The Batman: 7 Reasons George Miller Must Replace Ben Affleck

What this crisis needs is a genius lunatic...

The Batman George Miller
DC

Warner Bros are facing a crisis - seemingly of their own making - on The Batman. They had the perfect director in Ben Affleck and they should have given him the resources and the time he needed to make a project worthy of his and the character's billing. He seemed to be publicly asking for that allowance, while ominously threatening to leave if the project didn't match up to his exacting standards.

And now that's gone and bloody well happened.

If the studio want to pull back some of the bad publicity (and they've become masters of doing that recently), they need to act quickly and with purpose to hire a director who will excite fans as much as Affleck did.

Assuming Christopher Nolan is unavailable, the options are pretty broad: they could go for a David Fincher or a Kevin Smith (depending on the direction they want to go), or they could listen to fans and try for Joss Whedon... But none of them would be the best option.

George Miller has already been talked about as a potential DCEU director (and as a producer, actually) and he would be the kind of statement hire who would definitely easy the transition away from Ben Affleck.

Here's why the Mad Max: Fury Road director needs to be the one to step into Ben Affleck's shoes...

8. He Knows How To Be Theatrical

Mad Max Fury Road
Warner Bros. Pictures

Looking at Mad Max: Fury Road - and indeed the whole Mad Max franchise - the biggest take-away is that George Miller knows how to be theatrical. He knows how to balance pomp and circumstance with compelling, at times jaw-dropping spectacle that grabs audiences by the lapels and drags them irresistibly in.

Imagine a Gotham City cut in Miller's image, sharing some of Thunderdome's weird, incestuous system of self-governance and its army of freaks within the walls. There's definitely something in that scorched-Earth dystopian future that lurks beneath the surface of Gotham, and which also fits the special brand of Gothic theatricality that worked so well for Tim Burton's vision of the dark knight.

Thinking more about theatrical impact, Miller's characters in Mad Max are all based on the same mechanics of impact as Batman: they make themselves look fearsome, build mythologies around themselves (or in Max's case, see it happen around them) and they're all about appearances. It wouldn't even be too much of a stretch for Batman to inhabit the same world. Both he and the director fit.


7. He Makes Great Villains

Fury Road Immortan Joe
Warner Bros.

Even Chris Nolan knew that larger than life, theatrical villains are the key to making the best Batman films, and though it has gone a little far in the past (under Joel Schumacher's watch, mostly), the same approach is still very much welcomed. In terms of the comic book's logic, Batman's villains have to offer him balance: they need to be as absurd and as monstrous as him, or his whole image and symbolism is redundant.

Now take a look at Miller's Mad Max villains, and tell me they aren't exactly how you'd want Batman's future villains to be. Toecutter and his gang of motorcycle monsters, Wez and his goons, Aunty Entity and Immortan Joe absolutely exist in the same grotesque space as The Joker, The Penguin, Two Face and the Scarecrow: what worked for the Max villains would absolutely work Batman's.

And having more human characters with grandiose levels of villainy is exactly what we need after the weird mesh of Lex Luthor's precocious dotcom evil and the unfathomable, unsatisfying scale of Doomsday.


6. His Justice League Proved He GOT Comic Book Movies

Justice League Mortal
Warner Bros.

Justice League: Mortal never actually got off the ground (thanks to a tax issue in Australia) but more recently some artwork from the planned film has hit the web, offering a look at Miller's vision and some of the world's we would have visited. In short, it looked a lot like he was ready to make a film that retained DC comics' aesthetic and pulpiness, paying homage to the golden age of comics.

His grand scale landscapes and vibrant colour palate is pretty far removed from what we've seen in the infamously glum DCEU (a hangover from Chris Nolan's more muted Dark Knight trilogy), and more akin to the Marvel approach to film-making. If you think that's a bad thing, simply because of the link to Marvel, you're a blinkered idiot: their films work for fans and at the box office because of their feel and their spirit.

Even with the darkest of all of the DCEU's characters, a more colourful Batman under Miller's charge would be entirely welcome, and it's not like his striking use of colour in Mad Max: Fury Road contradicted the darker tone.


5. He Can Do Heart, Humour AND Horror

Mad Max Fury Road
Miramax

The most curious thing about Miller's body of work is how wildly different some of his most successful films are: sure, he's most famous for Mad Max and all of the spectacle, insanity and weirdness involved there, but he also made a Babe sequel and two Happy Feet movies. Yep, the same guy who then went back to Fury Road made movies about a big-hearted talking pig and a dancing ecology warrior penguin.

More importantly, it's the director's range that should be most celebrated. He transitioned from a world of grotesque monsters to family friendly, universally appealing stories. He has the capacity to segue from horrific content to heart-warming, humanist emotion, and that's something the DCEU is missing.

So far we've seen muscular directing from helmers without a great deal of range: sure, Snyder knows how to make visually stunning films and David Ayer knows impact, but could either have made Babe In The City? Let me rephrase that - could either really handle subtle emotional nuance? Doubtful.

And for all of Batman's impact, he's all about subtlety and emotion - they're the keys to understanding his identity, rather than simply accepting it, and they need a director who can work on a broad spectrum.


4. The DCEU Is Ready For Some Insanity (And Fun)

Mad Max Fury Road Oscar
Warner Bros.

Like it or not, the word "fun" has become a dirty one for some DC fanboys. Thanks to its association with the lighter, easier content of the MCU, those fans have applied it as a derogatory contradiction of "adult" - which they imagine is what DC movies should otherwise be.

But since when did comic book movies being fun become a toxic idea? That's precisely what comic books were built on, and there's absolutely no contradiction in saying they could be complex, adult and fun at the same time. It's about time that was embraced again, and the man who made the deliciously bonkers Fury Road is absolutely the right man for that job.

Miller isn't just imaginative, he's unhinged, which led to some supremely stunning visions in Fury Road, and which would translate incredibly well to Gotham City and the Dark Knight. That would also finally provide some respite from the impenetrably glum, po-faced spirit of the DCEU, which has made the films so far a slog at times. God knows we need it.


3. He's Incredibly Original

France Cannes Opening Ceremony George Miller
Thibault Camus/AP

In contrast to the MCU's attempt to sign on directors who can fit the overall image of the shared universe and who are malleable rather than auteurs (Joss Whedon aside), the DCEU seems to have been built on the principle of hiring directors praised for their individualism. Miller would absolutely suit that agenda, and would arguably be the most fiercely personal film-maker they could ever hope to hire.

Consider how people talk about his Justice League vision:

"The best way I can describe it is: George Miller’s mind is so operatic and big and expansive, it’s a shame that the world didn’t get to see what he would do with superheroes. It was allegorical, like a story of Greek Gods almost. He was doing things with the Superman character and Batman character, and all the iconic favorites, that’s never been done before. Watch Fury Road and you can only imagine what he would do with those iconic characters."

That's one thing we would definitely be assured of with a Miller comic book movie: an original approach, and if DC and Warner Bros want to see their auteur manifesto through, they should take a gamble on a wilder card than they've played so far.


2. The World Deserves More Miller

Babe: Pig In The City
Universal Pictures

It's still a travesty that outside of Mad Max films George Miller has only made Babe: Pig In The City, two Happy Feet films, the excellent Witches Of Eastwick and Lorenzo's Oil. This is in almost forty years since the first Mad Max came out, and that is a bloody travesty.

Sure, he almost made Contact and Justice League in that time as well, but his focus on producing robbed all of his fans of more of his artistic vision. We now have a fifth Mad Max project in production, of course, but at 71, there's an awful feeling that he won't be around making films for that much longer. He deserves another major production and as Ben Affleck said for a long time before he passed, you don't get that much bigger than Batman.

It needs to happen.


1. He Understands Batman (And His Vision Suits The DCEU)

Ben Affleck Batman V Superman Dawn Of Justice
Warner Bros.

One of the key complaints about Zack Snyder's approach to writing the Justice League concerns how little he seems to understand his characters. He changed Batman and Superman so much (with admittedly fluid results) on the back of consciously admitting he didn't like mainstream comics and would make superhero movies so dark that Batman could get raped in prison, that it felt like he was being provocative with it, in fact.

Miller, on the other hand, proved in his Justice League: Mortal script that he knew how to write Batman, even in a pretty poor, unpolished script. Looking at it now, his cynical, paranoid Bruce is a fore-runner for the Civil War Tony Stark - suspicious, affirmatively committed to monitoring (and controlling) heroes in fear of their dangerous potential. And he knows why Batman needs to seek solace and also how he can find brotherhood to come together for Justice League.

That's exactly the image of Batman we should have got for Batman v Superman; it's almost the one we did get, actually.

Imagine how much more satisfying it would have been for Batman's revelation that he needs other heroes (and family) had come after learning it despite his suspicions (as in Mortal), rather than from a weird confusing fantasy/dream. The first part almost happens in BvS, but the conflict between Batman and Superman isn't allowed to develop that way because of the ridiculous "Martha" conclusion.

Would you like to see George Miller's The Batman? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.