The Batman: 10 Perfect Roles Mahershala Ali Could Play
He’s already Blade, but could the double Oscar winning be coming to Gotham City too?
A new rumour has suggested Mahershala Ali could be joining Matt Reeves and Robert Pattinson on The Batman, as well as heading into the MCU as Blade. He’s a hugely talented actor, having won two Oscars in the past three years for Moonlight and Green Book (trivia: also became the first Muslim to win an acting Oscar), and his career is experiencing a massive rise.
He’s also impressed in True Detective and House Of Cards on the small screen recently, and has superhero experience from his roles as Aaron Davis in Into The Spider-Verse and Cottonmouth in Luke Cage. There’s huge anticipation for his take on Blade, and there’s a plethora of Batman roles he’d be perfect for too.
Ali has enormous range and if the rumours are true, Reeves’ Batman movie becomes even more exciting. With other rumours suggesting their could be up to six villains in the flick, some will likely be slow burn, franchise characters who’ll stick around. Ali’s depth as an actor makes him ideal for this, though he could certainly handle an single starring role too.
That’s not to say antagonist is the only option though. Batman has a sizeable team behind him, and Ali might find a home there instead.
10. Bronze Tiger
Bronze Tiger has already appeared in the Arrowverse, so it’s not like he’s too obscure to ever be adapted on the big screen. With Ezra Miller playing the DCEU version of Flash, they’re clearly keeping it separate from the Arrowverse. Given how successful Arrow and the rest have been though, the DCEU surely has to look to it for inspiration.
Bronze Tiger is especially interesting if there is indeed to be multiple villains in The Batman. He starts out as a villain, though later works together with the Dark Knight and transforms into more of an antihero.
If Ali sticks around for a few films in the franchise (and DC can finally commit to a long term vision), a multi movie arc as Bronze Tiger could be compelling.
9. Hugo Strange
Despite being an enigmatic and complex villain, Hugo Strange has largely gotten the shaft when it comes to Batman adaptations. The Batman: Arkham City game has probably given him the most spotlight, and even then he was overshadowed by the likes of Joker, Ra's al Ghul and Harley Quinn.
BD Wong does a phenomenal job as Strange in Gotham too, but the nature of the show as a Batman series without Batman means it’s always felt a little detached from everything else going on.
In The Batman though, Matt Reeves could pull Hugo Strange firmly into the spotlight. Mahershala Ali might not be the natural first choice, but then how many had Robert Pattinson at the front of the queue to be the caped crusader himself? Ali is an actor capable of great intensity, and could be a dark horse for the role.
As Spider-Verse’s Prowler and Luke Cage’s Cottonmouth, that intensity was more of a ‘foot on your throat’ kind. Hugo Strange will require a more mesmerising brand of terror, perhaps asking Ali to channel his True Detective days. Hugo Strange would certainly make for a layered villain, and is a more grounded choice than the wackier ones on offer.
8. Calendar Man
Even moreso than Hugo Strange, suggesting Calendar Man might feature is a long shot. With Chris Messina set to play Victor Zsasz in Birds Of Prey though, it’s clearly not just the major villains who are getting their chance to shine.
That said, the later, more likely entires here do hypothetically cast Ali as more household names. With nothing confirmed yet though, it’s worth having a little fun with the weirder picks.
Calendar Man, as his name suggests, is a serial killer who murders his victims on specific dates. Quite often he wears a costume corresponding to his murderous holiday as well, and when he debuted in the fifties was viewed as a bit of a joke villain. Since then though, various writers have made him much darker, more twisted and serious.
It would need a lot of gravitas and menace to pull this role off, but Mahershala Ali isn’t short of either.
The fact Calendar Man would only be active on certain dates might be difficult to fold into a longer running franchise, but not impossible. It raises the possibility of a recurring villainous character too, which if the six villains rumours is true will likely happen to at least one of them.
7. Two Face
After a few shots at the moon, Two Face represents a character with a much greater chance of featuring in The Batman, having already been played on the big screen by Billy Dee Williams, Tommy Lee Jones and Aaron Eckhart.
After Nolan’s trilogy explored his origins so perfectly though, there’s a danger that Reeves might not want to put his own spin on the character when there are so many more with stories untold. We all saw how poorly things worked out for Jared Leto’s Joker, after all.
We wouldn’t need to start with the origins though, in fact it’s increasingly becoming a trend to ditch the played out ‘how they got here’ stories. Starting with an already two faced Harvey Dent could help Ali & Reeves’ potential Two Face stand out.
Ali is a powerful force to be reckoned with, and in many ways, Two Face is the perfect marriage of grounded intensity and comic book wackiness. It’s the same sort of balance Ali will be striking as Blade, so he’s definitely up to the task.
6. Mr Freeze
Another major Bat villain, Mr Freeze’s big movie appearance in Batman & Robin was decidedly less popular than The Dark Knight’s Two Face. Played by Arnold Schwarzenegger, the scenery was well and truly chewed as Freeze spouted camp quips and cheesy puns.
Beneath all that though, Mr Freeze is one of Batman’s most sympathetic villains. His central motivation is his wife, Nora, who is suffering from a terminal, incurable disease. Freeze is determined to save her by any means necessary, and this has led him down a very dark path indeed.
Clearly, despite Schwarzenegger being paid a whopping $25 million for the role of Mr Freeze (with only 25 days on set, that’s a cool million per day), he was totally wrong for the part. Mr Freeze needs to be threatening, yes, but at the same time he needs to be emotionally complex, tender, and deeply hurt.
Not every actor would be up to the task, and as Batman & Robin proved, it’s easy to get wrong. Mahershala Ali though is an actor of immense talent, and his take on the tragic Mr Freeze would be wonderful to see.
5. Martin Hawkins Or Amadeus Arkham
After a couple who have a decent shot of getting in with or without Mahershala Ali, we’re back to a bit of a wildcard. Not only one, but two, as Ali could probably pull off both sides of this story.
Martin Hawkins is little more than a footnote in the Batman canon, but has huge links to Arkham Asylum, a setting which has been severely under-utilised on the big screen.
Hawkins was a serial killer who targeted women, and ended up being sent to Arkham Asylum. When he escaped, he targeted the Asylum’s founder, Amadeus Arkham.
In a grisly chain of events which will surely be edited if Hawkins is adapted, he killed Amadeus’ wife, then raped, killed and decapitated his daughter, stuffing her head in a dollhouse. The DCEU can go dark, and Joker and Birds Of Prey have R ratings, but that still seems a little much.
This is the catalyst to Amadeus’ descent into madness, but not before Hawkins is captured and electrocuted to death at Amadeus’ hands, one year to the day after the murders.
It would be fun to see Ali go full villain as Hawkins, or more manic as Amadeus. He’s got the range for both.
4. Azrael
Aside from Gotham and various video game appearances, Azrael hasn’t done an awful lot outside of the comics. It’s a shame too, because he’s a character with a lot of depth that a silver screen adaptation could explore.
Mahershala Ali will have to become handy with a sword to play Blade, so why not two birds one stone it and imagine him as Azrael too?
Jean-Paul Valley, to give Azrael his real name, starts out as a computer science graduate student. He’s completely unaware that he’s the latest in a long line of assassin enforcers for The Sacred Order Of Saint Dumas. He’s been brainwashed since birth by The System, a psychological conditioning program to turn him into the next Azrael.
Once his father dies, Valley’s conditioning is activated, and he becomes Azrael.
On his first mission, he is sent to kill an arms dealer and crosses paths with Batman. Once the two meet though, Azrael sees the light and rebels against his brainwashing, saving Batman and deciding to fight criminals rather than follow his destiny within The Sacred Order.
Similar to Bronze Tiger, Ali’s hypothetical Azrael could feature as a villain but move to the side of the heroes in future flicks.
3. Carmine Falcone
A lot of the characters here are portrayals it would be very interesting to see Mahershala Ali take on. His filmography is already quite eclectic, and Blade plus potentially The Batman are only going to diversify it further. With Carmine Falcone though, Ali has a chance to use his wealth of experience from his previous comic book roles.
Mafia head honcho Carmine Falcone isn’t a million miles away from Ali’s Cottonmouth role in Luke Cage. That short lived role only lasted six episodes, and left all of us wanting more.
Marvel have duly obliged by bringing Ali to the MCU through Blade, but DC could swoop in tap into Ali’s brilliance as Cottonmouth.
Though he’s not as much of a blockbuster villain as some others in Batman’s rogues gallery, Falcone is perfect for a gritty, crime infested Gotham. As a lurking, recurring presence in the background, Ali could really sink his teeth into the role.
It might not be as expansive as some of the others on offer, but as a seasoned character actor, Ali would excel in a slow burner role too. With several villains allegedly set to feature, Falcone could be pulling the strings behind the scenes.
2. Martian Manhunter
Really swinging for the fences with this one, but why not?
Martian Manhunter is a fantastic DC character, one who’s been a key player in several adaptations, be they cartoon, video game or live action TV. On the big screen though, he’s not had any love. He was set for a big role in 2008’s Justice League: Immortal, a project which was eventually canned during the Writer’s Guild Of America strike.
At the same time, Joss Whedon’s Wonder Woman script and David S. Goyer’s Flash movie were also thrown out. How different the DCEU might have been, eh?
Back in 2019 though, adding Martian Manhunter to The Batman might look like DC continuing their trend of running before they can walk.
However, with yet more rumours swirling that Warner Bros. are looking at a Martian Manhunter movie with a black lead, Ali could establish himself in the DCEU here then team up with Batman later. J'onn J'onzz first came to earth as a GCPD detective, so it could totally happen.
The DCEU is clearly trying to copy the MCU’s togetherness and camaraderie, so we may see more team ups in solo flicks. As for whether Ali would be willing or contractually able to play two superhero leads in competing franchises is unclear, though.
1. Jim Gordon
Last but certainly not least, we have Jim Gordon. The character is practically guaranteed to be in The Batman, he’s perfect for Mahershala Ali and marks a big contrast from his other upcoming comic book role, Blade. If Ali’s two Oscar wins haven’t made him a household name, an MCU stint certainly will.
Jim Gordon could keep him in the mainstream spotlight without seeing him typecast. Ali isn’t the kind of actor who only takes one sort of role, so it makes sense that even his blockbusters see him diversifying his options.
Jim Gordon, the grizzled cop who helps Batman keep law and order in Gotham, fits right in the centre of Ali’s wheelhouse. He’s recently won praise for playing a lawman in True Detective, although Gordon is quite different from Purple Hays.
Both J.K. Simmons’ and Gary Oldman’s versions of the character have just been kind of... there. Both terrific actors, but the script just didn’t get the best out of them. Hopefully, whether Mahershala Ali joins the cast or not, we’ll see a more active Gordon proving why he’s such a key figure in the Batman lore.