Star Wars Episode 7: 10 Things To Avoid

With the shock news yesterday that not only has Disney purchased LucasFilm for a whopping $4.05 billion, but that they are planning to move forward with Star Wars Episode VII, the Internet geek collective exploded with theories about who would be directing it, and what it might actually mean for the franchise as a whole. Being skeptics of Star Wars ever since George Lucas unleashed onto us his (mostly) abominable "new trilogy" of prequels, we can't help but be equally skeptical now that another new film - and potentially another trilogy - is heading our way. That said, without Lucas directing or even producing the project, it's possible that it can be a hit, if his successor is sure to avoid these pitfalls, which range from mistakes that Lucas is frequently criticised for already, to errors in judgement that plague sequels on the whole.

10. Telling The Same Story

There was the definite feeling at the end of Return of the Jedi that the story was neatly tied up, and there was nothing left to tell; Luke, Han, Leia, Chewie and Lando had kicked the Imperial's collective ass, Vader was dead, the Death Star was space dust, and the Ewoks even got to have a little dance. One sure problem is that in every piece of canonical sequel fiction ever written, that was far from the end, and the war continued to rage, with various Imperial administrators fighting for control, sparking a civil war that itself could probably take up a trilogy of films, while they also tried to contend with the rebels. The issue with saying "oh, you thought the war was over? Guess again!", is that it would forever devalue Episode VI's ending because, to be completely frank, people pay a lot more attention to a new movie than they do a spin-off novel, which most would assume is just non-canonical fan-fiction anyway. The best thing they can do with this new Episode is to divorce it as far as possible from Luke's legacy; perhaps make him a mythic figure of the past, and move on with a different, maybe more intimate but nevertheless epic story. Given the expansive nature of this Universe, and how successfully it has been re-interpreted in video games for one, it shouldn't be too difficult, especially if people more talented than Lucas are brought on board.

9. Too Much Green Screen

For the love of God, Xenu, or whoever George Lucas prays to, please tone down the CGI backgrounds and objects in Episode 7. Even the most skilled actors in the series such as Liam Neeson and Samuel L Jackson evidently struggled with the sheer volume of CGI sets that define Lucas' new trilogy. After all, how easy can it be to act opposite a tennis ball stuck to a ruler? The acting evidently suffers, and in the case of the less-skilled members of the cast, such as Hayden Christensen, they could really do with something physical and practical to interact with. There's the hope that with a new creative thrust, perhaps this could be scaled back a bit, giving the series less of a slick feel and more a practical look, perhaps in line with J.J. Abrams' excellent Star Trek reboot, which combines visual effects with real sets superbly. Granted, Star Wars has a far larger, more ambitious aesthetic to maintain, but reining it in just a tad would be worth it if things felt more authentic at the end of it.

8. Wasting Talented Actors

So, after Samuel L. Jackson hinted like crazy that he wanted in on the Star Wars prequels, Lucas made one of his few good decisions of the last fifteen years and cast him as Mace Windu, a Jedi Master who, above all else, should surely be one of the most badass characters in the Star Wars saga, right? Right? What Lucas did, in fact, is cast one of cinema's most likeable actors, and did absolutely nothing with him; he spends the majority of his screen time listening to other characters, and spitting out mundane dialogue about space politics. He rarely gets any big "moments", and his eventual death at the hands of Palpatine - being lighting-blasted out of a window - was surprisingly underwhelming. Despite Jackson being so invested in the series - specifically requesting a purple light sabre, of all things - it's surprising that he didn't lobby harder to, you know, actually do something.

7. Lack Of Strong Female Characters

While the original trilogy certainly had a strong female protagonist in Princess Leia - she was headstrong, whip-smart, self-assured, and cute to boot - the new trilogy suffered a real dearth in this department, especially with the arc of Padmé Amidala (Natalie Portman). In the first entry, she is a relatively intelligent politician, cunning and even not too bad when it comes to handling a weapon, but after hooking up with Anakin, she's rendered inert, a mere piece of window-dressing, a plot device used to propel Anakin to the Dark Side. What's worse is that Lucas doesn't even give her the slightest morsel of common sense; it's clear as day to anyone - whether they've seen the original trilogy or simply exist within the Star Wars Universe - that Anakin is turning evil, and instead she ends up crying far too often, which feels wholly opposed to the steely demeanour that had been previously established. It's another instance of a wasted talent, because Natalie Portman - now an Oscar winner - has been a skilled thesp right from her early days in Luc Besson's Leon. Lucas, unfortunately, failed to harness this, and didn't manage to come up with any other admirable female characters in her stead. Hopefully a writer-director with a more firm grasp on writing women will step up for Episode 7.

6. CGI Mascots

Star Wars fans will frequently tell you that Jar Jar Binks is not only the biggest faux pas in the entire franchise, but probably the biggest in the history of cinema. Jar Jar Binks was introduced in the new trilogy as a means of comic relief, to keep the tone light, and of course, to appeal to children (and therefore sell more merchandise). The problem is that he's not charming and funny like, say, a Pixar character, but instead he's more like the Crazy Frog; loud, obnoxious and extremely, extremely annoying. Even ignoring the fact that many believe Jar Jar to be a racially insensitive stereotype, he's simply a useless, annoying flourish, popping up during countless scenes and ruining them, and just when it seemed like Lucas had seen sense and ditched him from Episode 3, he appears right at the very end, smugly walking along, content that he was able to rile up tens of millions of cinemagoers once again. While it might make financial sense, there's the hope that someone with a little more creative integrity might hop aboard Episode 7. Or better yet, have your cake and eat it; design a commercially viable sidekick character who is also likeable and hilarious. Then everybody's happy.

5. Space Politics

Something George Lucas really dropped the ball on with his prequel trilogy is the plot; outside of Anakin's well-telegraphed arc, the focus on the mind-numbing minutiae of space politics is a dreadful decision for a series that wants to, with its soul-destroying comic side-kicks, aim itself squarely at children (and their parents' pockets). What the film is over-encumbered with is dull, verbose dialogues about absurd trade negotiations we couldn't be paid to care about, and the various cog-turnings that keep things going in space. The innumerable galactic senate hearings are always the parts we fast-forward through when watching the new trilogy again - or at least attempting to - and frankly, they often feel like deleted scenes, given how little import and impact they have on the narrative. Ask someone to recall one of these dialogues, of which there are many - I bet they can't. It is Lucas coasting on the fact that people love his Universe so much that they won't be bored by even the most banal dialogues known to man. He was wrong.

4. Awkward Tonal Shifts

This is a problem for a lot of screenwriters, but for George Lucas, it has been a real thorn in his side for the prequel trilogy. He simply doesn't know how to massage multiple opposed plots together into a meaningful, consistent, emotionally gratifying whole. Take Episode 1, which cuts between a number of different stories with an absolute absence of discrimination; Qui Gon Jinn is slaughtered by Darth Maul, and within mere moments, Lucas cuts to Jar Jar Binks - an already execrable entity in his own right - cracking funnies. While this might sit alright with emotionally developing children, adults are likely to find it grating, even unsettling; we should linger on the pain of Qui Gon's death, because that's how we know that it actually matters. Lucas, disrespecting his own characters in a sense, breezes past the moment of death, creating a wide tonal chasm that just feels...wrong. But at least with someone else at the creative helm, there is a strong possibility this will be fixed for Episode 7.

3. Droid Battles

Somewhat tied into the above complaint about overt CGI, can we please not have anymore bland, soulless droid battles? The problem, as with many similar films, is that the viewer is denied agency by simply watching two blatantly artificial creations do battle against what is also obviously a 100% CGI set. It gets boring and wearisome after a few moments, and the fact that Lucas peppers so many of them throughout the new trilogy is troubling, especially when compounded by the mundane trade dialogues and so on; it reminds us how much filler populates these newer films. While we're not suggesting that Lucas go for practical effects - because, realistically, it won't work and will cost billions - why not at least make some real sets, or better yet, have more humans doing the fighting? Or talk to James Cameron and get him to whip up some machines that actually look convincing. Either way, this is not an animated film, so please populate the screen with some actual human life every once in a while if you want us to get viscerally involved in the action.

2. Letting Lucas Anywhere Near It

This one should be a no-brainer, and given that it appears George Lucas isn't writing, directing or even producing the new film - but simply serving as a consultant - then perhaps a new voice will be able to regain some of Star Wars' esteem and respect. However, there's always the worry that once a new film succeeds - and after all, Lucas only said he wouldn't be working on the one film - that he might try and get in on the action for subsequent films. The best thing anyone can tell George at that juncture is, of course: no. While Lucas is unquestionably a better director than he is a writer - who can forget his classic "I hate sand..." speech from Episode II - he's best kept at arm's length from the project as much as possible. Give him final cut privileges, but let a new creative talent get the chance to place their own stamp on a franchise that has become an embarrassment in recent years. One can hope that, given the poor esteem of the newer films, Lucas has been scared off touching it again.

1. Competing With The Original Trilogy

Whoever tackles Episode 7 absolutely cannot try to do this, because it will not work; our nostalgia for the original characters is sufficiently strong that reaching to evoke a similar feeling will come off as desperate. It would be better to do as Lucas did initially, and build a foundation of characters which, if the first one is a hit, we might come to love in later instalments. Distance here will be crucial, given that Episode 7 will not only have to contend with most likely establishing a new band of heroes, but also a new villain, and of course, living up to Luke's crew and Vader's Empire will prove extraordinarily difficult. Similarly, the Death Star is such an iconic vehicle, that though the temptation with sequels is always to go bigger - and therefore "better" - size really won't matter if it doesn't come to mean something first. Simply, whoever ends up scribing Episode 7 needs to nail the fundamentals before they try and focus on weaving a new myth. How are you feeling about the announcement of Episode 7? Excited? Terrified? Angry? And what other pitfalls will the filmmakers need to avoid? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Frequently sleep-deprived film addict and video game obsessive who spends more time than is healthy in darkened London screening rooms. Follow his twitter on @ShaunMunroFilm or e-mail him at shaneo632 [at] gmail.com.