Star Trek Beyond Review: 8 Ups And 2 Downs

Like a feature-length episode of The Original Series.

Star Trek Beyond

Rating: ★★★★

Here’s one for you. Before the press screening of Star Trek Beyond, me and a group of other critics were chatting Star Wars and discussing everything that happened at last week’s Celebration event; how it was ran, the quality of the reveals, and the future of the galaxy far, far away, getting hyped for movies that are years out. Before Star Trek we were talking Star Wars.

That’s how poor the marketing for this film has been – the trailers have been incredibly underwhelming and Paramount have almost looked like they’ve wanted to hide the film, so the excitement has been oddly mooted for the studio's big summer release.

But let me tell you, once the movie was over, all we could talk about was Trek.

Beyond’s great, just a cut below J.J. Abrams 2009 reboot, and will appeal to just about anyone. If you’ve been brought in by Justin Lin’s Fast & Furious, you’ll have plenty of action to enjoy, and if you’re a proper Trekkie who’s not a big fan of the Kelvin timeline, you'll be pleased to discover a lot of major complaints about themes and narrative have been addressed.

Here's eight ups and only two downs from Star Trek Beyond.


The Ups:

8. The Enterprise Crew All Get Their Time To Shine

star trek beyond spock bones
Paramount

You already know the youthful recastings of the Enterprise crew are good, but they’ve never worked as well as an ensemble as they have in Beyond.

They're really a team this time, not just support for Spock ‘n’ Kirk’s rocky friendship, and pretty much everyone gets more time to shine here in their own unique way. The idea of this being a group cast runs through the film, plays a big part in key emotional pay-off and is even reflected in the closing credits, where they’re listed in alphabetic order, rather than importance.

Karl Urban in particular gets more to do – Bones and Spock spend a good portion of the movie together, and as a result the doctor’s even more grumpy and sardonic. It's a brilliant double-act, and one I hope gets more screentime in future movies. Also worth noting is Jaylah, an original character who is – gasp – treated with real respect alongside the fifty year old characters, rather than a throwaway one-shot hero.

The only one who’s seriously underserved is Chekov, which obviously a shame as this is one of Anton Yelchin’s final screen roles (although he does get a nice dedication in the ending credits).


7. The Enterprise Attack Is Jaw-Dropping

Star Trek Beyond Villains Formation
Paramount Pictures

You’ve seen glimpses of it in the trailers, but they can't prepare you for how good the sequence early on in the film where the Enterprise is actually destroyed is. It's just fantastic.

It’s a really methodical sequence. Justin Lin takes his time, slowly taking down the ship and forcing the crew to face increasingly mounting problems. It runs for a good ten minutes and in that time it establishes key plot points, develops the characters and gives us a taste of what villain Krall’s thinking’s like.

Obviously Justin Lin’s proven himself before in constructing big action sequences, but this is one of his best. He takes his time escalating the conflict, methodically taking down the ship and forcing the crew to face increasingly mounting problems. The whole thing runs for about ten minutes, and in that time it establishes key plot points, develops the characters and gives us a taste of how villain Krall thinks.

And, of course, it's thrilling and engrossing; he effortlessly conveys the layout of the ship and how each area affects the others, and the camera flips from inside to out constantly (his camera work across the movie is great by the way, especially in the all-angled Yorktown).

Best of all, when it’s over you’ve still got a good hour or so of other good action to enjoy.

There’s little isolated moments within it that don’t 100% work, but that’s a something for the downs.


6. It’s Like A Feature-Length Episode

Star Trek Beyond Enterprise Crew Captured
Paramount Pictures

I think where Beyond is really going to win back diehard Trekkies is that it’s essentially a feature-length episode from The Original Series. Star Trek was a prequel and Into Darkness a non-surprise Wrath Of Kahn remake, but this is just pure Trek; The Enterprise is on a mission, gets wrapped up in this planet and find a plot that reflects their own internal conflicts. There’s dashings of different genres in there, but it all comes back to that crew.

And the cause for this big difference between Beyond and Abrams’ films isn’t the director, but the writer. Simon Pegg co-wrote the script with Doug Jung and you can just tell it comes from someone who doesn’t just understand, but loves, Trek. His screenplay is full of so many little easter eggs and shout outs to the classic series and the complex continuity, and also expertly balances the more humorous bits carefully throughout, so this never threatens to come close to being a comedy - the opening captain’s log is tongue-in-cheek send up full of in-jokes that almost steals the show.


5. Idris Elba’s Villain’s The Best Of The Reboot

Star trek Beyond trailer cap idris elba
Paramount Pictures

One of the major criticisms I’ve heard of the film has been that Idris Elba’s villain Krall is rather one-note and takes a backseat to all that group bantering. And to that all I can say is "Really?"

Now I can’t really go too much into this one as it’s linked into later reveals (and, on that note, try and avoid the recent TV spots), but I’d say Krall's the most interesting bad guys of the reboot run. He’s got a long-standing plan more logical than Nero’s, is less gimmicky than John Harrison and not as snarling as Peter Weller. Most importantly, you understand what his motivations are and why he's dealing with them in this way.

The criticisms may come from the fact he’s not on screen as much as the heroes, but his character looms over everything and ties directly into the movie’s wider themes that it doesn't really matter.


4. The Music

Star Trek Beyond Scotty 3
Paramount Pictures

Music has been a bit of stickler for Star Trek Beyond. The first trailer was for scored to Beastie Boys’ Sabotage in an attempt to mimic Guardians Of The Galaxy and the third had Rhianna’s exhausting tie-in song.

Now here’s the surprise - the movie’s soundtrack is actually great. I mean, it is Michael Giaccino, so what did you expect, but still a nice surprise, like the rest of the film it has a great mix of throwback and new. It’s all very evocative of the classic series, with simple, old-style instrumentalisation in what would otherwise be big action sequences, and a rare lack of reliance on the classic themes.

The coolest thing, though, is that they do use Beastie Boys and it works. It’s part of a bigger sequence, but having it blaring out as Bones calls it classical music – one of many nods to changing times – will have a big grin on your face.

Just make sure you rush out of the cinema after the main opening credits so you don’t have to listen to Rhianna’s again.


3. It Actually Has A Three Act Structure

Paramount Pictures

Now this one shouldn’t be all that big a deal, but 2016 has brought us so many movies where the traditional narrative structure is ignored. You know the ones - the second act is a rush of disjointed scenes and the big finale kicks in randomly as you strain to know why anyone’s doing anything and character development is a dirty word.

Beyond has a clearly defined three-act structure that almost perfectly maps to all those basic set-up, confrontation resolution graphs you see, and because of that is a much more well rounded and enjoyable film than its contemporaries. I could tell you exactly where to put the ad breaks if this was a real episode.

I can't overstate how impressive this is. Of course Pegg would be able to make something that pleases Star Trek fans – he is a massive Trekkie, no matter what he says about geek culture – but that’s he’s penned a big summer film that can actually be called a film promises even more great things.

The pacing isn't totally perfect, but again that’s something for downs.


2. It Feels Like You’re In The Frontier

Paramount Pictures

Set design in Star Trek was always one of necessity. What’s near LA that can pass for an alien planet? Good, just throw in some fake boulders and a couple of costumed aliens and you’re done.

Star Trek Beyond honours that "style", but makes it looks incredible. The planet most of the film’s set on feels like real locations done up with solid set-dressing, and the design is very reminiscent of what was achievable on a 1960s TV budget, just pushed so it feels real. There’s CG augmentation, but you can’t see the lines, and the aesthetic is so welcoming you don’t really want to look for them anyway. Realism is clearly a big focus here, as evidenced by various moments with Iñárritu-style grime on the lens.

The space sequences are also gorgeous too. Gone are the constant close-ups and lens flare and instead there’s these massive wide shots of the Enterprise flying tiny alongside swarms of ships or through nebulas that look incredible.


1. It Deals With Legacy And Generations Perfectly

Paramount Pictures

So Pegg has story and narrative structure down, although where he really wins is how he gives Star Trek back that philosophical side, looking at how the heroes in the 23rd century view themselves in the here-and-now while living in the shadow of mass human development and expansion.

Kirk laments how he’s now older than his father Chris Hemsworth ever got and there’s an overriding sense that, as the five-year mission enters its second half, they’re beginning to drift into emptiness; there's comments that things are feeling episodic. Conversely, the villain longs for the days when space travel was wracked with conflict, motivating a plot that embraces using the past while looking to the future.

It’s nice as 50th Anniversary celebration, not dissimilar to what Bond did with Skyfall, and the handling here isn't just fitting for a show that was always about hope for the future, but sets a baseline that the movies can just run and run from.

One of the most effective ways this is done is with the tribute to Leonard Nimoy – the lack of Ambassador Spock is dealt with so delicately in the film and informs Commander Spock’s arc, but also acts as a representation of how the franchise will go forward.


Downs:

2. The Hand-To-Hand Combat Is Iffy

Star Trek Beyond Idris Elba
cdn.collider.com

So yeah, the movie has pretty great action throughout that’s consistently inventive and varied. There’s one area, however, where it really didn’t work for me; the hand-to-hand combat.

It’s most prominent in the Enterprise crash and a side-fight during the motorbike sequence, but throughout the fist fights just weren't engaging. It feels like at random points Lin suddenly though he was Paul Greengrass, shaking the camera and cutting incessantly, but he can't get the cuts to flow right and we’re so close up it becomes impenetrable.

It’s so strange when everything else works so well. Although at least it’s better than the Gorn showdown.


1. It Moves Way Too Fast

Latest
vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net

We may have a story that actual feels like a fully well-rounded plot, but sometimes things are moving so frantically it doesn’t get time to breathe. The positive side of this constant pace is it’s very hard to get bored, but it also means subtler beats can be rushed over and underplayed. Jaylah’s hurt a bit by this; overall she’s a great new addition, but her long-standing goal to get off the planet is made increasingly less prominent as the film goes on.

It’s not even like it the two hour runtime needed stretching - there’s several individual shots that if they’d run on for just a few more seconds would have a much more profound impact.

Given how poor the pacing of other films this year have been, however, it's a minor quibble in a film that is simply good, old fashioned fun. Ignore the trailers and check it out.

What are you looking forward to in Star Trek Beyond? Discuss the movie down in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.