Terminator: Dark Fate Trailer Reactions - 6 Ups & 6 Downs
Sarah Connor is BACK! And that's... good?
The Terminator franchise is as inevitable as the tides. No matter how many poor sequels there seem to be (three if we're counting specifically), the studio fundamentally believes that there is enough fan enthusiasm and confidence in the brand to justify them continuing to make them. For a while, that was growing tiresome, but then in the wake of Genisys' failure (not at the box office, but critically), Paramount played their trump card by revealing they were rebooting back to Judgment Day and bringing back Linda Hamilton to play Sarah Connor.
Given how well the Halloween rebootquel did by following that exact same nostalgia-soaked model, this was always going to be a good idea and it gave Paramount a definite marketing hook for the movie beyond the Terminator brand generally. Whether they'd deliver on it properly or not was very much in the balance though, because everyone remembers the Genisys marketing campaign all too well.
And not the first teaser is out and we have more of an idea of what we can expect. Here's the trailer...
It's by no means terrible, but there are definitely some points of interest in there that are... less than inspiring to say the least. Then again, there are also things absolutely worthy of praise.
First, let's get into those negatives...
Downs
6. There's Literally A Glitch In It!!
So, if you're going to do a countdown and make a really prestigious event of your hotly-anticipated trailer (and it was hotly-anticipated as around 12k people were watching the countdown live as the trailer kicked off), you should definitely make sure it's actually been checked for bugs.
That clearly hasn't happened here, because at around the halfway point when Sarah Connor says "I've never seen one like you before," her face literally glitches. It's like she's Princess Vanelope from Wreck-It Ralph. It might seem picky, but come on, how many people watched this and missed that?!
5. Isn't This The Exact Same Plot As Logan?
It's always going to be difficult to do much different with a Terminator movie that hasn't been done before, which is why seeing an evil machine hunting key humans and a good Terminator protecting them and the Connor family being involved is entirely to be expected and completely forgivable. It's just the staple of the series by now and trying to reinvent the wheel wouldn't have worked when the story is ostensibly about reframing Sarah Connor's involvement.
But there's more than just brand familiarity here, because the idea of a superhero (by another name, but that's what she is) escorting an important individual who is key to the end of the world as they know it while being pursued by nefarious agents of death is basically the plot of Logan. Like, beat for beat the same. It even seems to be set in a sort of sun-bleached desert wasteland near-future for the most part. It can't be accidental.
It also doesn't help that this feels an awful lot like the Sarah Connor Chronicles story, which fans are bound to pick up on too.
4. It's Not Working Hard To Stress The Difference
To its eternal credit, the Halloween reboot/sequel mash-up marketed itself perfectly as a palate-cleanser designed to wipe the insufferably bad sequels out of existence. Sure, it killed off a couple of decent follow-ups, but by making it clear, front and centre that it was a follow-up only to the original, it scored extra points with fans who had grown disillusioned with the franchise.
It would be fair to say that Dark Fate had the same duty and the same opportunity. We've already been told that it's following on from the timeline of Terminator 2 and ignoring everything else (it has to, because otherwise Sarah Connor would be dead), but the trailer basically ignores that huge marketing opportunity. Other than Sarah Connor appearing, there's no allusion to it at all.
In essence, what you get is a sequel that still feels like the sixth film in the series rather than the third (and a soft reboot). And given how awful Genisys was, this film needed to SCREAM its status as a fixer/reboot a hell of a lot louder than this, because this just doesn't make it clear enough organically.
3. It's Awfully Dark
Who turned out the lights? Some of the shots in there are pretty great, with an eye for composition and cinematographic depth that makes it look genuinely beautiful. And then there are other scenes that are simply not visible at all.
This is the film's first teaser: it should be setting everything out as frankly as possible, not shrouding it all in darkness and inviting accusations of a lighting imbalance. And yet here we are, doing exactly that because some of the sequences in there are impenetrably dark.
It's not a problem limited to this trailer by any means, because too many films equate atmosphere with "no light" and because darkness masks lots of effects work, but it's still frustrating enough to warrant mention.
2. Some Of The Effects Are A Little... Iffy
While a lot of the effects in here are great (and so they should be, because the whole metallic fluid Terminator thing has been their bread and butter for ages), there are others that are not great.
The sequence showing the new villain Terminator jumping from his truck through the air makes it very obvious that he's been 100% renders using VFX and he's got a very pronounced rubber-face look. It's almost at Agent Smith fighting Neo in the Matrix sequels levels of rubber-face, in fact. It actually looks more like a video game cut-scene than a live-action one.
It's not even like you can blame it on incomplete effects, because that's not what this looks like (it's usually very obvious) - it just doesn't look all that great.
1. The Music... Oh God The Music
The idea that the best music for a trailer is always a stripped down, indie version of an existing song is not one that's going away without a fight. Even when fans taunt trailers that do it for being cliches and the kind of musicians who record those parred down versions have become the subject of mocking from some quarters, trailer companies still love them.
Dark Fate takes this to an entirely new level by using Bjork's song "Hunter," which fundamentally is not very good (though what it lacks in quality, it makes up for in weirdness, so that's something) and stripping it down thanks to RIAYA (who is accompanied by vocalist John Mark McMillan). The result is an improvement on the original, but it doesn't fit the trailer beyond a vague marriage of the lyrics and the storyline.
Given how consciously silly the rest of the trailer looks, it would have been WAY better for them to just use something like Ballroom Blitz or a high-octane but poppy rock song. Really push the silliness rather than forcing this strange sombreness that isn't right for it at all.
And now to the positives...
Ups
6. The Fast & Furious Vibes
Where Terminator: Genisys went wrong was by introducing a lot of silliness (like the father/son-in-law daftness of Pop and Jai Courtney's relationship and the whole time travel thing) but pretending that it was still a serious film. The film-makers got the tone tragically wrong and we were fed what was supposed to be a high-concept, highly complex sci-fi with weirdness bolted on that seemed to have been written by a high-functioning toddler.
While the first half of this trailer provides a similar vibe, by the end, it's gone full Fast & Furious with planes crashing into each other and into cars and the suggestion that this is going to be more on the brainless action side rather than it trying to pretend to be sci-fi high-art. After all, the first two Terminators weren't great because they aspired to be smart or over-written, they were great because they were entertaining and used a strong concept efficiently. Since then, the conceit has been balled up into so much nonsensical sci-fi lore that it's lost its appeal.
Hopefully, Tim Miller is bringing back something a bit more purely entertaining and the hints are certainly there.
5. Very Little Arnie
As soon as Arnold Schwarzenegger took time out from his being kicked in the back schedule to reveal that the trailer for Dark Fate was coming in 48 hours, some big alarms should have started going off because it suggested that he would be the primary marketing hook for the entire movie. You know, despite the fact that the return of the OG Sarah Connor is the ACTUAL selling point.
That could have led to him being absolutely all over this trailer, dragging his massive, hulking frame around and looking like he shouldn't be getting into fights at all at his age (see also: Genisys), but we can all let out a massive sigh of release.
Mercifully, the trailer includes him just once, looking like Old Man Logan - sorry Old Man Terminator - and answering the door to the trio of female badasses so he can hopefully not save the day as the only male character... Anyway, less is definitely more with Arnie and no matter what they do with him in the film, keeping him away from being the chief marketing tool is a smart and very welcome move.
4. The Terminator Action (and Most Of The Effects)
If you're a fan of the Terminator movies, you're a fan of the pillars of the franchise that stuck around even when the sequels started to deliver poorer and poorer results. You want to see cyborgs fighting, you want to see evolved Terminators showing off new skills and techinical abilities and you want to see some human (or human-allied) heroes trying to stop the end of the world.
Thankfully, most of that is delivered on and most rewarding of all is the look at the new Terminator (played by Agents Of SHIELD's Gabriel Luna), who combines an exoskeleton (seemingly made of a harder, darker new metal) and the liquid metal of the T-1000 and is able to multiply himself by stripping the liquid element of his body from the exoskeleton.
The effects for that showcase look really great and it's really hard not to admire what's gone into it and if we get as great action throughout the film as this teaser seems to be hinting at, Tim Miller will have delivered on one of the key elements of his brief with applomb.
3. It Really IS The Exact Same Plot As Logan? (But There's New Stuff)
Look, so for all the complaints about the similarities with existing stories like Logan, there's a good reason for them leaning on that sort of familiarity - Logan is great. The idea of a machine with existential anxiety seeking to protect a human who will be key to the future and the defeat of Skynet (presumably) and them travelling on a roadtrip while trying to stay alive is a genuinely good way of framing this monster movie.
It means we don't get too drowned in futurism and we can return to the perverse horror of something so deadly from an alien future coming to OUR world and showing such disdain. That's where Genisys and Salvation fell down - they forgot that the appeal here was the same as any slasher/monster movie where real people are chased through real environments where they're supposed to feel safe by something completely super-real.
And on top of that, the fact that Mackenzie Davis' Grace doesn't recognise Sarah Connor hopefully means that we aren't just going to get ANOTHER story where John Connor is the chief narrative thrust. After Genisys, wiping him out of the story for a while was always going to be a good decision.
2. Sarah Connor Front And Centre
While the trailer opens a little confusingly on Mackenzie Davis' Grace and Natalia Reyes' Dani Ramos (as well as very briefly showing Diego Boneta's unnamed character) - confusingly because we have literally no idea who any of them are and it's not framed to really offer any answer to that consciously - the focus changes when Linda Hamilton's Sarah Connor returns.
This should always have just been about her, because the film's biggest selling point is indeed her return, and the decision not only to go with a strong female focus for the trailer but also keeping Hamilton at the heart of things is a very smart move. It gives her a sort of Old Man Luke Skywalker feel and it's very obvious that she's still the badass she was in Judgment Day.
If you can't get excited about Linda Hamilton wielding a sem-automatic shotgun and a great big bazooka, there's no point in even watching another Terminator trailer. Because this is her world and we just keep it tidy for her.
1. It Doesn't Drop A Great Big Bloody Spoiler In There
The minute this trailer didn't follow Genisys' lead of literally spoiling the film's biggest twist with utter disdain for its audience, it became infinitely better than the entire Genisys marketing campaign.
Now, it is slightly a shame showing that Grace is a cyborg, but that was heavily rumoured almost from day one of her announcement and it doesn't lose anything for showing that really. More importantly, most of the story is protected - or the key details are, at least.
What we know is that there's a new Terminator chasing Dani Ramos for some reason, Sarah Connor turns up as some sort of Terminator hunter and then their trip takes them back to meet Arnie's ageing T-800 for some reason. Beyond that, there's teases of action sequences, but the biggest focus is on atmosphere and emotion rather than just outright cheap spoilers. Let's hope they stick to that for the subsequent trailers, eh?
What did you think of this trailer?