The Hobbit: 10 Dumbest Character Decisions

Even Gandalf wasn't wise all the time.

The hobbit gandalf battle of the five armies
New Line Cinema

Even now, two decades later, the Lord of the Rings trilogy is widely thought of as one of the greatest film franchises in history. Peter Jackson returned to Middle-earth to try and recapture that same magic ten years later, but ultimately fell some way short.

One of the greatest aspects of The Lord of the Rings is its characters, with whom audiences were able to form instant connections. The same can be said about many of the Hobbit characters, though certainly not for all of them.

While Gandalf will always be a pop culture icon, Smaug and Bard added to the long list of legendary Middle-earth characters, and the likes of Thorin and Tauriel underwhelmed greatly.

Yet, whether good or evil, loved or hated, just about every character in Middle-earth has made a decision or two to really make you scratch your head.

Some came in the heat of battle, while fleeing from certain death, while others were just pure bad judgement from some of the supposedly smartest people in the world. No one it seems, is safe from a stupid decision, whether it was by design of their character or not.

10. Thorin Assumed Azog The Defiler Was Dead

Azog The Hobbit
New Line Cinema

This is technically less a decision and more an assumption, but it is still more than stupid enough to earn a place on this list. Thorin didn’t exactly cover himself in glory throughout the Hobbit trilogy, and this is just the start of it.

During the battle between Dwarves and Orcs, in which Thror was killed and Thorin earned the name Oakenshield, the latter engaged Azog the Defiler in combat. The Dwarf was on the ropes for most of the fight, but in the end managed to cut the Orc's hand clean off his arm. His troops dragged him away from the battle, and the Orc army broke.

The way it is portrayed in the movie and the flashback, this was the last Thorin saw of Azog. No major injuries but for the loss of his hand, and the Dwarf prince just decided that his enemy had died, like there was no other possible outcome. No need to see a body or anything.

There was absolutely no reason to believe that Azog was dead, yet even when he was told the Pale Orc lived many years later, he still didn’t believe it.


9. The Master Tried To Escape With Too Much Gold

The Hobbit the Master
New Line Cinema

After Smaug was awakened and angered by the Dwarves in Thorin’s company, he headed to Lake Town in a fit of rage and revenge. Within a few moments he had all but destroyed the town, leaving it a burning shell floating on the water.

Most people tried to escape the fire, save for Bard and his son Bain, including the Master of the town. Ever greedy, selfish, and unaffected by the plight of his people, the villainous Master tried to flee on a boat with as much gold as he possibly could.

This made their vessel just too heavy, and too slow to escape the fiery death that stalked them. He even knew they were going too slow, but instead of sacrificing his and the town’s heavy gold, he pushed Alfrid into the lake, making very little difference.

He was ultimately crushed under the weight of the humungous beast falling from the sky, but if he hadn’t been quite as greedy, he may well have made it out alive. Instead, he died surrounded by the gold that he loved more than anything.


8. Thorin Wouldn't Show His Map To Elrond

Hobbit Elrond Rivendell Map
New Line Cinema

Though this would seem to be Thorin’s quest, to return to his grandfather’s throne and bring his kin back home, the direction of the journey was very much down to Gandalf. If it wasn’t for the wizard seeking Thorin in Bree there wouldn’t have been a quest at all.

One of the biggest keys to success for Thorin was a map and a key that Gandalf was in possession of. Not one of the company could read the map however, and there were few in Middle-earth who could. Luckily, their path led them directly to one such Elf.

After taking refuge in Rivendell, something that Thorin would have avoided at all costs if he had his own way, Gandalf wanted Elrond to read their map. It was a huge coincidence that they just so happened to be in Elrond’s presence when the very moon needed to read the map was above them.

Even so, with the reading of the map an essential part of their quest, Thorin was still against letting Elrond see it. He hated Elves so much that he would truly cut his nose off to spite his face. If it wasn’t for Gandalf reasoning with the pig-headed Dwarf, Thorin would have never known when he needed to get to Erebor, and how to find the secret door.


7. Bard Forgot His Black Arrow

The Hobbit Bard
New Line Cinema

One of the greatest heroes of the entire trilogy, and in Middle-earth in general, is Bard the Bowman. It was he that killed Smaug the Terrible, who could have easily reigned terror on the entire country should he not have been stopped by that fateful black arrow.

As the ancestor of Girion, the man who was so close to defeating the dragon all those years ago, this almost felt like fate. So much so that Bard even kept a black arrow hidden in his home, seemingly for just the occasion of Smaug’s return.

Though he was imprisoned when the great dragon began his descent on Lake Town, he soon escaped and made his way up to the top of the bell tower. However, he took with him just a bow and a quiver of arrows, nothing that would ever have a chance of piercing the hide of Smaug.

It was only when his son, Bain, brought him the black arrow that he seemed to remember it even existed at all.

You may say that there wasn’t time to go home for it, but in the time it took to waste all of his arrows pointlessly trying to kill the beast, he could have gone and got the one weapon that actually had a chance to kill him.


6. Everyone Ignored Gandalf's Warning

Gandalf The Hobbit
New Line Cinema

Just before the path of Thorin’s company took them through the dark land that was Mirkwood, they parted ways with Gandalf. The wizard sensed something even darker, and headed to Dol Guldur to investigate what would ultimately be the Necromancer.

More on that decision later, but he was imprisoned by the Nine ring-wraiths and left to hang in a cage. He did at least learn about the army of Orcs ready to march upon Thorin and the Lonely Mountain.

When Gandalf returned, he pleaded with the likes of Thranduil and Dain of the Iron Hills to abandon the battle for the mountain, as legions of Orcs were on their way. This was a much bigger threat than anything either army could throw at each other, and yet they all ignored him.

Gandalf is one of the wisest beings in all of Middle-earth, and when he came with reports of an entire army of Orcs, no one cared to listen. Instead, they focused on nothing more than the gold within the mountain.

It is of no surprise then, that they were woefully under-prepared when Azog the Defiler led his troops down on the fight at the foot of Erebor.


5. Smaug Just Kept Talking

The Hobbit Smaug
Warner Bros. Pictures

It has become such an overused trope in TV and movies that the villain either explains their plan or likes to hear the sound of their own voice so much, that it has almost become a trope to reference that they won’t be conforming to the original trope.

This wasn’t the case for Smaug the Magnificent, as he really did love the sound of his own voice. I mean, who didn’t, Benedict Cumberbatch gave an incredible performance as the fire drake from the north, but maybe if he knew when to shoot fire from his mouth rather than words he wouldn’t have died when he did.

Firstly, he engaged in conversation with Bilbo, the trespasser and thief in the mountain. All he had to do was incinerate the hobbit before giving him the chance to escape, but instead he wasted his opportunity.

Then, when he came face to face with Bard on the top of the bell tower, he could have easily killed him immediately.

However, instead he decided to talk for a while, to gloat and boast that Bard would never kill him, thus giving the bowman the chance to get ready to kill him. Bard was nowhere near ready to fire the arrow when Smaug spotted him, but the dragon just couldn’t help himself and wound up dead because of it.


4. The Dwarves Tried To Burn A Dragon

The Hobbit The Desolation Of Smaug Gold
Warner Bros.

How do you kill a dragon? In Middle-earth you need a big black arrow, a ridiculously good archer, and a pre-existing wound to aim for, flawlessly, from an impossible distance.

While in Erebor with Smaug, the Dwarves had none of these things.

Things seemed bad for Thorin and company, as they were trapped with this hulking dragon, with no weapons, and nothing to stop them from being melted. However, Thorin actually had a great idea in that they would trick Smaug into lighting their forges.

Could this have made some impromptu weapons? Sure. It would have been difficult, and would have taken some distraction to keep Smaug from killing them, but it would have at least been worth a shot. The Dwarves were master smiths after all.

However, the Dwarves instead made the decision to burn Smaug to death. They tried to burn a dragon, basically a huge incinerator with wings, to death. All they did in pouring molten gold over the beast was enrage him, and send him on his way to Lake Town with revenge and death on his mind.


3. Gandalf Went Into Dol Guldur Alone

Hobbit Gandalf
Warner Bros. Pictures

Gandalf had a great concern about the fire drake that took up residence in the Lonely Mountain so many years ago. However, there was far more on his mind than just Thorin and Smaug, one of which dragged him away from the Dwarves arguably right when they needed him most.

It was Radagast the Brown who first felt the dark and uncomfortable witchcraft of the Necromancer, and after he went to investigate, he was able to prove to Gandalf thanks to a morgul blade that there was evil afoot.

Right before entering Mirkwood, Gandalf went to seek information for himself. At first he took Radagast with him, but sent him away before entering the haunted fortress that was Dol Guldur. On his own, he was of course absolutely no match for the nine ringwraiths.

Gandalf was defeated and imprisoned quickly and easily, and thus missed his meeting with the Dwarves, was absent for their fight with Smaug and the dragon’s subsequent attack on Lake Town, and arrived at the mountain way too late to stop the Battle of the Five Armies. If it weren’t for the help of Galadriel, Elrond, and Saruman, he would never have left.


2. Thorin Refused To Share The Wealth Of Erebor

The Hobbit Thorin 2
New Line Cinema

The quest of the Dwarves of Erebor, from Bag End in the Shire to the Lonely Mountain, was not done in isolation. Thorin and company wouldn’t have gotten anywhere near the mountain without the likes of Gandalf, Bard, and the people of Lake Town.

For the latter, all they received on the other end of the quest was fire and death, in spite of being promised a share of the wealth within Erebor. Bard only wanted Thorin to honour his word and give what was promised, while Thranduil wanted a handful of gems that once belonged to the Elves.

While it is slightly understandable Thorin wanted Thranduil to have no part of the treasure, as he offered no help when Smaug first attacked the mountain, even so would this not have been worth avoiding war? He could have given half of his gold away and would still have had wealth beyond measure.

Whether it was dragon sickness or just greed, something within Thorin’s mind led him to war, death, and destruction rather than sharing the spoils of the mountain as he promised. He traded his and the lives of others instead of losing a mere drop in the ocean of gold.


1. Gandalf's Entire Plan

Gandalf Bard Hobbit
Warner Bros./New Line Cinema

How do you even begin to rid the world of a dragon shut up inside a mountain? Though it was Thorin who lost his home, it was Gandalf who came up with the plan to take a ‘burglar’ from the Shire to steal the Arkenstone from under Smaug’s nose, unite the Dwarf armies, and take back the mountain.

Ultimately, the Dwarves did retake Erebor, but in reality it was not thanks to Gandalf in any way. All the grey wizard did was risk everyone’s lives involved, including the innocent men, women, and children of Lake Town. While trying to take the Arkenstone, Bilbo, who was absolutely no burglar at all, woke Smaug who preceded to burn the town and its people to ash.

If it weren’t for a very lucky Bard with a very lucky black arrow, the enraged dragon would have killed everyone in Lake Town before returning to Erebor, killing thirteen Dwarves, and then going on to do who knows what throughout Middle-earth.

Even in the ridiculously unlikely event that Bilbo was able to get the Arkenstone to Thorin without seeing everyone engulfed in flame, reuniting the seven Dwarf armies under Thorin’s banner, no amount of Dwarvish axes could bring a dragon down before everyone was burned to a crisp.


In this post: 
The Hobbit
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

This standard nerd combines the looks of Shaggy with the brains of Scooby, has an unhealthy obsession with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and is a firm believer that Alter Bridge are the greatest band in the world.