The Avengers Vs. Avengers: Infinity War - Which Is Better?
Does the classic original hold up?

With the honeymoon period surrounding Avengers: Infinity War starting to cool down, it's much easier to have an even-handed discussion about the merits and flaws of the Russo brothers' epic superhero tentpole.
In particular, we can figure out exactly how it stands up against the comic book team-up movie that started them all: Joss Whedon's 2012 classic, The Avengers.
While Whedon's 2015 follow-up, Avengers: Age of Ultron, is clearly the weakest of the three Avengers movies to date, the original and Infinity War meanwhile stand tall as arguably the two strongest entries into the Marvel Cinematic Universe to date.
Certainly, nothing can match them in terms of scale and audience impact, but by considering each movie in every category that matters - from direction, to characters, writing and technicals - we can figure out which film rules the roost once and for all.
Critics tend to side with Whedon's movie, while audience metrics favour Infinity War. So, by digging deep into the meat of each blockbuster, let's get a decisive answer once and for all...
15. Direction

Though Joss Whedon did a fantastic job bringing The Avengers together for their first outing, it's fair to say that the movie's direction is one of its weakest aspects.
Whedon, who is better-versed in the world of TV, tends to stick to fairly uninspired shot selections that feel like they belong in a TV show (that awesome money shot of the team aside, of course).
The Russos, meanwhile, have a far more ambitious canvas to work with, and having cut their teeth on two prior Captain America movies, feel far more at home with the cinematic scope of Infinity War.
Winner: Infinity War, without question. The Russos' craft matches the majesty of the production, whereas Whedon seems rather like he's punching above his weight.
14. Pacing

Unsurprisingly, neither of these films are short movies. The Avengers clocks in at 143 minutes, but in large part due to the novel appeal of seeing this collection of superheroes brought together for the first time, it absolutely flies by.
While Loki's (Tom Hiddleston) imprisonment might feel a tad overlong on rewatches when you know what's coming, overall Whedon does marvellous work lingering on the right moments and knowing when to speed ahead.
Similarly, Infinity War is highly enthralling for most of its 149 minutes, though it's fair to say the movie is sometimes a little too breathless and frantic for its own good, rushing through early character iterations and team-ups because, somewhat understandably, there's so much to cram in.
Winner: Neither disgraces themselves here, but The Avengers wins out because it never once feels rushed or in a hurry to race to the main event.
13. The Heroes

The Avengers may seem at an immediate disadvantage if only because it's dealing with a much smaller stable of superheroes, but that also gives the movie a laser-trained focus, with Whedon actually able to put all six mainline Avengers in the same room. From the early squabbles through to their third-act team-up, it's all splendidly done.
Infinity War meanwhile smartly compartmentalises the heroes into a number of disparate groups, because attempting to have them all share the screen for most of the movie would've been a director's worst nightmare.
These pairings are generally terrific - especially Thor (Chris Hemsworth) and the Guardians - and the sheer wealth of heroes on screen at any moment gives it an easy leg-up from the get-go.
Winner: It's a tough one, because The Avengers has a more natural dynamic, yet Infinity War has an insane fleet of characters and some truly inspired teamings. We'll go with Infinity War, but it's pretty damn close. Drax (Dave Bautista) clinches it, honestly.
12. The Villains

For many, many years, Loki was held up as the MCU's best villain, and as many fans complained about the franchise having a "villain problem", he was the one shining, unambiguous instance of the series touting a charming, bada**, highly entertaining antagonist.
Then Thanos (Josh Brolin) came along. After six years of hype, the Mad Titan finally arrived on the scene, and his Infinity Stone-fuelled rampage certainly didn't disappoint. More than any comic book movie villain in recent memory, his motives were provocative and intriguing, and he truly believed that what he was doing was the absolute right thing for the universe.
Winner: They're both terrific villains, but Thanos' more imposing nature, strong character development and the devastating scale of his warpath make him the definitive victor here.
11. Novelty Factor

It cannot be overstated just how much of a novelty it was to see Iron Man (Robert Downey Jr.), Captain America (Chris Evans), The Hulk (Mark Ruffalo) and so on sharing the screen for the very first time back in 2012. It was wish fulfilment on the most epic scale imaginable, at least at the time. It truly felt like a cinematic event, and honestly still does.
While Infinity War doesn't boast quite the same spine-tingling, goosebump-raising freshness, seeing the likes of Iron Man and Star Lord (Chris Pratt) hanging out for the first time is unmistakably gratifying, even if the character interactions are a little more subdued given the sheer number of characters the Russos have to juggle.
Winner: Infinity War gets a significant boost from the various hero combinations and Thanos' long-awaited arrival, but there's something about the uniqueness of the original 2012 team-up movie that even Infinity War's awe-inspiring scale can't quite replicate. The original still feels the freshest.
10. Narrative

Both of these movies have fairly simple narratives at a base level, with The Avengers revolving around the heroes stopping Loki from conquering Earth, while Infinity War focuses on the scattered Avengers trying to prevent Thanos from acquiring all six Infinity Stones.
In terms of plotting, though, The Avengers feels decidedly more piecemeal, if only because it spends so much time focusing on the interactions between the focal heroes. Infinity War is certainly a more intricate adventure, with Thanos frequently hopping between locales and making some tough calls to get what he wants, all the way up to that stunning ending.
Winner: Infinity War, easily. Both elevate rather basic narratives with their strong execution, but the more recent movie brings with it the full weight of a decade of hype, and dares to go to far darker and more intriguing places.
9. Supporting Cast

The supporting players often end up stealing the show in MCU movies, though this has generally been less-true of the Avengers movies, if only because their presence is severely limited in order to juggle all the superheroes.
The Avengers' prime supporting players include Agent Coulson (Clark Gregg), Nick Fury (Samuel L. Jackson) and Maria Hill (Cobie Smulders), and while Hill is basically just part of the furniture, Coulson has an extremely memorable arc throughout the movie, and Fury is undeniably instrumental in bolstering the team as we know it.
Infinity War has a far larger cast of supporting characters, though as a result they tend to get precious little screen time each: the Black Order are generally forgettable save for the brilliant Ebony Maw (Tom Vaughan-Lawlor), while the likes of Wong (Benedict Cumberbatch), Pepper Potts (Gwyneth Paltrow), M'Baku (Winston Duke), Ned (Jacob Batalon) and countless others feel like fairly cursory additions.
The supporting cast members who actually get something to do - namely Shuri (Letitia Wright), Okoye (Danai Gurira) and Eitri the Dwarf King (Peter Dinklage) - score at least a few memorable moments each, even if they're squarely backseat propositions compared to the dozens of superheroes at the forefront.
Winner: What 2012's The Avengers lacks in numbers it more than compensates for with a ton of heart, with Coulson and Fury especially getting their fair due, while Infinity War's peripheral characters often feel thrown in "just because."
8. Stan Lee's Cameo

What would a Marvel movie be without a Stan Lee cameo? The comic book legend appeared in a TV interview at the end of The Avengers ("Superheros in New York? Give me a break"), and even shot a scene opposite Cap that was eventually deleted (so we can't count it, sadly). It's a cute little moment but nothing more.
In Infinity War, Lee plays the bus driver taking Peter Parker (Tom Holland) and Ned to school, who upon witnessing the Black Order ship arriving in New York City says, "What’s the matter with you kids? You never seen a spaceship before?"
Winner: Neither cameo is one for the ages, in fairness, but The Avengers wins out due to the amusing irony of Lee's line about superheroes in New York, whereas his Infinity War cameo felt decidedly more perfunctory and disposable.
7. Visuals

As fantastic as The Avengers is, it's a bit of a disappointment as a visual package. For starters, Seamus McGarvey's cinematography is extremely bland, full of dull grey colours and rarely capturing the event movie feel it absolutely should.
Combined with Whedon's direction, it too often feels like a high-budget TV show. The visual effects have aged relatively well, though the Chitauri are pretty drab-looking.
Infinity War has an obvious edge visual effects-wise being a brand new release, but even ignoring the fidelity of the CGI itself, the effects are employed to a far more intriguing end, rendering the tricky antagonist in all of his larger-than-life glory. Considering how awkward it can be to make a performance-capture villain work - looking at you, Justice League - they absolutely nailed it.
The movie's trippy, Infinity Stone-influenced shenanigans also lend it an added visual zing, and the cinematography is certainly above-average for the standards of the MCU.
Winner: Infinity War and it's not even close.
6. Music

It's a frequent criticism of the MCU that too many of the movies don't have memorable musical cues, but at least that can't be said about The Avengers. Bringing the legendary Alan Silvestri onboard was a terrific idea, and much like his work on Captain America: The First Avenger, he brings a refreshingly old-school bombast to the mix.
The movie introduced the now-iconic Avengers theme, which is enough to make the musical score an absolute winner.
Infinity War's score was also composed by Silvestri, and while the movie makes occasional re-use of the Avengers theme, there are numerous memorable orchestral cues elsewhere, especially when Scarlet Witch (Elizabeth Olsen) destroys Vision (Paul Bettany) set to "I Feel You", and the subdued, haunting string piece that plays out in Thanos final moment of quiet celebration ("Porch").
Winner: They're both great scores, and Infinity War owes an undeniable debt to The Avengers, but it's also allowed to go to some more interesting places due to the movie's darker tenor. Either way, Silvestri nailed it, and thankfully he's returning for Avengers 4.
5. Action Sequences

Though The Avengers is immediately held back by Whedon's weaker direction and the generally less-interesting visuals, it did nevertheless serve up plenty of scintillating action. The opening car chase is an absolute mess, but the film follows up with a number of highly entertaining beats, namely anything involving The Hulk and the suitably overblown final battle.
Infinity War is insanely action-packed and benefits the most from both its variety and finally delivering on the long-awaited arrival of Thanos. The Infinity Stones simply give the Russos so much more to work with, and they do a great job balancing all the power sets while giving each hero (and villain) their moment to shine.
Winner: The MCU is still waiting for something to topple Civil War's delirious airport fight, but Infinity War came close with The Avengers' desperate battle against Thanos. Both movies struggle through generic fights against faceless CGI enemies, but Infinity War keeps it to a far smarter minimum.
4. Standalone Appeal

While both movies are tied firmly into the fabric of the MCU, how do they stand up to an isolated viewing away from all that wonderful nonsense?
The Avengers is a simply laid-out team-up movie that can be watched and enjoyed even if someone hasn't seen a single prior MCU film. You won't get as much out of it, sure, but it manages to fire broadly without seemingly overly pandering. Though it does set up the arrival of Thanos, it's not much of a muchness at this point.
Infinity War is obviously built off the back of a decade of buzz, so it doesn't work nearly as well when viewed cold, but that's precisely the point. It also ends on a cliffhanger, which again bolsters its agenda as part of a movie universe rather than something your bored uncle might watch and fully understand after randomly stumbling across it on TV.
Winner: The Avengers is the clear winner in this regard, but if it were any other way, Infinity War likely wouldn't be as great as it is.
3. Tone

If there's any one thing that's made the MCU such a huge success, especially in comparison to the DC Extended Universe, it's the tone, which generally keeps things pretty light and jovial, but isn't afraid to get dark and sad when the time calls for it.
The Avengers did a fantastic job setting the tone that most MCU movies have followed, with Joss Whedon liberally fielding out hilarious one-liners, but also making the audience care about Agent Coulson's death in particular. Whedon took the gag-spitting too far with Age of Ultron, but in the original, he totally nailed it.
The Russos and screenwriters Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely had a far more daunting task with Infinity War, given the more sombre, imposing narrative, which had to be interwoven amid the usual wise-cracking MCU shenanigans.
Nobody would've blamed the Russos if the movie had tonal issues, but miraculously, the gags are smartly dispersed and almost never upend any of the Serious Drama.
Winner: Both films have a firm handle on tone, but due to the sheer challenge and complexity involved, Infinity War's consistency is a more impressive achievement.
2. Rewatchability

The MCU's movies are great to revisit when you're struggling to find something new to watch, because they're generally fun, easy, undemanding fare while working within a familiar framework.
The Avengers and Infinity War both no doubt enjoyed a ton of repeat business at the box office and are sure to be loved by legions of fans at home for decades. Whedon's movie has that unmistakable novelty factor, even if it seems positively quaint by the current standards of the MCU.
Infinity War, while certainly a more "epic" movie than The Avengers, is also a less purely "fun" outing due to its bleaker tone and, well, the fact that most of the Avengers "die" at the end.
Winner: If you want something shamelessly, chest-thumpingly upbeat to fill your listless Thursday night, Whedon's movie is definitely the better pick, simply because it's less-heavy and a little warmer to the touch.
Plus, that standalone appeal also works in its favour. Most fans will probably revisit Infinity War time and time again, but you'll probably want to be in the right head-space for it first. The same isn't really true for The Avengers.
1. Overall

And finally, we come to the scores at the doors, to decide which Avengers movie is truly superior. After duking it out in fourteen categories, Joss Whedon's The Avengers scored six wins, while the Russos' Infinity War nailed an impressive eight victories.
And with that, our deep dive of these two heavyweight superhero classics is complete. Infinity War stands tall as the confident victor, even if the one that started it all isn't especially far behind, and they're both top-shelf MCU movies regardless.
It'll be interesting to see how Avengers 4 stacks up against them both, but of course, there's a whole agonising year to wait before that answer is revealed.
Which Avengers movie do you prefer? Shout it out in the comments!