Star Wars: 10 Massive Plot Holes The Prequels Stupidly Created
Let the hate flow through you.

I saw Star Wars in a very odd order. Only watching The Phantom Menace when the print of Yellow Submarine I was meant to be watching didn't turn up, I didn't see any of the other films until Attack Of The Clones hit in 2002. It was only after this better instalment that I finally saw the originals (thankfully in order, although knowing the big twist), culminating, along with everyone else, with Revenge Of The Sith. Out all the possible (popular) orders (I-VI, IV-III, IV-V-I-II-III-VI), this is not one Id recommend.
Because I saw the films with no conceivable chronology, many of the odd additions Lucas retroactively made to the franchise went over my head; Anakin as a kid, the Jedi as an order of monks, Darth being a Sith title (and the notions of Sith at all). But as time went on and I rewatched the films with a more critical eye, my naivety lessened. The prequels weren't as much tying up loose ends, but extending the overall life of the franchise. It became clear there were numerous discrepancies between the two trilogies, with George Lucas seemingly forgetting much of what he's done decades earlier.
In this list we bring you ten major Star Wars plot holes that were created solely by the prequels. These aren't the self contained ones (like an army being created for Republic despite there being no way of them knowing about it or the clones attacking the ship the one person theyre there to save is on) but events in the prequels that creative massive continuity errors given what we know from the originals.
I'd just like to clarify that I do enjoy the Star Wars prequels. Theyre very well functioning blockbusters that have good action, wide scope and tell an interesting story. They do have many weaknesses, some of which are addressed here, but don't at any point think this is simple prequel-bashing; it's more opening up the faults of their plotting.
10. How Could The Head Bang Stormtrooper Be A Clone?

One of the most well known background jokes of the whole saga is the clumsy Stormtrooper. When breaking into the observation area R2-D2 and C-3PO are holed up in, one of the Empire's finest soldiers bangs his head on the door. A minor mistake that got left in the final film, later editions have added an audible bump, signifying George Lucas acknowledgement of his mistake.
To really canonise it, Attack Of The Clones contained an identical moment with Jango Fett. As Episode II introduced what would eventually become Stormtroopers as clones of Fett, the implication is that the head bumping is somehow genetic.
Aside from that making no scientific sense and the soldier not having a New Zealand accent (like all the clones and Boba Fett have for some reason), it doesn't add up in the timeline. For a clone to be still functioning as a Stromtrooper in ANH is would need to be a minimum of twenty years old, which with accelerated ageing would make it at least the grand old age of forty. I somehow doubt regular soldiers at the major Imperial base would be so aged and likely inefficient, making the whole in-joke nonsensical.
9. Why Did Palpatine Want To Turn Luke When It Would Lead To His Death?

On the face of it Palpatine's plan in ROTJ makes a lot of sense; trick the rebels into an ambush, turn Luke to the Dark Side and be home in time for Jawa juice.
The plan to turn Luke into a Sith was the main drive of both Empire and Return Of The Jedi. At the end of the battle on Cloud City, Vader not only reveals his identity to Luke, but also his plan for them to overthrow the Emperor with him (and unlike his plan in ROTS with Padmé, it feels a little less made up on the spot). From what we've learned about the Sith this is a natural thing to happen and no one should know this better than Palpatine.
The general rule with Sith is that the Apprentice's do eventually kill their master, just like Sidious did with Darth Plagueis. He's already gone through at least two learners and has militantly followed the rule of two set down long in the galaxys past. Why, at the point when he can gain full control does he break it and introduce a new variable that very likely could lead to his undoing? What was once a logical evil plan becomes bogged down in complications.
8. Why Did Technology Suddenly Become A Lot Less Advanced?

Of course, there's a very simple real world solution for this one; CGI got much, much better. In fact, the advancements showcased in the early nineties were the sole reason Lucas decided to make the prequels.
The original Star Wars was incredibly entertaining and boasted groundbreaking action sequences, but what really made it so revolutionary was what it did with sci-fi. Up until then it was all clean white and sleek designs; George Lucas introduced a used future and the genre became something a lot more realistic and relatable. The opening of A New Hope, with the blast marks on the white corridor walls, is a muddying of everything that's been before.
The prequels were equally as forward thinking, introducing previously impossible designs (the silver Naboo cruisers) and heightening the action (the pod race and any large scale action sequence). But as cool as it looked, it was increasingly distant from Star Wars. Why in the original trilogy was technology so behind and, yes, realistic? It seems the obsession with good effects lost the sense of style.
The most outrageous change is the introduction of R2-D2's rocket boosters, which he uses willy nilly in AOTC and ROTS, but doesn't use when he really needed them in the original trilogy.
7. Why Was Leia A Princess?

When The Phantom Menace was released, everyone knew Padmé was Leia's mother. Not only did they share the same love of extravagant hairstyles, but the woman who would become Mrs. Vader was a Queen. How else would Leia be a princess?
Well, there's never an answer. Lucas quickly forgot why he made Padmé Queen in the first place, turning the role more of a ministerial one and the character into senator. It did help get the audience involved in the gradual crumbling of the Republic, but then left it open how Leia would be a princess; the title Queen wasn't carried over after Padmé left office.
No definite answer is given, but the implication is that because her adoptive father is senator of Alderaan she gets the honorary title. But that comes across as more than a little contrived. It would have been better if Lucas hadn't mentioned it at all; in referencing royalty everyone expected an airtight explanation of Leia's title.
6. Why Did Anakin Revert Back To His Twenty-Two Year Old Self As Ghost?

Not a direct thing raised by the prequels, but the Special Editions, this plot hole is so heavily prequel-influenced that I think its appearance is justified here.
As everyone gleefully remembers, Return Of The Jedi ends with Anakin becoming a force ghost. In the original version he was played by Sebastian Shaw, whod also been the dying Anakin a few minutes earlier. Nowadays, from the 2004 Special Editions onwards, Shaw is replaced by Hayden Christensen, who hasn't been seen for three films and Luke doesn't have a hope of recognising.
The implication of the original is that Anakin has been redeemed and can now rejoin to Jedi. The newer edit seems to ignore redemption, instead saying Anakin was last good before he turned. Obviously it's disrespectful to the character's death and title to say that he hadn't at the end returned, but the real prequel-fuelled issue is that we never really see Anakin as a good person after Episode I. In AOTC he's whiny and quick to anger, slaughtering innocents and betraying his oath. In ROTS he's pretty much the same for the entire film, only this time he shouts more.
Yes, it's another change to the originals everyone hates, but the real sense of distaste comes from it making no sense in the context of the prequels. If you're really going that route, shouldn't it have been Jake Lloyd at the end instead?
5. Why Did Obi-Wan Age So Rapidly In Twenty Years?

Finding out the Galactic Empire stood for the sum total of twenty-three years (the same amount of time since the Berlin Wall fell) is pretty disheartening - the whole thing seems a lot less menacing. But it also opens up the mind to all the timing inconsistencies the prequels introduced. Primary among them is how Obi-Wan aged at least ten years more than he conceivably should have.
Ewan McGregor was in his early thirties when he played the Clone Wars Obi-Wan, but Alec Guinness was a whopping thirty years older in Star Wars, despite only a nineteen year gap between films. When you consider Guinness was made to look a fair bit older for the role, it becomes plain ridiculous.
McGregor was clearly cast in Episode I for his youthful looks, but as his role switched and he became the master, the age problem became prominent. Now he was aged slightly by the time ROTS came around, but not to the extent where it's believable hed be Ben old come Star Wars. Look at Ewan McGregor now - does he look ten years off Alec Guinness?
Maybe the Tatooine suns gave Ben a painful sunburn a few years into his stay and his skin never recovered.
4. Why Did The Jedi Hide In Plain Sight?

The ending of Revenge Of The Sith is much documented for its stupidity. Between Darth Vader's Noooooo and Padmé's unexplained death, it'd sometimes be easier to ambiguously end the film twenty minutes earlier. The most mocked element (Vader's scream aside) is the Jedi's plan to keep the children safe; one easily becomes part of a family who wanted a child anyway and the other keeps his name and goes with his family. One out of two ain't all that bad.
But while hiding Luke in more than plain sight is a little dumb, Obi-Wan's (and to a lesser extent Yoda's) decision to wear traditional Jedi robes when their kind is still being hunted is far from hiding. When making The Phantom Menace, Lucas made the poor decision to use what Obi-Wan wore in A New Hope as the uniform of the whole order. While it allowed a play on Jedi dress iconic status for marketing purposes, it made little sense; the implication in the original trilogy was that Obi-Wan was dressed like that to blend into Tatooine, not to make it clear he was Jedi.
What's even worse is that Obi-Wan's reserved nature, something present to aid his hiding, was also worked in the order at large, turning these great masters into boring meditators.
3. How Could A Nine Year Old Build An Identikit Robot?
If what Lucas has said in previous interviews is to be believed (and time has taught us that it's not) the only characters intended to appear in every Star Wars (be it nine or twelve films) are R2-D2 and C-3PO. Because he knew that way back in the eighties, youd have imagined their introduction in Episode I would have been a little less slapdash.
Admittedly Artoo's entry was noble, if a bit sudden, but 3POs was just lazy. Turns out the robot who looks like thousands more the galaxy over was created by chance by a ten year old. It's the Star Wars galaxy equivalent of a child making an iPhone indistinguishable from what Apple churns out.
While it is relatively believable that Anakin used the design of typical protocol droid and replicated it because midichlorians are super powerful or something, it's all too convenient. Whats even more convenient is that Shmi Skywalker managed to finish 3PO perfectly after her son left.
This plot hole was so gaping an attempt was made to control it; at the end of Episode III 3PO's mind is wiped so the naturally chatty droid isn't out of character when he doesn't mention anything about Anakin to Luke. It's the robot equivalent of amnesia.
2. How Could Leia Remember Her Mother When She Died In Childbirth?

Before the prequel trilogy there were few references to the time before the Galactic Civil War. We had Obi-Wan's intriguing speech in A New Hope but it was all rather hush hush undeveloped territory. As Vader's fall became apparent more was fleshed out; the story of Anakin Skywalker was already forming. And with it came the birth of the twins, including the tantalising hint at Leia remembering her real mother.
When Revenge Of The Sith rolled around, however, this line (along with much of the hints throughout the trilogy) was rendered useless. Not only did Padmé die giving birth to the twins, but Luke was the first out, negating even the slightest argument of having marginally more time alive having an impact. The implication from Return Of The Jedi was that Leia spent some time growing up with her mother who was still grieving the loss of her husband before being adopted by the Organas, a long way off what actually happened.
The majority of ROTS' final act seemed to be a hasty tying up of loose ends, but in this area the ball was really dropped. Now one of ROTJ's most emotional scenes ends up being a painful contradiction for fans.
1. Was Every Word Out Of Obi-Wan's Mouth A Lie Or Was He Just Senile?

Here's a plot hole the original trilogy partially created and solved in its run time. It wasn't until the second draft of Empire that Lucas decided Vader was Lukes father, which led to a few inconsistencies. Any reference to Anakin in A New Hope was wrong and even some of Empire made no sense; the Emperor and Vader are being way too cryptic in their conversation given what they know, made worse by the new dialogue in the special edition name-checking Anakin.
The problem was dealt with in ROTJ by Obi-Wan revealing he lied to protect Luke. Hokey, but believable. Hopefully Lucas would make the same contradictory mistake again.
Well he did. Now much of what Obi-Wan says in A New Hope is terribly incorrect. Heres just a selection of the buffet of falsities Obi-Wan claims in the original trilogy that the prequels turn into massive plot holes:
Why didn't he remember R2 and 3PO? Why did he say Anakin wanted Luke to have his lightsaber when another lie would have been more efficient? Why did he say Owen didn't want Luke to follow him as Anakin had? Anakin didn't follow Obi-Wan and Owen hardly knew his (step) brother. Why did he say Yoda trained him? And the quick solution of Yoda training younglings in AOTC doesn't count. Why did he call Vader a ceremonial name, Darth, in their confrontation? Throughout the originals it was assumed Darth Vader was an actual name Anakin had adopted, but Obi-Wan knew it was a title used by all Sith.
There's no explanation for these inconsistencies from any point of view. Is Obi-Wan flat out lying to influence Luke (which makes the Family Guy version of the character less creepy than the real version) or has he just gone senile in his old age (even though he's not that old). It all comes from Lucas not watching his older films before making their prequels.
Well there you have it, ten major plot holes in Star Wars that could have been easily avoided. Are there any more you'd like to add? Or do you have solution to one we've raised? Let us know what you think in the comments below.