The Batman Movie Review: 8 Ups & 2 Downs

Batman gets his darkest, boldest blockbuster outing yet.

The Batman
Warner Bros.

There's no denying that The Batman is one of the year's most anticipated movies, the killer combo of acclaimed director Matt Reeves and star Robert Pattinson teasing a big-screen foray for the Caped Crusader quite like none that have come before.

If the marketing has done a fantastic job of selling the film as a singular evolution of previous Batman movies - especially Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight Saga - then it's a relief to report that the end product lives up to that hype.

Time will tell whether or not The Batman is held by consensus to exceed de facto standard-bearer The Dark Knight - this critic thinks not - but on its own merits Reeves' film is a tremendously ambitious, daring, and artful superhero film.

Its lengthy runtime and mostly dour tone won't be for all tastes, but for those prepared to spend three hours soaking in the richest, most atmospheric Gotham yet, there are rewards a-plenty to be savoured. Above all else, this film is going to make a major quarter of Batman fans very, very happy.

But before we get to lavishing The Batman with praise, first here's what doesn't quite work...


Downs...

2. It's Definitely Too Long

The Batman Catwoman
Warner Bros.

The Batman clocks in at a beefy 176 minutes, making it the longest Batman film to date by a fair margin, beating out The Dark Knight Rises by more than 10 minutes.

And while this extended runtime certainly grants Reeves latitude to really get down in the weeds and let scenes breathe, all things considered it's probably fair to say the film could've been given a few nips and tucks without suffering much.

The third act in particular, which seems like it's set to wrap up three or four times before it actually does, might've benefitted from a little more restraint.

And while the three hours pass quickly enough on an initial sit, it ultimately might make committing to a rewatch feel like a bit of an ask, especially for audiences who aren't totally ecstatic about the film already.

Credit to Warner Bros. for at least letting Reeves paint on such a large canvas, even if some trims in the edit bay wouldn't have gone amiss.


1. The Sequel Setup Will Divide Fans

The Batman
Warner Bros.

No spoilers here in the slightest, as it's no secret at all that Matt Reeves made this movie with the intent of setting up both a trilogy of Batman films and a wider universe incorporating spin-off TV shows for HBO Max.

The film ends at a point that clearly sets up the probable direction of the sequel, and it's a tease that's likely to divide Batman fans right down the middle.

For a film that bucks so many traditional notions of a Batman movie, it's a shame to see it hinting at more familiar concepts of Batman lore we've seen played out before for the sequel.

There's no guarantee Reeves will go in this direction of course, but a certain climactic scene which most pointedly hints at what we'll see in the next film does feel rather tacked on, almost as if mandated by the studio.

These issues aside, though, here's what The Batman gets so, so right...


Ups...

8. It's The Darkest, Boldest Batman Movie Yet

The Batman Riddler Paul Dano
Warner Bros.

Once upon a time the Christopher Nolan Batman films were thought of as almost inconceivably dark and gritty, and for their era they certainly were, but Reeves' film categorically outdoes any of Nolan's where grim bleakness is concerned.

Though there are faint flecks of hope to be found on occasion, this is unquestionably the most pervasively dark, depressing Batman movie to date.

The Riddler's (Paul Dano) various murders are very clearly inspired by the Zodiac Killer and to that end feel ripped straight out of a horror film, while Gotham is a festering crap-bag of a city, and for much of the story there's an intense distrust of both social institutions and even superheroes themselves.

Across its expansive runtime, that darkness runs deep enough that it's easy to imagine more casual-minded viewers simply finding it too relentless, even with some well-placed moments of levity and catharsis.

It absolutely won't be for everyone, but for those craving some tonally adventurous, deep-dish superhero storytelling, this may well go down a treat.


7. Robert Pattinson Is A Fantastic Batman

the batman
Warner Bros.

Certain ignorant quarters of the Internet cried foul when Robert Pattinson was first cast as Batman, because of course comic book fans have learned nothing no matter how many times a whined-about superhero casting choice has ended up working out perfectly.

If Pattinson's terrific performance in this film can't shake off the stink of Twilight once and for all, truly nothing can.

Pattinson spends the overwhelming majority of the three hours in the Batsuit and delivers a more subdued, internalised Batman than we've ever seen before on the big screen.

Brooding and moody, with occasional explosions into exasperated rage, Pattinson's Caped Crusader is sure to become many fans' favourite interpretation of the character to date, and even if not, he acquits himself extremely well as both Bats and Bruce (but especially the former).

Above all else, it's clear that Pattinson has what it takes to carry the mantle for at least a trilogy of movies.


6. Matt Reeves' Phenomenal Direction

The Batman
Warner Bros.

Matt Reeves has proven himself to be one of the most skilled blockbuster filmmakers working today with his exceptional helming of the last two Planet of the Apes movies, and The Batman should truly elevate him to the upper echelons of big-budget tentpole directors.

This is such a meticulously controlled piece of work from start to finish, both in terms of its tone and pacing.

If it's easy to say that Reeves has basically made a Batman movie in the vein of a David Fincher thriller like Se7en, he exhibits a patience and restraint that'd surely make Fincher blush.

Even if Reeves didn't need three hours to tell this story, it's hugely refreshing to see a superhero movie linger on images as much as he does here.

In doing so, Reeves confirms the artistry that can be wrought in the superhero space when skilled filmmakers are given the room to fully express themselves.

With Reeves set to return for the sequels, it's clear that the franchise's cinematic future is in extremely capable hands indeed.


5. The Superb Ensemble Cast

Penguin batman 2022
Warner Bros.

The Batman is blessed with one of the most impressively stacked supporting casts of any recent superhero movie or blockbuster, period.

In the villainous stakes, Paul Dano is mesmerisingly creepy as The Riddler, who while on-screen less than you may be expecting is spine-tinglingly unnerving every single second.

Meanwhile Colin Farrell, under a pile of makeup to the point that he's near-unrecognisable, is outstanding as The Penguin, landing on just the right side of hammy and providing some welcome comic relief just when the movie needs it.

John Turturro is also perfectly cast as mobster Carmine Falcone, bringing a sly menace to the part that's quite chilling in its own way.

Elsewhere, Andy Serkis delivers an instantly likeable, younger iteration of Alfred, and Jeffrey Wright is excellent as the hard-boiled Jim Gordon. As for Zoë Kravitz's Catwoman? We'll get to her shortly.


4. Greig Fraser's Oscar-Worthy Cinematography

The Batman
Warner Bros.

In addition to Matt Reeves' pin-sharp direction, this is a phenomenally photographed movie, courtesy of Oscar-nominated cinematographer Greig Fraser (Dune).

Compositionally this is by far the most thoughtfully, artfully filmed Batman movie, for while it doesn't match the epic scope of Nolan's Dark Knight Saga, it isn't even remotely trying to.

Instead, Fraser immerses us in the grimy alleys and seedy clubs of Gotham, with occasional glimpses of the sun-kissed skyline.

There's also far less camera movement here than is typical for the genre, allowing the audience to drink each scene in without spatial confusion, as is especially key during the film's lavishly staged action sequences.

Fraser, who is currently nominated for a Best Cinematography Oscar for his work on Dune, could very well find himself nominated again next year for The Batman, because his lensing on this film is utterly breathtaking.


3. Zoë Kravitz Almost Steals The Show As Catwoman

The Batman Catwoman Zoe Kravitz
Warner Bros.

Just as Robert Pattinson had some mighty shoes to fill, so too did Zoë Kravitz as Catwoman.

And while she's not going to replace Michelle Pfeiffer's portrayal in the minds of many, she acquits herself extremely well regardless with a performance that's sensibly on an entirely different wavelength.

Kravitz steals just about every scene she's in as the angry, embittered young woman with some seriously personal motivations for prowling Gotham's streets at night.

Beyond the obvious sex appeal requirements of playing Catwoman, Kravitz brings a real weight and gravitas to the part, ensuring her version of the anti-hero effortlessly holds her own against Pattinson's Batman, aided by solid chemistry between the pair.


2. The AWESOME Action Sequences

the batman 2022
Warner Bros.

It's worth stating upfront that The Batman's action sequences are considerably more understated than the epic, operatic ones witnessed in Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight Saga, and that's absolutely by design.

Taking place as it does in just Batman's second year "on the job," his missions and their action-packed outcomes are decidedly more modest, yet nevertheless outstandingly choreographed and staged in their own right.

The various fight scenes convincingly establish Batman as a physical threat but also a hero who isn't beyond making mistakes.

The easy highlight, however, is undeniably a face-melting mid-film car chase between Bats in his Batmobile and The Penguin, as has been understandably focused on in trailers.

It's a magnificent, electrifying sequence that deploys VFX only when necessary, often milking the simple thrill of a high-speed pursuit for every drop it's worth.


1. Michael Giacchino's Phenomenal Musical Score

The Batman
Warner Bros.

Last but certainly not least we have an incredible musical score from Michael Giacchino, who adds a bevy of outstanding music to Batman's cinematic canon.

Given the brilliance of Danny Elfman, Hans Zimmer, and James Newton Howard's previous Batman scores, Giacchino certainly had a lot to live up to, but has managed to deliver a haunting suite of tracks that feel totally singular.

There's an elegant simplicity to the central Batman leitmotif in the movie - it's immediately catchy and yet accentuated by an intoxicating slow-build in the score's seven-minute title track.

But it's not all dour and grim - there are some fantastic orchestral sweeps that sound practically romantic, ensuring Giacchino's score is as diverse and dynamic as it is unforgettable.


In this post: 
The Batman
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.