Star Wars Episode 7 - 7 Composers Who Could Replace John Williams

Who Should Direct?; Which Characters Could Return?; Mistakes to Avoid - collectively debating every possible aspect of Episode VII. Now that Disney has announced that Michael Arndt will be writing the screenplay for Episode VII, it's only a matter of time before a director is announced, and soon after that the rest of the main crew positions, including the all important duty of who will compose the score for what will be one of the most anticipated films in years. Let me be clear - it's not my intent to suggest anyone other than John Williams should do the score, presuming he's still healthy, able and willing to do so. But let's be honest, he just turned 80 earlier this year, and his once prolific output has slowed to only coincide with Steven Spielberg movies. In fact, you'll have to go all the way back to Episode III in 2005 to find a non-Spielberg movie on his resume/CV. But again, if Williams is healthy and willing, this job should go to him and no one else. The purpose of this article is to suggest who might be able to fill his admittedly large shoes and score the new Star Wars film(s) should Williams decide not to do it, or if the unthinkable happens and he simply doesn't live that long. (If it were up to me, John Williams would be granted immortality and score every film, but we all know that's not gonna happen). So without further ado, here are 7 composers (and one honorable mention) that could take on the unenviable job of following John Williams into the depths of the Star Wars universe.

Honorable Mention: James Horner

Listing all the highlights of James Horner's career would take too long, there are that many. Suffice to say, James Cameron, Ron Howard and Mel Gibson won't make a movie without him behind the conductor's podium. His style is very classic - lots of brass and strings - and he's certainly able to create a "big" sound, which would be necessary for a Star Wars score. In fact, he's already got experience scoring movies that take place in, or close to, space - Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan, and Avatar. He's also scheduled for Avatar 2 & 3, so that would most likely prevent him from jumping over to Star Wars. Now, on to the list...

7. Thomas Newman

Why Him? Thomas Newman is currently wowing anyone who listens to his score for Skyfall, and rightfully so. It's grand, yet subtle. Aggressive, yet tender. And it really knows how to sneak up and punch your ears in the face. There are those who might feel that his sound is too sparse and spatial for the Star Wars universe. To those people, I would direct you to listen to his score for Wall*E. It's Newman's most accomplished score, ranging from the small and intimate to the grandiose and bombastic, and it's a perfect example of what he could do with an interstellar canvas. (For a more thorough charting of his pre-Skyfall evolution, check this out.) Plus with Skyfall, he's shown he can step into an existing franchise, with existing themes and put his own spin on it, while turning in terrific work. (He's actually one of several on this list that have jumped into existing franchises, and one of two Bond composers.)

6. Howard Shore

Why Him? Oh, I don't know - he's only an Oscar winner who scored one the greatest trilogies of all time. (If you don't recognize that graphic design from above, the aforementioned trilogy is Lord of the Rings.) He typically evokes emotion through the use of stringed instruments, but he does employ brass flourishes from time to time with great verve and intensity - something required of a Star Wars score. A lot of today's composers are getting bitten by the generic action/drama type score, with very little identifiable melodies to hum in your head afterward, but Howard Shore is experienced in creating several different that themes work together on a large canvas. This is of course, another crucial element of the Star Wars universe - think Han & Leia's theme, Vader's Imperial March, Luke's theme, etc. Now try to imagine a Star Wars score without those themes, and in their place, some generic driving rhythm. Yeah, I don't like it either. That's not to say that Star Wars should never employ a driving, syncopated, drum heavy rhythm during an action scene, but it'll be so much better to have an actual melody. Shore can do that. (Side note - I'm streaming the score to The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey while I'm writing this, and it's very good.)

5. James Newton Howard

Why Him? He's a terrific composer that earn's the loyalty of just about every director he works with. Tony Gilroy, M. Night Shyamalan and Christopher Nolan have all worked with him more than once, as have several others. The reason for that is his versatility and willingness to have a little fun - both desirable traits in a Star Wars score. His score for Duplicity is great, and I listen to it about once every week or two. (The movie is also criminally underrated and overlooked, but that's another article.) The reason I mention Duplicity is not because it has any relation to what Episode VII will look or sound like, but as an example of how he can match the score to fit the vibe and feeling of the movie. It's a fun movie, that has fun with itself, and the music compliments this idea beautifully. On the flipside, his score for Blood Diamond, released the same year is gritty, brooding and intense. Plus,you have Batman Begins and The Dark Knight, which he co-wrote with Hans Zimmer (more from him in a minute). Those films couldn't be more opposite from Duplicity, and the scores keep up without missing a beat (pun intended). Next to John Williams, he's one of the most versatile composers working today. He's also another composer who's jumped into established franchises before - The Bourne Legacy the most recent example of this.

4. Hans Zimmer

Why Him? He's Hans Freaking Zimmer for one. For two, he just finished up a stint on one of the biggest and best trilogies of all time (you know the one), teaming up with James Newton Howard for the first two, and going it alone for The Dark Knight Rises. His score for TDKR was nothing short of amazing, and overall he's never been better than he is right now. His scores for the Sherlock Holmes series have displayed a sense of whimsy that he would need to bring to Star Wars, and we all know he can do booming action scenes like nobody's business. The one thing that could count against him, and it's minor, is his tendency to use less brass than most typical Star Wars scores. However, Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End was a terrific score that's one of his best, and that would probably be more in line with what we'd get from a Zimmer Star Wars - more so than his Batman work anyway. He's also one more composer on this list who's jumped into an existing franchise with existing musical themes and turned out great work in the process - Pirates 2 & 3, Batman (though this one doesn't count as much), and the upcoming Man of Steel. The interesting thing about Man of Steel is he initially stated he didn't want the job, because the original theme - by who else, but John Williams - was so iconic, and the job of composing the score would be "unenviable." But he ended up taking it anyway. Maybe he'll have the same attitude toward Star Wars.

3. Alan Silvestri

Why Him? Can you name another composer from the 1980's that left his mark on film music in a big way, other than John Williams? If you can, chances are that composer is Alan Silvestri. His work on Who Framed Roger Rabbit, Predator and my personal favorite movie of all time, Back to the Future, stands second only to Williams in terms of recognizable work from that era. In fact, since he's long been seen as playing second fiddle to Williams' first chair violin (strained metaphor?), he might want a shot at taking on the themes of the big man himself, to finally earn the mainstream respect I feel he deserves. Some might say that he's largely laid low for the better part of the last 15 years since Forrest Gump, and up until last year, I'd have been inclined to agree with you. However, with his score for Captain America: The First Avenger - the best, most memorable one from Marvel's Phase One films - and then the score for The Avengers this year, he's proven that he's still got the ability to turn in crowd pleasing work in the old school style. This is what Star Wars needs.

2. David Arnold

Why Him? Outside of number one on this list, his style is the closest to John Williams. He loves that big, bold, brassy sound, but he's also capable of writing small, intimate moments that are haunting and compelling. That alone makes him a great candidate for Episode VII. Further examination of his oeuvre indicates a versatility that is imperative for any Star Wars composer. His scores, especially Independence Day, are also a blast to listen to on their own. (This can be said for everyone on the list, but still.) Most recently, he was the resident James Bond composer, turning in great work from Tomorrow Never Dies through Quantum of Solace, losing Skyfall to Sam Mendes' right hand man Thomas Newman. (For those keeping track of this random stat - that makes him another composer to jump into an existing franchise.) If it weren't for the next composer on this list, and their stratospheric rise in the last 8 years, David Arnold would be the best, and most likely choice to compose the score for Episode VII. Who's this brash young upstart you ask?

1. Michael Giacchino

Why Him? There are numerous reasons the job is his to lose: He's risen to the A-list of composers ridiculously quickly. After starting in TV (Alias, Felicity) and doing video game work (Medal of Honor), Giacchino made the jump to feature film with his terrific score for The Incredibles, which was widely hailed as the biggest breakthrough moment by any composer since David Arnold's ID4 score. It's fun, playful, action oriented and just all around great. He's JJ Abrams go-to guy, scoring all of his movies (they were childhood friends), and basically Pixar's resident composer, having done Ratatouille, Up (which he won an Oscar for), Cars 2 and numerous shorts since The Incredibles. He was the composer for LOST during all 6 seasons, and is currently composing Fringe, which makes all his film work done at the same time, even more impressive. He's the type of composer that believes in the old school melodies and themes for different characters that all work together to create a broad canvas of a score. This is primarily because he's the only composer who's outwardly admitted to having been directly influenced by John Williams and his style. (He's also the youngest person on this list.) And, oh yeah - Steven Spielberg has all but officially anointed him the spiritual successor to John Williams' crown. Watch the Super 8 special featurette on the music to see Spiels gush over Giacchino like a fanboy gushes over Spielberg. The main reason he says all this is because Giacchino writes/records his music for/by a live orchestra - an increasingly diminishing practice. Lastly, the biggest reason for Giacchino to get the job is because, if my prediction holds true, Brad Bird will get the directing job for Episode VII. And with the exception of The Iron Giant, Giacchino has scored every Bird movie, Mission Impossible: Ghost Protocol being the most recent - and the final example of a composer jumping into an existing franchise. (He actually jumped in with JJ and MI:3, but still.) So there you have it. Any of these men could do a terrific job at composing Episode VII's score, if John Williams doesn't, but Michael Giacchino is the number one choice. Agree? Disagree? Let me know in the comments below. Until next time, I'm Savage Ron, reminding you to stay savage!

Contributor
Contributor

Lifelong lover of film. Married to a wonderful woman, newly 30, and a brand new father of a beautiful baby boy. Writer, editor, director, and all around savage beast.