Spider-Man: Homecoming Review - 9 Ups & 3 Downs

Like Iron Man meets Archie...

Spider Man Homecoming Tom Holland
Marvel Studios

After Sam Raimi made two exceptional Spider-Man movies in 2002 and 2004, Spidey fans had been on a deeply upsetting slide down into mediocrity that began with the "too-many-cooks" disaster of Spider-Man 3 and ended with the comparative fatality of The Amazing Spider-Man 2. Sure, we all hoped there'd be a great Spider-Man movie again in the future, but few could have expected that it would come within the borders of the MCU after the astonishing tonic of Spidey's cameo in Captain America: Civil War.

But as soon as Marvel and Sony got to the table to sort out a rights-sharing deal, Homecoming's success was assured. Sony would be injected with Marvel's muscular story-telling experience, Spidey would be treated with the same dignity and joy as the MCU's other prime characters and fans would be invited to feel as well as to be entertained. And the final result delivers on almost every hallowed promise Kevin Feige must have mapped out in that meeting with Sony's head honchos.

It's not a flawless film, by any means, and it's hard to avoid the sadness at how heavy Sony went on marketing, but it will delight a lot of people - both Spider-Man fans and MCU die-hards - and it stands as a monument to the good sense behind Sony and Marvel getting together to make this deal possible.

So how good is it, and what could have been done better? First the negatives...


3. Robert Downey Jr Is Actually A Little Pointless

Spider-Man Homecoming Tony Stark Angry
Marvel Studios

Considering how big a presence Tony Stark seemed to have in the marketing, he's actually not in Homecoming all that much, and while he plays an important spiritual role in Peter's development - representing what he wants to become, he's not actually all that necessary.

In actual fact, the film could have functioned exactly the same without him in it at all. If anything, it might have actually been improved by approaching Stark the same way Harry Potter & The Order Of The Phoenix portrayed Dumbledore - removing him from the story entirely until the very end.

By arguably under-using Tony Stark, all Marvel have done is cost themselves a lot of money (or Sony, it's hard to keep track fully) and actually making him seem like the crutch cynics have accused him of being. There's nothing he does that can't be achieved with Happy Hogan in a slightly expanded role, and having Peter covet an Avengers position without direct interaction with Tony would be a better approach.


2. The Rag-Dolling

Spider Man Homecoming Web
Marvel Studios

For the most part, the effects in Homecoming are excellent, building on the strong swing mechanics of Civil War and impressively capturing fully rendered characters a lot throughout the film.

But when the effects aren't quite up to the highest standards, they look really, really poor. Think matrix sequels Agent Smith versus Neo fighting poor. There's way too much rag-dolling - particularly when Spidey is moving fast, and it threatens to really pull you out of the film (especially with the forced perspective of 3D).

The opening shots of Vulture in his suit in the prologue are also pretty poor too, and while it all does get better, there are way too many instances where the effects actually come off as incomplete.


1. Hey Sony, Why So F*cking Spoilery?!

Spider Man Homecoming Vulture
Marvel Studios

If you watched all of the trailers, TV spots and promotional material for Homecoming, 94% isn't just the Rotten Tomatoes score it inspired, it's also the proportion of the film you've already seen when you sit down to watch it. It's almost like the film struggles with that awful bad comedy film disease where all the good jokes are shown off to make you think the whole thing is like that. And ludicrously, Homecoming just doesn't need it.

As it is, there are a couple of magic moments in there still, and two very big gasp-worthy ones, but almost every action scene was needlessly spoiled in some way. It's not ruinous, but there's certainly too much that seems to have been spoiled for cheap marketing heat.

Did we even need Sony to go that hard on the marketing? It's not only an MCU movie but it's a Spider-Man one. That combination is already billion dollar worthy.

Spoiling that much about the film was just vulgar and it would have needlessly robbed a lot of scenes of some of their shine.

And now to the good stuff...


9. The Final Post-Credits Scene

Spider Man Homecoming Cap
Marvel Studios

By now you know to sit through the long credits for MCU films, in the hope that there's something there linking to the next film in the series, or just rewarding you the same way Guardians Of The Galaxy Vol 2 did with gags.

The first credits scene for Homecoming is great, and sets up a potential sequel appearance for Michael Mando's Scorpion (let's hope so, because he needs way more screen-time), but the second is the greatest prank pulled by a Marvel movie. Without outright spoiling it, it plays on the whole culture of sitting through end credits, using the Captain America PSA format established at various points in the film.

Sure, it's a massive f*ck you, but it's also a delightfully affectionate rib, and the tongue-in-cheek approach allows Marvel to get away with the cheekiness.


8. The High-School Vibe

Spider-Man Homecoming Goth
Marvel Studios

When Marvel got the rights back to make their Spider-Man movie within the MCU, Kevin Feige and Amy Pascal were very clear about their agenda to make a high-school movie predominantly and to keep Peter Parker at school. That would fly in the face of the accelerated school lives of both Sam Raimi and Marc Webb's versions of the character, and the hint that we'd get some John Hughes references in there too made it all sound very exciting.

It's very pleasing to report that the film pulls off its high-school vibe perfectly, establishing not just a normal school environment but a sort of diluted Hogwarts magic, thanks to the fact that everyone is a tech genius, and most of the kids are eccentric in some way.

The Hughes references aren't as blatant as the one Ferris Bueller gag in there, but that's a good thing - Watts' approach is far more subtle and more indie, and it never feels like this is just a stepping stone to Peter growing up and getting his Daily Bugle job.


7. The Clever Fidelity To The Origin

Spider-Man Homecoming
Marvel Studios

We were also told very early on that we wouldn't be getting a Spider-Man origin story, as he'd already arrived in the MCU fully-formed in Civil War. Still, Watts could quite easily have gone with key flash-backs to establish how Peter got his powers and the whole Uncle Ben thing, but he resisted and the film benefits from that boldness.

But that doesn't mean the origin story doesn't bubble under the surface. For instance, thanks to smart, non-expositional dialogue around Ned learning Peter's secret, we know that Peter was indeed bitten by a spider and we know that a heavy trauma hangs over Aunt May (Peter doesn't want to put her through the added anxiety of knowing he's Spidey). We are never invited to obsess over those elements, and there's no fetishism of Spider-Man's origin as there has been elsewhere.

The decision to make Uncle Ben's death very much Aunt May's story rather than Peter's is a smart move too, because it gives the film space to have Peter find his own driving mantra in place of the "with great power..." shtick.


6. The Humour & The Tone

Spider Man Homecoming 13
Marvel Studios

Homecoming actually feels a little like an Archie comic. The characters are similarly constructed (aside from the more traditional MCU elements anyway), and there's a similar comedic spirit.

The majority of the gags come courtesy of Jacob Batalon (who might well be the supporting character MVP) who occupies the same sort of narrative space as Michael Pena's Luis from Ant-Man, but he's not the only funny guy. Peter has his moments, Zendaya's Michelle is a dead-pan, odd-ball marvel and both Martin Starr's Mr Harrington and Hannibal Buress' Coach Wilson are hysterical.

Crucially, none of the gags feel particularly shoe-horned in, because of the way Watts balances tone. Even though the marketing made it look like Homecoming was essentially two films smushed together, the spectacle of Peter's secret life sits comfortably with his school life (and any friction actually serves the narrative). And you really have to admire how organically Watts managed to knit his John Hughes-like high school movie into the edges of the MCU without it feeling like an imposter.


5. Michael Keaton

Spider-Man Homecoming Michael Keaton
Marvel Studios

Michael Keaton's best performances tend to be on the weird spectrum or have some sort of fundamental duplicitousness about them. He is a master of performing disguises and disguised characters, and his Adrian Toomes sits nicely alongside his Batman and Bruce Wayne.

But he's more than that: you can see elements of Keaton's other performances in Toomes - there's something of Beetlejuice's monstrosity in his vulture, and there's also the homely charisma of Multiplicity - he's absolutely no one-dimensional crook. And there's also something of Alfred Molina's tragic Doc Ock there too: he might be evil, but he's motivated by good (or at least personally logical morality) and he never really abandons his fundamental charm. He's more an advert for moral greyness, clashing against a pure, uncomplicated morality in Peter Parker.

Keaton never turns his Toomes into a cliche (despite how easily he could have become one), and nor does he turn him into a pantomime act. He's ferocious but layered and he feels like a man wearing several masks through necessity. Only when we discover who he really is and why he does what he does do we find him at his most comfortable, and in that respect he shares a lot with Keaton's Batman.


4. The Future Set Ups

Spider-Man Homecoming Donald Glover
Marvel Studios

Even though there's a very loud ticking clock attached to Spider-Man's time in the MCU (for now at least), the film does a great job spreading seeds that could become stories in possible sequels.

Not only do we get hints of the sequel's big villain in a couple of scenes, but we also meet Donald Glover's Prowler (Aaron Davis) and hear about his nephew (one Miles Morales no less), see a potential future Spider-Man suit and see a map to him becoming an Avenger. Then there's the hints at a future flowering romance with very familiar roots, and a huge narrative point of tension for the sequel at home for Peter.

And it's not just the bigger guys either, if you don't come away wanting to see more of Flash Thompson, Michelle, Hannibal Burgess' Coach or then you weren't watching properly. They made this world feel lived in and they will be welcome components of the sequel.

In contrast to The Amazing Spider-Man 2's scatter-gun approach to seeding, this is how you set up sequels and an expanded universe without pulling away from the core film reductively.


3. The Action

Spider-Man Homecoming Suit
Marvel Studios

It's a shame that it was all shown in the trailers needlessly, but there's still a lot to enjoy about the action scenes in Homecoming. Even with a lighter tone and the fact that this is very much a teen comic book movie, the combat sequences are surprisingly hard-hitting (mostly thanks to the technological augmentations offered by The Tinkerer's tech).

There are some set-pieces in there that will imprint on the memory in a way that makes their spoiling in the trailers all the more baffling: the ferry sequence for instance and the plane fight between Spidey and Vulture.

Sony are lucky that their over-zealous, suffocating marketing campaign wasn't enough to rob the joy out of seeing Spidey swinging around New York, and those who consciously avoided the trailers will have experienced it all with the wide-eyed happiness that we all should have.

Perhaps because he's "just a kid" too, a lot of the action lacks finesse - he's just a fledgling after all - and the threat to him feels more authentic. You might know that he'll survive, but he goes through the ringer on the way there, particularly in the final act, and that's a real art.


2. Ned

Spider Man Homecoming Nice Gif
Marvel Studios

Alongside Luis from Ant-Man and Wong from Doctor Strange, Ned leaps to the top of the list of comic book movie best friends (Happy Hogan has been a competitor at times too). In Jacob Batalon's hands, he's a hysterical, awkward goof-ball with a whip-smart intellect and the kind of social ineptitude that delightfully mirrors Peter's initial struggles with superheroism.

He's the archetypal John Hughes dork (though the high-school world is a lot more forgiving now than it was in the 80s), and while he and Peter are the target of bullies, they're still more like Harry Potter and Ron Weasley or Bart Simpson and Milhouse rather than total outsiders.

Ned is all of us, invited to know a secret that threatens to vomit itself out of him unguided at every turn, pushed up by a tide of excitement. It's his eyes that we see Peter's double life as Spider-Man play out, and it's a masterstroke of story-telling to do that.


1. Peter Parker

Spider Man Homecoming Peter Parker
Marvel Studios

It was already said after Captain America: Civil War, but Tom Holland is easily the best Peter Parker to date. He is helped considerably by the fact that he's been cast to play the high-school version of the character who is yet to really blossom into either a man or a fully fledged hero, but his cocky bravado and stifling vulnerability combine to make him feel like the purest screen iteration of the comic book character.

Holland ticks every box, capturing Peter's slight gawkiness in his own skin and Spider-Man's just-charming-enough cockiness (which could be hugely annoying in other hands), balancing the obnoxiousness with an earnest enthusiasm that is delightfully intoxicating.

Like John Hughes' finest heroes, you really care about him, even when he's not making the right decisions (which is a simple thing, but a hugely important one in this type of film), and Holland's ability to encourage that shouldn't be underplayed.

What did you think of Spider-Man: Homecoming? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.