The Dirt Review: 5 Ups & 7 Downs

"Anyone can make a sh*tty rock movie!"

The Dirt
Netflix

A movie based on Motley Crue's collective autobiography, The Dirt, has been in consideration for years. Its pages hold the kind of authorised depravity and debauchery that rock music in the 1980s was all about, even as the rise of grunge made bands like Crue a strange living anachronism. There are moments in there - and in Nikki Sixx's stunning follow-up The Heroin Diaries (seriously, read it) that would make Ozzy Osborne blush. Some of them even involve him.

Fundamentally, it's a story ripe for the telling, with personal tragedies, excessive behaviour, meteoric stardom and crashing darkness all sewn together by alcohol, drugs and the kind of music that makes you want to get your eye-liner out, squeeze into some leather pants and do the kind of stuff that only Prince would sing about.

It's taken as long as it has because, in Sixx's own words "Anybody can make a sh*tty rock movie. We don't want to do that." Well, you know what they say about the best laid plans and all that...

First, the positives...

Ups

5. It's A Biopic For The Jackass Generation

The Dirt Netflix
Netflix

Now, admittedly, this might be classed as a down for a lot of people, but Jackass had as many fans as Motley Crue do. And the way the film captures the more outrageous moments will absolutely fit with what made that show (and its movies) popular.

There's a break-neck speed to the story, a hyperactiveness to the partying, which is just as it should be and a dizzying charm to this ragtag bunch of misfits. That absolutely works, even when it comes at the cost of conventional story-telling, so you're left in the strange situation where you find yourself wondering why you're not enjoying it a lot less.

Jeff Tremaine makes a lot of mistakes in his story-telling, but his previous work does gift us the rather brilliant (though hardly high-art) sequence shot from Tommy Lee's perspective, which is basically a remake of The Prodigy's "Smack My B*tch Up" music video.


4. The Fourth Wall Breaking

The Dirt Iwan Rheon
Netflix

Even though the voice-overs don't quite work, the fourth wall breaking that happens at several points in the movie is actually pretty great. Mick Mars does it first and he's the best candidate, given Iwan Rheon's disaffected performance - he steals a trick from Michael Winterbottom's glorious 24 Hour Party People by explaining when something swerves away from the true story.

It's almost a shame there are more moments like that, because it would have added a self-awareness to proceedings and would have given Tremaine further licence to make this film what Motley Crue clearly wanted it to be without anyone watching it realising - a fantasy. Dexter Fletcher's Rocket Man is setting out its stall to do that, so there's certainly room for it.

The knowing winks to camera give it an edge of Wayne's World and even The Big Short (without the nuance) and you have to admire the cockiness to defy story-telling convention. It's very, very Motley Crue.


3. The Music Is Still Incredible

Mötley Crüe 2005
By Alec MacKellaig [CC BY 2.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0)], via Wikimedia Commons

If you're a fan of Motley Crue, you'll get a kick out of The Dirt. Just as Bohemian Rhapsody was enjoyed vastly more by massive fans of Queen, there's definitely an agenda to appeal to Crue fans who lived the music and wanted to live the lifestyle. That's why there's such an overt attempt to make everything so aspirational - even when it involves heroin overdoses, car crashes and problematic behaviour. Because the consequences aren't really dwelled on, it feels like a wet dream.

For anyone casually into Motley Crue's music, there's some engagement with explaining where the music comes from, though it could have talked Nikki Sixx up more as a song-writer. But at least you'd be able to piece together the story that him dying inspired Kickstart My Heart.

As with all musical biopics, there's a lot of enjoyment here around the relationship between a story - even one disconnected from history in some big ways in the interest of narrative neatness - and the music and if it doesn't have you loading up Motley Crue on Spotify or dusting off physical copies, it'll be a shock. You probably just have to have loved them first.


2. The Key Performances

The Dirt
Netflix

Considering only Iwan Rheon is massively established of the leading four actors, they're all very impressive. Douglas Booth, Machine Gun Kelly, Daniel Webber and Rheon are all very, very watchable and even when their performances deviate from what long-term fans will recognise of Crue, they're still wholly convincing of a band like that.

Most impressive is that their performances are so on-point at times when the material is no help to them. When you want depth, the material's not there, but they make up for it in other ways. Even when they amount to lookalike performances because of the writing, you're with them enough for it not to always be a problem.

And while there's bound to be a morbid fascination to the more perverse moments from their history, the subtleties of their performances - the observations in small touches and quirks is where they're the most impressive. Special mention, in that respect, has to go to Machine Gun Kelly, a musician himself who has turned to acting and who is an absolutely spot-on Tommy Lee. It's scary at times.


1. It Is Genuinely Entertaining

The Dirt
Netflix

Like Jackass, The Dirt is entertaining despite itself. There are huge problems with it and it's hard not to see why it's on Netflix (because, let's be honest, some films are still on Netflix because they weren't going to work in the cinema), but it's infectious.

Should you be thrilled to see that infamous moment when Ozzy Osbourne sniffed a line of ants and then his own piss off the side of a pool? Probably not and there will be a significant number of people who watch it with the same disgust as the respectable poolside families do in-film. You should also question the agenda to make this all seem like a fantasy and lots of the story-telling decisions but like Girls Girls Girls and Home Sweet Home, it's still very entertaining, even when you recognise what's going on.

It's bound to be divisive and it's bound to rub a lot of people up the wrong way. But if you don't think Motley Crue would absolutely love that thought, you don't know Motley Crue.

And now to the negatives...


Downs

7. The Wigs

The Dirt Douglas Booth
Netflix

The STYLE of the wigs is great all the way through as we see Crue go through the various aesthetic eras of the band, but they should have tried to shoot them indoors as much as possible, because the natural lighting is deeply, deeply unforgiving.

It's particularly poor right at the end of the movie when we see the band reunited and Nikki Sixx and Tommy Lee meet Mick Mars at the hospital and they're bathed in sunlight. The synthetic material looks like the wigs cost pennies, which is seriously unfortunate when the rest of the costumes and make-up is so impressive.

It's not all terrible, of course, but once you start to notice, it's really, really hard not to notice. And that's particularly bad when Vince Neil is struggling so badly and all you can focus on is his weird, fake stubble.


6. Spinal Tap Did It Better

Spinal Tap Nigel
Embassy Pictures

The single biggest problem with The Dirt for a lot of people will be that everything that it shows in earnest - the excess, the grotesque caricatures, the sheer, delicious idiocy of it all - has all been done before. And done in a way that they could never, ever compete with.

Step forward This Is Spinal Tap - a mockumentary so pin-sharp that everyone in a band around the time of its release believed themselves to be the inspiration. In reality, that film drew from multiple sources for a story so ridiculous it couldn't possibly be true. Unfortunately, Motley Crue's story was arguably even more silly, even more outrageous and even more over the top.

But in the wake of Spinal Tap owning cliches that they actually sought to lampoon, it's difficult to accept some of what's gone on here. It's like trying to watch a slasher movie in the wake of Scream - we're too aware.


5. Pete Davidson's Performance

The Dirt Pete Davidson
Netflix

Pete Davidson is disarmingly great on SNL and a very engaging man all round. Unfortunately, as A and R man Tom Zutaut, he sticks out like a sore thumb. A sore thumb pretending to be a nerd in a poor wig.

His performance is way too much like Peter Davidson has wandered into the film with an agenda to add some comedy (he literally gets ball punched for a prat fall at one point) and it's completely ruinous for the immersion factor. Which is saying something in a movie that literally breaks the fourth wall on purpose a lot.

This is not to say that he's a particularly bad actor, this just wasn't the role. He's not entirely believable as the comedy target and there's an SNL-style painful awareness of where the camera is that sticks around too much.


4. It's Come Out At Entirely The Wrong Time

The Dirt
Netflix

Motley Crue are to progressive thinking what mary Whitehouse was to creative liberalism. They're story is one deeply, deeply rooted in a period that was way too invested in sexual exploitation, when bands wrote songs about their genitals and built careers and reputations on them. It was a bubble that was yet to be pricked by awareness or consequences.

Because this film is basically a love letter to that era - and will resonate with those who went through it (or still live it) - the representation of women is very much what it is in a Motely Crue video. They're one-dimensional, more-often-than-not naked and given precious little to say, think or do. There is no hint of equality in here, which is absolutely the point, but there's also no comment on that at all, which is unfortunate at best and entirely distasteful at worst.

It really, really doesn't help that some of the framing is little more than puerile too.


3. Some Of The Accents Are Appalling

The Dark Ozzy
Netflix

When Ozzy Osbourne turns up (as played by School Of Rock's Tony Cavalero - the TV show, not the movie), he looks the part from far off and in side profile. There's also a hint of just about the right accent for a while, but the longer he sticks around, the worst his accent gets. Again, it's hard not to think of Spinal Tap.

He's not the worst either, and the most distracting accent goes to Max Milner, the preposterously cast former contestant on The Voice UK who's done no film acting to date. He looks the part as Razzle, the tragic drummer of Hanoi Rocks who died in Vince Neil's car in December 1984, but his accent is horrific. And this is a man from London playing a man from Leamington Spa (brought up in Coventry). He shouldn't have done it that much of an injustice.

There are other times accents wander too, but the main cast mostly do remarkably well, considering only Machine Gun Kelly is American (the others are Welsh, English and Australian). Occasionally, Douglas Booth's accent slips - mostly in voice-over - but it's forgivable.


2. The Voice-Overs Jar

The Dirt Netflix Trailer
Netflix

You can see why the film opens with voice-overs from the band members, but they're immediately too jarring. It's a convention that can be quite bold, when it works, but here it comes off too much like Mike Myers' voice-overs in Wayne's World. Or a bad parody of them.

For some reason, there's a weird tweeness to the way the film uses the convention, which is clearly an attempt to bring the voice of the autobiography into focus more and also to establish more rapport with the characters. Sadly, it's just way too obvious how manipulative that attempt is and instead of building rapport, it becomes too obvious that we're watching performances.

The end shot of Nikki Sixx smirking to camera as he signs off the movie is also pretty awful. it's just all very dated.


1. It Doesn't Do The Story Justice And Doesn't Explore The Darkness Enough

The Dirt Tommy Lee
Netflix

As with any biopic that comes out with the stars involved in the production, The Dirt misses out on the opportunity to tell a truly objective story because the band are just too close. There's too much of an agenda to show how cool they were and to protect from some of the more difficult elements.

As such, the film misses Nikki Sixx's own desire not to just focus on the thrills and not get into the characters because it hurtles too quickly through the moments of substance in favour of fetishising the moments inspired by substances. There's some flirtation with those deeper elements, but they're too easily pushed aside.

There's also a major imbalance in the story-telling, because director Jeff Tremaine fudges the transitions between moments, particularly towards the end. In the interest of telling us about some of the more notorious moments, the final third becomes a Forest Gump-like greatest hits compilation without enough character work for us to really connect.

What did you think of The Dirt? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.