The Conjuring Universe: Ranking Every Film
How does The Nun stack up?
When the original Conjuring film debuted in 2013, few could have guessed just how prolific of a franchise it would lead to. The potential for sequels was obvious, but no one was quite expecting this.
Over the course of the last five years, the franchise has released five films including spin-offs, sequels, and prequels to constant financial success. In crafting their own version of a shared universe, this horror franchise has been able to dominate the box office in recent years.
With the release of the newest entry, The Nun, the Conjuring universe is poised to become the highest-grossing R-rated horror franchise of all time, all at only five movies in. That said, even with The Nun being guaranteed financial success, how does it stack up in terms of quality to the rest of the entries so far?
The Conjuring Universe has certainly had its fair share of ups and downs, but does The Nun reach dizzying heights, or reduce the overall bar of quality to new lows?
Across just five years, which is the best Conjuring film so far?
5. The Nun
The newest film from the Conjuring Universe is also easily the worst one.
It's a gluttony of squandered potential, as Valak herself was a breakout success in Conjuring 2, and this film's period setting offered up plenty of opportunities to deliver an entirely different beast of a horror film. Instead, The Nun falls back on the exact same haunted house horror tropes that have been this franchise's bread-and-butter for years now.
The end result is a film whose jump scares aren't remotely earned, and feel more like watered-down versions of things we've already seen done much more effectively. From its inability to pick a narrative lane, to its atrocious editing, to its insistence on inflicting 'Frenchy' on audiences across the globe in the name of a cheap tie-in, this thing is rough.
There's a big reveal in the third act that Jesus Christ's blood (yes, the actual Jesus Christ) is the MacGuffin everyone's been after this whole time, and somehow that still isn't the dumbest thing about this movie.
4. Annabelle
After the barnstorming success of The Conjuring, Warner Bros. was quick to jump on the idea of turning the various items in the Warrens' occult basement into the subjects of their own spin-offs. And logically, the first to get the honor was the scene-stealing doll from the first act of the film, Annabelle.
Unfortunately, in the rush to get this film out barely a year after the original, the creators went stumbling head-first into a mess they'd have to spend the next two films cleaning it up. Annabelle has its fair share of moments that do work, but a half-baked script doesn't do it any favors.
It spends a lot of time ripping off better horror films (Roman Polanski might as well get a writing credit for how much it takes from Rosemary's Baby), but can never come close to capturing what made those films so scary or affecting in the first place.
And most strangely of all, it can never quite figure out what to actually do with Annabelle herself. Seeing as she's never allowed to move, she's less a character and more just a piece of set dressing. She's a creepy-looking prop for sure, but she's never able to become an antagonist in her own right, leaving this Annabelle film in vast need of more Annabelle.
3. Annabelle: Creation
The second Annabelle film is burdened by cleaning up the mess that the first film made, both narratively and formally. Thankfully, it is supported by a much stronger narrative and David F. Sanberg's keen eye behind the camera.
Technically a prequel to the first Annabelle, Creation goes even further back and retcons the entirety of how Annabelle became haunted in the first place. Gone is the strange and flimsy 'blood drop possession' from the first film, replaced by a much more thorough and compelling backstory that makes her that much more frightening.
Focusing the story on a group of orphaned young girls is an inspired choice that works really well, and Sanberg and his team even find some really inventive ways to bring Annabelle herself to life in a way the prior film didn't.
Having said all of that, the film does still suffer from its inability to ever really deliver pay-offs. The film is over-populated with great set-ups, like the toy gun sequence, but features shockingly few great pay-offs.
Most of these sequences end with a pointless jump scare that goes nowhere or an anti-climax. It's all in the interest of generating suspense, which it does at first, but the technique becomes more grating as the film goes on.
2. The Conjuring 2
This sequel benefits from having luxuries the spin-off films did not; James Wan returning behind the camera and the charismatic pair of Vera Farmiga and Patrick Wilson returning as the Warrens.
It also sees Wan tackling his most ambitious horror project to date, which is both a strength and a weakness. On the one hand, he is able to communicate more in a single shot here than most directors can in entire sequences. The long take of Patrick Wilson speaking with the possessed girl in the background as she literally morphs into the spirit of the old man whose haunting her, is so simple yet so powerful.
However, from a narrative standpoint, Wan's ambition can sometimes get the better of him. Seeing him tackle both the Amityville and Enfield stories in a single film is a thrill, but it stretches the movie thin. Coming in at nearly two-and-half-hours, this film is long. And when it reaches its climax and the Warrens figure out that the old man isn't even the one responsible for the haunting, its Valak the nun, through some tape audio tape falling down on a train, it all gets a bit too convoluted for its own good.
1. The Conuring
The original Conjuring film is still pretty easily the best in the series.
A huge part of that is almost certainly because of just how revolutionary it was and still is. The horror genre had been moving away from grisly torture porn and into the realm of the supernatural, with films like Paranormal Activity or even Wan's own Insidious films, but The Conjuring was the one that changed everything.
Utilizing classical horror techniques with a simple and horrifying story, Wan and his team were able to craft one of the best horrors of the last decade.
The hide and clap sequence is so simple, and doesn't require any big effect or advanced design, for example. It provides a simple set-up, teasing the audience with the possibility of an appearance by the spectre, creates loads of suspense, and then delivers with a simple yet effective pay-off when the hands clap behind Mrs. Perron.
The film also benefits from being the first. Every subsequent film in this universe has borrowed heavily from this films bag of tricks, but the scares here still feel fresh and effective because they are so well-crafted.
In utilizing classic horror film techniques, keeping the narrative simple, and capitalizing on great set-ups with great pay-offs, the original Conjuring film cements itself as the crown jewel of the franchise.