Star Trek Into Darkness: 6 Flaws That Almost Ruined It

Harrison Before I get into this, let me qualify that Star Trek Into Darkness is a four star film. It is bold, vastly entertaining and it has moments of emotional poignancy that the original creator of the sprawling space soap opera, Gene Roddenberry, would have marveled at. And the better moments, like most of those featuring Benedict Cumberbatch's grandslam villain and Abrams' numerous and epic action set-pieces, drag it easily into that rating band, but it is far from flawless. It would seem to be a disease of the modern tent-pole sequel that along with the high points, there are some jarring bum-notes: The Dark Knight Rises was badly hamstrung by poor creative decisions and diabolical editing, and Iron Man 2 & 3 were fun, but deeply flawed. In the quest to do everything bigger and bolder after an initial success, mistakes can creep in, and just as the success peaks are higher, the flaws tend to be exponentially more noticable. After all, when you're closer to perfection, the missteps are magnified, and that is the case with Star Trek Into Darkness. Audiences will not be wowed as much as with the original, and at least some are likely to point to the following issues to stress their complaints. So in the interest of pre-empting the complaints, here are the six flaws that almost derailed Into Darkness...

6. Spock/Uhura

Spock Uhura The key to the half-Vulcan/human relationship at the center of Abrams' first Star Trek movie was the way it played with expectations - an underlying theme that Abrams continues to roll out in Into Darkness, almost consciously defying everything canon might suggest would happen (the marketing has consciously reinforced this through openly defying links to the original series) - and it worked in the original. But after too long, the idea of Spock in a committed relationship begins to feel like a betrayal of the character as we know him and though we aren't supposed to see this Spock as anything like the old Spock, the appearance of "Spock Prime" in this new canon draws an unhelpful comparison. Yes, Spock's human side is his most intriguing asset, but it is far more engaging to see the mask of logic slip in charged situations, as happens towards the end of the film when his voice even breaks with emotion, and we see something of a Spock we haven't seen before. That is far more worthy of investment rather than seeing how his odd-couple romance is playing out.

5. Crew, What Crew?

Sulu Key to Kirk's genesis as a character, and the familiar arc he takes through Into Darkness is his relationship with his crew - or so we are lead to believe. They are his life-blood, his reason d'etre, and as he openly states when things get rough, his "family," and he would do anything for them. That is the moral that underpins the entire narrative, and it is a shame that we don't really get much chance to explore the rest of the crew in anything like the detail that would make Kirk's devotion understandable. Kirk is a maverick, and it's hard to marry up his altruistic conviction with a crew that are largely absent, or at worst furniture to fill chairs when a slightly higher billed cast member pops out for an away party. The Kirk/Spock/Harrison triangle is very strong, and it's obvious that Abrams has concentrated on his strongest chips, but everyone else is under-cooked. Too many characters are there simply to make up the numbers (Sulu gets about three important minutes on-screen without any development at all,) and there are way too many comic relief characters. Speaking of which...

4. The Humour

Chekov There is something of an inconsistency in the tone of the film: this is not the gleeful romp that the first one was, but like Iron Man 3, the scripters seem overly keen to shoe-horn in as much comedy as possible despite an agenda to make things darker. So while worlds fall apart, and hearts burst into flame, we are treated to a Bones McCoy reduced entirely to metaphors and quips (he should be SO much more,) a bumbling Scottie with a comedy side-kick in tow, and a Chekov who feels way too much like a taller version of self-abusing house-elf Dobby from Harry Potter. There is too much humour by far, and too many characters burdened with bringing smiles in place of them being given any actual development. Even Michael Bay knows you should only have one comic relief character, and too many clowns will ruin anything that aspires to be as tragic (in parts) as Into Darkness does.

3. To Boldly Stay

Star Trek Into Darkness The plot is very good, but when it all boils down to it, nothing really happens to change where we were at the end of the first movie, and where we are now after the second. For a film called Star Trek, there is a curious lack of any actual Star Trekking. Yes, there's a sojourn to a forbidden enemy planet, but it's fairly underplayed in favour of just presenting an interesting looking backdrop to an excellent fire-fight, but it feels a little like someone pressed a reset button and we're back where we started. The impact of the events in the narrative should have shaped something different, and changed the very nature of Starfleet, but instead of any exploration of that, and also because of the final-act twist that fundamentally changes the trajectory of one major character (who had been given a hugely poignant conclusion) the events in London, as presented in the trailer, seem to have no real legacy. If everything is supposed to be different to canon, why does it feel like every deviation is still pulling us back to the same end-game? By its own agenda to chart the undiscovered country, Into Darkness fails, since it actually just reinforces old points.

2. What's My Motivation?

Harrison Benedict Cumberbatch's villain is an astonishingly provocative creation - not only in his performance, but also in the creative decision that moulded the character. I don't quite agree with the marketing campaign behind the character, in light of the events of the film, because it does little more than make a pantomime out of a perfectly legitimate threat for a while, but his impact is such that that doesn't quite get in the way of his performance as a whole. It doesn't matter who he is, or who he isn't, because he is a brilliant villain. However, even Cumberbatch's well-dressed villain has his problems - he is driven by a singular motivation, and by a massive betrayal initially, and that is hammered home in the way he is framed for much of the film. He is a superior being, ignorant of the ants scurrying around him thanks to his hell-bent agenda of vengeance (that offers nothing more than the trailer reveals, by the way.) But, once he has achieved his goal, Harrison changes entirely, and becomes a different breed of villain, and though there is some exploration of why he might have changed his focus in a throw-away comment, there is a huge inconsistency in how he is presented at first and what he becomes. Story-tellers are of course able to employ misdirection, but there should be sign-posts and hints early that reveal themselves in retrospect, and for Into Darkness it feels like a creative decision designed to artificially add scale to the finale (which ironically, wasn't needed in the end.)

1. Scotty

Scotty As much as it pains me to say it, Simon Pegg was miscast as Scotty. He is Shaun Of The Enterprise, rather than a reliable chief of engineering with some personality quirks, as the character specifications requires even despite the non-canonical reinvention of the crew (everyone else is a close approximation of their "other selves.") There are some pleasant moments, like a clash with his captain, and some successful jokes ("I'm running!) but you're never far away from the feeling that there is too much of Shrek in his comic outrage, and too much of other Pegg characters in the rest of his nerdy make-up. Unlike the rest of the characters, Scotty never really displays anything that suggests why he would be part of the premier crew in Starfleet in this universe - yes he is hyper-intelligent, but when you couple that with wanton buffoonery and a lack of any kind of physical threat, he is basically a liability. The expectations of a Scottish engineer are somewhat at odds with this mild-mannered odd-ball, to say the least. Plus his accent wanders all over Scotland, as well as England at some points, and it's all very distracting. These may seem like minor gripes, but in the context of what is otherwise a great film, they matter. That does not mean you shouldn't go and see the film immediately on its release. Star Trek Into Darkness is released to UK cinemas next week.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.