The Dark Knight Rises Sequel: 10 Things Warner Bros Must Get Right
The Dark Knight Rises is not the end... it is simply the beginning.
the title) is Joel Schmaucher's 1995 film Batman Forever. It has a mythic, timeless quality that is so befitting of the character who has existed in popular culture for over nine decades, much longer than I imagine 99.9% of the people reading this article have been sucking air and he will live on for 100% longer than our own lifespans. Batman will live on, artists will be telling his story, re-telling his origin and finding new ways to develop the character long after everyone has forgotten about us. Batman is not a fad. Perhaps in ten years, new movies involving the character won't hit the $1 billion mark like they are currently but there will always be films that pull in over several hundred million dollars and that, for good or bad, will be dominating the filmic discussion over the summer months whenever there is a new movie about The Caped Crusader. The Dark Knight Rises is not the end... it is simply the beginning. A new dawn is coming and a new Batman movie is inevitable and the way Chris Nolan and Warner Bros consciously ended The Dark Knight Rises shows us that, unlike The Amazing Spider-Man, the next movie will most likely be a continuation, Batman 4 rather than Batman 1 if you get me. With that in mind, here's ten things we want to see...
1. Choosing The Right Director / Screenwriter
The king is dead... long live the king. The most important decision Warner Bros must make in the next 12 months is over the hiring of a new director and screenwriting team. Whilst it might sound easy on paper just to hire a talented helmer, the task is actually much tougher than it was just over a decade ago when they originally hired up-and-coming British thriller filmmaker Chris Nolan. He was an obscure name in the mainstream, notable for his narrative bending thriller Memento and for his atmospheric remake of Insomnia but he was not a household name and most Batman fans wouldn't be able to pick him out a line-up back in 2003. When Warner Bros first hired Nolan, he was seen as a low-risk appointment. They had already turned down an extremely dark pitch from Indie filmmaker Darren Aronofsky for a Frank Miller approved adaptation of Batman: Year One that would work as a reboot to the character and they weren't really in the business of making more movies with the character. The success of Sony and Fox's adaptations of Marvel properties Spider-Man and X-Men brought confidence back to Warner Bros that there could be an audience for The Dark Knight once again. They gambled a $150 million budget with Nolan, thinking he might just deliver a moderate success and that the comics fanbase was big enough that they would at least get their money back if it didn't work out... but Nolan delivered far more than they could have ever hoped. Although Batman Begins grossed less than $400 million in its overall run (note: The Dark Knight Rises is passing that already) it was a huge success and it restarted a dead franchise and a box office busting sequel would emerge just three years later. Now WB's task of hiring a new director is much harder. Firstly they have to try and top Nolan's trilogy, which to some might seem an impossible task. Plus, Batman is no longer a dormant franchise that has been rotting for eight years, it is instead the biggest property Warner Bros currently has. Any sniff of who they are interested in hiring to replace Nolan from this point will be all over the internet with hundreds of thousands of fanboys voicing their pleasure and disgust. Back in 2003, it was only a small internet following who were clamouring for what the nest Batman movie should be and at that point, they would have probably been satisfied with anything. Now, the Batman audience each all have a different opinion on what they want to see... and guess what? Everyone's is different. What I want to see in the next Batman movie is probably not what you want to see, etc, etc. But what is important is that Warner Bros hire the right team to take the character forward. Warner Bros MUST hire someone who understands Batman, is a fan of the character and is willing to read and consider the source material in the way Nolan did to craft his vision of the character. That person must also have the sense to hire a comics expert screenwriter like David Goyer, who Nolan invited to write the now legendary screenplay for Batman Begins and who together crafted the overall outline of this trilogy. And thirdly, the director they choose must be enthusiastic and talented and be willing to be in it for the long haul. Warner Bros should draw up a shortlist of several hungry, young directors - the likes of Ben Affleck (whose excellent first two films Gone Baby Gone and The Town at WB must make him a contender with his growing maturity behind the camera, his natural ability to make an exhilarating contemporary crime picture, his relationship with WB and love of comic books), Zack Snyder (possibly the favourite for the job seeing as though Nolan hired him for Man of Steel), Duncan Jones, Jon Favreau, Matthew Vaughn, Wally Pfister (who was Nolan's DP and is now prepping his directorial debut and has clearly learned from the best) and see what all their individual takes are for bringing this universe forward. They must also speak to screenwriters David Goyer and Jonathan Nolan... clearly their influence on the Nolan movies should not be under-stated. They are the big Batman fans, the pair who know the comics inside out and will be able to find the story that can unlock the mystery of how to make a sequel to The Dark Knight Rises. Hell, they already did it once with the sequel to The Dark Knight...
2. Sign Up Joseph Gordon-Levitt For Three Films
As our What Culture writer Luke Stevenson had ever so astutely predicted months before the film was released, Joseph Gordon-Levitt's John Blake character did prove to be far more vital to The Dark Knight Rises than we first imagined and it is now clear he is going to be a major part of the sequel, probably taking on the lead role. I imagine Warner Bros have all but done this already, they wouldn't have dreamed of finishing the Batman film saga the way they did without doing this, but they must sign and lock him down for future movies... preferably a new trilogy. Levitt is likely to have taken the franchise burden away from Christian Bale and Warner Bros and Nolan were extremely smart in hiring a new franchise actor before speculation ever needed to really begin on who was going to play the new Batman after The Dark Knight Rises. And now we all liked his performance and are into his character, we are comfortable with Levitt leading the next Batman movies as a character that isn't Bruce Wayne and the controversy of where the next movie could be headed never really reared its ugly head. I mean, can you imagine if this time a year ago we found out that Levitt would be leading the Batman movies after The Dark Knight Rises as a character that isn't Bruce Wayne? We would have been outraged but right now it sounds like something we might just want to see...
3. Convince Michael Caine, Gary Oldman & Morgan Freeman To Stay On Board
So Christian Bale is staying loyal to Christopher Nolan and doesn't want anything to do with any Batman movie that he is not involved in and whilst for a time it looked like Gary Oldman, Michael Caine and Morgan Freeman thought the same way, the end of The Dark Knight Rises perhaps suggests they haven't fully given up the series... yet. Depending on who Warner Bros hire and what direction they go in, Oldman, Freeman and Caine might just be tempted back. The trio certainly weren't written out of the storylines. The veteran actors, who all fit their roles in this Batman universe like a glove, are so desperately required by WB to stay on board if the studio want to keep the continuity moving forward with Blake. At least two of the three need to, especially Caine and Oldman and it will be great to see how they interact with a new Batman in the form of Joseph Gordon-Levitt. Alfred has a new orphan he needs to take care of and nurture as he takes his first steps into the world of being a crime-fighting vigilante. Re-casting Michael Caine with any veteran actor in the role of Alfred wouldn't come across too well. Similarly, it needs to be Oldman's Gordon who the new Batman (or Robin or Nightwing) interacts with as he is the living embodiment of that character and wouldn't it be something to see how Blake's vigilante and Gordon interact, knowing how little Blake now thinks of Gordon. The new Batman/Gordon relationship won't be like the old one... Blake turned his back on Gordon when he found out the truth behind the cover-up of the Dent act. His hero in the police department was a fraud all along and seeing how this dynamic plays out for a sequel could be fascinating. Of course if none of the three can be convinced on returning, it leaves Warner Bros with the difficult task of finding new actors to play these roles in what will become an odd move forward in continuity and one that seems inadvisable.
4. Don't Be Afraid To Re-Cast The Joker
Christopher Nolan decided early on that he wasn't going to re-cast The Joker out of respect to Heath Ledger who tragically passed away just a few months before Nolan had finished editing the last movie. Had Ledger lived, you can be certain Nolan would have brought back the actor after his Oscar winning performance as The Clown Prince of Crime and he would have been part of The Dark Knight Rises in some form. Obviously we can't say for sure but most likely he would have been a freed prisoner from Blackgate Prison and his murderous, chaotic ways would have terrorised Gotham once again - or perhaps the Nolan's and Goyer would have gone in a completely different direction with the film and included The Joker more prominently? The Joker has existed for as long as Batman and there's plenty more interpretations we'll see of the character yet. Warner Bros and whomever they hire for the next movie MUST NOT BE AFRAID to use The Joker character if they feel it enhances the story they want to tell. There are plenty of A* class actors out there who would be chomping at the bit to give their take on the Clown Prince of Crime and there's more Batman stories that could be improved with his use. The Joker character is just awaiting for someone to come up with a challenging new story for him. Although he wasn't hinted at in The Dark Knight Rises, the character does get a mention in the official novelisation of the film. As written by Greg Cox (and which has been officially licensed by Warner Bros, though probably not in continuity) The Joker's absence from the film is explained as thus; Now that the Dent Act had made it all but impossible for the citys criminals to cop an insanity plea, it (Blackgate Prison) had replaced Arkham Asylum as a preferred location for imprisoning both convicted and suspected felons. The worst of the worst were sent here, except for the Joker, who, rumor had it, was locked away as Arkhams sole remaining inmate. Or perhaps he had escaped. Nobody was really sure. Not even Selina.They surely can't keep the Joker locked away forever?
5. John Blake's Anger Issues
If the ending of The Dark Knight Rises is to setup John Blake as the new Batman (and one of the themes of the film is that "anyone" can become him) then the new writer/director team would be wise to look carefully at the character's portrayal. He talks about his anger issues, he talks about the smile he wears to mask the anger that is going on inside. We know he lost his parents young and he tells Bruce Wayne the story of how his father was gunned down. We also know that, unlike Batman, Blake is willing to kill as he shot two criminals in the cement yard and as a cop has carried a gun his whole life. There's lots of ways this could be explored in the sequel. Blake could find out about his parents killer using Batman's technology... becoming obsessed with the idea of taking him down, whether it be Tony Zucco (the killer of Dick Grayson's parents in the comics) or another villain in the Bat-universe. Perhaps Blake, adopting the new mantle of the Batman, takes things too far and kills Zucco and other bad-guys he comes in contact with, perhaps even threatening to kill a new version of The Joker. Once he has killed the low level thug Zucco, he then goes after Tom Wilkinson's Carmine Falcone who makes a comeback from the first movie and this new Batman's way of delivering justice is not how it should be done. Nolan has already adapted parts of Knightfall for The Dark Knight Rises, the second half just looks begging to be the continuation. In that comics arc, Bruce Wayne gives up the mantle of being Batman to Jean-Paul Valley who after his first months in the job becomes increasingly unstable under the pressure of being Gotham's protector. He eventually looks to avenge his father's death and searches Gotham for his father's killer, his mind warped as the real killer was defeated years ago. This would make a great storyline to follow as Blake keeps believing other Gotham mobsters have something to do with his parents death. It would be like Magneto's mission in X-Men: First Class to take revenge on all Nazi's. This could lead into Bruce Wayne regretting his stance that "anyone could be Batman" and lead to this...6. The Dark Knight Returns
Who is to say that Bruce Wayne has actually retired and given up the cape and cowl for good? Sure, Gotham believes that Bruce Wayne is dead (well until someone spots him in Florence or wherever and catches a picture of him with their iPhone... let's not forget he is an eccentric billionaire of great notoriety) but this could only help his cause as Batman if he wants to return. He no longer has to pretend to be a playboy or live the life of Bruce Wayne at all, he can simply focus on being Batman and ridding Gotham of the kind of evil that had recently engulfed it. And let's consider what happened at the end of The Dark Knight Rises again shall we. Batman is indeed shown in Florence and he has indeed given coordinates and directions to Blake to find the Batcave but is it ever specifically mentioned that he has retired? What if Bruce Wayne is simply on a long holiday with Selina Kyle and he fully intends to come back to Gotham after a vacation and help mentor Blake as his new sidekick... A lot of criticism has been delivered at Nolan for ending his saga the way he did with Batman giving up the mantle of the Caped Crusader but maybe the new director will simply decide that he hasn't. If the storyline for the new Batman movie follows the plot line that we have outlined above concerning Blake's struggle to take on the responsibility of Batman occurs, then a third act is required that sees Bruce Wayne return to Gotham and to stop Blake before he tries himself insane and becomes an executioner. This could even lead to a Batman vs Batman fight - a battle over the Cowl - perhaps with Anne Hathaway's Catwoman having come between Bruce and Blake as a love triangle ensues (comic book movies always revert back to love triangles and there's a good reason for that... because it works!). Of course a new actor would be required to play Bruce Wayne now that Christian Bale doesn't want to comeback without Nolan but there'll be plenty of fine actors out there to take on the cape and cowl. The Dark Knight Returns is by far the most expected film title for the next Batman entry. It works, it sounds iconic, it fits in with the title and yes, it has been used in a famous comics storyline but who cares?
7. Gotham Needs To Be Rebuilt
The devastation caused by Bane and The League of Shadows on Gotham in The Dark Knight Rises should not be underplayed. They left the Caped Crusader's city in ruins, the entire infrastructure of the city has been destroyed and the social and political environment will be in upheaval. The Dark Knight Rises sequel must look into the aftermath of the darkest days in Gotham's living memory and how the city's leaders completely failed to act during the crisis. They also need to be questioned about how the law and order of Gotham was built on the lie of Harvey Dent and the Dent Act. Despite the heroics of Gordon during the crisis, it is hard to see how he would keep his job in the force and the political and social minefield as the Gotham citizens asks questions of their leaders should be at the forefront of the new movie. And that leads us to one key villain for the new movie...
8. Lex Luthor Rebuilds Gotham
What, wait... Lex Luthor? Superman's arch nemesis in a Batman movie? Okay, here me out... Lex Luthor has appeared as a bad guy in several Batman stories over the years, noticeably in the "No Man's Land" story arch when Luthor was a major force in rebuilding Gotham after a disastrous event. Sound familiar? With Batman declared dead at the end of The Dark Knight Rises, the Mayor killed in the blast at the Stadium and the Dent Act outed as being one big fat lie, the residents of Gotham are in need of a new hero for the rebuilding process. The President of the United States is unlikely to be that figure after turning his back on the city and so many of the wealthy in Gotham lost their wealth and had been left in financial ruin by Bane's actions. The sequel could have Luthor attempting to buy Wayne Enterprises in the wake of Bruce Wayne's "death" and perhaps becoming a strong political figure as Gotham attempts to rebuild itself. There is also an arc from "No Man's Land" where Lucius Fox thwarts Luthor's land ownership scheme which has been his ruse for rebuilding Gotham all along. It would only be a supporting role in The Dark Knight Rises but the seeds could certainly begin to be planed towards Warner Bros' ultimate goal... to have Batman and Superman on screen together as part of the Justice League. This is how a crossover with Man of Steel and The Dark Knight franchise can begin.
9. A Nolan Style Villain
I understand the argument that one positive that can come out of Chris Nolan giving up the Batman universe is the opportunity for the more fantastical version of Gotham's protector to appear on our screens but I think it would be wise for the next movie to ease in these elements over the course of the next movies. The Dark Knight Rises sequel should mostly look to keeping the elements that have proven to be so successful in the previous films and that has been the realistic way that the villains have been portrayed. So there shouldn't be a Killer Croc or Solomon Grundy or The Mad Hatter terrorising Gotham but instead it should be villains who can be grounded in reality. The likes of Lex Luthor as mentioned above or The Riddler, Dr. Hugo Strange or The Penguin. Our preferred choice for the villain would either be The Penguin or Black Mask to be tied into Blake's criminal past. Perhaps The Riddler could be an additional side villain but if Blake's parents were killed by a mob boss then The Penguin or Black Mask would seem to be the way to go.
10. More Gotham Central
The Dark Knight did something I had been wishing all the previous Batman movies had and that was introduce Gotham Central i.e. the wider unit of the Gotham Police Department, the team that Jim Gordon is in control of. In The Dark Knight they gave us the corrupt Det. Wuertz, the turncoat Det. Ramirez and the tough Det. Stephens, the one cop who Gordon can trust. We really wanted to see this expanded in The Dark Knight Rises but none of these characters were included. Wuertz of course was killed by Harvey Dent in the last movie but Stephens survived and made enough of an impression that he should have returned. Keith Szarabajka did a great job playing him that it was a shame Nolan decided not to bring him back. The next Batman movie should definitely look to bringing in Stephens AND introduce other characters of the GPD. The likes of Detective Montoya, an ambitious female cop who wants to take Gordon's job as he nears retirement, and perhaps Detective Bullock who has questionable methods but gets results. Gotham Central is a part of the Batman universe and the new director would be wise to incorporate their elements. So there you have it folks, our 10 Things Warner Must Get Right and include in the inevitable sequel to The Dark Knight Rises. We would love to hear your thoughts on our picks in the comment section below.