Suicide Squad's Extended Cut: 8 Problems The Movie Needs To Fix
Now we know why they call it the DC 'Extended' Universe...
Blockbuster movies are incredibly expensive to produce. Once you factor in marketing, cast and crew, visual effects and reshoot costs, overall budgets can very easily outscale the 200, 300, even 400 million dollar mark - and recouping that cash is the number one goal.
So when we get an extended cut for a movie on this scale, it's usually a financial move on the part of the studio. They know it'll pique our interest and we'll be more likely to part with our cash, to get more of a movie that we loved, or a better movie than one that proved unfulfilling in cinemas.
Suicide Squad leaned toward the latter camp when it released this past August. Love it or hate it, there's no avoiding it had a handful of notable issues that prevented it from being the runaway success DC desperately needed after the reaction to Batman V Superman. The movie didn't feel fully complete or coherent, with several gaps in logic, haphazard subplots and wasted characters making for a rather unsatisfying cinematic experience.
But fortunately, the extended edition has an opportunity to fix all that. We're not expecting the studio to rectify every single complication the movie had, but if the additional 13 minutes address even one, two or half of the following issues, then Suicide Squad will be all the better for it. Here are eight problems that it needs to fix!
8. Slipknot's Lack Of Screen Time
Imagine you're actor Adam Beach and you've just signed a contract with Warner Bros to appear in Suicide Squad. The contract stipulates that your character is to die, but at least you get a cool backstory before that happens! You sit down to watch the finished cut, and then... disaster. All your scenes have been axed, and your character is reduced to a plot device to show how Rick Flag's remote explosives work.
It's pretty laughable to watch, too. This guy is introduced as a complete !*$%, (he punches someone in the face the very second he steps on-screen) but minutes later, his head's blown off, making you wonder why the filmmakers bothered to include him in the first place. If all he needs to do is die, why waste a potentially interesting character in such a brainless fashion?
Well - it's because Slipknot was originally in the film a lot more. Speaking to Empire, director David Ayer revealed that his team shot a backstory sequence for the character, and that Adam Beach dabbled in combat training to prepare for his role in the film. This means that somewhere out there, there's a good chunk of Slipknot footage just lying about, and the extended cut needs to put it back in.
For starters, it felt odd to watch every other character get a flashback sequence or flashy title animation, and Slipknot to get nothing. Because he's introduced in such a throwaway fashion, you instantly know that he's expendable, and you're just waiting for him to die instead of, you know... caring about him as a character.
We're not asking for Slipknot to avoid death - that's built directly into the film. But that death would've been a much weightier moment if the movie at least tried to make his character seem important, or interesting, or... human - and the extra footage could do just that.
7. The Virtually Nonexistent Second Act
Suicide Squad's most common criticisms generally stem from its structure and pacing. The movie seems like it's in a rush to sprint to the boss fight and get to all the action, and consequently, it lacks a definitive second act. When watching the movie, this may seem like a relatively minor problem, but it actually carries a lot more consequence than you'd think.
The first act mostly consists of introductions and backstories - which is fine - but then the team is unceremoniously shoved together and sent after the big-bad, and the movie just devolves into one long third-act action sequence. What we should've got, in between those two moments, is a much longer second act, and ideally, this would consist of us spending more time with the team before all the shooting and quipping starts.
We've seen many shots in the trailers that could provide this - Deadshot gazing at the rain, deep in thought, El Diablo contemplating then extinguishing a flame, Rick and June sharing a moment - and these tiny pieces, when combined, could help flesh the characters out. Currently, they're not fleshed out at all. The squad is a collection of wacky personas and surface-level relatability that lacks real depth because the movie, judging by the trailers, chose to cut most of it out.
By filling out the middle of Suicide Squad a little bit more, the extended cut could give us that depth the theatrical cut sorely lacked.
6. The Choppy Editing
Here's another issue with Suicide Squad's structure and pacing, but one that permeated the entire movie. Even though the film was over two hours long, it constantly felt like it was zipping along at a lightning pace, trying to cram in as much as it possibly could and failing to leave scenes the breathing room they desperately needed.
The movie jumps from flashbacks to exposition to action and dream sequences in a breathless fashion, appearing as though it's trying to mask its shortcomings behind a flurry of quick edits and montages. Adding more fuel to the fire, the finished film was apparently stitched together by a company that specialises in producing film trailers, which explains Suicide Squad's overly kinetic feel.
Subsequently, at least one or two of those 13 extra minutes should be used to just slow things down a bit. They don't need to add any extra footage here - just make the action less choppy by holding those shots a bit longer, and make the film's overall editing less tight. This makes it easier for audiences to follow along and understand what's going on, which works wonders in a movie that's as chock-full of characters and plot threads as this one is.
5. The Movie Didn't Settle On A Single Tone
David Ayer's original cut of Suicide Squad was reportedly a lot darker than the one we got. Warner Bros didn't like it, however, scheduling reshoots to make the movie a bit lighter, resulting in a finished product that combined Ayer's grit with a candy-coloured sheen that's typically found over at Marvel. Consequently, Suicide Squad was a tonal mess, and it would be far better if the extended edition stuck to its guns and picked one side over the other.
It's not even like these problems were subtle, either; they were blatant. One moment, Rick Flag is giving a super-serious, hard-edged lecture to the squad before they set out on their mission, and seconds later, Eminem's 'Without Me' starts playing over a humorous montage. The film was full of illogical juxtapositions like this, and it made the entire product rather jarring to watch.
So how can the extended cut help? Given that we know there's a darker 'Ayer' cut out there somewhere, it would be wise for this version to be reinstated as fully as possible, or at least scenes exclusive to that reintroduced. For starters, a grittier feel is a much better fit for the film's premise (a group of violent, despicable supervillains) and it would also bring Suicide Squad more in line with the rest of the DC universe tonally.
Plus, by settling on a single direction, the film will feel more confident in itself, rather than coming across as slapdash and carelessly thrown together.
4. Joker & Harley's Relationship Wasn't Convincing
Harley and Joker's twisted romance was one of Suicide Squad's biggest selling points; after all, it's a relationship we've never seen play out on the big screen before. And while there were a couple of standout moments, the pieces never really gelled, and it came off as more than a little bit forced.
To be fair, it's clear that a lot of this material was cut out - the film's trailers are proof of that. Still, that appreciation doesn't stop the subplot from being any less convoluted; we don't really understand why Harley is so infatuated with Joker other than that the script says so, and the characters seem to be riding on their comic-book history for their on-screen love story to make sense.
Case in point; we see the pair sat at a table, with Dr Harleen Quinzel questioning a restrained Joker. Joker asks her to deliver him a machine gun, and the scene cuts to a shot of those guns in action. Shouldn't there be a scene in between those two that shows Harley falling under his spell and being driven to retrieve the weapon for him?
Well, yes. And there is! We've seen leaked set videos of Harleen Quinzel holding the clown at gunpoint before he talks her out of it, and the trailers showed shots of the psychiatrist riding a motorcycle, chasing down the Joker's sports car. Adding this footage back in could make an unconvincing relationship a lot more coherent, filling in some of the blanks the theatrical cut mistakenly left us to decipher.
3. Enchantress's Powers Were Poorly Explained
Unlike your regular run-of-the-mill villain - whose powers are definable and abilities usually simple to quantify - Enchantress, with all her spells and incantations, lacks an easily distinguishable set of limits. Because she's magic, we don't really know the full extent of her powers, and that's problematic.
Worse, Suicide Squad never even attempted to explain what she can and can't do, and that left her skillset feeling quite hazy. If she's so powerful, why can't she just destroy the squad with a wave of her hand? Why can't she just teleport her heart back to her? Again, the trailers showed a bunch of axed scenes that could've helped here.
There was a shot of June saying "let's do something fun". Fun with her abilities, perhaps? Did she use/explain more of them in this scene? Or, perhaps the feeling of love can suppress her magic, and it's her connection to Rick that's holding back her powers? We see a couple of shots of the pair getting rather close, so at the very least there was more to their relationship than in the finished film.
It's a lot of assuming, but that's all we can do when we don't have all the information. What we do know is that Ayer shot a lot of June/Enchantress footage that he never used, and these scenes could fill in the missing pieces. This may make the villain feel like more of a threat - if we know what she can do, we know what she's capable of, and that's more compelling to watch.
2. Unanswered Questions. So Many Of Them...
Because of Suicide Squad's aforementioned structural and editing problems, a lot of questions were left dangling. Usually, this would be fine; most movies have one or two. But when your film has one every five minutes - and some are quite glaring - it becomes a huge distraction.
And because of all these missteps, the movie just feels unpolished. How exactly does Katana's sword work? What happened to Griggs, the prison guard who reluctantly works for Joker? If Harley's so infatuated with the Clown Prince, why doesn't she go and find him instead of willingly returning to prison?
And bizarrely, the film's promotional material reveals that these questions do have answers that got cut. We see an omitted shot of Katana brandishing her sword with a green, smoky glow around it, which could've explained her powers. In pretty much every trailer, Joker says he "can't wait" to show Griggs his toys, meaning there could've been a scene showing the prison guard being tortured.
The 'bar' scene was originally a lot longer too. Trailers showed Harley taking drink requests from her squad-mates, where the movie just cuts to Diablo's depressing backstory. By making and gathering drinks for them, we can see that some part of Harley cares and it then makes sense that she'd stick by them instead of galavanting back to the Joker at the end.
Even the smallest of inconsistencies can yank someone right out of a film, and with the sheer amount on display here, the extended edition would be wise to start filling out some of those more questionable moments.
1. The Joker Was Superfluous
1255311Suicide Squad is a film of solid pieces and moments that never quite come together. Jared Leto's Joker practically personifies this train of thought, with his take on the character proving to be genuinely fresh and creative while simultaneously feeling like it belongs in a completely different movie.
For starters, he's only on-screen for about ten minutes, and seems rather inconsequential to the main plot. The film almost knows this, too - right after he rescues Harley, his helicopter crashes and he vanishes for nearly 40 minutes, leaving her right back where she started and proving that the story can chug along just fine without his presence.
From the trailers (and Jared Leto's own comments), we know that there's tonnes of Joker footage that was left on the cutting room floor. But rather than just adding it back in haphazardly, the filmmakers must be careful to reinstate scenes that bring the Joker's tale more in line with the squad's.
This footage does exist - the trailers showed shots of him with a burnt face, a scene that reportedly involved a brief encounter with Deadshot and the gang. Why cut this out?! As it stands, you could literally remove the Joker from the film and it wouldn't change one bit.
By adding these small details back in, the character will actually feel like he belongs in the movie, and we won't be left with a string of random scenes that - while pretty engaging in their own right - feel completely, and utterly, out of place.
What do you want to see from Suicide Squad's extended cut? Drop us a comment down below!