The Great Wall Review: 6 Ups & 5 Downs

Matt Damon with a side of cheese.

Great Wall poster
wiki

Amid a ton of controversy about perceived "white-washing", the Matt Damon-starring The Great Wall is in cinemas now, and it's safe to say that critics are decidedly mixed on its quality.

While few would profess this to be a great movie, it does prove that most of the pre-release hand-wringing wasn't worth the fuss, and sometimes a dumb action flick is exactly what the doctor ordered.

Those going in hoping for a legitimately brilliant epic might be disappointed, but if you go in expecting a silly time at the movies with plenty of explosions and corny quips, you'll probably be entertained.

Downs...

5. Matt Damon Is Totally Wasted

Matt Damon In The Great Wall
Universal Pictures

In fairness, Matt Damon's presence in this movie has been viewed by most ahead of release as nothing more than a blatant paycheck role, so just about nobody was expecting him to put on a top-tier performance.

Still, he's basically an also-ran here in his own movie, unable to do much with his character beyond the most basic action hero beats.

Strangely, Damon also puts on an imperceptible, ever-shifting accent, resulting in several scenes of distracting, bemused unintentional hilarity.

He just about does what he needs to in order to make the role functional, but pretty much any moderately competent actor could've taken this part no problem.

Damon got it because he's bankable and almost universally liked, which is of course extremely important for a big-budget movie aimed at a broad international audience.


4. The Monsters Are Incredibly Generic

The Great Wall Taotie
Universal Pictures

The crux of the movie sees Matt Damon's William Garin teaming up with a Chinese military squad to help fend off an army of hideous monsters known as the Taotie, who want to ravage not only China but the entire world.

Somewhat unsurprisingly, the beasts are probably the lamest part of the movie, highly unimaginative beasts rendered with fairly unremarkable CGI and boasting character designs that wouldn't look out of place in just about any mediocre mid-2000s video game.

Ultimately they're just fodder around which the film's luxurious action sequences are built, and that's fine, but it's a shame they didn't amount to something just a little more interesting.


3. Plot & Characters Are Virtually Non-Existent

The Great Wall Matt Damon Pedro Pascal
Universal

If you're looking for a compelling narrative and well-drawn characters, you've absolutely come to the wrong place. The Great Wall is a movie concerned with big set-pieces and elemental ideas, but little in terms of nuance and intelligence.

The narrative is extremely thin and doesn't go far beyond "guy shows up to help Chinese army kill green monsters", while the characters are pure archetype and you'll probably struggle to even remember most of their names.

It is a film centered around its action more than anything, which isn't a huge problem, but if you're expecting something as well-written as some of Zhang Yimou's other movies, you'll be disappointed.


2. Not Enough Willem Dafoe

The Great Wall Willem Dafoe
Universal

You'd be forgiven for forgetting that Willem Dafoe is in this movie, but yes, he has a few brief scenes as Sir Ballard, a wanderer who helps Garin and co. in their quest.

Ultimately, though, Dafoe doesn't do much other than creepily stare into the middle distance and provide some occasional exposition dumps for the heroes.

It's a supporting part that really could've been cut entirely, and it feels like the role was more about securing a respected western actor rather than fleshing out the movie's roster of characters.

Sure, it's inherently hilarious to see Dafoe in a movie like this, but he's sadly nowhere near as fun or well-utilised as you'd hope.


1. It's One Of Zhang Yimou's Worst Films

The Great Wall Matt Damon
Universal

The one thing that gave people hope for this movie was the presence of Zhang Yimou, the director of beloved films such as Hero, House of Flying Daggers and Curse of the Golden Flower, to name just a few.

While Yimou acquits himself just fine, it's safe to say that the rather low-effort script makes him unable to craft a film that truly lives up to his past successes.

Basically, it feels like a hack-for-hire job, one Yimou pulls off gracefully to his credit, but a stronger script could've made much, much better use of his inimitable talents.

Critics seem to largely agree on the whole: of his 20+ films to date, The Great Wall is his second-worst-reviewed, sitting at around the 35% mark at the time of press.

All this said, the film isn't without its pleasures, and so here's everything that made The Great Wall totally worth watching...

Ups...

6. It Doesn't Take Itself Seriously. At All.

The Great Wall Matt Damon
Universal

The movie's greatest asset bar none is that it doesn't even begin to pretend it's a serious epic about man staring down beast.

Unlike many of Yimou's previous films, this is an unapologetically ridiculous film that also wears its silliness on its sleeve.

The script doubles down on the cheesy one-liners and it's clear that the cast are having a lot of fun with it, which if you're in the mood for a corny B-movie, can make this quite the entertaining experience indeed.

Regardless of whether you actively like it, it's a difficult movie to truly hate because it's so light and easy to watch.


5. (Mostly) Great Visuals

The Great Wall
Universal

This is a gorgeous looking movie for the most part. Yes, the CGI monsters could look better and there are some purposefully goofy moments with questionable visual effects, but for the overwhelming majority, Yimou has made a terrific visual feast that he can certainly be proud of on a visceral level.

The film has a huge scale, but the gigantic expanses and huge armies never really feel blatantly digitised, and the compositing in particular, where characters are stood atop a giant fortress yet in reality are surely on a green-screen soundstage, are uncommonly convincing.

Strong style has always been one of Yimou's greatest gifts, and bar some occasionally cringe-worthy slow-motion moments, he nails a magnificent look for his film.

The 3D is also pretty solid for the most part, with Yimou indulging in a ton of hilarious fly-in-your-face effects for maximum goofiness.


4. Pedro Pascal Steals The Show

The Great Wall Pedro Pascal
Universal

Matt Damon has the MVP award unceremoniously stolen from him by Game of Thrones' Pedro Pascal, who plays glorified sidekick Pero Tovar.

Pero is basically the movie's wise-cracking know-it-all, and Pascal tackles the role with great relish, making the best of his daft one-liners and enjoying some fun chemistry with Damon.

While he may not be the movie's selling point from a marketing perspective, he sure brings more personality to the movie than anyone else, and further proves he's just waiting to become a huge star.


3. Thrilling Action Sequences

The Great Wall
Universal

True to form, Yimou serves up some deliriously entertaining action here. The strong visual effects, sharp cinematography and Yimou's generally skilled control of the camera combine to ensure the set-pieces, of which there are many, are dynamic and consistently entertaining.

Nobody should come to this movie for the story, so at least Yimou smartly doubled down on the insane action, and to that end the film just about manages to justify the price of admission.

Basically, the various battle sequences against the beasts are fast-paced, varied and straight-up fun to soak in.


2. It's Well-Paced & Doesn't Outstay Its Welcome

The Great Wall
Universal

Epics of this sort can so often clock in at bloated 130-150 minutes run-times as they begin to buy into their own import while forgetting how crucial good pacing is.

The Great Wall, on the other hand, is a lean 103 minutes long, and considering that the closing credits comprise more than 10 minutes of this total, it ends up being a 90-minute sprint that doesn't waste any time.

As mentioned, plot and character are minimal concerns here and the film very quickly gets to the dizzy action, which is well-placed throughout and ensures the pic never gets bogged down in overt talkiness.

There are many reasons to criticise The Great Wall, but at least it knows exactly what sort of experience it's offering, and gets in and out in an extremely reasonable amount of time.


1. Jing Tian Is A Strong Female Lead

The Great Wall Jing Tian
Universal

One aspect of the movie that unfortunately hasn't been talked about much is the presence of Chinese actress Jing Tian as Commander Lin Mae.

While viewers would be forgiven for assuming that Tian is just another attractive Chinese model shoved into a Chinese-American co-production for her looks and native appeal, she actually gives one of the best performances in the movie and is probably also the film's most developed character.

Lin Mae is a strong female lead, and while the film hints at romance between her and Damon's Garin, it actually ends up surprisingly avoiding this in favour of something much less cliched. Also, it sure as Hell helps that Tian's grasp of English is excellent, and so she doesn't sound like an actress just reading the dialogue from phonetic cue cards.

Have you seen The Great Wall yet? What did you think? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.