hegehog" meme, and even a joke about the 2016 Presidential election that couldn't feel more weirdly placed.
But this weirdness helps Sonic feel like slightly more than just a cookie-cutter adventure film for kids: its eccentricity helps keep it just unpredictable enough to be continually interesting for even adults who aren't Sonic fans.
2. The AWESOME Credits Scenes
Make sure to stick around for a few minutes after the movie ends, because there are two credits scenes on offer, and they're both absolutely worth the wait.
The first, which occurs almost immediately after the end of the film, is a potent and amusing set-up for the sequel's possible setting, though the second, which comes mid-way through the credits, is an insanely crowd-pleasing reveal that's sure to have fans hyped for what will hopefully come next.
As much as credits scenes are so utterly routine, even mundane, these days, Sonic's second credits scene in particular offers up an extremely tantalising direction for the next film, should this one be a commercial success.
1. It's One Of The Best Video Game Movies Ever
As much as this can't avoid sounding like a back-handed compliment, Sonic the Hedgehog is absolutely one of the greatest video game movies of all time.
Granted, the bar is set incredibly low, but it's honestly tough to imagine many video game adaptations which actually nail their protagonist so successfully, nor capture the style and tone of the source material so effectively.
There are arguments to be made that the likes of Mortal Kombat, the original Resident Evil, Silent Hill, and Detective Pikachu are at the top of the pile, but Sonic really isn't far behind at all, and in some respects gets things right which these movies don't.
Better still, with everything being teased for the potential sequel, it's looking highly probable that Sonic 2 could end up being a solid improvement.