The First Purge Review: 2 Ups & 7 Downs
The franchise crashes and burns.
Giving audiences a welcome break from all the summer blockbuster bombast, The First Purge is the fourth entry into the improbably prosperous The Purge franchise, serving up a prequel which explains how the infamous night first began.
None of the Purge films are great movies, but they basically know exactly what they are and play up to their own wanton silliness. Sad it is to report, then, that the charm feels mostly gone this time around, with the John Carpenter-inspired style and tone of the last two movies largely absent here.
If you're a hardcore fan of the franchise it might deliver enough to be moderately entertaining, but if you were hoping for anything remotely clever, fresh or inventive, it really just feels like a needless victory lap for a series that's clearly running out of juice.
This doesn't mean that the inevitable fifth movie or upcoming TV series - the latter of which is teased in a post-credits scene, by the way - will follow suit, but it's also not terribly encouraging that the franchise has much left to say or do...
Downs...
7. Marisa Tomei Is Totally Wasted
The fact that an actress of Marisa Tomei's calibre could be roped into appearing in a Purge prequel is surprise enough, but it's disappointing that she wasn't at least given an interesting or substantial role to have fun with.
Tomei plays Dr. May Updale, the so-called "architect" of the Purge, who observes the experiment from the apparent comfort of a control room in order to examine its effectiveness and how "human nature" responds to it.
Sadly Tomei spends most of her 10-ish minutes of screen time confined to this single room, doing nothing but spouting lazily-written exposition and bringing some star power to a movie otherwise completely devoid of it.
Most disappointing of all, however, is how abruptly she disappears from the movie. It's as though the producers realised they could only afford Tomei for so many days and had to quickly contrive a reason for her character to no longer appear in the movie. Terrible.
6. It Suffers From "Prequelitis"
Even the best prequels usually have an uphill battle on their hands trying to justify their own existence, and sadly The First Purge doesn't do a remotely good job of it.
For starters, it would've made so much more sense for The Purge 4 to be a direct sequel to the previous movie, Election Year, depicting an all-out civil war between the NFFA's followers and, well, everyone else.
Instead, this movie goes back in time to depict how The Purge began, which while not an inherently bad concept for a movie, isn't explored here with much depth or interest.
Typical for prequels, there's technology featured here that doesn't appear in the future movies - namely drones which scour the night for ethnic minorities to murder - and overall it just doesn't do enough to convince that it needed to be made.
Plus, the absence of Frank Grillo, who really helped bring the last two movies to life with his charismatic performance as Leo Barnes, is sorely missed here.
5. The Painfully Cheap Production Values
Despite having by far the biggest budget of the four Purge movies - it cost $13 million, more than quadruple the original - it feels embarrassingly cheap at times, with howlingly ropey production values proving incredibly distracting throughout.
For starters, the CGI is frequently appalling. Marisa Tomei's very first scene sees her awkwardly stood against a green screen background, where little effort has been made to make the lighting sources match. Elsewhere the action scenes are filled with hokey digital blood splatter, even hilariously splashing onto the camera in one instance.
Then there's the sound. A woeful amount of dialogue has clearly been dubbed-over in post-production, with scenes awkwardly and unnaturally cutting away from characters' faces while they're speaking.
The sound editing, meanwhile, is basically criminal for a major Hollywood movie released in cinemas worldwide.
It's as though the sound department just used a royalty-free sound bank for the various stock screams and gun reload sound effects, because if you watch a decent amount of movies and have a good pair of ears, a lot of the sounds in this film will be rather familiar indeed.
4. The Visually Sloppy Action Sequences
In addition to the low-rent production, the actual set-pieces themselves are disappointingly messy, though this doesn't really seem to be a result of the budgetary constraints given that the last two movies delivered thrilling action at lower price points.
The main problem is Gerard McMurray's slapdash direction: most of the close combat fighting is spasmodically shot and edited for maximum confusion. It's a frequent headache trying to have even a basic idea of what's going on, such that looking for clear spatial awareness of how a fight's unfolding quickly becomes a fool's errand.
This culminates in a visually irritating finale, in which a repeatedly flashing light is needlessly thrown into the mix, turning an otherwise mildly entertaining showdown into an actual eyesore.
3. It's Shockingly Boring
Whatever you think of the previous Purge movies, you probably wouldn't call them boring. The last two films in particular have a tenacious sense of energy and even fun to them, playing-up the theatrical insanity of the Purgers and revelling in their go-for-broke action sequences.
The First Purge, however, suffers from bad pacing, mediocre action that lacks the invention of its predecessors, and a diminished sense of edginess compared to what came before.
Perhaps this is simply a case of the series generally entering the "curtailing returns" period of its life, but given that this is the first Purge movie not directed by franchise writer James DeMonaco, it's easy to lay most of the blame at McMurray's feet.
The Purge finally feels utterly pedestrian and ordinary, and that's a real shame.
2. All The Unintentional Comedy
These films have never exactly had a perfect handle on their tone, amping up the carnage to such tasteless and ludicrous levels that, sometimes, the only response is to let out a perverse chuckle.
This fourth movie finally tips the balance unambiguously in the wrong direction, by doubling down on the hammy silliness to the point where it's genuinely accidentally hilarious, and therefore clashes jarringly with the apparent "seriousness" of all the murder and mayhem.
The primary culprit is a mentally unstable drug addict named Skeletor (Rotimi Paul), whose psychotic behaviour is just as likely to elicit laughs as it is raised eyebrows and genuine terror.
Here overacting and daft writing conspire to completely upend the movie's tone and leave audiences unsure of exactly what they're supposed to feel.
1. It's The Most Ridiculous Purge Movie Yet
It would be absurd to criticise these movies too harshly simply for being ridiculous, but The First Purge's central conceit requires such an overwhelming suspension of disbelief that it can be straight-up distracting.
While the previous Purge movies at least involved the entire U.S. being forced into the "game" - unless you could afford to take a vacation, of course - here there's very little conceivable reason why any non-psychopathic person would dare remain in Staten Island on Purge Night.
Some flimsy excuses are raised - the gangster characters can't risk moving their money and contraband for fear of losing it - while others characters' decisions to stick around are barely even mentioned at all.
The movie attempts to lampshade this by having poor participants be paid $5,000 to remain on Staten Island during the Purge, but if the argument here is that people's lives are so destitute they're willing to risk them for five grand, that's just too damn contrived.
When most of these characters' problems could be solved by driving a few miles out of the town, it's not easy to remain invested in giving a damn about their survival.
As bad as The First Purge is, though, it does have a couple of bright spots. Only a couple, mind...
Ups...
2. The Surprisingly Decent Performances
Though Frank Grillo's absence leaves a void that nobody in this film can fill, the performances of the central characters are at least rock solid if not genuinely good for the most part.
As gangster Dmitri, Y'Lan Noel brings a bada** swagger to the table that makes him an easy action hero to root for, while on the more pacifistic side, Lex Scott Davis is likeable as determined anti-Purge activist Nya.
Granted, you probably won't remember either of their names - nor anyone's else's, honestly - by the time the end credits roll, but at least the leads are lending more conviction to their parts than either of them really deserve.
In fact there aren't really any especially bad performances from the entire ensemble, and most of the principal characters sell the fear and terror of the night solidly enough. What a waste it all is, though.
1. The Amusingly Unsubtle Social Commentary
These movies get zero points for subtlety, but The First Purge does get a small sliver of credit for leaning into the peak insanity of Trump-era America, by rolling it into the movie's general social commentary of a divided United States.
There are countless references to the Black Lives Matter movement, the NFFA is effectively attempting to "Make America Great Again", and there's even an outrageously on-the-nose moment where Nya gets caught in a trap and has her crotch grabbed by an assailant (who she calls a "p***y-grabbin' motherf***er").
Though the movie doesn't go as far as introducing a Trump substitute caricature, his presence is felt throughout the film even if he's not explicitly featured or named.
The film definitely could've taken things much further in this regard and it mostly feels like a gloss for the action above all else, but it's still a giggle to see the movie taking such loaded pot-shots at America's current social ills.
What did you think of The First Purge? Shout it out in the comments!