The Dark Knight Rises: 10 Neglected Plot Lines That Should Have Been Developed
It's been over a year since The Dark Knight Rises was released and whether or not it was a good film is still a topic of discussion even to this day. The film doesn't have anything that would be considered bad (in fact it's one of the best films of 2012) however when comparing it to the other two films in the franchise it's surely the weakest one in the whole trilogy. What made Batman Begins unique was that it took the concept of Batman to another level: It made Batman much more realistic, it turned him into a badass ninja and it gave him some of the coolest gadgets ever to be featured in a Batman movie and taking one of the (let's face it) weakest villains and turning him into a cool mentor for Bruce Wayne. The Dark Knight it's definitely the best film in the whole trilogy, it took all the things that made Batman Begins an incredible movie to the max. With the Joker we had a story that went everywhere because of how unpredictable the Joker was, but that's not it. It also featured the peak of Gotham's fight against the organized crime, which indirectly unleashed the events of the movie. On the other hand we have The Dark Knight Rises, which had a very basic story with some characters that should've been introduced (or at least mentioned) in previous movies and while the ending wasn't bad, the execution it had was very sloppy, especially coming from a director like Christopher Nolan. It wasn't the ending a franchise like this deserved. It had so many opportunities to step up the challenge and story from The Dark Knight and turn it into the best movie of the trilogy, however it didn't explore all the possibilities that the story offered. How different would the film had been if they had decided to explore some of them? Quite different, actually.
10. Whatever Happened To Gordon After The Dark Knight?
In every Nolan film we see Jim Gordon having some sort of story-arc. In Batman Begins he was the only good cop left in a city filled with criminals and corruption, and how he tried to make Gotham a better place; in The Dark Knight, he was giving the best of him in order to fight what was left of the criminal scum in Gotham, the troubled relationship he had with Harvey Dent and how much the Joker screwed up things for everyone. In The Dark Knight Rises we see that he's considering retirement and...that's it. Don't get me wrong, it was kind-of interesting to see him dealing with living with a lie and how much he betrayed the laws he promised to protect. However at no point we see him going through some story arc in the movie, considering the time gap that happened between those movies, as well as some things that are addressed in the first part of the movie we should've seen more of what happened to Jim Gordon after the events in The Dark Knight. And for that matter, why don't we see what happened to him or how much it affected him Bane's insurrection in Gotham, I'll go a bit deeper on this subject later on this article but we only see him for a little portion of the movie when they're showing what was going on in Gotham at the time. What kind of things did he do? How did he manage to contact the government? How did he manage to gather an army to fight against Bane? There were many opportunities to give a good story-arc to Jim Gordon, however he didn't got the proper development in the movie. Such a shame.
9. Bruce's Life Inside The Pit
This one was one of the major criticisms the movie had, and while I didn't have that much of a problem with it I think it could've been executed in a better way. After Bane breaks Bruce's back in the most one-sided fight scene in recent years we only see Bruce laying in there for a couple of minutes, then being attended by the world's worst chiropractic and then a small training montage before he left the Pit. Bruce's broken back was a very important story arc back when it was first published. It affected him physically and mentally so much to the point in which he said that Bane "Destroyed him." On the film this could've been explored in so many ways, since (like in the comics) Bruce was completely destroyed. Let's not forget that he was in a prison that destroyed the mind by giving the prisoners hope. The movie could've explored Bruce's depression during his time in the prison, as well as his need to save Gotham from Bane's control and to reassure himself as the Dark Knight, training himself to not only leave the pit, but also to be able to fight Bane and defeat the League of Shadows. However we were left with a very basic story of him overcoming not his fears, but his injuries. Great, but somehow that's not as cool.
8. Catwoman's Relationship To Bane
Catwoman was definitely one of the highlights of the movie. It's well known that Christopher Nolan didn't want to include her character in the movie, but his brother persuaded him to do so. Despite this he managed to include her in a cool, realistic way with a marvelous story and motivations that made her not only a sympathetic character, but also an incredible Catwoman. But if I should point out a flaw that involved the character it would have to be that we never knew what kind of relationship Bane and Catwoman had. Don't get me wrong, I don't mean relationship in a "romantic" manner, I mean as in how Bane found her and why she was so afraid of him. In the whole movie they're together for only 2 scenes: when she and Batman are on the roof and when she blows him into smithereens. I would've loved to see how he managed to encounter one of the world's most wanted criminals, how he convinced her to work for him and why she began to fear him. For example: Bane met Selina when she was trying to recover her life, she worked for him a couple of times but as time came by she realized Bane was much more dangerous that he thought. She tries to get away but Bane almost kills her, so she makes a deal with him to bring Batman in exchange for her life. There, I know it isn't awful but at least that would've given us a much more interesting character development and it would've shown us a pretty cool fight scene between Bane and Catwoman.
7. Batman Without His Gadgets
One of the arguments that always pops up whenever 2 people discuss whose the best superhero is that you can take away Batman's gadgets, money and friends and he could still be a badass superhero capable of bringing down even the most dangerous criminal. This is something that we've seen many times in the comics (a small example is shown in Batman R.I.P.) however it hasn't been fully explored in the movies yet. It had so many opportunities to show Batman using all of his intellect and experience to find a way into Gotham or a way to deactivate the nuclear reactor, yet the only thing they showcased was that Batman had some pretty cool gadgets again. Sure it's really nice and awesome to see Batman in all of his bat-glory but c'mon, it would've been much more interesting. The funny thing is that the plot point of taking away all the things that defines a superhero was been explored in a film in a much better way, and what makes it even funnier is that it was explored on the superhero you'd least expect it.
That's right, in Iron Man 3 Tony Stark behaved much more like Batman than Batman in his own film. They took away his money, his suit, his gadgets and he had to improvise a way to fight Killian's minions, as well as how to infiltrate his mansion. Hell the closing line of the movie is the line pretty much everyone uses when they're trying to prove that Batman is better than Iron Man, how Iron-ic. We're still yet to see Batman doing this sort of thing in one of his films. I was expecting to see Batman improvising his way into Gotham, fighting against some of Bane's thugs and even facing him with an improvised plan. But no, we just saw him recovering his old suit and balancing the final battle using a brand new Batwing.
6. Life Inside Bane's Gotham
At this point we can all agree that The Dark Knight Rises should've been either much longer, or a two-parter. I mean, how cool would've been that the first movie ended with the cliffhanger of Bruce's back broken and thrown in the pit, with Bane in Gotham and the city at his control? This would've not only allowed for a much better character development, but it would've also allowed us to explore much more things that the film didn't show. For example: how the people in Gotham survived and lived during Bane's insurrection. I think it's fair to assume that not everyone was excited about Bane releasing all of Gotham's prisoners, killing the mayor and telling them that everyone can do whatever the hell they wanted and there would be no consequences. It would've been interesting to see people adapting to that big change, to see the beginning of Gordon's resistance as well as how the contact with the government began. And most importantly, to see all those civilized people eating each other.
5. What Was Bane Doing During The First Two Movies?
Bane's surely one hell of a character. Both in the comics and in the film he was a menacing criminal who was smart enough to discover Batman's true identity as well as a way to destroy him both physically and mentally. While the movie gave the character a couple of interesting twists on his origin story, it didn't explore the full potential this character had. In this entry I'm mostly going to focus on one aspect on how Bane was portrayed and that is that we never knew what he was doing during Batman Begins and The Dark Knight, nor during the 8 year gap between The Dark Knight and The Dark Knight Rises. Was he gathering his army to fight against Bruce Wayne? Was he training himself to be a mercenary? And most importantly, what was Bane and Talia's original plan? After all both of them were excommunicated when it was discovered that Bane had a crush on Talia, and unwilling to let her best friend go she left the League of Shadows alongside Bane. What happened after that? Were they just gathering an army with the purpose of fighting against Ra's's? Or were they trying to prove that they could do it better than him? This also raises an important question: how can you explain that despite being excommunicated they had full control of the League of Shadows? And for that matter: how did they know who Batman was if Ra's never had a chance to tell them? So many questions, and yet not a single answer.
4. Why Bruce Wayne Retired From Gotham's Social Life
For everyone who loves comics, it's quite evident that The Dark Knight Rises was heavily inspired by Frank Miller's The Dark Knight Returns. In both of them Bruce Wayne retired from being Batman and after he realizes he's had enough he decided to get back in the game. The major difference comes from the fact that in the comic Bruce only lets go his secret identity. In the end that is the most logical action to take in a situation like that. Especially if he didn't want anyone to find out who he really was, and while in the film is explained (sort of) in that Bruce has no longer interest in the outside world because he felt he lost everything when Rachel died, this idea isn't fully explored. You'd expect to see a bigger impact not only on how the city now hates him for crimes he didn't commit and for the death of the love of his life, but also after the big reveal that Alfred burned Rachel's letter. All those things (especially the latter) should've had a big impact on Bruce's decisions and development throughout the movie, yet we only see a very basic response to all of them. It would've been much more interesting to see how all those things affected him, and what role they played in his downfall. And while we're at it...
3. Bruce's Need Of Batman
The very first thing Bruce did once he found out someone has stolen his mother's necklace as well as his fingerprints is to suit up and investigate the movies behind the burglary, when he could've just reported that to the hundreds of police officers outside his house. Not only that, but after he has enough evidence to help the Gotham Police Department arrest Bane or at least Catwoman he decides to take matters into his own hands. Considering the motives behind his retirement and that he was in no condition of going in the middle of the night and fighting crime, it's fair to say that it wasn't a very smart move coming from him, especially if we take into account that in matters like that he always goes to the police. While some blame this on poor writing I believe that this was (in a way) supposed to represent that despite what he might think, Bruce Wayne will always have some sort of dependance towards Batman. While this plot point was developed in a good manner in the movie, I don't think it explored enough the implications that came with it. Does he want to be Batman once more because he suspects that something else is going on? Or does he have a self-destructive personality, only wishing to find a way to die in the battlefield? Something as important as that should've been addressed in the movie.
2. What Truly Meant "It Could've Been Everyone"
Throughout the movie we see the new Batman training John Blake. His story is quite similar to Bruce's and as the movie goes by we see how he slowly realizes the limits that the current system imposes and how he finds out that if he wants to make a difference he must become the symbol of hope that Gotham needs. While this one is a good example of Bruce's idea that Batman's identity didn't matter , in the end it just feels like it was really forced, like it was only an excuse to have to have Robin in some form or shape in the movie. Considering what happens in the middle of the movie this could've created some interesting development among the citizens of Gotham. This kind of idea could've also been explored in The Dark Knight, during the Joker's hunti for Batman. In fact this idea could've been quite useful at the time, since it probably would've prevented Two Face from being created. However, The Dark Knight already had a long and complex story, so it would've felt like an unnecessary extra.
1. Bane Is The Son Of Ra's Al Ghul
When I first saw this movie I was really interested in the idea that Bane -a character that is in many ways related to Ra's al Ghul in the comics- was the son of Ra's al Ghul. This would've been a pretty cool twist in the film and it wouldn't have needed the extra character that Talia al Ghul was in this movie. When you think about it they could've achieved the same thing and the movie would be no different if she was out of the whole thing. This isn't the kind of idea that would've pissed off the fans since it's the kind of changes we're used to in Christopher Nolan's Batman universe. And the idea of Bane as the dishonored excommunicated son of Ra's al Ghul wanting to triumph where his father failed would've made for a much more interesting development for Bane. I mean, just think about it. It would've spared us from watching Miranda Tate's terrible death scene, it would've spared us from the awful way Bane was cut off from the movie like another cheap lackey and it would've made the movie shorter, leaving more time for character development or at least a longer climax. But no, he decided to add Talia al Ghul to the mix and turn Bane from the main villain of the film, to the main lackey of it. He was this generation's Bob, so much room for opportunities and not even one of them was used to the max. At least he wasn't as bad as he was in Batman & Robin, so I'll give the movie credit for that.