The Batman: Dream Casting Matt Reeves' Trilogy

Mister Freeze please. And NO cold puns.

Mr Freeze
@jaxsonderr

With a new addition at the Batman cinematic experience set to hit cinema screens (hopefully) next year, the anticipation has been building massively to see who will be cast and who will they play.

Already a long list of key figures of the Batman universe has been confirmed, including the titular Caped Crusader, Commissioner Gordon and the trusted butler Alfred Pennyworth. As exciting as these characters are, it's the villains and ancillary characters that are really interesting.

Zoe Kravitz has been cast to play Catwoman, Colin Farrell as The Penguin and Paul Dano as The Riddler (which could be the secret standout of the film). Other casting confirmations have hinted at a possible Two-Face lingering in the background, and with a planned trilogy in the pipeline, it's anyone's guess on who else could make an appearance.

It's worth considering the fact that The Batman will feature a much younger interpretation of The Dark Knight given the noticeably youngish cast. And while we're just speculating, will The Batman lean into the supernatural and mystical or stay grounded in reality?

Both these points are factored in guessing how and who could make an appearance in the films to come.

Until the names are confirmed, let's take a run at fan-casting and what-could-be's for the new trilogy. Here are 10 characters who could/should make an appearance, and who would be ideal to play them.

10. Solomon Grundy - Michael Shannon

The Shape Of Water Michael Shannon
Fox Searchlight

If you were to ask the man on the street to name five Batman villains, it would be fair to say that Solomon Grundy might not make many lists.

While not a particularly well-known or even recognised villain, but Solomon Grundy provides comic book readers (and potential movie audiences) a potential glimpse into the mystics around the DC Universe canon.

Solomon Grundy isn't a villain who could take centre-stage as an antagonist, and probably has more clout as a henchman or side-villain. However, his roster of super-powers and history with fighting superheroes could make for a few interesting and entertaining fight sequences.

Let's talk about casting this big nursery-rhyme zombie! Michael Shannon had his run at superhero movies before; playing General Zod in Man of Steel. He's a tall, imposing figure who even at his friendliest (in interviews) comes off as terrifying. Playing an undead muscle-man might be the best casting choice since Danny DeVito as The Penguin.

No disrespect to Michael Shannon! The man is an incredible actor, who was under-utilised in Man of Steel. His ability to turn himself into a rage-monster - not unlike his character in Boardwalk Empire - is exactly what's needed for a live-action Solomon Grundy.


9. Hugo Strange - F. Murray Abraham

F Murray Abraham Grand Budapest Hotel
Fox Searchlight Pictures

A majority of Batman's best villains have been ones that aren't physically threatening. Many of The Dark Knight's foes have tried to tear him down from the inside, using emotional or mental torture and that always made for a better villain than a physically imposing one.

For Dr. Hugo Strange, he's a villain that does not have to outmatch Bruce's physicality, or prepare elaborately themes traps to cause distress for him.

Psychological damage aimed at the Dark Knight is a common occurrence in Gotham City. But, where villains like the Riddler are constantly trying to prove how much smarter they are than Batman, Hugo Strange understands and dismantles the psyche of Batman in ways that others could not imagine.

Casting F. Murray Abraham as Hugo Strange would be a dream come true. Aside from being just a phenomenally great actor who is no stranger to playing menacing figures (playing Dar Adal in Homeland), F. Murray Abraham could carry the hauntingly sophisticated mannerisms and intellect of Hugo Strange.

We've seen many sides to F. Murray Abraham over his long career. His Oscar-Winning performance in Amadeus was not only well deserved, but showed a vulnerable, frustrated side to him that would be an excellent contrast when Batman finally bests him.


8. Basil Karlo AKA Clayface - Henry Cavill

Mission Impossible Fallout Henry Cavill
Paramount

It's strange that a mainstream live-action film hasn't attempted to bring Clayface to the big screen yet. A villain as iconic and unique as him should have been attempted by the studios by now, but alas, most movies we've got so far have tried to stay grounded - and sadly Clayface isn't the most subtle of villains.

The draw for Clayface would be the abused and mutated theatre actor who becomes a shape shifting villain for Batman to contend with. While it might be easier to make a realistic Clayface a man of many disguises, it would be fun for Matt Reeves' Trilogy to plunge into the supernatural.

About the casting; Henry Cavill is an objectively handsome man. He's Hollywood Handsome. Stick him in a period-piece movie and he'll be right at home. So if you're going to centre your villainous Clayface around an actor gone mad, it would make sense to cast someone who looks incredibly Hollywood.

Now, Henry Cavill is still technically Superman, but the likelihood of him returning is decreasing. Should he make a return to superhero films, a one-off role as Clayface would be more ideal. And if not Henry, then cast someone Henry Cavill adjacent in looks and physique.


7. Jonathan Crane AKA The Scarecrow - Domnhall Gleeson

Brooklyn Domnhall Gleeson
20th Century Studios

Cillian Murphy's portrayal of Jonathan Crane in The Dark Knight Trilogy was brilliant, and in Batman Begins especially we got a sterling imagining of the crazed psychiatrist. But as the trilogy went on, Scarecrow's appearance' were diminished to cameos, and unfortunately the films didn't show us more of his maniacal mannerisms.

Fear as a plot device is something that never gets old in Batman stories, so bringing Scarecrow back for another round would be welcomed with open arms.

The right actor to play him would have to be someone who can carry them self as an intellectual with sinister undertones, but mask that at times with a charming exterior.

Domnhall Gleeson is a great candidate for the role of Jonathan Crane. Besides bearing a physical resemblance to the versions of Crane in the comics and animated series, his own voice itself rings of what the Scarecrow would sound like.

Gleeson's role in the new Star Wars trilogy gave him a free space to showboat a high-pitched, snivelling, enraged and sometimes haunting role. If he were to adapt this do cackling over drug-induced fear hallucinations, he'd surely make us jump out our seats in the cinema.


6. Jervis Tetch AKA The Mad Hatter - Kevin Sussman

The Big Bang Theory Stuart
CBS

The Mad Hatter is an odd villain for Batman. On the one hand, he's a maniacal genius with the ability to control minds. On the other, he's a creepy, weird little man who would get floored in a fist fight with Scarface (even without the Ventriloquist).

But supposed Matt Reeves' keeps his films grounded in reality, and takes a peak at the homicidal, red-pilled version of The Mad Hatter.

Video games and cartoons did the character justice before, and a Mad Hatter whose grand plan is kidnapping or enslaving might be a change of pace from a bad guy with a bomb.

Who could play The Mad Hatter? In the nicest way possible, Kevin Sussman (Stuart from The Big Bang Theory) would make a great Mad Hatter. An actor who not only physically embodies what a young Mad Hatter would look like, but can carry the sad-sack, loser in love approach brilliantly.

The TV series Gotham introduced The Mad Hatter, but he came off physically and verbally more like a handsome magician than a sexist stalker. The Mad Hatter is a compelling villain, and needs who can be mopey and sinister at the same time.

Kevin, no disrespect, but you're the guy.


5. Barbara Gordon AKA Batgirl - Logan Browning

Dear White People Season 3
Netflix

The version of Batman canon you're most familiar with can play into what Batgirl represents in your mind's eye. Would she be the young apprentice to Batman, or a mature love interest for The Dark Knight?

I'd like to think the development of Batgirl has moved beyond simply being another one of Bruce Wayne's students. Matt Reeves has already superseded expectations with his casting choices, it would make sense to continue for future films.

Given the exciting casting choice of Jeffrey Wright as Commissioner Gordon, the daughter of said police chief could open the floor to a more diverse choice of Barbara Gordon too.

Logan Browning is probably more recognised today as Samantha White in the Netflix series adaptation of Dear White People.

Throughout the series Logan has displayed a broad range of emotions, that with the right writing could be harnessed and folded into the role of the aspiring vigilante. Logan isn't a stranger to thrillers, as seen in the Netflix' film The Perfection.

Casting Logan as Barbara Gordon opens up a number of exciting opportunities for the character; none more so than finally getting a Batgirl spin-off film helmed by a rising star in entertainment.


4. Pamela Isley AKA Poison Ivy - Alexandra Breckenridge

american horror story maid.jpg
FX

It's not fair to throw vitriol at Joel Schumacher over what happened with Batman & Robin. His stylistic choice was a conscious one, that did enrage fans and embarrass the cast, but in order to learn from mistakes, they must be made first.

That being said, Uma Thurman's portrayal of Poison Ivy might have done long-lasting damage to how mainstream audiences view the character. Poison Ivy is legitimately one of Batman's greatest villains, given the array of powers she possesses and the fanatical viewpoints she has on the world.

While many of Batman's enemies are gangsters or themed serial killers; Poison Ivy is an eco-terrorist who in her mind is fighting for good. A proper representation of the character would be someone audiences can sympathise with.

Casting Pamela Isley might seem easy from the outset, but finding an actress who can be both alluring and quietly sinister leans into the realm of what Poison Ivy represents. Alexandra Breckenridge showed all of this as Moira the maid in American Horror Story.

With a brief role in The Walking Dead, and recurring in This Is Us, Alexandra is showing a diverse range of acting that would slide into the role of Poison Ivy with ease.


3. Dick Grayson AKA Robin - Noah Schnapp

Stranger Things 3 Will Byers Noah Schnapp
Netflix

It's sometimes easy to forget that the character of Robin is a child, and not Chris O'Donnell with stubble posing as a sixteen year old like we got in the Joel Schumacher films.

While Robin has been every bit as a reliable fighter as Batman, it would be interesting to remind audiences that not only are Batman's Boy Wonder's kids but adolescent ones too. Even during the era of Adam West's run as Batman, Burt Ward was a grown adult running around in pixie boots and gymnast tights.

For a good Robin, the Boy Wonder needs to be impressionable and much younger than Batman. With Robert Pattinson in the lead, a sprightly young fellow would be needed to play Robin.

Which brings us to Stranger Things' actor Noah Schnapp. As the tormented and terrified Will Byers, he has a lot of responsibility playing a lot of emotions. Hot take; he's low-key the best actor out of all the kids on that show, and it's odd he's not blowing up as much as the other actors.

Noah's the right age for a young Robin to learn from R-Patz' Bruce Wayne. Cast him quickly though, these kids grow up fast.


2. Mister Freeze - Sir Ben Kingsley

Shutter Island Ben Kingsley
Paramount Pictures

The last time we saw a mainstream Mister Freeze on screens it was a diabolical representation of a very serious and tragic character.

Arnold Schwarzenegger is a cinematic treasure, but given the pathos of the character, it was very difficult to take the *chilling* villain seriously when every other sentence uttered was a groan-inducing snow pun.

If Mister Freeze were to be introduced, it would do the character justice if he were the main villain of the film. His back story and earnest hope of curing his dying wife would add tense melodrama to the film, and with that tragedy there needs to be an actor who can evoke those emotions.

Sir Ben Kingsley already dabbled in superhero films as the fake-Mandarin in Iron Man 3. Before the veil was lifted, and Trevor Slattery was revealed to be a comedic performance, the low droning tones of the fake-Mandarin were downright scary.

Aside from being a good age to play a mature Mister Freeze battling a young Batman, Ben Kingsley also bares a physical appearance. Should he take up the cold-suit of Mister Freeze, ask him to bring his voice and mannerisms from Iron Man 3 and he would be golden.


1. The Joker - Rhys Wakefield

Purge 2
Universal Pictures

A perfectly casted Joker is like a perfectly cooked steak; everyone's got a preference.

In the last decade, there have been multiple iterations of the Clown Prince of Crime with different mannerisms, personalities and even maniacal codes of ethics. In each performance of the Joker there lies a unique idea for what Batman's arch-nemesis would play in the story- or on their own if we're looking at last year's standalone film.

The right casting for Joker would all depend on the environment in which it is set. As of now there has been no trailer that sets the tone for what Matt Reeves' Batman Trilogy will be like, but should the main performers be a lot younger than their comic-book counterparts, the ideal casting would be a much greener Joker who is discovering themself in Batman's rising.

Rhys Wakefield will probably best be remembered as the "Polite Leader" in the very first Purge Movie. You know him as the faux-articulate, thin-faced menace who torments Ethan Hawke.

While he may not have made appearances in many other mainstream films, he is still a working actor and bares the wide and chilling grin that would work for a young and animated Joker.


Watch Next


DC Quiz: How Well Do You ACTUALLY Know Batman?

Batman Robin Dick Sprang
DC Comics/Dick Sprang

1. In What Comic Did Batman First Appear?

Contributor

I overthink a lot of things. Will talk about pretty much anything for a great length of time. I'm obsessed with General Slocum from the 2002 Spider-Man film. I have questions that were never answered in that entire trilogy!