Star Wars: 10 Things Rogue One Did Best
A look back at the Star Wars Prequel it's socially acceptable to like...
All wings report in, Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is finally available as a home release. And you know what that means: constant re-watching until it completely loses all magic. Who are you kidding? That’s never going to happen. It’s Star Wars.
Rogue One was always going to be a bit of a gamble. It was the first spin-off movie and wasn’t able to rely on the nostalgia of Original Trilogy characters… as much. But fortunately, despite the doubts of some fans and the not-inconsiderable reshoots, Lucasfilm and director Gareth Edwards pulled it off. And you can’t argue with a billion dollar gross and an 85% Fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes.
Thanks to Rogue One, we have HD X-Wing action for the first time, and Darth Vader tearing through Rebels in what’s probably the closest we’ll get to a Star Wars horror film. While on the other hand, we didn’t get dialogue like “This is a rebellion isn’t? I rebel”. Hey, I liked the movie but it’s not like it’s some kind of sacred text. That’s the Original Trilogy’s turf.
So as we all prepare to rewatch Rogue One a lot more than is objectively healthy, it’s time to take a look back at some of the things that it did best. Both as a standalone movie and for the franchise. May the Force be with us…
10. Gareth Edwards' Directing Style
Gareth Edwards has a lot in common with George Lucas when you think about it. A young upstart (Life begins at forty after all) who got his big break on an effects driven feature (Monsters) that he was the driving force behind. And even though he only had one big budget blockbuster under his belt, he was the perfect choice for Rogue One.
As a director, Edwards has a much faster and chaotic style than we have previously seen in Star Wars, which works brilliantly in the action scenes. It also helps that he’s very hands-on. If you look at the behind the scenes footage, you’ll often see him behind the camera.
Which is an approach that can bring unexpected and often excellent results. A lot of shots both in the movie and only seen in the trailers come from random moments of Edwards stumbling across things that work by constantly beavering around the set looking for different camera angles.
And thanks to new technology and an iPad with a Vive Controller stuck on the back, Edwards was able to bring his style to the entirely digital scenes like the space battle, allowing him to be even more hands on.
Edwards’ way of doing things has exactly the kind of energy that Star Wars needs. Or maybe he was just hopped up on Blue Milk and Death Sticks the whole time.
9. Laying The Spin-Off Groundwork
The future of Star Wars spin-off movies is still unclear. The Han Solo movie will determine whether or not Rogue One was a fluke, and Star Wars’ history in this area is… less than 100%. Let’s not forget the Ewok movies, and Carrie Fisher singing to a room full of Wookiees in Snuggies. Wow, the 70s were weird.
Admittedly a Star Wars movie is always going to be a sure-fire money-spinner but the real question was if Rogue One would hold up when moving away from the broader themes and structure of the series. Spoiler alert: it did.
Rogue One has thrown open the doors of the movie side of Star Wars, which means that almost anything could happen with the spin-offs in future. We only know a few broad plots points of the Han Solo movie but since it’s being directed by Phil Lord and Christopher Miller (The Lego Movie), it’s probably going to have a pretty light tone.
But it’s not just tone and story that Rogue One has provided more options for, it’s direction. The franchise isn’t locked into the style set by George Lucas, Irvin Kershner, and Richard Marquand anymore. Something that was George Lucas’s intention in the early 70s, originally planning nine very different movies, each with a different director.
8. The OT In HD
For better or worse, all three Star Wars trilogies have their own visual identity. Which makes sense since they were made years apart with massive technological leaps in-between. But by being about as immediate a prequel as you can get, Rogue One shot for trying to capture the look of A New Hope. And unlike a Stormtrooper, it was pretty damn accurate.
Rogue One has absolutely magnificent attention to detail; with Industrial Light & Magic scanning the models from the Original Trilogy to build the digital versions, and the new Darth Vader costume including all the imperfections of the original. And it’s not just the accurate prop and model recreations, but the actual aesthetic of the films themselves.
Obviously the compositing is much cleaner than the Original Trilogy and a lot of sequences are achieved with digital effects work, but it pulls off mimicking not just the idea of a dirty and used universe but also the specific look of those films.
The Star Destroyers look they’ve been taken straight from the Lucasfilm Archives and shot against blue screen. And managing to successfully capture the look of a forty-year-old movie without compromising the new film’s visual quality is quite an achievement.
7. A Greyer Rebellion
In the Original Trilogy and Rebels, the Rebellion is pretty much the band of big brave heroes out to make everything in the galaxy hunky dory again. Which is understandable for a franchise where the first three films were rated U in the UK. But Rogue One doesn’t stick to the black and white morality of the fight against the Empire.
Thanks to a jump forward in what you can show in movies, and Rogue One having different eyes on the original story, we get to see a different take on the Alliance. Mon Mothma and Bail Organa are still the morally upstanding level-headed leaders, but we also get Rebels who are happy to kill first and ask question later.
Cassian is a part-time assassin, Galen Erso gets taken out by friendly fire; and it’s the Rebellion who start the Galactic Civil War thanks to Admiral Raddus firing the first shot by bringing his fleet to Scarif. And thanks to shots of the escape pods being cut from the movie, the crew of that Hammerhead Corvette are basically kamikaze pilots. You didn’t see anything like that in A New Hope.
It doesn’t necessarily mesh together well with the Original Trilogy in terms of tone but it’s nice to see a different side of the war and some more morally complex characters fighting for the good guys.
6. Grand Moff Tarkin
A Darth Vader cameo in Rogue One was pretty much a given but the real question was “what about Tarkin?”. It was a tricky situation: It takes place right before A New Hope and Tarkin is the big cheese on the Death Star, but it takes place right before A New Hope and Peter Cushing died over twenty years ago.
Thanks to eighteen months of hard work from Industrial Light & Magic and an excellent casting choice in Guy Henry, Rogue One came up with an impressive if not completely perfect solution. Because Rogue One and A New Hope are so close together and Tarkin is so prominent in both films, recasting the character would be kind of jarring. But recreating Peter Cushing digitally (however imperfectly) makes for a stronger connection between the two movies.
And because of the decision to use Tarkin so prominently, we also see him as a more developed villain than A New Hope allowed. We already knew he was the bad guy but by making Krennic his enemy, we get this other side of him as a schemer working his way through the ranks of the Empire. Except he uses a planet-killing laser to get promoted rather than inter-office politics.
The effects used to create Tarkin will age, there’s no doubt about that. But Rogue One took that hit to help move the technology forward. It’s a technique that’s proven to work and means that future Star Wars movies could include cameos from characters we never thought we’d see again.
5. Fanservice
Gareth Edwards is such a Star Wars fanboy that he once took food dye with him on holiday to Tunisia so he could drink Blue Milk in Luke Skywalker’s house. I think we all knew what we were in for when he took this job.
Some of Rogue One’s cameos were a bit in your face like Ponda Baba and Dr Evazan (yes, I am a massive nerd if that wasn’t obvious already) popping up on Jedha, but a lot more of them work really well. It’s fanservice helping the film instead of the other way round.
Among other things, Gareth Edwards and Lucasfilm made full use of the incredibly fortunate timing of the movie. Ten years after Revenge Of The Sith, Genevieve O’Reilly (Mon Mothma) and Jimmy Smits (Bail Organa) were the perfect age to reprise their roles onscreen, while some actors from the Original Trilogy like James Earl Jones and Angus MacInnes (Gold Leader) were still able to make voice cameos.
But the best part of these nods to the other films is that, in some cases, they’re actually used to improve the film. Darth Vader’s final scene is pretty much pure fanservice but it not only improves the image of Darth Vader, but also bridges the gap to A New Hope as much as is humanly possible.
4. Space Combat
Because the Battle Of Coruscant in Revenge Of The Sith mostly happened around Obi-Wan and Anakin boarding General Grievous’ flagship, and the attack on Starkiller Base in The Force Awakens was a small-scale raid; Rogue One is the first in-depth space battle since Return Of The Jedi. And it takes full advantage of that.
Thanks to Rogue One’s third act having less of a split focus with all three fronts of the battle crossing over, we get to see more of the space battle as a whole. And because of this focus on actual ship-to-ship engagements; the sequence is able to get inventive and take advantage of the diverse Rebel fleet. Plus the Y-Wings got their cinematic groove back after their bombing runs above Endor were mostly in the background. About time.
And even though it’s not exactly a new development: the CGI ships being created and shot adds some excellent depth to the scenes that’s hard to pull off with compositing. Gareth Edwards being able to direct the virtual cameras with an iPad is also a massive plus because it lends a more natural feel to the battle than what was possible with model shots in the 80s, or a meticulous frame-by-frame creation of an incredibly dense sequence.
3. A Different Story
While the first six Star Wars films all tell specifically different stories, the whole saga follows the same archetype. They’re all large-scale space operas inspired by Akira Kurosawa with the familiar tropes of good vs evil, a fledgling hero, and wise old masters. So for Star Wars’ first spin-off; most of that was parked to the side.
Instead, Rogue One follows different character types on a different journey. There are shades of Han Solo’s journey from smuggler to hero in Jyn and Cassian (although Cassian definitely shot first) but they’re distinct enough not to be piggybacking on his character development. And at the start of the third act, rather than the main characters acting out of pure nobility or to save themselves, we get morally dubious figures deciding to make things right by going on a suicide mission.
But most significantly of all: apart from Chirrut’s untrained connection to the Force, and Darth Vader turning the Rebel flagship into his personal slaughterhouse, the Jedi have no place in this story. This approach has happened a lot in the Legends continuity and in both TV series but it’s the first time that we see it in the movies. And long may it continue.
2. Darth Vader
Until Rogue One, Darth Vader’s only onscreen appearance since Revenge Of The Sith had been some very effective cameos in The Clone Wars and Rebels. And apart from that, he had been kind of neutered by a lack of serious screen-time, and the cumulative effect of plenty of parodies. Also, whatever the hell this was...
But Rogue One fixes all of that and hands him back his brass nuts thanks to the movie’s editor Jabez Ollson, who suggested the final scene of Vader going all slasher movie. If you want to be picky, you could argue that this second Vader appearance in the film wasn’t strictly necessary. Especially since it wasn’t part of the original plan. But it’s more Darth Vader so screw necessary.
As well as helping to restore the image of Darth Vader as a merciless force of evil, It actually manages to bring something new to the party. In the Original Trilogy, Darth Vader always enters the battle after the fighting dies down.
So this is the first time in the movies that we actually see him on the front lines, in a situation where everyone’s disposable except him. Cue as much as violence as a 12A certificate will allow.
1. Binding The Galaxy Together
On top of everything else it had to achieve like proving the viability of Star Wars anthology movies and, you know, actually being good; Rogue One was in the position of being the bridge between the two biggest eras of Star Wars. And although it bumps up right against the Original Trilogy, it ends up tying everything together.
In Rogue One, every film and television element of Star Wars (the canon ones at any rate) pre-Force Awakens comes together. Along with the obvious connections to the Original Trilogy; we get actors and characters from the Prequels, The Clone Wars, and Rebels brought together in one place for the first time. Even the Hammerhead Corvette that plays a pivotal role in the movie first appeared and continues to appear in Rebels.
For the first time in the movies; the hierarchy of canon status from the pre-Disney era is gone, and we really get the sense of everything existing on the same level. It will probably all get junked again in thirty years’ time when there is so much new material that Lucasfilm can’t produce anything set around the Original Trilogy but, for now, Star Wars is one (mostly) coherent story. And it’s Rogue One that finally cemented it as that.
What do you think Rogue One did best? Let us know in the comments below...