The Dark Knight Rises - 10 Things We Are Still Talking About
As The Dust Begins To Settle…
As The Dust Begins To Settle The Dark Knight Rises is no longer top of the UK or US box office, so as Batman begins his decent its time to get reflective on what exactly Christopher Nolan has achieved. Was the bats third and final reign under Nolan underwhelming? Did fans subconsciously want to hate it? Or was it indeed the masterpiece finale everyone had surely hoped for? The intention of the following 10 points is not to bitch and moan, but to highlight the things that are being talked about in its aftermath, or indeed, what should be being talked about. It takes a look at the films wider significance, its downright achievement, its criticisms and its legacy. A lot has been said not only about The Dark Knight Rises, but Nolans Batman trilogy as a whole, yet still theres a lot more to say, so without further ado, here are 10 things we feel are worth your consideration. Yes, there are probably more than 10 talking points, so feel free to add your own at the bottom or if youre feeling extra constructive just familiarise yourself with the spelling of sigh and tell us why were wrong. It should also be noted that the article is written with reference to the films, not the preceding comic books, though more on that later. Warning: May contain spoilers.
1. Its A Superhero Movie Yet Its Grounded in Reality
This isnt to say its realistic but the fact that Nolan has clearly made the decision to set The Dark Knight Rises in a recognisable environment, in some form of reality, is important not only to Batman but to the films audience and wider cultural significance. It doesnt take a comic book geek to know that Batman doesnt have any special powers. Putting all motives aside (because thats an article unto itself), Batman is essentially able to do what he does by making use of his extreme wealth in conjunction with years and years of training, despite this he is still a preposterous character. Nolan has had to do a lot of work for Batman to be taken seriously but its vital that he did. The tone of Nolans trilogy is serious; the plight of Batman not just in The Dark Knight Rises but also in the previous films is serious and the audience has to feel the weight of this. The audience has to understand Batmans burden, to feel his pain, otherwise the stakes are not felt, and there is no element of doubt. If Batman isnt grounded, any perilous or climactic scenes lose their excitement because the audience knows there is only one victor, the whole arc of Batman being broken by Bane doesnt work. Nolan had to translate this element of Batmans character to the screen. Although this is a quality of Batman in the comic books, this isnt something that previous directors of Batmans big screen ventures have achieved. While its significant that the character of Batman is grounded, its an impossible task if there isn't something to ground him to, which is why Nolans Gotham is equally important. Being a fictional city with a superhero protector its vital that Gotham is relatable not only as a city but the problems it faces. Some have compared the issues Gotham has in The Dark Knight to the occupy movement or applied more general left or right-leaning politics to its portrayal. Whilst we dont live in a time where ulterior messages need to be snuck into films and Nolan doesnt seem the type to be concerned with projecting his political standing, the idea that critics have applied modern day politics to Gotham must be rather pleasing to Nolan because immediately theyre comparing it to reality, just as he would have wanted. Reality is what sets Nolans trilogy apart not only from previous Batman incarnations, but superhero films as a whole. They feel different because they dont feel like superhero films at all. The hero is fallible and the tone more akin to films like Michael Manns Heat or televisions The Wire than the gothic fantasy of Tim Burton or the camp crusade of Joel Schumacher. Even though films like Spider-Man are set in real places like New York, its Gotham that feels more real.
2. Its Standing in Comparison to Nolans Previous 2 Batman films & Wrapping Up The Trilogy.
Some may take offence to the use of the term Nolans Batman, though to do so is to misunderstand the point entirely. Yes Bob Kane created Batman and it would be incorrect to suggest otherwise, though just as there have been a number of different interpretations of Kanes creation, this is Nolans, he co-wrote the screenplay, hes co-producer, hes the director, this is his vision. But lets not get sidetracked. The Dark Knight Rises felt very much like a completion of what Batman Begins had begun and in some ways The Dark Knight was an episode in between. The most obvious connection here is The League of Shadows. With Liam Neesons Ras al Ghul being the lead antagonist of Batman Begins, the basic storyline largely concerns Batman serving as protector of Gotham, preventing Ras from destroying the city. Fast forward to The Dark Knight Rises and despite not being revealed until late on, the lead antagonist, the mastermind, is Talia, Ras daughter whos intent on completing her fathers work, with Batman again serving as protector. The similarities in the villains motives mark a similarity in the films. They are about Batman having to overcome personal demons to save his city. In The Dark Knight, Batman must stop a mad man; in Begins and Rises he must save Gotham. The Dark Knight is more concerned with Two Face and The Joker than it is Batman. Batmans problem in this film is not stopping them, but what he represents to the citizens of the city. Quite soon into TDKR, Batmans potential issue with the townspeople is resolved, he isnt in hiding for very long, meaning the trilogy can again focus on him, his inner turmoil, his fear, grief and motivation before again becoming Gothams hero. TDK didnt really wonder if the bat was up to the job, whereas the trilogys completion with TDKR, Batman, the supposed hero, quite rightly took centre stage again.
3. Comparing It To The Comic Books
Before this list progresses too far, its important to address the issue of comparing the Batman films to the comic books. Granted, fans of The Dark Knight trilogy that read the Batman comic books are overall in the minority, but they are some of the most vocal and the internet is their mouthpiece. Comic books are very dear to many people; people take them to their hearts. Before video games and before the Internet, back when being a geek wasnt trendy, this is what geeks did. So its understandable then, particularly with Batman as it has a particularly ardent following, that when the source material is disrespected they get upset. What needs to be understood here however, its that source material is all the comic books are. Nolan hasnt created Batman, but he, with the help of co-writers Jonathan Nolan and David S. Goyer, has adapted it for the screen. Hes taken characters, settings and mythology that fans know and love and adapted it for the big screen. This movie is totally geek-friendly; its made for fans of the comic books but not just for fans of the comic books, in fact, mostly not for the fans of the comic books. Make no mistake, this is a summer blockbuster that exists first and foremost to make money, it just so happens that its made by a hugely talented director to whom artistic integrity is more important. For this fans should be thankful, even understanding, so why doesnt it feel like this is the case. Summer blockbusters pretty much all have a source material nowadays, from Twilight to Harry Potter to countless other comic book adaptations. Batman fans however seem more upset then most when aspects of the film are different to those in the comics and to a certain extent this is understandable and there could be a number of reasons behind their grumblings. Firstly, the source material is diverse, Batman has been adapted a number of times before it even made it to the big screen. So it would entirely depend on what era or incarnation of the comic book or graphic novel Nolan or whoever else was using and entirely impossible to please everyone. Secondly, when it comes to feature films, Batman fans have had a rough time of things. Burtons Batman films were well made and well received, but there was no expectation, at the point Burtons first Batman came out in 1989, fans were lucky to see their favourite comic become a film, they didnt have the right to be picky. Then Joel Schumacher took over and made Batman Forever and Batman & Robin, this is when they had to right to be disheartened. The thing with Nolans franchise is fans have been spoiled. Batman Begins was released in 2005 with little expectation, a promising yet inexperienced director making a comic book movie whose previous incarnation couldnt have sunk any lower, and they lapped it up. Batman fans had faith again and expectation was on the rise, but more on this later. The point is comic book fans, is that dissatisfaction that something isnt like the source material is only relative its success in the first place and consequently as the film franchise grows, the comic book fans become disenfranchised. So complaining it isnt like the comics is only natural really because what is really happening is that the fans start to want their Batman back. The thing is bat fans, is that you never lost it in the first place. Take solace every time Nolan recreates a moment from the comics, that is a little present just for you, the film as a whole is for you to share with everyone else.
4. It Wasnt in 3-D
OK, point three got a little bit lengthy there, so this one will try and be a little briefer. The significance of TDK and TDKR (Batman Begins was released a little before it all kicked off) not being shot or released in 3-D is hugely encouraging for all those sick of having inflated prices and poorly retro-fitted 3-D effects shoved down their throats because it shows just how unnecessary it is. Electing to shoot extended sequences in IMAX was a choice Nolan was no doubt able to make due to Batman Begins success, but its one that could have positive ramifications moving forward. By shooting in IMAX and digitally, Nolan and his cinematographer Wally Pfister were able to achieve a look and feel that arguably wouldnt have been achievable shooting in 3-D. Whilst 3-D often has a tendency to feel gimmicky and distracting, with TDK and TDKR they were able to achieve a crystal clear, sweeping image of Gotham City, doing it justice in a way only IMAX can. The epic feel to Nolans trilogy (Inception could also be included in this) is so far unique when compared to other comic book movies with TDK receiving an Oscar nomination for its cinematography that year. It also proves that audiences are at best apathetic towards the use of 3-D with TDK currently lying in 12th place and TDKR in 29th in terms of all time worldwide box office. Sceptics suggest that 3-D is just a moneymaking, anti-piracy tool, yet with Nolans insistence on not shooting TDKR in 3-D on artistic ground, it could be the case that both the sceptics and creatives alike get their way in the long run. With Nolan staying away and legendary directors like Ridley Scott and Martin Scorsese returning to 2-D for their next projects after dabbling with the 3-D format, the future for 3-D may not be so rosy after all.
5. The Plot Holes
Ah yes, the plot holes, theyre undoubtedly there and they have been highlighted by many detractors (many on this site), but how much do they really matter? Whilst a plot hole isnt usually intended, whether they are a criticism or not is another matter and could potentially be underlying of a larger issue. One of the most commonly cited plot holes (dont worry, Im not going to go through them all) is the idea that Batman was not only transported to a mythical prison in a far away land, but that he, after pushing his spine back into place and escaping, manages to get back to and enter Gotham, but the audience is left dumbfounded as to how. Guess what kids? Hes fucking Batman. Is The Shawshank Redemption bad because clearly his cell is in the middle yet spoiler alert when he digs through the wall his cell is at the end of a row? Its one thing for plot holes to be cited as a criticism against a film, but its a damn cheek for those lamenting the plot holes to also suggest that theres too much expositional dialogue. Would TDKR have been made any better if this were explained? Absolutely not. As stated above, this is just one of many, so why then are they brought up at all? One theory on this is that if youre sitting there and instead of becoming absorbed in Nolans Batmans final outing youre thinking about the logistics behind Bane knowing where Bruce Waynes lair is located, the movie has already lost you, which is a shame. Maybe it didnt even have you to begin with. This theory could be completely wide of the mark but to my mind ties in with the more discerning fans and their expectations. To some, TDKR couldnt win. Expectations had been blown with Batman Begins. Leading up to TDK they became insurmountable yet somehow Nolan pulled the rabbit out of the hat, to please everyone a third time was almost impossible. However good it is, TDKR suffers for being last out of the blocks. TDK is far from a perfect film yet largely due to Heath Ledgers show stopping performance, its so damn immediate and iconic that whatever follows either goes bigger (which TDKR thankfully didnt) or pales in comparison. When looking back on these films in years to come Id wager the todays naysayers realise that TDKR isnt Nolans Return of the Jedi but his Return of the King.
6. Bane and Talia
The problem with releasing almost episodic superhero movies, as is the current trend, is that until the inevitable reboot gets green lit, each movie requires a new villain. Thankfully TDKR avoided the trap Spider-Man 3 fell into and Nolan saw sense to not throw as many villains at the screen as will stick, ultimately diluting the threat to the hero. Prior to being made, Spider-Man 3s and TDKR had a shared problem, how to follow part 2. When the middle film of a trilogy has a highly threatening, hugely iconic antagonist how does the third film follow that? Nolan stuck to the one villain formula with Bane and it largely paid off, though a few aspects couldnt help but underwhelm. Where Bane succeeds, at least in the first two thirds of the movie is that hes an immediate and legitimate threat to Batman. As iconic as Ledgers Joker was, The Joker is essentially playing one big game with no end goal other than to cause as much chaos as possible whilst poking the bat and hoping for a reaction. Bane is different; Bane is straight down to business. Hes got a plan and hes not playing games, if someone, anyone, tries to get in his way hell remove them from his path. In his first meeting with Batman, what was exciting was not just the efficiency and brutality with which he beat Batman down, but the fact that in a superhero movie, the superhero was given a pummelling and at no point did it feel like he stood a chance. Bane succeeded as a villain because he brought Batman out of his comfort zone, he didnt hide and operated at street level, meaning Batman had to do the same, no sneaking around using mobile phone sonar this time. Some have criticised Nolans technique when shooting action sequences when really theyre a breath of fresh air. With the typical action blockbuster climax usually involving a confusing CGI-fest of lasers, loud noises and giant robots, Nolans stripped down brawl involving Batman and Bane was impressively visceral. The casting of Tom Hardy as Bane worked very well. Coming off the back of Bronson and Warrior, Hardys physical presence was key to his imposing performance. A performance that didnt afford the grandstanding opportunities of someone like The Joker, nor should it. Banes demise in the film is in line with Banes demise as an effective villain. For what must have been 80-90% of the film, Bane is the treat, yet in a matter of moments Bane is quickly rendered useless (damaging the mask), undermined as the central villain (Talias reveal) and disposed of off-screen (Selenas arrival on the Batpod). Although this doesnt, by a long shot, ruin the film, the reveal of Bane as basically Talias bodyguard/puppet does undermine his character, making his demise rather anticlimactic. Clearly this isnt an accident on Nolans part, the climax here lies with the fate of Gotham City, but his reveal does retroactively remove some of the tangible dread. The reveal of Talia is obviously key to this. The fact that her relationship with Bruce garnered very little screen time meant that not only Banes demise, but hers too is not only anticlimactic, but almost brushed aside. Being someone with Nolans expertise and Batman not being just another superhero movie, none of this is accidental, the way they are dispatched is befitting of Batmans style, they are a small part of a larger whole, yet to approach the villains in this way is a bold move on Nolans part, if a little surprising.
7. The Ending
There isnt a whole lot that needs to be said about the ending, its there on screen for all to see, however its interpreted is purely subjective but is that a good thing? Could it have been better? There are a few schools of thought here. Now the most obvious and it has to be said, likely, interpretation is as Alfred had previously described, what he had always hoped for. As he had earlier told of his hope to be on holiday, sitting at a table in Florence, to look up and see Bruce, they dont talk but they see each other, Bruce is free from burden and Alfred suitably relieved for him, all is well, they all live happily ever after etc. This is literally what the audience sees and most choose to interpret this in the literal sense. If this were indeed the case then it would be harsh to begrudge Batman the happy ending he thoroughly earned over the last 3 films. This probably is the case, right? Or did Batman really give everything? Whether he did or he didnt is open to interpretation and it would be churlish to try and convince you one-way or the other. What does work about this ending though, is that Nolan has effectively given Batman the ending hes earned the same way the audience gets their expected happy ending that was in doubt since his Batcopter (or whatever its called) disappears over Gothams skyline. It gives this whilst leaving that little smidgen of doubt, that can we really say for sure? level of uncertainty either leaving the audience satisfied because all is well that ends well or satisfied that they got their talking point, whatever they choose to believe. A relatively common suggestion has been that as this scene plays out, just as it did earlier in the film, as Alfred looks up the film ends, leaving the audience with an Inception-style did the spinning top start to wobble? type conundrum. This could work, but is the added mystery really necessary? This isnt Inception; its the end of a trilogy of superhero movies. To leave the audience guessing wouldnt be befitting of events leading to this point, that shred of doubt is just enough. Further to this is the Blake/Robin epilogue. Less of a talking point perhaps, though is Nolan potentially setting up some kind of spin-off here? Or is the idea just to show that whilst Batman may be done, hes aware Gotham still needs help and has left it in capable hands, hence the reminder from Gordon about the importance of a symbol. Still, was including the use of the name Robin a tad provocative?
8. The Anticipation, Box office and Aftermath
There are a number of things to consider here, some have already been touched on a little. At the time of writing 3 full weeks have passed since TDKRs release in the USA, yet compared to a similar time back in 2008 after TDK was released, the remaining buzz feels somewhat underwhelming. This appears to be backed up by the box office too. Using the USA takings as an example, in its third week of release in the USA, TDK took around $64 million compared to TDKR which in its third week took $52, still a substantial amount, especially for a third week, yet considerably less. What is different this time around? In terms of anticipation, each film seemed very much on a par. Films of this scale are critic-proof, so any difference in quality can reasonably be ruled out. To again use Spider-Man as an example, the critically panned Spider-Man 3 took $890 million worldwide, whereas the critically well-received Spider-Man 2 took $783 million. Thats not to say that TDKR is Spider-Man 3, the critical response has been relatively similar to TDK (TDK holds a 92% fresh rating on rotten tomatoes compared to TDKRs 87%), but to rule that out as a reason. The difference could be down to re-watch value, depending on how much re-watch value equates to in box office bucks though its hard to believe there would be that much difference in terms of who a re-watch would appeal to and the difference in figures above. And the economy now is as depressed as it was then, so it cant be that. There are obviously significant and disastrous events surrounding the release of TDK and TDKR and although enough has been written about the each tragedy, their impact on the films release and box office could account for the difference in each films box office and TDKRs subsequent underwhelming aura. The fact that the events in Aurora took place in a cinema on the opening night of TDKR would no doubt have turned some people away from seeing the film in that environment. Not only this, but the event really puts whats important into perspective and the legacy of TDKR will always go hand in hand with that tragedy. Conversely, although Heath Ledgers death prior to TDK was equally tragic, the nature of it, the unfortunate, unintended publicity was like slowing down when passing an accident on the side of the road. People want to know what the fuss is about. It drew peoples attention. In a celebrity-obsessed world, people who wouldnt have otherwise given the film a second thought went to see it. These terrible events aside, despite both TDK and TDKR being released in Olympic years, TDKR was only open for a week before The Olympics started vying for its attention whereas TDK was open for almost a month before the Beijing Games began its impossible to gauge its impact but global events like this must not only make a difference to box office takings but help focus attentions elsewhere.
9. What Next?
Despite Warner Bros. insisting on announcing a Batman reboot before TDKR was even released, it feels it would be in everyones interest to take a step back, appreciate what weve got and not rush headlong into an unnecessary reboot. From Warners point of view a reboot is a no-brainer, especially when a Spider-Man reboot that came 10 or so years after the original showed that audiences will lap up whatever is put in front of them so long as the names are recognisable and the characters are familiar. Now theres nothing wrong with the idea of a reboot, but this is Batman. Not only is he a beloved character but a game-changing trilogy has just been made about that character, one unlike anything before it, lets just appreciate that for a moment. Yes people did go to The Amazing Spider-Man in their droves, but the build up wasnt exciting, the whole thing wasnt an event and the outcome was pretty mediocre, theres no need for Batman to go the same way. Relative to TDK and TDKR the anticipation for Batman Begins was minimal, the excitement was saved for coming out of the cinema. Now everyone has their own experiences but upon leaving the cinema after seeing Batman Begins for the first time the excitement was palpable, it was one of the few experiences Ive had of reaching that level of excitement at the cinema. Now full disclosure, Im not a Batman guy, but I was as excited as the next person on the lead up to The Dark Knight, just as you should be when a proper, flagpole, summer blockbuster is approaching. Just like crowds would have been leading up to The Godfather Part II or The Empire Strikes Back, people should be excited to see these movies. The point here is, sure, make your reboot, but wait a while, get the right script, the right director and the right cast and do it right, dont rush it to make a quick buck, make a film that upon release isnt met with well, it wasnt as good the Christopher Nolan Batman films.
10. Any Other Business
When making this list there were a number of considerations that didnt quite warrant their own segment so heres a quick run through of any other business. - The addition of Selena Kyle was hugely entertaining. Anne Hathaways performance exceeded all expectations though her arc didnt pass without a couple of issues. Firstly, as has been pointed out, the inclusion of the subplot with Juno Temples Jen seemed a little unnecessary other then to promote Selinas Robin Hood-esque moral standing. Although Temples star is now on the rise, if a complete unknown played Jen it would perhaps not have garnered the same attention. Also, correct me if Im wrong, but isnt Catwoman (I know the name is never mentioned) supposed to be a little more morally dubious? Speaking as someone who bought fully bought into the climax on the whole, one thing that was never really in doubt was her intention to help out. And would she really be there with Bruce in that last scene? - The relative lack of CGI for a summer blockbuster was impressive and hugely refreshing. - I dont personally agree with What Cultures recent list triumphing Nolan as the greatest director of the 21st Century, and although he occasionally gets a little criticism for his action scenes, his penchant for spectacle is a joy. The grandiose opening scene of TDKR was so unnecessary but so brilliant. James Bond-esque, surely hes next in line? - I was more than happy to buy that Blake recognised Wayne as Batman almost immediately, what I didnt realise until the end of the film was the Gordon didnt know, yet it took the rather tenuous talk of a jacket around a boys shoulders for him to figure it out. - Stop complaining about the time bomb device, all you pedants go back and watch it again and enjoy it for what it is. If you can successfully do that and youre feeling ambitious, go back and do the same with Prometheus (results may vary).