The Exact Moment Futurama Lost Us

If Futurama had just stopped before the "movies", things would have been all the better.

Futurama Seymour Jurassic Bark
FOX

When you think about long-running TV shows, even without narrowing it down to just the animated genre, your mind will immediately go to The Simpsons. Though Matt Groening's colossal show will go to at least season 34 before ending, his second show certainly hasn't been able to enjoy a similar run.

In the same vein as Family Guy, Futurama has suffered thanks to being canceled multiple times, and no matter what, that same magic from the first run has never been recaptured. Though there is still a loyal army of Futurama fans out there, no one can deny that the show is now a far cry from what it once was.

There are currently 140 episodes within Futurama's back catalogue, but no matter how many times you comb through it, there is always one point in which you can see exactly when things start to change. This is the release of the four 'movies' that now make up season six of the show.

After its initial run and cancellation, Futurama was revived with four straight-to-DVD movies that were essentially each four episodes strung together.

'Bender's Big Score', 'The Beast With A Billion Backs', 'Bender's Game', and 'Into The Wild Green Yonder' brought Futurama back to our screens, but let us down for a number of different reasons.

6. False Hope

Futurama Planet Express
20th Century Fox

It’s rare for any TV show to end well. Whether it has an unsatisfying conclusion like Game of Thrones, or outstays its welcome like The Simpsons, a perfect ending is often elusive even amongst the very best TV shows. Futurama however, was different.

At the conclusion of the show’s first run, fans were left wanting more, and so the news that it would be returning with four straight-to-DVD movies was met with a huge amount of excitement. Who could possibly object to seeing more of the Planet Express crew, right?

With Futurama returning once again in 2023, this particular revival has been met with a certain amount of skepticism after the show’s gradual decline and the initial reports that John DiMaggio wouldn’t be returning. This wasn’t the case the first time around, unfortunately.

Fans went into the release of the movies with high expectations and the false hope that they would be getting the same old Futurama as before. How wrong they were. Even though 'Bender’s Big Score' is arguably the best of the movies and the closest to old school Futurama, all four were still a huge let down.


5. The Writing

Futurama Colleen
Fox

When Futurama returned after two years off the air, there were always going to be differences and changes. Obviously, not all of these were for the better, and one of the most noticeable differences was the writing. Arguably, no aspect suffered more between the end of the show's first run and its second.

The show had always had the ability to make you laugh, make you think, and make you cry. It may sound like a cliché but it's true. It was a smart comedy series that utilised science like few others, yet could pull out a 'Jurassic Bark', 'The Sting', or 'The Luck of the Fryrish' and reduce you to tears.

There was barely a hint of any of these aspects throughout the four movies. Sure, there was a time travel story but one that was far less compelling or thought-out than what had come before, and with the exception of the final scene of Into the Wild Green Yonder there was no real emotion. Even this is reaching.

What happened? This wasn't the Futurama we all knew and loved, this was an almost boring shell of the phenomenal series. Possibly the most irritating part of it is that the writing team didn't even undergo huge changes, they seemingly just got worse.


4. Everything Was Rushed

Futurama Five Fingers
FOX

The four movies that made up Futurama’s return can be broken down into 16 episodes, which is essentially a full season of the show. This is a lot of work, and it feels that throughout the movies there were far too many corners cut and moments rushed.

The storylines of all four lacked somewhat, in particular 'The Beast with a Billion Backs', while 'Bender’s Game' was a weak spoof of several different fantasy stories mixed into one. The worst culprit of this however was 'Into the Wild Green Yonder'.

The fourth and final movie was absolutely riddled with mistakes, plot holes, and continuity errors. Leo Wong randomly had five fingers at one stage, when and where the Feministas revealed themselves and who knew what was going on was ridiculous, and during one conversation the Professor's hand very noticeably changes to that of Hermes and back.

The whole thing stunk of being rushed and no one actually putting in the effort to make it as good as Futurama used to be. Why should the audience care about a project if the people actually making it don’t?


3. Some Of Its Greatest Moments Were Retconned

Futurama Fry Seymour
20th Century Fox

When you think about the most iconic moments in the history of Futurama, chances are your mind will immediately go to Seymour waiting for Fry outside of Panucci’s Pizza, and Fry finding out that his nephew had been named after him to carry on his spirit.

These are two of the most emotional moments in animated TV history, and thanks to 'Bender’s Big Score', they have both been ruined. As have any imagery of Fry’s family missing him, even those from 'Game of Tones' that came six years after the first movie.

In order to escape the alien scammers in the 31st century, Fry used the universal time code and jumped back to the year 2000. From here his time paradox duplicate lived for 12 years before discovering he was actually Lars and rushing back to freeze himself again. This meant that, to the people in the past, Fry didn’t disappear in the year 2000.

He was there every day for Seymour before ultimately going on his voyage, and since he never mysteriously disappeared, there was no reason for Yancy to name his son Phil. Time travel is a tricky narrative to navigate, and in doing so the Futurama writers ruined some of their greatest ever moments.


2. It Ruined A Perfect Ending

Futurama Ending
Fox

As said previously, the perfect ending is something that most TV shows will never experience. Breaking Bad did it, Sons of Anarchy did it, and with ‘The Devil’s Hands are Idle Playthings’, Futurama did it. However, this was ruined with the return of the show.

The first Futurama run came to a close with Fry and Leela walking off into the distance together. This was part of Fry’s holophoner recital, but with Leela the only one left to hear it despite it sounding terrible, this was all the confirmation fans needed that they were finally getting together after all this time. What a way to end the show.

Fast forward two years however, and it’s like the writers forgot that this was where they were supposed to pick up from. It was like this incredible moment in the story of Fry and Leela, arguably the most prominent and important story throughout the series, never happened.

When the Planet Express crew reconvened, Fry and Leela’s relationship was barely even referenced. Fry was still like a lovesick puppy for Leela, but she still barely noticed him. Instead, she fell in love immediately with Lars. Yes, this was ultimately still Fry, but she didn’t know that at the time, and in completely ignoring the final scenes of the show's first finale, the writers once again ruined one of their greatest moments.


1. It Was Just The Beginning

Futurama Bender's Big Score Nudar
Fox

As rare as it is for a show to stay relevant enough for long enough to produce a spectacular perfect ending, it is even rarer to maintain such a high level of quality from start to finish. Even the best shows dip, but the very best will recover and bounce back better than ever.

Unfortunately, this wasn't the case with Futurama. Looking back over the entire run now, with the smart money saying that this will still be the case after its latest revival in 2023, there is a very clear and obvious point where the show changed and was never the same again. This is the movies.

For all the reasons already listed these four straight to DVD features saw a dramatic dip in quality from the original run. Had things gone back to the way they were once the series was properly revived on Comedy Central this may have been seen as little more than a bump in the road. However, as this never happened, instead of a blip these movies are now seen as simply the beginning of Futurama's fall from grace.

There is nothing on the other side of 'Into The Wild Green Yonder' that even comes close to how Futurama used to be, perhaps with the one exception of ‘Meanwhile’, which was just that – exceptional. Things have never been the same since the movies, and its impossible not to resent them for it.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Futurama
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

This standard nerd combines the looks of Shaggy with the brains of Scooby, has an unhealthy obsession with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and is a firm believer that Alter Bridge are the greatest band in the world.